Key Takeaways
- Flat revenue, rising costs: Turnover was flat YoY at ₹114 Cr while raw material prices rose 25–30%, compressing margins. Management expects the pressure to persist through Q2 before normalizing from Q3.
- Production doubled but sales lag: Production tonnage increased ~2x YoY, pushing Value of Production up ~90%. The sales conversion of that higher output is expected in Q2 and Q3.
- Order book anchored by space and naval: The ₹1,377 Cr order book is dominated by space (~₹600+ Cr) and naval (~₹300+ Cr) programs, with a target of ~₹1,000 Cr in new orders this year.
- Wide plate mill begins to pay back: Stopping outsourcing of plate rolling saved ₹4–5 Cr in Q1, with a full annual savings potential of ₹60 Cr once the facility runs at full capacity.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the higher production volume converts into sales as guided, the trajectory of raw material costs, and any order inflow from the Sukhoi engine certification process.
Top-Line & Volume Dynamics
- Flat turnover despite output surge: Q1 FY23 turnover was flat YoY at ₹114 Cr even though production tonnage doubled. The disconnect is timing: higher Value of Production sits in inventory and is expected to convert to sales in Q2 and Q3.
- Dispatch mix confirms defense dominance: Q1 dispatches were led by space at 37% and defense (including PSU) at ~48%, with energy and exports making up the remaining ~11%.
- Geopolitical disruption hit sales, not execution: Some sales were affected in the last financial year due to supply disruptions from the Ukraine/Kazakhstan region, but no execution delays occurred.
Dr. S. K. Jha: "We have given the target of around 25% growth every year, so the idea behind that 25% it is coming under every field since we have to grow by 25% profit also has to go importantly."
Margin Pressure & Raw Material Headwinds
- Raw material cost spike: Raw material cost as a percentage of sales was very high because production tonnage more than doubled, increasing raw material consumption, while prices of nickel, moly, and cobalt rose 25–30% YoY.
- Fuel and power costs added to the squeeze: LPG costs and power from Telangana State Power Corporation rose as captive power plant supply was unavailable, compounding the margin pressure.
- Margin pressure expected to persist through Q2: Management guided that the impact will continue in the second quarter and may normalize only from Q3 onward.
- Scrap substitution provides partial relief: Improved utilization and scrap consumption helped compensate for raw material cost pressure in Q1, but full-scale scrap substitution is limited by technology and product quality requirements.
- Management declined to forecast net margins: When asked for net margin guidance, the CMD said it is "very difficult to predict right now" and suggested analysts are better positioned to forecast.
Dr. S. K. Jha: "There will be a pressure on the margin level of raw material, not only for Midhani for any metal company... first two quarters we will find the impact of that."
Inventory: Elevated & Sticky
- High inventory driven by raw material prices: Inventory stands at ~₹1,000 Cr against ~₹800 Cr in annual revenue, inflated by a 30–40% rise in raw material prices and supply chain disruptions that forced bulk purchasing.
- Scrap consumption efforts offset by price rises: Management is trying to reduce inventory by consuming scrap, but the benefit has been neutralized because raw material prices rose 30–40%, keeping the value of remaining inventory elevated.
- Near-term reduction not expected: Efforts to reduce inventory through scrap consumption are ongoing, but management does not expect a meaningful reduction in the near term due to elevated raw material prices and supply chain disruption.
- Inventory includes value addition, not just raw material: The change in inventory figure is higher than raw material consumed because inventory is valued at various stages of finishing, incorporating power, fuel, and labour costs.
Dr. S. K. Jha: "...unfortunately when we are trying to minimize it the raw material prices have gone up, so whatever we are trying to reduce by consuming scraps they have not been reflected because straightaway the raw material prices have gone by 30%, 40%..."
Order Book & Program Pipeline
- Order book composition: The ₹1,377 Cr order book is predominantly space (~₹600+ Cr) and naval (~₹300+ Cr), with missile, energy, aero, Airbus, and railway making up the balance.
- FY23 order inflow target: Management expects to secure ~₹1,000 Cr in new orders this year, mainly from defense, against an annual plan turnover of ~₹950 Cr.
- Sukhoi engine certification in final stage: A committee has been formed to expedite certification of indigenized products, with Midhani as a member. The total engine opportunity runs into thousands of crores, but Midhani's share depends on the quantity leveraged from them and no order has been placed yet.
- Adour engine parts follow-on order: Midhani received a regular follow-on order worth ~₹66 Cr from HAL after executing 40 sets.
- NALCO JV progressing: Land acquisition and environmental clearances are in place, a consultant has been appointed, and tenders have been floated for equipment and technology suppliers. Project execution is expected to take 1.5–2 years from order placement.
- Pinaka missile opportunity limited: The material component is very low-alloy steel with low value and low margin; management said Midhani may not be able to compete on material supply and will participate in open tenders to try to become L1.
