Key Takeaways
- Volume up, EBITDA down: Total gas sales volumes rose 13% YoY to 4.04 mmscmd, but EBITDA slipped to INR399 crores from INR418 crores QoQ as higher opex and a one-time APM gas allocation cut squeezed margins.
- APM gas cut is a structural reset, not a blip: The government reduced APM allocation for CNG by ~20%, and management expects APM availability to keep declining gradually year-on-year, forcing a permanent shift toward costlier new-well and LNG gas.
- Industrial volumes are the new growth engine: A 1.5–2 year push to switch industrial customers from liquid fuel to gas with a guaranteed 10% discount to furnace oil is now paying off, driving a double-digit increase in industrial volume that management expects to continue for at least another year to 1.5 years.
- The INR10–INR12 EBITDA/scm guidance is a floor, not a promise: Management reiterated the range but stressed it is not strict, can go down depending on gas procurement costs, and did not disclose a specific margin floor when pressed.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether MGL raises CNG prices to protect margins after the APM cut, the pace of new-well gas allocation wins, and any update on the PNGRB exclusivity notices that now cover all three of MGL’s GAs.
The APM Gas Shock
- What happened: ONGC changed its classification methodology, triggering a one-time government decision that cut APM allocation for CNG by ~20%. Overall APM (domestic plus CNG) now covers ~71% of requirement, down 13%–14% in absolute terms.
- Why it matters: APM gas is the cheapest input. The cut forces MGL to replace it with new-well gas priced at ~12% of the Indian oil basket (~$9) or spot LNG, permanently lifting the cost base.
- The structural trajectory: Management was explicit that APM will definitely not be available to the extent it is now, and future reductions will be gradual year-on-year. CGD entities do get priority allocation for new-well and HPHT gas, but at higher prices.
- Procurement strategy in flux: MGL is evaluating all options for cheapest gas procurement and will take a pricing call depending on bids received in the next month or so. The rate discovery process will determine how much of the cost increase is retained versus passed through to consumers.
- The unanswered question: When asked why the APM cut was applied to CGD and where the gas was reallocated, management declined to comment, calling it the government’s prerogative.
Management: "I think we are not the right agency to answer this question... pricing and allocation is a prerogative of the ministry. So we don't want to comment much on it."
Volume Growth: Industrial Surge, CNG Steady
- Industrial & commercial breakout: Volume from GA-2 and GA-3 customers switching from liquid fuel to gas delivered a double-digit increase, the payoff from a 1.5–2 year initiative offering a guaranteed 10% discount to furnace oil. One large-volume customer ramped to full requirement in September.
- Sustainability of the industrial run: Management expects low double-digit industrial growth to continue for at least another year to 1.5 years, with new industry contracts already signed for connection in the coming construction season and next year. Sourcing of the incremental volume is partly covered via LNG contracts.
- CNG vehicle additions holding pace: 23,000 vehicles added in Q2, bringing H1 to 44,000 versus 77,000 for all of last year. Incentives for commercial goods vehicles were relaunched in October, and the CNG 2 Mohotsav scheme now subsidizes 50% of conversion cost.
- The discount cushion: CNG currently trades at a ~16%–17% discount to diesel and ~47%–48% to petrol. Management’s empirical observation is that a 15%–25% diesel discount sustains traction for new vehicles and conversions, while the petrol delta provides a substantial incentive even if it narrows to 30%–40%.
- Customer lock-in is the moat: Once a vehicle is on CNG, it has no other fuel choice (diesel vehicles cannot switch back; petrol vehicles can but rarely do). A buyer is hooked for 15 years, so the company’s strategy focuses on getting the vehicle onto CNG in the first place.
- Volume guidance nudged up: First half clocked ~7% growth; management expects to add another 2%–3% in H2, touching a double-digit number for the full year, up from the earlier 7%–8% expectation.
Management: "Today for a new car buyer, CNG is offering almost 50% lower fuel cost compared to petrol today's price. Tomorrow even if that goes down to 40% or 30%, there still remains a substantial incentive to CNG."
Margin Pressure & the Pricing Decision
- Q2 opex headwinds: Operating expenses rose ~INR0.25 per scm from three items: a gratuity policy revision linked to the income tax limit increase (INR20 lakhs to INR25 lakhs), an ex gratia payment, and higher repair, maintenance, and CNG promotion spend. Together the first two cost INR7–8 crores.
- The margin guidance is soft: Management maintained the INR10–INR12 EBITDA per scm range but called it not a strict number, one that can go up or down depending on gas procurement cost. When asked directly for a baseline margin floor, no specific number was given.
- The pricing lever is live but undecided: MGL is evaluating all options for cheapest gas procurement and will take a call on CNG pricing depending on bids received in the next month or so. The decision is an independent Board call weighing alternate fuel prices, procurement costs, operational costs, volumes, margins, and overall strategy.
- Offsetting mechanisms exist: Management pointed to operational efficiencies, depreciated assets, volume growth, procurement efficiencies, and alternate gas sources (Brent-linked, Henry Hub-linked, HPHT, new-well gas, APM gas not connected to the grid) as legroom to absorb the APM cut without fully passing it through.
