Key Takeaways
- Volume dipped on CNG pricing, but a sharp price cut is already reversing it: Q4 CNG volume fell 2.6% QoQ as Rs. 89.5/kg pricing slowed vehicle conversions and idled ~300+ BEST buses. An Rs. 8/kg cut on 8th April drove a ~7% week-on-week volume pickup, and the buses are back.
- EBITDA per SCM jumped to Rs. 12.8, the metric management wants judged: Q4 EBITDA rose to Rs. 390 crores from Rs. 256 crores in Q3, driven by a favorable gas sourcing mix. Management insists EBITDA per SCM, not percentage margin, is the right yardstick because gas cost is a pass-through.
- The Kirit Parikh gas-pricing reform is a structural tailwind: The new APM formula caps priority gas at $6.5/MMBtu for two years, and HPHT gas is now allocated on priority to CGD, together covering almost 100% of PNG and CNG volumes since February.
- Raigad and industrial volumes are the next growth leg: The first CGS and mother station are commissioned in GA3, and a new CGS3 pipeline is expected to drive at least double-digit industrial volume growth in FY24 and FY25.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-price-cut CNG volume momentum sustains, the pace of new CNG vehicle conversions, and any progress on the stuck CDU rollout and the BMC biogas plant.
Volume & Demand
- CNG volume hit by price and a one-off: Q4 CNG volume fell 2.6% QoQ. The Rs. 89.5/kg price slowed private car conversions to 9,000 (from 11,000-13,000) and small commercial vehicle additions to 1,300 (from 1,600-2,000). Separately, ~300+ BEST buses were off the road for about a month for testing after an accident, and all were back by April.
- Price cut triggered an immediate response: After the Rs. 8/kg CNG price reduction on 8th April, week-on-week volumes rose ~7%. Management will monitor elasticity and review pricing month-on-month if momentum disappoints.
- Vehicle additions are now almost entirely OEM: Retrofitting is negligible; over 95% of additions come from the OEM market. Management expects better conversion in FY24 as several OEMs launch new CNG models and the price differential widens.
- Domestic PNG grows steadily: Normal annual growth of ~5%-6% is expected, unaffected by the CNG pricing dynamics.
- Long-term volume growth target is 5%-6% CAGR: Raigad industrial volumes and environment-related government or court initiatives could push this higher.
Management: "We will be looking at elasticity of demand as far as CNG is concerned. If we find that the volume momentum as expected is not coming off, then we will review our pricing because at anytime price review is in our hands."
Gas Sourcing & Cost
- Q4 gas cost fell sharply on three drivers: Replacement of Q3 spot gas (avg $33/MMBtu) with HPHT gas ($12.5), spot prices dropping from $33 to $17, and term contract price reductions of $1 to $3 across RIL, GAIL Henry Hub, and GSPC contracts. APM allocation of 2.73 MMSCMD contributed partly but was not the primary driver.
- APM plus HPHT now covers nearly all priority volumes: From February 2023, government allocated HPHT gas on priority to CGD for CNG and domestic PNG. Combined with APM, this covers almost 100% of those volumes, nearly eliminating the need for market-price gas in the priority basket.
- The Kirit Parikh APM formula caps input cost: Effective 8th April, APM gas is priced at 10% slope to the Indian crude basket, with a floor of $4/MMBtu and a ceiling of $6.5/MMBtu for the first two years, then annual escalation of 25 cents.
- New HPHT tie-ups add supply security: MGL recently tied up 0.1 MMSCMD in a Reliance auction at ~$12.12/MMBtu and signed a 5-year contract with Reliance Gas from 1st May for a similar volume.
- Near-term gas cost outlook is benign: For the next few months and 1-2 quarters, gas cost is expected to remain under Q4 levels, with the $6.5 APM ceiling, HPHT availability, spot prices at $10-$12, and stabilized index-linked contracts. The expiring GSPC contract is not a concern because Henry Hub volumes are now fully available and HPHT plus spot can fill any gap.
Margins & Profitability
- EBITDA per SCM is the metric, not percentage margin: Management repeatedly stated that EBITDA margin as a percentage of sales is misleading because gas purchase cost is a pass-through. The correct performance measure is absolute EBITDA per SCM.
- Q4 EBITDA per SCM of Rs. 12.8 was above trend: This compared to a full-year average of Rs. 9.5, driven by the favorable gas sourcing mix. Management is comfortable in a Rs. 9-10 per SCM range going forward and will see how the year rolls out.
- OPEX per SCM is seasonal but stable annually: OPEX per SCM runs lower in H1 and rises in Q3 and Q4 (to around Rs. 5.75) due to maintenance, spares, and post-rains pipeline work. Annual OPEX rose only 6 paisa to Rs. 5.45, which management called normal given inflation.
- I&C margins improved on lower gas cost: Realizations were broadly flat QoQ, so the margin improvement came entirely from reductions in Henry Hub-linked, spot, and term contract gas costs.
Management: "Normally, the cost is pass-through. So, we don't keep that margins with us. EBITDA to the sales is not a correct parameter to judge the performance. Better parameter is EBITDA to the per SCM, i.e., the volume sold."
