Key Takeaways
- Flat quarter, one project to blame: A single large US auto robotic-simulation project went on hold in late November/December, flattening revenue and pushing MES EBITDA down to 13%-14%. The project is expected to reopen mid-February with work from March.
- Employee cost spiked 30% as capacity was built ahead of demand: 173 trainees, 12-15 seniors, and new BD hires hit the P&L in Q3, creating a trough in utilization that management calls the benchmark worst case. Revenue from these investments is expected from Q1 FY25.
- Civil structural kept growing and carries the floor: Civil grew 7% despite high US inflation and a flat construction market, driven by outsourcing share gains and a 200+ client base. Management sees a path to 15%-20% civil growth if the US industry picks up even modestly.
- New segments and an acquisition are the growth-acceleration bets: The company is adding press tools, dice, wiring harnesses, and SPM, while pursuing a structural engineering acquisition via high-end M&A firms. Both are expected to contribute from FY25, with structural engineering promising much higher EBITDA margins.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the held MES project actually restarts in March, the pace of trainee billability as they exit training in April-May, and any concrete progress on the structural engineering acquisition timeline.
The Q3 Hold-Up: One Project, Concentrated Impact
- Single-project dependency in MES: A major robotic simulation project from a leading US auto company, executed through a Mexican Tier-I contractor, went on hold during the last weeks of November/December. The client is now talking about reopening it in mid-February with work starting from March.
- Capacity paradox made it worse: Because capacity was full when another MES project was awarded in September/October, the company declined it. That work went to competitors, and then the large project was delayed, leaving paid-for capacity idle.
- MES client concentration amplifies volatility: MES has only 3 Tier-I and 7-8 Tier-II contractors, versus civil's 200+ clients and 25-30 larger accounts. When one MES client pauses, there is no offsetting flow from others.
- January order book improved sharply: More than $1.5 million worth of projects were blocked in January, driven by improving credentials and repeat orders rather than any change in the economic situation.
Rao: "It was a major project from one of the leading automobile companies in USA executed by a Mexican Tier-I contractor for the robotic simulation, supply of robotics and simulation. So that project has gone into hold during the last weeks of November December and just now they are talking about reopening it."
Employee Cost & The Utilization Trough
- Cost spike was deliberate, not runaway: Employee costs jumped ~30% because of three simultaneous investments: 173 trainees onboarded in June-July (training active through Q3, costing ₹45 lakhs/month), 12-15 seniors at ~₹1.5 lakhs/month each, and 1-2 BD managers with 3 more joining from March.
- Q3 as the underutilization floor: Management explicitly framed this quarter as the benchmark worst case for underutilization, arguing that once multi-skilled people are available and trainees become billable, the percentage will only improve.
- Trainee billability timeline: The 173 trainees (103 civil, 73 MES) will be fully utilized in FY25, with project-handling capability from April-May onwards.
- MES skill-set mismatch: Different MES software skills (PS, Delmia, NX) are not uniformly available across the workforce. People were added during last year's sudden growth spurt, and retraining is happening now, contributing to the salaried-staff increase.
- Employee cost will keep rising near-term: BD hires still joining through March mean employee cost grows for another couple of quarters before the revenue flow catches up from Q1 onwards.
Rao: "The worst substantial cost could be what happened in this Q3. It wouldn't be worse than that because once we are well equipped with multi skilled people this percentage underutilization also will come down further. So, what I see is this quarter can be taken as a benchmark for as far as underutilization is concerned."
Civil Structural: The Steady Engine
- Growth despite a flat US market: Civil grew 7% in a quarter when US construction was dampened by high inflation and interest rates. The growth came entirely from outsourcing share gains as US contractors and fabricators increasingly prefer Indian vendors with established credentials.
- Client breadth creates predictability: With 200+ clients and 25-30 larger accounts, civil does not depend on any single project or contractor. Work keeps flowing even when individual clients slow down.
- The 15%-20% growth path: If the US construction industry picks up by even 5%-7%, management believes civil can reach a 15%-20% growth bracket because the outsourcing trend is additive on top of industry growth.
- Quality as a growth constraint: The company cannot simply double or triple the team because quality suffers. Historical back-charges of $300K-$500K/year have been brought below $100K, and training engineers to American standards (feet-pound-second system) is challenging when engineering graduates prefer IT and AI careers.
- Connection design is the margin lever within civil: Connection design commands $30-$50/hour versus standard detailing rates, and the team of 15-20 MTech structural engineers already working on it can be extended to member design with some training. The cost delta between BTech (₹25,000) and MTech (₹35,000-40,000) is nominal while pricing is 50%-70% higher.
New Segments & The Structural Engineering Bet
- Four new segments entering trial phase: The company has started picking up senior personnel in press tools, dice, wiring harnesses, and SPM (special purpose machines), and is completing trial projects for leading automotive companies in Europe and Mexico. Revenue is expected from Q1 FY25 onwards.
