Key Takeaways
- A "work in progress" quarter: Rising costs across energy, raw materials, and wages made Q4 FY22 a "very tough quarter," but management expects sequential improvement as customer negotiations conclude and chip supply eases.
- India and Americas are the bright spots: Standalone India margin reached 18.2%, partly boosted by a one-off ₹65 crores fee, while the Tuscaloosa and Kecskemét plants are now performing at or above SMP averages.
- Cost pass-through is contract-by-contract: There is no automatic inflation shield; management is in active, transparent discussions with customers, but the pace and extent of relief will vary by contract and relationship.
- PKC margins hit by double-digit wage hikes: A 22% minimum wage increase in Mexico and similar pressures across Europe compressed margins in the people-intensive wiring business, compounded by erratic production from material shortages.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of customer cost-support agreements, the trajectory of chip supply improvement toward the September-end target, and the new segment-wise reporting construct.
Cost Environment & Margin Pressure
- Inflation was broad and relentless: Costs rose "almost weekly" across energy, raw materials, freight, and people. SMP bore the brunt of European energy cost increases because it has more plants in Germany and affected areas, while SMR is more present in non-affected regions.
- PKC wage shock: Unprecedented double-digit minimum wage increases hit most European countries, and Mexico imposed a 22% minimum wage hike, directly squeezing the labor-intensive wiring harness business. Erratic production due to material shortages prevented 100% capacity utilization, adding further margin pressure.
- MSWIL held gross margin flat: Despite raw material price increases, MSWIL's gross margin was broadly flattish from nine months to full year FY22 because teams worked intensively to contain raw material, shipping, freight, and transport costs.
- One-off legal costs: One-time legal expenditures related to the segregation of two companies were written off in the quarter, adding to the reported cost burden.
- Working capital swelled: Consolidated working capital expanded by ₹2,000 crores because supply chain disruptions forced the company to keep much higher inventory levels and maintain multiple supplier bases to ensure service continuity.
Sehgal: "I call it a work in progress kind of a year very challenging year. We have come back really hard, and we are confident that the coming quarters is going to be better."
Customer Negotiations & Pass-Through Mechanics
- No automatic pass-through: SMP contracts allow some margin of movement, but beyond certain limits, cost recovery requires direct discussion with customers. These discussions are annual, not continuous, creating a lag between cost increases and relief.
- Discussions are underway, but vary widely: Energy costs, raw material prices, and supplier cost increases are being transparently shared with customers. Some customers have already entered discussions wanting to compensate, but everything is contract-specific: timing, burden-sharing, and launch-related terms all differ.
- PKC contracts are shorter-cycle: Copper contracts are generally six-monthly or quarterly, and currency contracts are similarly structured for countries with currency risks, offering somewhat faster adjustment than SMP's annual cycle.
- Customers face the same pressures: Management noted that car makers are also affected by the same wage inflation, so there is "no way that they can run away from it," framing the discussion as a shared problem rather than an adversarial one.
Sehgal: "I hope yesterday, but look, we have to work together with the customer, make them understand the whole thing and then do it. So, we cannot do it with a breakneck kind of this thing over there, we have to be cognizant of the fact that everybody is facing a challenge."
Plant-Level Performance
- Tuscaloosa (Alabama): Now classified as a normal plant, not a startup. Serving Daimler SUVs, it has "very satisfactory" top-line and bottom-line performance, with all past Greenfield growing pains behind it.
- Kecskemét (Hungary): Also now a normal plant, supplying Daimler and Audi premium vehicles. Its financial indicators are performing above the SMP average. Hungary continues with its gas contract while the rest of the EU tries to move away from Russian gas and diesel.
- Both face inflation but are countering: Both plants face the same inflationary pressures as the rest of SMP but are countering with effective customer negotiations and pricing actions.
- MSWIL outperformance: Management attributed outperformance versus the industry to plant-level focus, meeting customer expectations, eliminating wastage, and using crises to advantage. A 60–70% female workforce with higher churn rate was cited as one factor helping margin sustainability.
Sehgal: "We never waste a crisis, we always come out stronger. You should have seen the last year's first quarter results, we almost had tears in our eyes. But then the next quarter, we came back very strong and that is exactly what we do we go face the crisis, we use that to our advantage."
Demerger & Reporting Changes
- First quarter post-demerger: Q4 FY22 is the first quarter giving effect to the demerger of MSWIL from SAMIL. The segregation of erstwhile SAMIL standalone businesses has been completed; businesses are now either in SAMIL standalone, 100% subsidiaries, or joint ventures as separate legal entities.
