Key Takeaways
- Volume recovery begins, but 6% target still distant: After two years of degrowth, CNG volumes jumped 4%+ QoQ on passenger-car incentives, yet commercial vehicle uptake remains missing and H1 leaves the FY24 growth target at risk.
- Price cuts are a sentiment play, not an elasticity lever: Management cut CNG by Rs. 3 to reverse the psychological damage of a Rs. 49-to-Rs. 89/kg run-up, conceding that measuring elasticity on such a small move is impossible.
- Margins are normalizing from an exceptional Q1: EBITDA per SCM slipped nearly Rs. 2 QoQ as one-off pricing upside unwound and I&C discounts kicked in, but the H1 print of ~Rs. 14.5 still puts the full year comfortably above the Rs. 10–12 guided range.
- I&C is being rebuilt with a volume-over-price playbook: ‘Take or Pay’ clauses were scrapped, a 3-year 10% discount was offered to large new customers, and over 1 lakh SCMD of contracts were signed, setting up a multi-quarter connection pipeline.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the OEM incentive schemes convert into sustained CNG vehicle additions beyond the festive season, the pace at which the 0.1 MMSCMD of new industrial contracts starts flowing, and the Unison acquisition’s regulatory clearance, which could add volumes from Q3.
Volume Recovery: The Turn, and What Is Still Missing
- Two-year tide has turned: After degrowth driven by CNG pricing and gas costs, Q2 marks a return to the growth track, though the 6% annual target has not yet been reached because commercial vehicle growth has still not picked up.
- Passenger cars did the heavy lifting: The majority of the ~4,000-vehicle QoQ addition came from private cars after incentive schemes launched in early-to-mid September; 100-odd buses also came through, but light and intermediate commercial goods vehicles remain well below levels seen when the CNG-diesel price differential was significant.
- Retrofitment market revived: A market that had nearly stalled was brought back to life by a new scheme routed through kit manufacturers and distributors rather than retrofitters directly, a move designed to preserve quality.
- October shows no material jump: Slight increases in overall volume were seen, but no significant step-change has materialized yet.
- Diesel-to-CNG conversion is the nearer-term prize: Management expects this shift to happen fast over the next 3–4 years, well before any material EV impact, which is judged to be 7–8 years out.
Management: "The volume hit which we took in the last 2 years mainly on account of pricing of CNG, pricing for our cost of gas which we got etc. that tide has turned."
CNG Pricing & Sentiment Repair
- Price cut was about reversing sentiment, not fine-tuning demand: CNG rose from Rs. 49/kg to Rs. 89/kg over two years, creating negative consumer perception; the Rs. 3 cut was opportunistic, triggered when gas costs fell on the HPHT price cap reduction and Q1 margins printed at their healthiest ever.
- Elasticity is unmeasurable at this scale: Management stated plainly that price elasticity for a Rs. 3 change is really difficult to measure, so the strategy is framed as sentiment repair rather than a volume-elasticity trade.
- Incentive schemes are the demand-side lever: Launched progressively from 7–8 September, with the last signed in the final week of September, these include a fuel card scheme for new commercial vehicles (limited to MGL’s own GA stations) and joint advertisements with OEMs like Maruti and Ashok Leyland alongside customer meets with fleet owners.
- OEM partnerships may outlast the festive season: If the schemes succeed, management sees no reason to discontinue them, since every new vehicle added stays in the CNG ecosystem for 10–15 years.
Management: "Price elasticity for a Rs. 3 change is really difficult to measure. But what we are trying to do is we are trying to reverse the sentiment in the market when in a span of 2 years CNG went up from Rs. 49 a kg to Rs. 89 a kg."
Margin Normalization & the Volume-Profitability Trade
- Q2 gross margin fell a little less than Rs. 2 per SCM QoQ: Q1 benefited from 7–8 days of higher prices; Q2 absorbed aggressive I&C marketing discounts to new customers, a 30–40 paise gas cost increase, and CNG margin variation by outlet mix (own outlet vs OMC vs private).
- Full-year margin guidance remains comfortably above the Rs. 10–12 range: Having already achieved almost Rs. 14.5 EBITDA per SCM in H1, management expects the full year to print higher than the guided band, with gas costs stable at least through year-end barring forex moves.
- No floor margin, but a pricing floor exists: Management declined to name a minimum margin per SCM, but confirmed it keeps a floor for pricing relative to gas costs plus some margin, with the overriding objective that absolute PAT and EBITDA rise with incremental volumes.
- OPEX will tick up on marketing: Some increase is expected in Q2 and Q3 once CNG numbers click in, though the marketing cost increase itself is described as nominal; the Q2 jump in other expenses was driven by volume-linked costs (transportation, power, fuel), repair and maintenance, consultancy from a strategy exercise, and digitization initiatives.
Management: "We don't keep any floor margin as such in the mind. However, we do keep floor for pricing with respect to our gas costs and some margin over that rather than keeping an absolute to this. But all that is done keeping in mind overall absolute profitability should go up."
Industrial & Commercial: Rebuilding the Book
- Q2 I&C growth of 14–15% QoQ was partly base effect: Q1 was depressed by maintenance shutdowns at 2–3 of the largest consumers; Q2 also captured an upside of 15,000–16,000 SCMD from one customer switching its remaining liquid-fuel requirement to gas.
- Contracts were restructured to be more user-friendly: ‘Take or Pay’ elements were removed, and a 3-year 10% discount guarantee was offered to new high-volume customers, a move management says still generates profit because I&C is fed through term contracts, not spot or HPHT.