Dr. S. K. Jha: "...it is basically the low alloy steel where the margin will be very less probably Midhani we may not able to compete as far as material is concerned."
Strategic Initiatives & Cost Savings
- Wide plate mill now operational: Outsourcing of plate rolling has been stopped, generating Q1 savings of ₹4–5 Cr. Full annual savings of ₹60 Cr are expected once the facility runs at full capacity.
- Rohtak plant ready, awaiting tenders: The Rohtak plant for bulletproof jackets is ready. Management expects tenders to be floated following DAC approval and will assess specification (BIS VI) and tender value before sizing the opportunity.
- Scrap theft incident addressed: Nine tons of scrap were confiscated in what management called a serious incident. Corrective actions have been taken to make systems foolproof, and the financial damage was described as very limited.
- Consultant engaged for business potential assessment: A consultant has been engaged to provide normalized inventory level projections and business potential assessment. The business potential figures are under evaluation by the ministry.
Indigenization & Long-Term Opportunities
- Fighter jet indigenization is a 4–5 year story: Progressive indigenization of aero-engine and frame materials is expected to reflect better in 4–5 years once complete. Currently, much of the material is imported, leaving very limited quantities for domestic supply.
- LCA opportunity tied to certification progress: Per-aircraft raw material requirement is ~₹25–30 Cr, with current orders at ~₹20–25 Cr. This is expected to grow as indigenization progresses; HAL initially sourced from outside due to lack of certification.
- UCAV trial completed: India's first trial of an Unmanned Aerial Combat Vehicle using the Kaveri dry engine has been completed with reported good performance. If the engine clears trials, India may go in a big way to manufacture the craft, creating recurring orders.
- Titanium monopoly confirmed: Management stated that Midhani is the only company in India producing titanium, describing certain technologies as strategic in nature that cannot be discussed on an open platform.
- Export ambition: Export is targeted to grow from ~\$1.75 million to \$5 million, nearly 3x, with management aiming for 4x.
Dr. Sanjay Kumar Jha: "Now the fighter plane whether the engine has to be purchased from the outside or made in-house, so these are the different ifs and buts west are there, so work is go in that direction, but if it is getting from the outside, the entire thing will be coming from the outside only."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Sales conversion from higher VoP | Higher Value of Production and inventory to reflect in sales output | Q2 and Q3 FY23 |
| Margin pressure | Pressure on margins expected to continue | Q2 FY23; may normalize from Q3 onward |
| FY23 order inflow | Secure ~₹1,000 Cr in new orders, mainly from defense | FY23 |
| Annual plan turnover | ~₹950 Cr | FY23 |
| NALCO JV project execution | 1.5–2 years from order placement | Tenders floated; timeline starts on order placement |
| Wide plate mill savings | Full annual savings of ₹60 Cr | Once full capacity is utilized |
| Growth target | ~25% growth every year across all fields, including profit | Annual |
| Turnover target | Nearly double turnover, aligned with Ministry of Defence target | By 2024–2025 |
| Export target | Grow from ~\$1.75 million to \$5 million (management aims for 4x) | Undated |
| Indigenization benefits | Progressive indigenization of aero-engine and frame materials to reflect better | In 4–5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹114 cr, flat YoY |
| Value of production | Up ~90% YoY |
| Production tonnage | ~2x versus Q1 FY22 |
| Raw material cost increase | 25–30% YoY across nickel, moly, cobalt |
| Order book | ₹1,377 cr, consistent with March 2022 |
| Order book – Space | ~₹600+ cr |
| Order book – Naval | ~₹300+ cr |
| Order book – Missile | ~₹130 cr |
| Order book – Energy | ~₹100 cr |
| Order book – Aero | ₹67 cr |
| Order book – Airbus | ₹65 cr |
| Order book – Railway | ₹12.5 cr |
| FY23 order inflow expectation | ~₹1,000 cr, mainly from defense |
| Annual plan turnover | ~₹950 cr |
| Average order execution timeline | ~1 year |
| Dispatch mix – Space | 37% of dispatches |
| Dispatch mix – Defense (incl. PSU) | ~48% of dispatches |
| Dispatch mix – Energy and exports | ~11% of dispatches |
| Wide plate mill savings | ₹4–5 cr in Q1 from stopping outsourced rolling |
| Adour engine parts order from HAL | ~₹66 cr (regular order after 40 sets) |
| LCA order | ~₹20–25 cr |
| Railway axle order executing | ₹4–5 cr; future indication ~₹15–20 cr |
| Midhani equity in NALCO JV | ~₹170 cr |
| Export revenue | ~$1.75 million current; target $5 million |
| Scrap inventory (FY21 balance sheet) | ₹218 cr; ~70% recyclable |
| Inventory carrying value | ~₹1,000 cr versus revenue of ~₹800 cr |
| Growth target | ~25% annual growth in turnover and profit |