Key Takeaways
- Flat revenue, margin pressure: Q2 revenue grew 3% YoY to INR220 crores, but EBITDA fell 17% and net profit dropped 40%, driven by higher ad spend and annual salary increments.
- Inventory discipline is the margin story: Management guaranteed inventory will be drastically lower by December 31 vs last year, which they expect to reduce discounting and improve margins.
- Winter season is the make-or-break moment: A late winter has delayed dispatches, but sales have started picking up; management expects the season to be at par with last year, not muted.
- Channel pivot underway: Quick commerce partnerships with Blinkit, Swiggy and Zepto are live, while smaller MBOs are being rationalized in favor of larger shop-in-shop formats and EBO expansion.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised inventory drawdown materializes by December 31, the pace of margin recovery toward the 100 bps improvement target, and the actual sell-through of winter stock given the delayed season.
Winter Season & Inventory
- Late winter, late dispatches: Winter arrived later than last year, causing dispatches to shift and inventory to build up on the balance sheet as of September 30; sales began picking up only in the last week before the call.
- Inventory guarantee: Management stated with certainty that inventory levels will have drastically come down compared to last year's levels once the quarter ends December 31, though they declined to share October-end figures when asked.
- Less discounting ahead: Lower inventory pressure gives the company headroom to offer lesser discounts than last year, when excess stock forced heavier discounting and higher sales returns that compressed margins.
- Sales returns target: The company intends to reduce sales returns by at least 10% compared to last year's levels, a direct consequence of tighter inventory management.
- COCO store expansion added to inventory: Company-owned store count increased from 97 to 128, which also contributed to the higher reported inventory figure.
Management: "But one thing which I can guarantee you with surety is that once we end this quarter, 31st December, you would see that inventory level has drastically come down as compared to last year's levels."
Margin Trajectory
- H1 margin hit from advertising: The major impact on H1 margins was advertising spend, which spiked in Q2 due to a new commercial launch; management expects this to even out in Q3 and Q4, keeping the full-year target at 3% of net sales.
- 100 bps improvement still on track: Management remains confident of delivering 100 basis points of margin improvement for the full year, citing a strong October and a November pickup as winters began in the North.
- High-value dispatch mix shift: Q3 normally sees higher-value dispatches compared to Q2, which will also help improve margins in the second half.
- Personnel cost headwind: Salary expenses increased due to regular annual increments, adding to the H1 margin pressure.
- Margin range guidance declined: When asked for a specific annual margin range, management said it was too early to give one and offered to provide a better picture in the next call.
Management: "We are very confident that whatever we have stated earlier in our con call that there can be 100 basis points of margin improvement. So as of now, we don't see any challenge in doing that because October has been very good, and November has just picked up because of now the winters have started in Northern region."
Channel Strategy & Mix
- Quick commerce goes live: The company has closed initial deliveries to Blinkit and Swiggy and is in discussions with Zepto for future collaboration, enabling up to 30-minute deliveries.
- MBO rationalization: Around 50 to 60 smaller MBOs have been closed due to bad payment issues or insufficient business size; the company is shifting focus to larger customers and shop-in-shop formats where sales are higher.
- EBO expansion continues: 8 new EBOs were added in Q2, bringing the total to 430 across 23 states and 4 union territories; guidance remains at 40 to 50 new EBOs for the full year.
- Channel mix stable: The mix is expected to remain broadly similar, with a slight increase in MBOs and EBOs, a slight decrease in large-format stores, and an increase in online sales driven by quick commerce.
- Like-for-like decline offset by expansion: Like-for-like sales declined around 3% to 4% in the first six months, but the addition of new EBOs and online sales is expected to compensate.
- Receivables concentrated in MBO/SIS: Receivables are higher in the MBO and shop-in-shop segment due to 90-day payment terms, while online, LFS and EBO channels see faster collections.
Footwear & New Initiatives
- Online pivot after store misfit: Footwear was initially piloted in around 40 EBOs, but store designs were not suited for selling shoes; the company shifted focus online and is now selling 150 to 200 pairs per day with minimal advertising.
- First round sold out, reorder placed: The initial footwear inventory sold out, and a second order of around 20,000 pairs has been placed, arriving in the next 2 to 3 months.
- Revenue target deferred: Management declined to give a definite footwear revenue number for this year, stating it will not reach INR10 crores this financial year, but said INR10 crores is a target for the next financial year.
- Brand Cloak & Decker: Three EBOs were opened for this brand, with plans to open more in sizes ranging from 500 to 2,000 square feet.
- Salesforce collaboration: A new collaboration with Salesforce aims to streamline operational efficiency and drive customer loyalty and experience.
Management: "We soon realized our EBOs were not - the store design was not accustomed for selling a pair of shoes. Then we took a call that we will focus online, and I'm very happy to tell you, on an average, we're selling 150 to 200 pairs per day online."
Demand & Growth Outlook
- Flat revenue guidance held: The company is sticking to its guidance of flat revenue growth to single-digit growth for this financial year, with H1 revenue marginally down 2% YoY.
- Next year optimism: Even under a pessimistic scenario where everything remains the same, management believes the company can grow around 10% next year, citing expected interest rate cuts and improving demand as inflation eases.
- Winter season at par: Management expects the winter season to be at par with last year, not muted, with top line remaining the same as last year and margin improvement coming from lower discounting.
- Production cut as corrective action: After last year's inventory overhang forced heavy discounting, production this year is lower than last year's level, and stocks at the retail level across EBO, SIS and MBO channels are also lower.
Management: "Even though with a lot of pessimistic view, if we have that, everything remains same, still we'll be able to grow around 10% next year."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Flat to single-digit growth | FY25 |
| Margin improvement | 100 bps improvement for full year | FY25 |
| Sales returns reduction | At least 10% less than last year's levels | FY25 |
| Inventory drawdown | Drastically lower vs last year's levels | By December 31, 2024 |
| EBO expansion | 40 to 50 new stores | FY25 |
| Advertisement spend | 3% of net sales on annual basis | FY25 |
| Footwear revenue | Target INR10 crores | FY26 |
| Next-year growth | Around 10% growth even under pessimistic view | FY26 |
| Inventory data disclosure | Share December 31 inventory level | First or second week of January 2025 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | INR220 crores, +3% YoY |
| EBITDA | INR28 crores, -17% YoY |
| Net profit | INR5 crores, -40% YoY |
| H1 FY25 revenue | INR346 crores, -2% YoY |
| H1 FY25 EBITDA | INR26 crores, -13% YoY |
| H1 FY25 EBITDA margin | 7.52% |
| H1 FY25 net loss | INR5 crores, vs net profit of INR2 crores in H1 FY24 |
| Full-year revenue guidance | Flat to single-digit growth |
| Full-year margin improvement target | 100 basis points |
| EBOs | 430, added 8 in Q2; 40–50 planned for FY25 |
| MBOs | 1,611, down from 1,774 YoY |
| National chain stores plus SIS | 1,212-plus |
| COCO stores | 128 as of Sep '24, vs 97 as of Sep '23 |
| Online sales share | ~7.5% of total revenue |
| Footwear revenue | INR2.15 crores in Q2; INR3.4 crores YTD |
| Sales returns | ~INR52 crores, vs INR55 crores in Q2 FY24 |
| Unencumbered cash balance | INR290 crores as of Sep 30, 2024 |
| Ad spend target | ~3% of net sales annually; INR19 crores spent in H1 |