- Pipeline of over 1 lakh SCMD signed: These contracts are to be connected over the next few quarters, with roughly 0.1 MMSCMD expected to start kicking in from Q4 or the March quarter, aligning with the end of the construction season.
- Next 1–2 years may see slightly higher I&C growth than the past, supported by the restructured contract terms and the signed pipeline.
EV Risk: Framed as Distant, with Near-Term Counterpoints
- EV impact judged not material for 7–8 years: Management’s base case is that diesel-to-CNG conversion will run faster in the next 3–4 years, sustaining the 5–6% volume growth trajectory for the next 5–6 years.
- Mumbai’s EV bus adoption faces physical constraints: BEST’s supplier commitment on EV buses is not being fulfilled; space constraints for charging and bus storage, lower EV bus range requiring more buses, and higher CAPEX all act as brakes, with BEST currently operating the lowest number of buses in its history and 45-minute queuing times.
- Counter-examples exist outside Mumbai: Pune’s PMPR is switching back to CNG from EV, and MSRTC is adding CNG buses from its diesel fleet on a month-on-month basis.
- Delhi’s aggregator EV mandate is a regulatory overhang: The Government of NCT of Delhi approved a scheme mandating a switch to EV for motor vehicle aggregators and delivery service providers, though it remains subject to the Delhi Governor’s office approval.
Management: "EV adoption of buses in Mumbai will be a slightly challenging job because of space constraint in Mumbai also. Right now, the charging happens at night and the buses run during the daytime. The range of electric vehicle buses is much lower as compared to CNG."
Gas Sourcing, Costs & CAPEX
- Gas cost stability expected through year-end: With HPHT capped at $9.96 and APM at $6.5, management sees costs as stable barring forex moves; very little dependence on spot for CNG and domestic PNG.
- Supply is ample: HPHT is available in sufficient quantity, spot is at reasonable rates, and dependence on spot has reduced due to more term contracts; Reliance and ONGC are expected to come out with fresh HPHT bidding.
- CGD gets first priority for HPHT from February onward: Bidding for November is around 0.4 crore MMSCMD; from February, first priority for HPHT sales shifts to CGD entities.
- Incremental volumes will be fed by tranches of term contracts: As volumes increase, MGL will evaluate and may go for more term contracts depending on the volume offtake expected to rise in the next few quarters.
- H2 CAPEX is always higher: Target is Rs. 700–800 cr, with potential to go up to Rs. 900–1,000 cr.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 5–6% annualized volume growth | Next 5–6 years |
| FY24 volume target | 5–6% growth target; H1 performance puts it at risk | FY24 |
| EBITDA per SCM | Rs. 10–12 achievable on an annual basis; FY24 likely higher after Rs. 14.5 in H1 | Annual, FY24 |
| Gas cost stability | Stable at least till year-end, barring forex moves | Through CY-end |
| I&C contract pipeline | Over 1 lakh SCMD signed; ~0.1 MMSCMD to start from Q4/March quarter | Next few quarters, Q4 onward |
| Unison acquisition | Regulatory clearance expected; numbers could flow in from Q3 | November clearance, Q3 FY24 |
| CAPEX | Rs. 700–800 cr target, up to Rs. 900–1,000 cr possible | FY24 |
| Employee cost | Should normalize QoQ going forward | From Q3 onward |
| OEM incentive schemes | Continuation if successful; no reason to discontinue | Conditional on success |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Overall average sales volume | 3.575 MMSCMD, +4.1% QoQ |
| CNG sales volume | 2.583 MMSCMD, +4.1% QoQ |
| Domestic PNG sales volume | 0.491 MMSCMD, -0.9% QoQ |
| Industrial and commercial sales volume | 0.501 MMSCMD, +15% QoQ |
| H1 overall gas sales volume | 3.494 MMSCMD, +1.2% YoY |
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA | ₹479 cr, vs ₹521 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| EBITDA per SCM | ₹14.6 for Q2; ₹15.6 for H1 FY24 |
| Net profit after tax | ₹338 cr, vs ₹368 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| H1 EBITDA | ₹1,000 cr, vs ₹538 cr in H1 FY23 |
| H1 net PAT | ₹707 cr, vs ₹349 cr in H1 FY23 |
| CNG price | ₹76 per kg, reduced by ₹3 per kg from ₹79 |
| Domestic PNG price | ₹47 per SCM, reduced by ₹2 per SCM from ₹49 |
| CNG vehicles added during quarter | ~19,900, including ~1,300 SCV-LCV |
| Domestic households connected during quarter | 43,051 |
| CNG stations | 319 as on Sep 30, 2023, 7 added during quarter |
| Industrial and commercial customers | 4,639 as on Sep 30, 2023, 120 added during quarter |
| Pipeline length | Over 6,653 km, 40.31 km laid during quarter |
| CAPEX in H1 FY24 | ~₹300 cr; full-year target ₹700-₹800 cr, up to ₹900-₹1,000 cr possible |
| HPHT gas ceiling price | $9.96 per MMBTU, reduced from $12.12 effective Oct 2023 |
| APM gas allocation | ~2.7 MMSCMD |
| HPHT procurement for priority sector | ~0.28 MMSCMD in Q2 |
| CNG volume in kg | 0.19 crore kg per day in Q2; 0.18 crore kg per day in Q1 |
| EBITDA per SCM guidance | ₹10 to 12 sustainable on annual basis; ₹14.5 achieved in H1 |
| I&C contracts signed for future connection | More than 1 lakh SCMD worth, to be connected over next few quarters |