Key Takeaways
- Revenue surged ~60% YoY, order book strong: Q1 revenue jumped on a ₹520 crore order inflow, dominated by defence including a ₹170 crore order and a first-of-its-kind PSLV deal with L&T.
- Export engine is igniting, but early-stage: Rolls-Royce certified MIDHANI's product, GE Aerospace placed an initial order that could grow 3-4x, and Pratt & Whitney is engaging, yet all remain at qualification or initial-supply stage with no committed volumes.
- Margin ceiling lowered to 25%: Management walked back any 28-30% EBITDA margin assumption, stating 25% would be "great", as competitive export pricing and a mix shift to costly super alloys pressure percentage margins even while absolute profits grow.
- NALCO JV shelved on viability: The high-end aluminum project is held up indefinitely after demand forecasts failed to support a bankable DPR, removing a potential capital drain but also a diversification avenue.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Arjun MBT armor order is signed this quarter as management expects, whether GE Aerospace follows through with a scaled-up order, and whether the titanium capacity expansion commissioned in August begins contributing.
Top-Line Performance & Order Book
- Revenue driver: A ~60% YoY revenue increase and 26% VoP growth came from substantial sales volume increase, not price-led gains.
- Order book composition: Q1's ₹520 crore inflow was a mixed bag with majority from defence, including a ₹170 crore defence order, a ₹95 crore PSLV order from L&T (first-of-its-kind public-private participation with L&T and HAL consortium), ₹50 crore from aerospace, ₹30 crore exports, and the balance from defence including missiles.
- Order execution cadence: Export orders can execute in 3 months, some naval orders span ~2 years, and the average order book execution period is about 1 to 1.5 years.
- Short-cycle preference: Short-cycle orders are better for the company because they bring quick money, though margins depend on the domain: international supply chains and competitive domestic bidding both pressure pricing.
- Order book target unconfirmed: Management gave a breakup of the current order book but did not confirm an analyst's question about crossing ₹2,000 crore by year-end.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "Today aero engine market is a big market. If we are able to even serve the 2% also I am just saying 2% also it will be a very big achievement for us."
Export Progress & Qualification Pipeline
- Rolls-Royce: Certified and cleared MIDHANI's product; the company is now looking for the next order.
- GE Aerospace: Placed an initial order after checking material properties; based on this supply, quantity could increase 3-4 times. MIDHANI is also trying to get qualified as a material supplier to GE's aero engine domain, especially as GE is setting up a facility in India with HAL, though this is in the preliminary stage with no commitment yet.
- Pratt & Whitney: Material was provided and the company agreed to provide new requirements.
- Tata Boeing: MIDHANI has explored inclusion in the Tata Boeing supply chain for its Hyderabad facility making civilian aircraft assemblies and is already discussing with their team.
- Export order target: The target is to go for more than ₹100 crore in export orders for the year.
- Competitive reality: Export markets are not on a nomination basis; customers compare both quality and price, so margins will be under pressure. The first task is to get qualified and prove quality at an acceptable cost.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "definitely they will not only compare the quality, they will also compare the price also, first our task is to get it qualified, our quality should be proven with the cost also"
Margins: Percentage Pressure, Absolute Growth
- Margin ceiling reset: When asked if 28-30% EBITDA margin was a fair medium-to-long-term assumption, management responded that 25% is the max and crossing 25% would be great, effectively declining to confirm the higher range.
- Structural cost headwinds: Raw material cost will definitely remain on the higher end because the product mix has shifted to very high-end super alloys at ₹4,000/kg (vs steel at ₹2,000/kg), requiring costly inputs like nickel, cobalt, moly, and tungsten. Super alloy volumes have increased dramatically: one quarter of last financial year equaled the entire previous year's quantity.
- Absolute profit commitment: Management assured that while percentage margins may not come, absolute EBITDA, net profit, and PBT will go up. The plan is to increase revenue more than concentrate on margins and utilize facilities at optimum extent.
- Competitive pricing pressure: Both international supply chains and competitive domestic bidding put pressure on pricing, though the opportunity is good and the company is managing to maintain margins despite increased costs from international market conditions.
N. Gowri Sankara Rao: "the margins may not come in percentage terms but we assure that in absolute terms the margin will go up, it means EBITDA, our net profit, PBT and all will go up and our plan is to more increase the revenue than concentrate on margins and utilize our facilities at optimum extent."
Capacity Expansion & Capex
- FY24 capex plan: ₹80 crore planned for the year, covering an aerospace fasteners plant (currently largely imported), a titanium plant for reverts and capacity enhancement, bar and wire facility modification for filler wire opportunities, and skull smelting for titanium castings.
- Wide Plate Mill ramp-up: Commissioned and operating for 1.5 years; delivered ₹45 crore revenue last year while operating only 1.5 quarters; targeting ₹150 crore from that facility this year.
