Key Takeaways
- Q4 loss halved, structural drag remains: The seasonal Q4 loss was cut by nearly half year-on-year through earlier provisioning, but the shift toward SIS, LFS and EBO channels permanently raises returns and discounting intensity in the quarter.
- Double-digit FY26 growth guided with confidence: Management is "very confident" of double-digit revenue growth, citing a strong winter trade show order book, a May sales recovery after a muted April, and macro tailwinds from a good monsoon and expected rate cuts.
- Pricing power is the margin engine: Realizations improved because the brand passed through price hikes even as raw material costs stayed flat; lower discounting versus last year added further profitability, and management expects EBITDA to keep improving from current levels.
- Channel mix is reshaping the balance sheet permanently: MBOs are converting into SIS and LFS is growing, so inventory stays on the company's books with no major cycle improvement expected; debtor days should fall 5–10 days as distributor advance-payment terms take hold.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the double-digit growth guidance is revised upward at the Q2 call, the pace of store openings (45–50 Monte Carlo, 10–15 Clock & Decker targeted), and any disclosure on cash deployment plans discussed at the Board.
Q4 Profitability: The Seasonal Loss and Its Structural Shift
- Loss halved by design: The Q4 loss was cut by almost half versus last year because adequate provisioning was taken in Q3, and management commits to repeating that approach next year to cut the loss further or eliminate it entirely.
- Channel mix is the permanent drag: Three structural changes explain why Q4 profitability has diverged from FY22/FY23 levels: returns are now booked in March rather than May/June, End-of-Season Sales start earlier across all brands, and more business flows through SIS, LFS, EBOs and SOR formats, all of which increase returns and compress margins in the quarter.
- Other expenses rose on ad spend: Advertisement and business promotion costs increased by INR10 crores even though turnover did not grow, pushing up other expenses as a percentage of revenue.
- Tax rate spike is one-off: The elevated ~29% tax rate this year stems from a change in the long-term capital gain structure and deferred tax adjustments from budget changes; management states it will not recur next year.
Sandeep Jain: "But as compared to last financial year, we have cut down this loss by almost half. The reason being is that adequate provisioning has been taken in the third quarter. And we will ensure that in next year also, we will take adequate provisioning to cut down the loss or to make it zero."
FY26 Growth Outlook: The Double-Digit Bet
- Confidence anchored in order book visibility: Management is "very confident" of double-digit growth in FY26, grounded in a strong winter trade show that drew over 1,500 retailers and generated a very good order book, plus visibility into Q2, Q3 and Q4 sales.
- Macro tailwinds stacked in favor: A forecasted good monsoon is expected to boost the rural economy and contain food inflation, while a widely anticipated 25-basis-point rate cut in the June policy should further support the economy.
- Muted April, recovering May: The year began with a muted April, but May started very well with a sales recovery; management expects a very good year ahead.
- Guidance revision possible at Q2: If everything tracks to expectation, management may revise guidance upward at the Q2 conference call.
- Summer wear is the structural growth leg: Summer wear volumes have grown every year for the last 4–5 years, even as winter volumes stagnated; summer now represents 30–35% of total annual garment sales, up from 4–5% a decade ago, and management sees the summer-to-winter ratio reaching roughly 45:55 in 1–2 more years.
Rishabh Oswal: "So, there's a lot of difference in the market situation 2 years back and today. So, the last 3, 4 winter seasons have not been that good. And for other brands, winter season constitutes a minority part of the revenue. So now their focus is shifting entirely..."
Margins: Pricing Power, Discount Discipline and the 20% Target
- Pricing power passed through twice: Realizations improved because price hikes were taken last year and again this year; the brand has the power to pass on prices to consumers even though raw material costs have not increased much.
- Discounts are coming down: Lower discounting compared to last year added to profitability, and cost optimizations across expenses, discounts and returns, combined with price increases across all categories, will further improve EBITDA going forward.
- 20% margin target, including other income: Management is confident of touching above 20% EBITDA margin going forward, including other income; excluding other income, the margin should be around 200 basis points lower.
- Finance cost is effectively net-zero: Total finance cost is INR34 crores in actual interest, while other income is also INR34 crores, so on a net basis the company pays nothing to the bank on finance cost; the remaining finance cost line item is asset-liability rent depreciation.
- Cash yield strategy shifted: The company has started investing cash in higher-yield debt instruments instead of debt mutual funds yielding 6–7%, which should support other income.
Sandeep Jain: "So luckily, our brand has a pricing power, and we can pass on the prices to the consumers, even though the raw material prices have not increased much."