Infrastructure & Expansion
- CNG station expansion shifts to new GAs: FY24 target is 30-40 new stations and 30-40 upgradations, mostly in GA2 (Thane, Navi Mumbai) and GA3 (Raigad). GA1 (main Mumbai) is largely exhausted.
- Raigad GA is now operational: The first CGS and first mother station have been commissioned in GA3, and CGS3 will connect Raigad industrial consumers, supporting at least double-digit industrial volume growth in FY24 and FY25.
- CDU rollout is stuck in regulatory hurdles: PESO approvals are not permitting deployment in the true spirit of CDU, making the units location-specific and conventional stations more economical. Two to three LOIs have been given but no progress has been made.
- CBG plant with BMC is at a very early stage: Discussions with MCGM cover a 300-400 tonne plant producing ~15 tonnes per day of CBG, but contours are not frozen, no MoU is signed, and DPR and FID are still to come.
- CAPEX guidance is Rs. 500-600 crores annually: This applies to both FY24 and FY25, subject to permissions and space availability.
Management: "Unfortunately, the CDU roll out is still stuck in a few regulatory hurdles. Currently, the approvals which we are getting from PESO are not permitting us to deploy the CDU as it is, in true spirit of the CDU."
Pricing & Competitive Position
- Two CNG price cuts were passed through in quick succession: Rs. 2.50/kg effective 1st February and Rs. 8/kg effective 8th April, alongside a Rs. 5/SCM domestic PNG cut on 8th April.
- Further cuts depend on elasticity and cost: Management will review pricing month-on-month, trading off volume and price based on observed demand elasticity, petrol/diesel prices, and total procurement cost. No commitment was given on further reductions.
- CNG retains a structural discount to liquid fuels: Management did not quantify the payback period for light commercial vehicle conversion but pointed to the CNG-diesel differential and OEM model availability as the key adoption drivers.
Corporate Developments
- UEPL acquisition closing expected by October-November 2023: The lock-in period ends in September 2023, after which final approval, share transfer, and money transfer will take place.
- Final dividend of Rs. 16 per share declared: Total dividend for FY23 is Rs. 26 per share (260%).
- Revenue and margin-percentage targets were declined: Management called revenue a meaningless metric because gas cost is pass-through, and redirected margin discussions to absolute per-SCM measures.
- Granular volume splits were not provided: Management declined to break out industrial from commercial volumes (citing classification changes), GA1 vs GA2 growth rates (citing seamless connectivity), and the split between new OEM vehicles and conversions or between cars and trucks.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Long-term volume growth | 5%-6% CAGR, with upside from environmental initiatives | Long-term (no end date) |
| FY24 APM allocation | 88%-90% of requirement | FY24 |
| CNG station expansion | 30-40 new stations, 30-40 upgradations | FY24 |
| Annual CAPEX | Rs. 500-600 crores | FY24 and FY25 |
| Industrial volume growth | At least double-digit increase | FY24 and FY25 |
| Gas cost | Expected to remain under Q4 levels | Next few months, 1-2 quarters |
| EBITDA per SCM | Comfortable in Rs. 9-10 range | FY24 (to be seen how year rolls out) |
| UEPL acquisition close | Final approval and share transfer | October-November 2023 |
| CNG pricing review | Month-on-month review based on elasticity and cost | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Average sales volume | 3.372 MMSCMD, down from 3.412 MMSCMD QoQ |
| CNG volume | 2.41 MMSCMD, down 2.6% QoQ |
| Domestic PNG volume | 0.51 MMSCMD |
| I&C volume | 0.452 MMSCMD |
| EBITDA | ₹390 crores, up from ₹256 crores QoQ |
| Net PAT | ₹269 crores, up 56% QoQ from ₹172 crores |
| EBITDA per SCM | ₹12.8, full year ₹9.5 |
| Operating cost per SCM | ₹5.45, up 6 paisa YoY from ₹5.39 |
| FY23 total dividend | ₹26 per share, 260% on face value of ₹10; final dividend ₹16 per share |
| CNG vehicle conversions | 13,700, down from 15,500-17,000 in Q2/Q3 |
| Commercial vehicle conversions | ~1,350 |
| New CNG stations added in Q4 | 12, total 313 as of 31st March 2023 |
| Domestic households connected in Q4 | 92,274, cumulative ~22 lakh |
| I&C customers added in Q4 | 115, total 4,558 |
| Pipeline laid in Q4 | 128 km, aggregate length 6,535 km |
| APM gas allocation | ~92%-93% for FY23; expected 88%-90% for FY24 |
| HPHT gas used in Q4 | ~0.19 MMSCMD |
| Spot RLNG bought in Q4 | ~0.14 MMSCMD |
| CNG price reduction effective 8th April 2023 | ₹79 per kg, down from ₹87 per kg |
| Domestic PNG price reduction effective 8th April 2023 | ₹49 per SCM, down from ₹54 per SCM |
| Week-on-week volume increase after 8th April price cut | ~7% |
| FY24 CAPEX guidance | ₹500-600 crores |
| FY23 CAPEX | ~₹580 crores |
| UEPL subsidiary volume FY23 | ~0.1 MMSCMD |