- Titanium capacity: The expanded facility is being commissioned this month (August 2023), adding almost 500 tons extra to reach around 750 to 800 tons per annum.
- Rohtak facility: Commissioned for armour products.
- Future super alloy capacity: Good demands are coming; MIDHANI may need to augment more facilities and projects for future equipment have been planned.
Inventory Challenge
- Elevated inventory: Inventory is high due to the nature of the business, with nickel-based alloys costing ₹4,000-₹5,000 per kg. The company has a plan to reduce it and faces regular review by auditors, the audit committee, the board, and directors.
- Aerospace purity constraint: The aerospace industry requires pure raw material with no recycled material allowed for aero engines or moving parts. All reverse and recycled material generated in the process remains lying with MIDHANI, creating a structural inventory buildup.
- Liquidation plan: The company is trying to find customers, domestic or international, who can accept recycled material to consume this inventory. Orders may come "maybe in next year or maybe two years."
- No specific reduction target: When asked for guidance on how inventory will be reduced over the next 2-3 years, management gave a general policy statement about zero waste and recycling but did not provide a specific reduction target or timeline.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "We cannot simply take the shelter of nature of business and go on building up the inventory so we have a continuous plan to cut short our inventory."
Indigenisation Opportunity & Platform Pipeline
- Policy tailwind: The Ministry of Defence has taken very quick action on sanctioning requirements. New platforms (Tejas, ALH Helicopter, missiles) are getting sanctioned fast, benefiting MIDHANI and other Indian industry. Existing platforms also need indigenisation of raw material to avoid supply chain cutoffs from Russian and Western-origin platforms.
- Aerospace material opportunities: Opportunities are lined up from Sukhoi and LCA indigenisation (export plan exists), LCA Mk2 (initial orders received), the AMCA project (developmental work in full swing), a 110kN aero engine for AMCA (initial material development program finalized), and various missile programs.
- Arjun MBT armor order: A media article suggesting receipt of an order for armor for Arjun MBT is incorrect; MIDHANI has not received the order and is in the process of negotiating. Management expects it "shortly... in this quarter."
- NALCO JV shelved: The high-end aluminum joint venture is held up because demand forecasts for the next five years do not support a viable DPR for bank loan support. Management concluded investment in that project is not viable as of now.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "we are not able to see the demand in coming next five years so considering that we are not able to make a viable report on the project DPR to go for the support from the loan from the banks and all so it is held up at that stage... we feel that investment in that project is not viable so we are keeping it hold"
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | "Definitely we are adding more than 20" percent top-line growth, above the existing 20% guidance | FY2024 |
| Wide Plate Mill revenue | Target ₹150 crore from the facility | FY2024 |
| Export order inflow | Target more than ₹100 crore in export orders | FY2024 |
| Titanium capacity | Expanded facility commissioned, reaching ~750-800 tons per annum | August 2023 |
| Arjun MBT armor order | In negotiation; management expects signing "shortly... in this quarter" | Q2 FY2024 |
| Capex spend | ₹80 crore planned across aerospace fasteners, titanium, bar & wire, skull smelting | FY2024 |
| EBITDA margin ceiling | 25% is the max; crossing 25% would be "great" | Medium-to-long term |
| Absolute profit growth | EBITDA, net profit, PBT will go up in absolute terms even if percentage margins do not | Ongoing |
| Inventory reduction | Plan to cut inventory by finding customers for recycled material; orders may come "maybe in next year or maybe two years" | FY2025-FY2026 |
| NALCO JV | Project held up indefinitely; investment not viable as of now | Indefinite |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (sales) | Up ~60% YoY |
| Value of Production (VoP) | Up 26% YoY |
| Order booking | ~₹520 cr, comprising ₹170 cr defence, ₹95 cr L&T PSLV, ₹50 cr aerospace, ₹30 cr exports, balance defence/missiles |
| Order book | ₹1,578 cr, 70% defence, 30% aerospace, railways and others |
| Order book execution period | 1 to 1.5 years average |
| Order book composition | 50% long cycle, 50% short cycle |
| EBITDA margin guidance | 25% max; crossing 25% would be great |
| Capex planned for FY24 | ~₹80 cr |
| Wide Plate Mill revenue target FY24 | ₹150 cr, up from ~₹45 cr last year (operated 1.5 quarters) |
| Export orders target FY24 | More than ₹100 cr; ₹35 cr booked, ~₹15 cr executed, ₹30–35 cr under discussion |
| Titanium capacity post-expansion | ~750–800 tons per annum, adding ~500 tons extra |
| NALCO JV total project cost | ₹4,500 cr, MIDHANI share ~₹170 cr; project held up on viability concerns |
| Raw material cost context | Super alloy at ~₹4,000–5,000 per kg for single elements, vs steel at ~₹2,000 per kg earlier |