Key Takeaways
- Volume growth accelerated, margins compressed: 9M volumes rose 12.75% YoY (CNG +11.4%, industrial/commercial +25.5%), but EBITDA per SCM fell to INR10.3 from INR13.95 as APM gas cuts and delayed price hikes squeezed spreads.
- APM reinstatement is partial and late: Two tranches of APM allocation cuts hit in Oct-Nov; only ~50% of CNG's APM was restored on 16 January, so Q3 bore the full brunt while Q4 gets only partial relief.
- The Bombay High Court catalyst is real but early: A PIL-driven committee will study phasing out diesel/petrol vehicles in Mumbai/MMR in favour of CNG and electric; MGL's MD sits on it, and the report is due in 3 months.
- A battery manufacturing JV diversifies the EV risk: MGL took 44% in a lithium-ion cell JV with IBC (USA), committing INR380 crores in phase 1 toward a 1 GW factory; management claims tested cells and ~18% IRR, but contracts are a year away.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q4 margin rebound materialises as guided, the committee's interim signals on commercial vehicle conversion, and any APM reallocation announcement from 1 April.
Volume & Demand Drivers
- CNG volumes beat the 8% guide: 9M CNG growth of 11.4% already exceeds the full-year expectation; management now sees ~12.5-13% YoY for FY25 and "at least double-digit" next year.
- Industrial and commercial volumes surged: Industrial/commercial PNG volumes grew 25.5% YoY in 9M, driven by new customer additions, though weighted-average realisation dipped because new customers get a committed 10% discount for 3 years.
- Vehicle additions are accelerating: 71,000 vehicles added in 9M vs 57,000 last year; Q4 expected to push the full-year tally close to 1 lakh, with 46% pan-India CNG growth outperforming other fuels.
- Commercial vehicles are the big untapped pool: ~4 lakh commercial vehicles operate in MGL's geographies but only ~38,000 (9.5-10%) run on CNG; management calls this segment a potential "volume churner" if policy tilts toward CNG.
- BEST fleet shrinkage is a near-term drag: BEST buses fell from 4,000 to 3,000, and ~2,000 expected electric buses have not yet materialised; MSRTC added 142 CNG buses in the quarter while BEST, TMT and NMMT added only 37.
Management: "So we see that this commercial vehicle segment could be a volume churner for us if something happens because that could be the first step to control pollution in terms of fuel -- vehicle related burning."
Margin Walk & Gas Sourcing
- The Q3 margin squeeze had three causes: Two CNG price hikes (INR2 and INR1 per kg) came late in November and January, so Q3 saw little benefit; midterm gas was contracted from existing suppliers on repeat order at elevated cost; and APM gas reinstatement only arrived on 16 January.
- EBITDA per SCM fell but stayed inside the guided band: 9M EBITDA per SCM of INR10.3 sits within the INR10-12 range; management expects the same INR9-11 or INR10-12 band to continue, depending on LNG, Henry Hub and other contract prices.
- Q4 margin should improve, not fully recover: APM reinstatement and procurement portfolio adjustments will lift Q4 vs Q3, but the benefit is "slightly reduced" because reinstatement was partial and mid-quarter.
- Henry Hub contracts were hiked after Q3: Contracts increased to ~1.45 MMSCMD post-quarter, which will shape the Q4 cost stack.
- Forex is an unhedged pass-through: All locally purchased gas is dollar-denominated and not hedged (RBI permits only INR forward contracts); industrial and commercial prices are indirectly hedged because they link to alternate fuels that are also dollar-derived.
- APM de-allocation is structural, not one-off: Around 7% per annum of APM is recommended for reduction and shift to NWG; the next re-adjustment is expected from 1 April, and de-allocated volumes will be sold at NWG prices to CGD entities.
Management: "I know that investors are more particular about both the things, one that the margin, second is the volume. So we also have a very clear cut, I mean, line of sight for volume growth which is more important for the longevity of the company. Margins can adjust for some time, maybe slightly higher or lower."
Bombay High Court Catalyst
- A PIL triggered a policy window: The Bombay High Court flagged pollution concerns and directed the state to form a committee to study phasing out diesel/petrol vehicles in Mumbai/MMR, permitting only CNG and electric; it also directed MPCB to act against polluting industrial units.
- The committee is formed and MGL has a seat: The Transport Department notified a committee on 22 January under retired IAS officer Sudhir Kumar Shrivastava; MGL's MD is a member, and the report is due within 3 months.
- Bakery conversions are a small, slow add: The court directed BMC to ensure bakeries switch from wood/coal to gas; management notes these are small establishments and volume offtake "will not be very huge," with connections taking time.
- The Delhi parallel is a reference point, not a forecast: If a directive similar to Delhi's emerges, CNG penetration could rise, but management says giving an exact penetration percentage "is very difficult as of today."
Diversification: Battery Manufacturing JV
- MGL invested INR35 crores for 44% equity in Battery Company India Private Limited, a JV with International Battery Company (USA) for a greenfield lithium-ion cell manufacturing facility in Karnataka.
- Phase 1 capex is INR380 crores of a total INR870 crores for the first gigawatt; the plant can scale to 5 GW with cumulative capex of INR3,700 crores.
- Timeline is 1.5 years to 1 GW: The first 500 MW phase starts in 14 months, the second phase 3-4 months later; management expects ~INR900-1,000 crores revenue from a 1 GW factory.