Channel Evolution: MBO Decline, SIS Conversion and Inventory Reality
- MBO segment is shrinking structurally: Smaller MBOs cannot compete with larger EBOs or national chains on discounts and are shutting down; bigger MBOs are converting into SIS, and even though the total number of MBOs has fallen, combined MBO and SIS sales are nearly flat because converted stores generate higher revenue per outlet.
- Inventory stays on the books permanently: Because MBOs are converting into SIS and LFS business is growing, inventory remains in the company's cycle; even COCO inventory is booked on the company's books, so inventory will stay at current levels plus or minus 5% with no major improvement expected.
- The small inventory increase resolves soon: A small increase in inventory will be taken care of in the next two quarters.
- Debtor days to improve 5–10 days: Debtors will come down as the company ties up with distributors for advance payment; creditors have already come down because MSME regulations require 45-day payment to vendors, and the company receives discounts from those vendors that reflect in other income.
- Inventory breakup not disclosed on call: When asked for a breakup of how much of the INR503 crores inventory is COCO finished goods and how much is aged beyond six months or a year, management deferred, offering to mail the details later.
Store Expansion and New Channels
- 45–50 Monte Carlo stores, 10–15 Clock & Decker stores planned: The pace of store openings will continue for the next two years with no challenges seen to maintaining that speed; 80–85% of openings will be in Northern, Eastern and Central regions, with 15–20% in Western and Southern regions.
- Clock & Decker EBOs performing: Twelve EBOs have been opened for the Clock & Decker brand, achieving INR8,000 per square foot per annum in sales.
- Quick commerce pilot live: Tie-ups with Blinkit, Zepto and Swiggy are underway; pilots with Blinkit and Swiggy in Delhi NCR cover pre-winter and winter clothing, and the company is also speaking with Swiggy about an exclusive tie-up for the home furnishing category.
- Global expansion in experimentation phase: Products have been sent to the US and Canada under the Monte Carlo brand name via Amazon; a team visited the Dubai IATF trade fair last week; a tie-up with Style from Landmark Group in the UAE will supply around 8,000–10,000 pieces. By the end of this financial year, management expects to be in a better position to give guidance on the global expansion strategy.
- Salesforce and Tableau deployed: The company has installed Salesforce and Tableau software for better retail merchandise planning across EBOs and other stores.
Unanswered Questions and Conservative Posture
- Cash deployment plans exist but are undisclosed: Management confirmed that plans were discussed at the Board meeting but declined to disclose them, saying they may share points at the next conference call; an analyst suggested using cash to grow the business rather than investing for yield would be more prudent.
- No aspirational 3-year target: When asked for an aspirational revenue target over the next three years, management declined, stating a preference for conservative guidance it can achieve.
- Inventory detail deferred: Breakup requests for COCO finished goods and inventory aging were not answered on the call; management offered to mail the information.
Rishabh Oswal: "We would not like to give an aspirational target and not be able to achieve it. So, we are very conservative when we give our guidance."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Double-digit growth in FY26 | FY26 |
| Q4 loss reduction | Adequate Q3 provisioning to cut Q4 loss or make it zero | FY26 Q4 |
| Store openings | 45–50 Monte Carlo stores, 10–15 Clock & Decker stores | FY26, pace sustained for 2 years |
| Debtor days improvement | 5–10 days reduction | Going forward (undated) |
| EBITDA margin | Above 20% including other income | Going forward (undated) |
| Guidance revision | Possible upward revision if everything tracks to expectation | Q2 FY26 call |
| Global expansion guidance | In position to give strategy guidance | By end of FY26 |
| Inventory normalization | Small increase taken care of | Next 2 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue from operations | ₹206 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹6 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 2.77% |
| Net loss | ₹10 cr |
| FY25 consolidated revenue from operations | ₹1,100 cr, +4% YoY |
| FY25 EBITDA | ₹187 cr, +31% YoY |
| FY25 EBITDA margin | 16.9%, improved ~360 bps YoY |
| FY25 net profit | ₹81 cr, +36% YoY |
| Final dividend recommended | ₹20 per share (200% on face value of ₹10) for FY25 |
| FY26 revenue growth guidance | Double-digit growth |
| FY26 EBITDA margin guidance | Above 20% including other income, ~200 bps improvement excluding other income |
| Inventory | ₹503 cr, up from ₹435 cr last year, +16% YoY |
| Same-store growth (SSG) | Decline of ~4% for FY25 |
| Store openings planned for FY26 | 45–50 Monte Carlo stores, 10–15 Clock & Decker stores |
| Price hike taken for FY26 | 8% to 10% across all categories |
| MBO channel sales | -7.9% YoY |
| Clock & Decker EBO sales | ~₹8,000 per sq ft per annum target being achieved |
| Investments | ~₹290 cr |
| Steady-state tax rate | 25.168% |