Key Takeaways
- Volume-led recovery, margin squeeze ahead: Gas sales rose 8.8% QoQ on strong CNG additions, but pool gas costs jumped at least $1-1.5/MMBTU since June and the full pass-through impact will only show in Q2.
- CNG conversion engine still firing: Nearly 19,000 vehicles added in Q1, matching prior trends, and July conversions stayed in the same range despite INR 86/kg pricing. Management sees no demand slowdown yet.[15-16]
- Profitability got a one-time I&C boost: EBITDA grew 32.5% QoQ partly because industrial/commercial realizations rose faster than term contract costs, a tailwind that reverses as alternate fuel prices fall.
- HPHT gas allocation is the big policy wildcard: Management is "quite hopeful" the Ministry will blend some new domestic HPHT production into the CGD pool, which would structurally lower input costs, but timing and quantum are unknown.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether CNG conversion momentum holds as the full pool gas price increase flows into margins, and any Ministry announcement on HPHT gas or CGD pricing support.
Volume Growth & Demand Drivers
- CNG additions steady despite price rise: Nearly 19,000 vehicles added in Q1, including OEM and conversions, with commercial goods vehicles at 2,700. July conversions remained in a similar range, and management says it is too early to predict any demand slowdown at current elevated prices.[15-16]
- OEM vehicles lead the shift: The major conversion driver is original equipment vehicles, both LCV and private cars, because consumers value warranty coverage, lower maintenance, and best-in-class fuel efficiency.
- CNG vs liquid fuel math matters: At INR 86/kg in Mumbai, the effective discount versus petrol is 30%+ when measured in mileage terms, not just price per unit, because CNG delivers better mileage per kg. Management calls 20% the minimum discount.
- CV-focused infrastructure push: The company is planning large stations catering predominantly to LCV/HCV segments, designating specific dispensing points for commercial vehicles, and creating outlets at strategic points like Thane Ghodbunder Road.
- Station expansion target maintained: A minimum of 25 new CNG stations and 25 upgradations are budgeted for the year, with many more proposals at land and other stages. Q1 saw only 2 new stations and 3 upgradations.
- Raigad waiting on CGS: Pipeline network expansion has created a good ecosystem for CNG and PNG, but demand unlocking waits on the Savroli CGS becoming operational.
Patel: "We will always you know keep margins and the pricing, keeping in mind how the new vehicles come on to CNG and we would like always balancing between number of people switching on to CNG and we grow. So, there can be growth in terms of margin of the bottom line as well as in terms of the volume. So, we would always like to balance both."
Gas Sourcing & Input Cost Pressure
- Pool gas price rising: UBP was USD 8.04-8.05/MMBTU in May-June 2022 and increased by at least $1-$1.5 since then for July and August. Management declined to give specific July/August figures, calling it a matter for next quarter.
- Spot LNG blending estimated at ~15%: GAIL is blending from its term portfolio and spot, but Gazprom defaulting on some term supplies has likely increased the spot percentage. Management cannot provide an exact share because blended price data is not available to them, and the share can fluctuate.
- CNG and domestic PNG fully on APM: These segments receive 100% APM gas at UBP, but under new quarterly allocation rules, volume growth beyond 2.5% QoQ must use market-determined or term contract gas for the incremental portion.
- I&C segment fully covered by term contracts: Post the 16th May 100% APM allocation to CGD, full term contract minimum quantity is consumed for industrial and commercial requirements. Term contracts are structured so that at minimum take-or-pay level, the full I&C segment is catered to. [10-11]
- New APM allocation rules add pressure: The shift from half-yearly plus 10% to quarterly plus 2.5% means growth volumes hit the higher-cost pool faster. Management's strategy is to bear a higher cost in one quarter to build volume that benefits from better allocation in subsequent quarters.
- HPHT gas the hoped-for relief: Additional domestic production from HPHT fields is likely to come to market. CGD companies have strongly represented that some part should be allocated and blended with the existing APM pool, and management is "quite hopeful" and "quite confident" this will happen, though timing and quantum are unknown.
Datta: "CGD companies have taken up very strongly with this government that since the sector carries a higher priority, so some part of the HPHT gas should be allocated and blended with the existing pool of APM gas. And this is under serious consideration at the end of the Government of India, Ministry Petroleum and we are quite hopeful that some additional quantity of HPHT gas which will have a much, much you know though it will be higher compared to the APM gas, but it will be much lower than what you know the long term contract of the spot, where the spot prices are. So, it is going to have a very beneficial effect on the overall pool price."
Margin Dynamics & Profitability
- Q1 margins benefited from I&C timing: EBITDA grew 32.5% QoQ to INR 286 crore, but the I&C segment got a one-time lift because the increase in term contract cost was lower than the increase in sales price realization, and alternate fuel prices (LSHS, 19 kg LPG cylinder) were high during the quarter.