- Cells are tested, contracts are not: Batteries from a prototype plant in South Korea have been tested in vehicles with customers for a year with positive reports, but offtake contracts will be finalised "maybe 1 year down the line."
- Pricing is import-parity with upside optionality: Selling price is based on China import parity; a duty on Chinese imports would provide upside.
- Return target is ~18% IRR on full project costs, based on a discounted rate of ~18%; management calls the investment "very, very primitive stage" and says confirmed numbers are not yet available.
Management: "we are the only company who have the project ready which is tested on road from the pilot which has been set up at Korea and the same setup is going to be restricted in Bangalore. So that's why we are very positive about this investment."
UEPL Merger & Consolidated Growth
- The amalgamation scheme is in process: Board approved the UEPL merger in October 2024; filed with NCLT Mumbai on 6 December; heard on 17 January 2025; interim order is reserved.
- UEPL is growing 20%+ but earnings drag at consolidated level: Q3 revenue was INR102 crores with net profit of ~INR1.27 crores; 9M revenue INR275 crores, net profit INR17.51 crores. Consolidated results show a minor reduction vs MGL standalone because MGL's investment carries large authorisation cost amortisation that exceeds UEPL's current profits, and UEPL bears higher depreciation and interest (MGL's loan is finance cost in UEPL books). Cash EBITDA is ~INR50-55 crores per annum.
- Tax synergies are immediate post-merger: UEPL's accumulated tax losses and depreciation of ~INR35 crores will be absorbed immediately on a merged-entity basis, versus 3-4 years for UEPL standalone.
- Consolidated volume growth is tracking ~13%: MGL standalone is outperforming the 8% expectation; UEPL is growing 20%+; consolidated growth is ~12% currently, expected ~13-13.5% at year-end, with next year "at least double-digit."
- UEPL capex is ramping: Standalone capex of INR125-150 crores this year, rising to INR150-200 crores next year as groundwork is done for more CNG stations across all three GAs plus Raigad.
Competitive Landscape: EVs & Alternate Fuels
- EV penetration in Mumbai is ~10% (4 lakh EVs), and management expects commercial vehicles will be the first segment impacted by policy intervention.
- CNG still has a 90% addressable gap in commercial vehicles: Management argues that the 90% of commercial vehicles still running on diesel more than compensate for whatever small segment is lost to EVs.
- LNG market outlook supports margins: LNG marketing is expected to be slightly surplus over the next 2-3 years; crude is expected to be costlier relative to LNG, which management believes will help maintain or improve margins over a 1-3 year horizon.
- CNG pricing strategy prioritises stability: Management wants to avoid price disruption and keep CNG prices steady, using a mix of alternate sources to determine the selling price while also watching petrol and diesel parity.
Management: "So that means 90% vehicles are still to be captured by CNG, which is currently running mostly on diesel. So that segment more than compensate for whatever small segment is lost to EVs."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CNG volume growth FY25 | ~12.5% to 13% YoY (raised from 8%) | FY25 full-year |
| Consolidated volume growth FY25 | ~13% to 13.5% YoY | FY25 full-year |
| Consolidated volume growth FY26 | At least double-digit | FY26 |
| UEPL volume growth | 20%+ across all three GAs plus Raigad | Ongoing |
| EBITDA per SCM range | INR9-11 or INR10-12, depending on LNG/HH/other contracts | Ongoing |
| Q4 margin vs Q3 | Improvement expected due to APM reinstatement and procurement adjustments | Q4 FY25 |
| Bombay HC committee report | Report on phasing out diesel/petrol vehicles in Mumbai/MMR | Within 3 months from 22 Jan 2025 |
| IBC battery plant Phase 1 (500 MW) | Production start | 14 months |
| IBC battery plant Phase 2 (1 GW total) | Production start | ~17-18 months (3-4 months after Phase 1) |
| IBC offtake contracts | Finalisation | ~1 year from now |
| UEPL merger | NCLT approval awaited; interim order reserved | No date (hearing held 17 Jan 2025) |
| APM reallocation | ~7% per annum reduction from APM, shifted to NWG | Next adjustment expected 1 April |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated total gas sales volume | 4.308 MMSCMD, up 1.84% QoQ |
| Standalone total gas sales volume | 4.116 MMSCMD, up 1.84% QoQ |
| CNG sales volume | 2.919 MMSCMD, up 1.16% QoQ |
| Industrial and commercial volume | 0.646 MMSCMD, up 2.86% QoQ |
| Domestic PNG volume | 0.551 MMSCMD, up 4.32% QoQ |
| EBITDA | INR313 crores |
| Net profit after tax | INR225 crores |
| EBITDA per SCM (9 months) | INR10.3 per SCM, vs INR13.95 in FY24 |
| EBITDA per SCM guidance | INR10 to INR12 |
| 9-month total gas sales volume growth | 12.75% YoY, to 4.006 MMSCMD |
| CNG vehicle additions (9 months) | 71,000, up 46% YoY |
| CNG stations | 361 as on 31st December, 9 added during the quarter |
| Domestic households connected (cumulative) | nearly 0.27 crore, 98,469 added during the quarter |
| Industrial and commercial customers | 4,974 as on 31st December, 83 added during the quarter |
| APM allocation for CNG | approximately 50%, reinstated from 16 January |
| Interim dividend | INR12 per equity share, 120% |