- MSWIL management fee: The management fee MSWIL pays to SAMIL goes before EBITDA as an expenditure. Factory premises taken on lease from SAMIL are accounted under Ind AS 116, converting the operating lease into interest and depreciation. The ballpark quarterly run-rate going forward is ~₹22 crores, with variations.
- One-off fee boost: Standalone other income rose sharply to ₹384 crores annually (versus ₹110 crores) because several companies were merged and ₹264 crores of dividend income was received in Q4. The 18.2% standalone margin partly reflects a one-off ₹65 crores pre-tax from nine-month rental and management fees MSWIL paid to SAMIL, accrued in Q4 as the first quarter post-demerger.
- New reporting construct coming: From next quarter onwards, a new reporting construct with broad business segment-wise revenue and EBITDA will be shared.
Chip Supply & Production Outlook
- Improvement expected by September-end 2022: Management expects the IC and semiconductor situation to ease considerably by September-end 2022. If delayed by war or other factors, improvement should be visible by December 2022. Improvement is already being seen daily and monthly.
- Recovery work is happening quietly: Management noted that even plants "which had been given up as bad have been raised, started," but companies are not talking about specific plant recoveries because competitors would gain sensitive information.
- PKC production erratic: Material shortages prevented PKC from running at 100% capacity utilization, compounding the margin impact from wage inflation.
Sehgal: "Actually, people are thinking that the world is doing nothing, but please believe me even plants which had been given up as bad have been raised, started, lot of things are happening, but the people are not talking about which plant what is happening and all that because the competitor gets that information that becomes at risk for tougher for obvious business reasons."
Strategy & Capital Allocation
- MSWIL electrification investments: Motherson Sumi Wiring Systems will invest a "tremendous amount of money" in electrification needs and hydrogen car requirements, including special investments in new technologies, new products, and new materials for non-normal wires and components.
- Capital return and growth balance: Cash generated by MSWIL will be returned to shareholders, while additional investments will be made to go ahead of time to service customers as the domestic industry undergoes change.
- Acquisition opportunities expected: Management believes the challenging environment will bring more acquisition opportunities, consistent with the company's historical pattern of using downturns to consolidate.
- EV localization caution: Management cautioned against blindly copying and localizing EV components without sufficient volume, stating that below a certain scale, importing is the better economic choice.
- Five-year plan disclosure: A half-yearly five-year plan and waypoint report will be presented in November 2022, detailing industrial segments and diversification plans for MSWIL.
Sehgal: "If you go and blindly go and copy the components since I am making it here, I think it is a big, big mistake, at the end of the day, you need the volume, otherwise, you are better off importing it."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Chip supply improvement | IC/semiconductor situation to ease considerably; if delayed by war, improvement by December | September-end 2022; fallback December 2022 |
| New reporting construct | Broad business segment-wise revenue and EBITDA disclosure | Next quarter (Q1 FY23) |
| MSWIL five-year plan disclosure | Half-yearly waypoint report detailing industrial segments and diversification | November 2022 |
| MSWIL management fee run-rate | Ballpark ~₹22 crores per quarter, with variations | Going forward |
| MSWIL dividend payment | Dividend proposed, to be paid to all shareholders including public | FY23 |
| Environment settling | Challenging environment needs time to really settle down | 3–6 months to a year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹16,911 cr |
| EBITDA (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹1,287 cr |
| PAT (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹122 cr |
| Revenue (SAMIL standalone) | ₹1,611 cr |
| EBITDA margin (SAMIL standalone) | 18.2%, includes one-off pre-tax income of ₹65 cr from MSWIL rental and management fees accrued for nine months |
| One-off pre-tax income (SAMIL standalone) | ₹65 cr, nine-month rental and management fees from MSWIL; post-tax impact of ₹48.9 cr |
| Revenue (MSWIL) | ₹1,662 cr, up almost 14% QoQ |
| EBITDA (MSWIL) | up almost 31% QoQ |
| MSWIL management fee expense (9-month catch-up) | ₹24 cr EBITDA impact, booked in the quarter |
| MSWIL PBT adjustment (prior 9 months) | ₹74 cr, difference from factory leased premises accounted for interest and depreciation per Ind AS 116 |
| Copper as a percentage of raw material cost (MSWIL) | 18% to 22%, varies by product mix, higher for EVs |
| SAMIL standalone other income (annual) | ₹711 cr, up from ₹110 cr; ₹264 cr dividend income received in Q4 |
| Consolidated working capital impact | ₹2,000 cr increase, driven by higher inventory and multiple supplier bases due to supply chain disruptions |
| MSWIL workforce composition | 60–70% ladies, which tend to have a higher churn rate |
| PKC minimum wage increase (Mexico) | 22% increase; double-digit increases in most European countries |