Key Takeaways
- Volume-led quarter, margin resilience holds: CNG volumes grew 6% YoY and industrial volumes grew over 20%, while EBITDA per scm stayed at 13.29, cushioned by a favorable shift in alternate fuel prices that offset the CNG price cut.
- Industrial strategy is working, visibly: A deliberate shift to guaranteed 10% discounts for new industrial customers added nearly 150,000 SCMD in contracts, with part flowing this quarter and the rest expected in coming quarters.
- APM allocation is the new variable to watch: The APM share dropped from ~84% to 78-80% this quarter, with no formal communication on whether the cut is temporary or structural; management backstops the gap with HPHT but acknowledges the CGD sector's growing demand may push the allocation lower.
- Unison acquisition closes this quarter: PNGRB approval received; consolidation begins Q4, with INR 100-150 crores of capex planned for FY25 to build out infrastructure across three already grid-connected GAs.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the APM allocation stabilizes or drifts lower, the pace at which the 150,000 SCMD industrial contract backlog converts to actual offtake, and any pricing response if petrol/diesel prices fall further.
Volume Growth: CNG & Industrial
- CNG additions accelerating: Quarterly vehicle additions rose from 15,000 in Q1 to 20,000 in Q2 to 22,000 in Q3, partly lifted by the CNG Mahotsav scheme; the passenger car segment alone saw a ~30% uptick. Management expects to touch 80,000 conversions this financial year.
- Commercial vehicle segment still a small piece: Only ~1,500 of the 22,000 quarterly additions were commercial goods vehicles. The base is so small that even the CV scheme's success did not move the needle on overall CNG sales. The bottleneck is transporter perception that CNG prices could cross INR 89 and touch diesel parity, a fear management is working to dispel by pointing to the government's domestic gas policy stability.
- Factory-fitted CVs now available: More than 30 CNG factory-fitted commercial goods vehicle variants are now available up to the 18-20 ton gross vehicle weight range, a segment that previously had no options. Management is partnering with OEMs to offer incentives and convince transporters to switch from diesel.
- Industrial volumes: GA-1 degrowth is relocation, not loss: Industries shifting out of GA-1 (e.g., Godrej closing Vikhroli) are moving to GA-2 and GA-3, where MGL captures the same volume. The net effect is high double-digit industrial growth, exceeding 20%.
- Station capacity built ahead of demand: Compression capacity is increasing at over 10% while sales volumes grow at 6-7%. Management is deliberately overbuilding, believing capacity creation drives demand by making CNG visibly available and convenient.
Management: "Your compression capacity probably is increasing at more than 10%, where the sales volumes are going at 6%, 7%. But when we intend to pursue that because we believe that once you create the capacity, the demand will pick up."
Gas Sourcing & Cost Structure
- APM allocation dropped without warning: The APM share fell from ~84% to 78-80% this quarter, understood to be possibly due to ONGC production constraints. Allocation is communicated only monthly, with no prior indication. Management expects the CGD sector's growing demand to push the APM share slightly lower over time, but backstops priority-segment requirements with HPHT gas.
- Spot LNG exposure is minimal: Only ~2% of gas came from spot RLNG, IGX, or HPHT for peaking requirements this quarter. The rest is tied up in mid-term and short-term LNG contracts. Management expects minimal spot usage going forward and will bid for additional HPHT if available.
- HPHT availability set to expand: Some HPHT gas is expected to come onto the market this financial year and next as Reliance and ONGC contracts expire and fresh bidding rounds open. Other term contracts indexed to Henry Hub and Brent are already signed and can be drawn on.
- Alternate fuel prices helped margins this quarter: LDO prices rose from INR 61,350 to 72,000 per KL and FO from INR 47,500 to 52,800, while 19 kg LPG fell from INR 1,700 to 1,641. Had this improvement not occurred, the INR 3 CNG price cut would have reduced sales realization; instead, industrial realizations held up.
Ashu Shinghal: "We see that minimal spot we will be using. We'll be also taking up any further HPHT if it is available through bidding in the next few rounds. So as far as gas cost is concerned, yes, and availability of gas is concerned, priority segment very well under control."
Industrial Customer Strategy
- A deliberate pivot one year ago: Management now guarantees a 10% discount for three years to any new industrial customer in GA-3 and any new large industrial customer in GA-2. This replaced an earlier, less aggressive approach and has already added nearly 150,000 SCMD worth of contracts. Part of that volume started flowing this quarter; the remainder is expected in a couple of quarters.
- Connectivity built into difficult areas: Pipelines have been extended into Patalganga and Taloja MIDCs, including a direct connection into the Godrej & Boyce factory at Khalapur, unlocking demand in areas that were previously hard to serve.
- Spot LNG opportunity passed through: Large industrial customers are being offered additional discounts if they consume more volumes, with MGL cashing on the spot LNG price opportunity to drive offtake, particularly in GA-3, Taloja, and Patalganga MIDC.
Management: "But consciously, for increasing our volumes and penetration, we changed that a year back, and we now guarantee a 10% discount for 3 years for any new industrial customer in GA-3 and any new large industrial customers in GA-2."
Pricing Strategy & Competitive Position
- CNG retains a deep discount to petrol: Fuel cost in CNG is roughly half that of petrol per kg vs per liter, and with a 15-20% mileage uptick, CNG is almost 50% cheaper in running rupees per kilometer. Management believes even a INR 5-10 drop in petrol would not materially impact CNG demand. The discount to diesel is narrower, at about 18-19%.
- Pricing response to fuel price cuts is reactive, not preemptive: If petrol or diesel prices fall, management will first gauge market reaction by watching sales volume growth. It will intervene with a CNG price cut only if it sees a slowdown in growth, calling it too early to speculate on triggers.