- Structural engineering acquisition is the margin-transformation play: Offshore structural design can achieve $50-$80/hour pricing with much higher EBITDA than current detailing work, because the cost of MTech engineers is only marginally higher than BTech hires while pricing is 50%-70% more.
- M&A strategy upgraded: The company has moved to high-end M&A firms and is in talks with a couple of targets, with a stated requirement that promoters stay for at least 5 years. One firm with multiple PEs is in very initial discussions.
- Plan B if acquisition fails: Recruit PEs directly (2 already onboard, target 3-4 more in the US), take smaller projects, and build traction organically. That path takes 3-4 years to reach big numbers.
- Timeline is vague but directional: Management's endeavor is to strike a deal in this financial year, acknowledges it is not possible before March, but says "probably in this calendar year at least."
Rao: "The cost arbitrage EBITDA margins will shoot up once we establish in the structural engineering domain."
Sales & BD Build-Out
- Sales team doubling: The MES sales team is expanding from 5-6 to around 10, all qualified with MES experience. The civil BD team of 4 will increase to 7, including an American front-end person. Impact is expected from Q1 onwards.
- US presence expanding: A bigger office has been taken in Atlanta, moving in March-April, capable of housing 10+ people versus the current 5-6. A couple of Americans have been shortlisted and will come on board very soon.
- MES client-base target: The plan is to have at least 10 strong clients in the MES BIW field by May-June, up from the current 3 Tier-I contractors, to reduce single-client dependency.
- Simulation team scaling: A team of 20 strong simulation engineers is in place, with another 20-30 people in training. Resources with prior simulation experience are scarce in India, making this a capacity-constrained growth area.
Technology Initiatives: AI, Drones & API Tools
- AI and drone inspection in early exploration: The company is in very initial talks with a couple of Indian AI companies about using drones and AI for quality control inspection in construction, specifically bolting and welding inspection on high floors. The intent is to take these companies to the US construction industry.
- API tools for efficiency, not AI replacement: The company is building API tools to improve efficiencies and quality checks. These are tool-driven, not directly AI, and must be built to each client's specific standards.
- Management skeptical on AI replacing detailing: The CEO expressed doubt that AI can replace structural detailing in the next 5-10 years, citing the fragmentation of US construction standards as a barrier: AI cannot be a solution unless everyone follows the same standards.
Rao: "I doubt that because at least for the next 5 to 10 years I don't see the technology emerging... AI cannot be a solution unless everybody in the US follows the same standards."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Held MES project restart | Major US auto robotic simulation project to reopen | Mid-February, work from March |
| New segment revenue | Press tools, dice, wiring harnesses, SPM to begin contributing | Q1 FY25 onwards |
| Trainee billability | 173 trainees fully utilized and handling projects | April-May onwards (FY25) |
| FY24 revenue growth | Revised to 10%-13% overall (from 20%-25%) | FY24 full year |
| Minimum growth floor | At least 10% top-line growth certain, driven by civil at 10%-15% | FY24 |
| Next-year growth ambition | At least 20%-25% top-line growth targeted | FY25 |
| Civil growth target | Civil to improve from 7% to 12%-15% | FY25 |
| EBITDA margin | Maintain 28%-30% going forward | Ongoing |
| MES client base | At least 10 strong clients in MES BIW field | By May-June |
| Sales team doubling | Impact of expanded sales team to flow through | Q1 FY25 onwards |
| BD team strength | BD team fully built out | End of March |
| Structural engineering acquisition | Deal targeted; if not, organic Plan B takes 3-4 years | Calendar year 2024 (endeavor) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 13% YoY for nine months, full-year guidance revised to 10% to 13% |
| EBITDA margin | 26%, down from 30-31% in Q3 last year; nine-month margin at 27% |
| Employee cost increase | ~30% YoY, driven by 173 new trainees and 12-15 senior hires |
| Civil structural detailing growth | 7% to 8% for nine months, expected to improve to 12% to 15% next year |
| MES revenue | ₹0.4 crore expected this year, up from less than ₹0.1 crore 2-3 years ago |
| Civil order book | ₹0.32 crore, against monthly turnover of about ₹0.15 crore |
| MES order book | ~$250K, excluding a held-up project of almost $700K |
| Total technical employees | ~1,050, with ~750 in civil and 250-300 in MES, of which ~50% are trainees |
| New trainees added | 173, the highest in the last 10 years |
| Sales team size | Doubling from 5-6 to ~10 members |
| Civil EBITDA margin | ~30% in Q3 |
| MES EBITDA margin | 13% to 14% in Q3, impacted by underutilization |
| Civil clients | More than 200, including 25 to 30 larger clients |
| MES Tier-I clients | 3, with another 7-8 Tier-II clients |
| Next-year revenue growth target | 20% to 25% |