Monte Carlo Fashions Ltd Q4 FY2024 Concall Summary

Source transcript PDF: https://assets.stockscans.in/docs/8svgh65cxzd4i506dyea28dz.pdf

Key Takeaways


The Q4 Debacle: What Happened

Sandeep Jain: "When we were growing at a 30 CAGR definitely we want to grow 15 or 24 next year also. So you plan more inventory, but the season didn't supported you, it didn't turn out the way we wanted."

Volume vs Value: The Demand Signal

Management: "Our volumes have grown but only because of higher discount the revenue has gone down and because of higher returns the sale has got impacted because when we have to take back the goods we reduce that from the sale, otherwise our revenue was up."

Store Rationalization: Cutting to Repair Profitability


Margin & Cost Actions

Sandeep Jain: "Definitely we admit that, we apologize for that, we failed margin crunch, we never expected that we have to go for such higher discount and such heavily discount..."

Strategic Questions Left Unanswered

Sandeep Jain: "I don't want to say again and again the coming quarters rather myself to speak, I would see that my results speaks for ourselves."

Guidance & Commitments

CommitmentSpecificsTimeline
RevenueFlat revenue in FY25, as ~40-45 new EBOs offset store/channel closuresFY25
EBO openings40 to 45 new EBOs across IndiaFY25
Home furnishing growthMinimum 15% to 20% growth in home furnishings segmentFY25
Finance cost reductionFinance cost to come down 100 to 200 bps as old stock liquidatesFY25
South revenueSouth region to cross ~₹70 crore from existing ₹52 croreFY25
West revenueWest region to reach ~₹90 crore from existing ₹80 croreFY25
Margin visibilityExact EBITDA level to be shared; whether 20% can be maintainedQ2 FY25 conference call
Guidance revision possibilityMay revise guidance upward if market improves and economy rebounds; can produce more sweatshirts/jackets in Sep-Oct but sweaters are difficult on short noticeQ2 FY25, conditional on demand
₹2,000 crore revenue targetOn the cards, depends on economy and discretionary spending3-4 years, no firm date

Key Metrics

MetricQ4 FY24
Revenue₹207 cr, decline of 13% YoY
EBITDALoss of ₹10 cr
Net profitLoss of ₹19 cr
FY24 consolidated revenue₹1,062 cr, de-growth of 5% YoY
FY24 EBITDA₹143 cr, declined 34% YoY
FY24 EBITDA margin13.46%
FY24 net profit₹61 cr
FY25 revenue guidanceFlat, with focus on improving profitability
FY25 profitability outlookSignificant improvement expected over FY24, 20% margin not assured
EBO count411, 55 added in FY24
FY25 EBO addition plan40 to 45 new EBOs
Same-store sales growthZero for full year, minus 3 in December quarter
Online sales₹111 cr, up from ₹91 cr, contribution at 9% of overall sales
Home furnishings revenue₹141 cr, de-growth of ~4% from ₹150 cr
Home furnishings growth outlook15% to 20% growth expected in FY25
Kids segment revenue₹92 cr, ~8% to 9% of turnover
Woolen volume21,46,000 units, up from 19 lakh
Cotton volume76,06,000 units, up from 74 lakh
Western region revenue₹80 cr, grew from ₹69 cr
Southern region revenue₹53 cr, grew from ₹40 cr
Price increase implemented7% to 8% in FY25 across summers and winters
Finance cost increase from lease accounting~₹4 cr
Stores being closed4 to 5 EBOs, 30 SIS, 40 to 50 LFS sale points, contributing ₹20 to ₹25 cr in revenue
Geographical mix88% to 89% of business from Northern, Central and East region
Advance collection at trade showMore than 15% compared to last year