Management: "It is not a very strict range, that INR10 to INR12 is some sequent number. It is just a guidance. It can go up or it can go down also, depending on the cost of procurement of gas because we will be floating the tenders."
Diversification Bets: LNG, Batteries & the Non-Fossil Push
- LNG retailing is in nascent deployment: MGL’s JV, Mahanagar LNG Private Limited, commissioned its first LNG station in Aurangabad in October, built within six months of land availability. A second station followed days later. Over the next two years, several more stations are expected from MLPL and other players like GAIL, IOC, and OMCs.
- The LNG thesis: One LNG fill delivers ~1,000 kilometers of range. Management sees electric vehicles as infeasible for long-haul heavy commercial use due to prohibitive capex, range anxiety, charging time, battery weight, and replacement cost. Hydrogen is 10–15 years away, leaving a long runway for LNG in trucking.
- EV battery manufacturing JV: MGL signed a non-binding term sheet with International Battery Company USA to set up a 1 GWh cell manufacturing facility in India (two phases of 500 MWh each), with proposed equity investment of ~INR385 crores. The Korean partner has a pilot plant in Korea and is testing products in Indian road conditions.
- Scale ambition: The factory can be scaled to 5 GWh in 2–3 years depending on first-phase performance. Management’s stated diversification target is to have at least 20%–25% of revenue and bottom line from non-fossil new areas.
- UEPL merger: The Board approved the merger of Unison Enviro Private Limited with MGL, which will add 85–90 stations to the combined network this year. The scheme is subject to NCLT and regulatory approvals.
Management: "If we talk about electric vehicles on long haul or heavy commercial vehicles, it is not feasible considering the very prohibitive capex, the range anxiety, the charging time and the weight of the battery and the replacement of the battery in a period of time."
Regulatory Overhang: Exclusivity & Allocation Risk
- PNGRB exclusivity notices: End-of-exclusivity notices have been sent covering all three of MGL’s GAs. The matter is subjudice; the court has given PNGRB freedom to conduct consultation, but any action with adverse impact on CGD entities requires a court check. Management did not answer a question on implications before the moderator moved on.
- APM allocation methodology: The cut is applied uniformly across all CGD entities based on a formula: last quarter’s average consumption is the demand base, availability projections are taken, and the percentage cut is applied irrespective of the number of GAs. This means MGL cannot negotiate its way to a better share within the CGD pool.
- New-well gas allocation: MGL bid for short-term allocation up to 31st March 2025 but did not get the full quota it quoted for. More gas is expected to come online, but the company declined to specify what percentage of the lost APM requirement it recouped, saying only “Not exactly” and promising to revert.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | Full-year volume growth of ~10% (7% achieved in H1, plus ~3% in H2) | FY25 year-end |
| EBITDA margin | INR10–INR12 per scm, subject to gas procurement cost and volume growth | Ongoing, no terminal date |
| Industrial & commercial growth | Low double-digit growth to continue | At least another 1–1.5 years |
| Capex | INR800–INR900 crores, with budget geared up to ~INR1,000 crores if conditions are positive | FY25 |
| Station expansion | 85–90 new stations combined with UEPL | FY25 |
| Battery JV signing | Definitive shareholder agreement to be closed | A few months from now (Q2 FY25 call date) |
| Battery factory scale-up | 1 GWh initial, scalable to 5 GWh | 2–3 years from first gigawatt performance |
| Diversification target | 20%–25% of revenue and bottom line from non-fossil new areas | No date given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Total sales volume (MGL standalone) | 4.042 mmscmd, +13.07% YoY and +4.75% QoQ |
| Total sales volume (MGL consolidated) | 4.206 mmscmd |
| CNG sales volume | 2.886 mmscmd |
| Domestic PNG sales volume | 0.528 mmscmd |
| Industrial and commercial sales volume | 0.628 mmscmd |
| EBITDA | ₹399 cr, down from ₹418 cr in Q1 FY25 |
| Net PAT | ₹283 cr, down from ₹285 cr in Q1 FY25 |
| EBITDA per SCM | ~₹11, within the guided range of ₹10–12 |
| Full-year volume growth guidance | ~10%, up from earlier guidance of 7–8%; H1 growth was 7% |
| APM gas allocation (CNG + domestic PNG) | 71% overall; CNG allocation down to 57–58% after reallocation, a 20% cut on CNG |
| CNG vehicles added during the quarter | 23,000, comprising ~15,000 private cars, 6,000 three-wheelers, ~1,200 two-wheelers, and rest commercial vehicles, buses, taxis |
| CNG stations (MGL standalone) | 352 as on 30 Sep 2024, 5 added during the quarter |
| CNG stations (UEPL) | 64 as on 30 Sep 2024, 7 added during the quarter |
| Domestic households connected during the quarter (MGL standalone) | 58,845 |
| Industrial and commercial customers (MGL standalone) | 4,920 as on 30 Sep 2024, 99 added during the quarter |
| H1 capex | >₹400 cr; full-year guidance ₹800–900 cr, budget geared up for ~₹1,000 cr |
| Discount to diesel | ~16–17% |
| Discount to petrol | ~45–50%, between 47–48% |