- Competition from multiple players is sub judice: The PNGRB chairman's statement about allowing multiple players where exclusivity has ended, specifically relevant to GA-1, is under challenge in the Delhi High Court. Management declined all comment, saying it awaits the court's decision.
- No near-term acquisition targets: Management is scouting for opportunities but sees nothing substantial in the market. It expects consolidation possibilities only after the minimum lock-in period expires for other CGD license holders.
Management: "We'll basically first gauge the reaction from the market. If our sales volume increase is not impacted too much, we may not intervene, but if we see any slowdown in the growth, then we may take a conscious call to do something on pricing."
Unison Enviro (UEPL) Acquisition
- Deal closing imminently: PNGRB approval for the transfer of control from Ashoka Buildcon (including shares held by Morgan Stanley/North Haven India Infrastructure Fund) has been received. The transaction will be consumed within Q4 itself, and payment is expected to complete in 2-3 weeks.
- Consolidation begins next quarter: From Q4 onwards, UEPL results will be declared alongside MGL results, with both standalone and consolidated numbers available. UEPL is already EBITDA positive, though management declined to share specific PAT or EBITDA figures ahead of the public disclosure.
- All three GAs are grid-connected: Each of Unison's three geographical areas is already connected to GAIL's main grid pipeline, with gas availability at the main hub. The Dabhol LNG loading facility, less than 50 km from Ratnagiri, is commissioned or about to be, offering a proximate LNG source.
- Capex plan: INR 100-150 crores in FY25: After takeover, management will thoroughly review the minimum work program and intends to be aggressive on capex to put basic infrastructure in place. The ultimate potential of Unison is estimated at ~0.12 crore mmscmd.
- Procurement optimization on the agenda: Management will relook at UEPL's existing gas procurement contracts and try to optimize transportation costs once the acquisition is complete.
Infrastructure & Expansion
- CNG station rollout continues at pace: 45 new stations are being added this financial year, with a similar number expected next year; the bulk will be commissioned in the last quarter. An almost equal number of stations are being upgraded with additional dispensers, compressors, or conversion from DBA to online stations.
- LNG station commissioned at Savroli: The first LNG station is operational, and LNG sales to B2B customers have commenced, though volumes are low and the impact on total financials will be minuscule.
- Raigad unlocking begins: The first CGS and first mother filling station at Savroli in GA-3 have been commissioned, enabling expeditious demand unlocking in Raigad.
- BMC MOU progressing slowly: An MOU was signed last year; discussions on the concession agreement and related land documents are ongoing and expected to take 1-2 months before proceeding. From the date of signing, the plant will take roughly 1.5 years to build.
- No further geographical expansion planned: With 98% of the population already covered and the 12th bidding round focused on Northeastern and Northern areas, management sees hardly anything left to come on the block and has no plans to bid.
- Mitsui O.S.K. Lines MOU signed: The December 2023 MOU covers production and utilization of hydrogen-associated products and LNG for various applications, though no timeline or financial details were disclosed.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Unison acquisition close | Transaction consumed and payment completed | Q4 FY24 (2-3 weeks for payment) |
| UEPL consolidation | Standalone and consolidated results declared alongside MGL | From Q4 FY24 onwards |
| UEPL capex | INR 100-150 crores invested in Unison | FY25 |
| MGL standalone capex | INR 800 odd crores | FY25 |
| CNG station additions | ~45 stations added | FY24, and similar number in FY25 |
| Vehicle conversions | Touch 80,000 conversions | FY24 |
| BMC plant construction | ~1.5 years to build | From date of concession agreement signing (agreement expected in 1-2 months) |
| Industrial contract backlog conversion | Remaining portion of ~150,000 SCMD contracts to start flowing | "A couple of quarters" |
| CNG volume growth | Maintain CAGR of last few years or "maybe better to some extent" | Ongoing; management declined to raise long-term guidance |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total gas volume sales | 3.671 mmscmd, +7.6% YoY |
| CNG volume sales | 2.632 mmscmd, +6.38% YoY |
| Industrial and commercial volume sales | 0.508 mmscmd, +15.84% YoY |
| Domestic PNG volume sales | 0.53 mmscmd, +6.37% YoY |
| Net profit after tax | ₹317 cr, down from ₹338 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| 9-month EBITDA | ₹1,449 cr, +82% YoY |
| 9-month net profit after tax | ₹1,024 cr, vs ₹521 cr in prior 9 months |
| EBITDA per scm (quarter) | ₹13.29 |
| EBITDA per scm (9 months) | ₹14.83 |
| Interim dividend | ₹12 per equity share |
| CNG volume growth in KG terms | ~8% YoY |
| Industrial volume growth | exceeding 20% YoY |
| New vehicle additions | 22,400 vehicles, up from 19,500 in Q2 |
| CNG stations | 320 as on 31st December, 1 added during quarter |
| Industrial and commercial customers | 4,691 as on 31st December, 98 added during quarter |
| Domestic households connected (cumulative) | nearly 0.24 crore |
| APM allocation in priority sector | 78%–80%, down from ~84% in Q2 |
| HPHT allocation in priority sector | 19.5%–20% |
| Spot RLNG consumption | ~2% of total sourcing |
| 9-month capex | ~₹500 cr, full year guidance ₹750–800 cr |
| Cash on books | ~₹2,000 cr+ as on 31st December |
| Unison Enviro volumes | ~0.13 mmscmd, mostly CNG, +18–20% growth |
| Unison Enviro CNG stations | 50-plus |
| HPHT gas price | ~$9.96/MMBtu from October, earlier $12.12 |
| Promotional scheme spend (quarter) | ~₹10 cr, with another ₹20–25 cr budgeted |