- That tailwind is reversing: Industrial and commercial realizations are expected to be lower in the current quarter because LPG prices have commercially come down and oil prices have fallen, with a lag between alternate fuel prices and Brent.
- CNG margin pressure is structural near-term: The full impact of the $1-1.5/MMBTU pool gas price increase will compress CNG and domestic PNG margins in Q2. Management declined to quantify the pass-through or margin hit for July and August.
- Volume-over-margin philosophy: Management will bear a higher cost in a quarter if it builds volume that benefits from better APM allocation in subsequent quarters, and is willing to accept temporary negative margins on incremental volumes rather than lose customers.
- No FY19-20 margin target: Management clarified it never set a target of returning to FY19-20 margins. The reference in a prior call was a comparison point, not a goal. FY21 was an exceptionally favorable year with all-time low gas prices and is not a benchmark.
Patel: "At any cost, we won't have dry out kind of a situation, we would always love to cater to our customers. If it is temporary, making some negative margins as well for the incremental volumes. So, we will add on to our customers and make in the long run all of them positive."
Policy & Regulatory Outlook
- Ministry is engaged on CGD pricing: Management says the Ministry is cognizant that CNG prices have crossed petrol and diesel prices in some places and the differential has squeezed significantly. Something is being worked on, and management expects favorable dispensation on pricing and availability in coming days.
- HPHT gas allocation under serious consideration: The government is evaluating blending some HPHT production into the CGD pool. GAIL will try to secure HPHT gas as and when volumes come up for bidding, but the ramp-up will be gradual and timing is unknown.[9-10]
- Industry viability argument being made: The CGD industry has represented to the Ministry that the sector requires support given the capex commitments and minimum work program obligations under bidding rounds. Without support, achieving those obligations at high gas prices is difficult.
- OMC commission gap is immaterial: A small gap remains on interpretation of trade margins for certain city classes where OMC demand is a few paise higher, but the value and quantum are very small and not significant.
Datta: "I think ministry is cognizant that in some places CNG prices have even crossed petrol prices and diesel prices, there is differential between CNG and petrol is got squeezed to a very large extent. And we know that there is something in the ministry that they are working on. And we expect that some favorable dispensation for meeting the demands of CGD in terms of pricing as well as availability are being considered within the Ministry and we hope to see that some positive announcements are made in coming days."
Infrastructure & Expansion
- MRU stations five-six months out: Three LOIs have been issued for Mobile Refueling Units. One party has identified land and is seeking statutory permissions. Actual setup and volume output expected in another five-six months.
- Household connection target raised: The company aims for 3,00,000 domestic connections this financial year versus 2,62,000 achieved last year. Q1 added 62,075 households.
- Capex outlook intact at INR 700-800 crores: Full-year capex dependent on availability of land, pipeline, digging permissions, and other approvals. Management says the capex outlook shows positivity about the sector and it is not worried about temporary margin pressures.
- LCV fleet transitioning to CNG: 95 out of 167 LCVs used for CNG transportation now run on CNG, with a plan to completely shift after expiry of the existing LCV hiring contract.
- Open to M&A: Management is open to all kinds of M&A opportunities available at a good price that add volume and value to the business.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CNG station additions | Minimum 25 new stations and 25 upgradations | FY23 |
| Household connections | 3,00,000 new domestic connections | FY23 |
| Full-year capex | INR 700-800 crores | FY23 |
| MRU stations operational | Three stations producing volume | Five-six months |
| LCV fleet fully on CNG | Complete shift after existing hiring contract expiry | Short span after contract expiry |
| I&C realizations | Expected to be lower as alternate fuel prices have fallen | Current quarter (Q2 FY23) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Overall average gas sales volume | 3.448 MMSCMD, +8.8% QoQ |
| CNG sales volume | 2.539 MMSCMD, +11.5% QoQ |
| Industrial and commercial sales volume | 0.439 MMSCMD, +4.9% QoQ |
| Domestic PNG sales volume | 0.470 MMSCMD, vs 0.474 MMSCMD in Q4 |
| EBITDA | ₹286 crore, +32.5% QoQ |
| EBITDA margin | 19.63%, vs 19.83% in Q4 |
| Net profit after tax | ₹185 crore, +40.5% QoQ |
| CNG price (Mumbai) | ₹86 per kg |
| CNG vehicles added during quarter | 19,000 plus, including OEM and conversions |
| CNG stations | 292 at quarter end, 2 new stations added |
| CNG station upgradations during quarter | 3 |
| Domestic households connected during quarter | 62,075, cumulative connectivity nearly 0.19 crore |
| Industrial and commercial customers | 4,366 at quarter end, 69 added during quarter |
| Pipeline length | Over 6,285 km, 65.21 km laid during quarter |
| Capex outflow | ₹150 crore plus in first three months, full-year outlook ₹700-800 crore |