Key Takeaways
- E-commerce drives profit surge: PAT more than doubled YoY to ₹43.84 crore, powered by e-commerce revenue growth to ₹83.36 crore and a clean provisioning slate in standalone financials.
- Marketing wind-down complete: Marketing revenue collapsed 90% YoY to just ₹10.19 crore, but management says the business is now almost over, removing a major drag on consolidated results.
- Vehicle scrapping gains traction: 1,459 vehicles received in Q1, roughly 50% above the FY22 quarterly average, signaling early momentum ahead of the government's October scrapping mandate.
- Zero-debt balance sheet: The company is virtually debt-free except for a disputed Standard Chartered claim it fully denies, giving it a clean platform for growth or capital return.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Coal India portal transition creates any revenue disruption, the pace of state-level vehicle scrapping policy adoption, and any update on the FSNL disinvestment process.
E-Commerce: The Growth Engine
- Revenue up despite price headwinds: E-commerce revenue rose to ₹83.36 crore from ₹64.96 crore YoY, driven by new client acquisition and higher business volumes, even as steel and scrap prices fell roughly 20%, partially offsetting the upside.
- Scrap dependency falling fast: Scrap revenue contribution has dropped from 75–80% a couple of years ago to less than 50% now, as the company diversifies into other e-commerce segments, reducing vulnerability to commodity price swings.
- New client wins validate the platform: Private sector names like Arcelor Mittal, Reliance, ESL, and Indus Towers are giving business to MSTC despite competition, while mine auctions come on a nomination basis with no competition.
- South India expansion underway: Agreements signed with a large number of principals in Karnataka and Chennai, including a temple trust for asset sales and e-procurement, broadening the seller base on the portal.
- Coal India risk contained: Management does not see a near-term threat from Coal India's own portal; MSTC is building the new policy portal itself, and even if volumes eventually leave, the contribution is less than 10% of total e-commerce earnings.
Gupta: "In the competitive environment also, we have survived and MSTC has grown. This is one thing. And we hope to continue our growth trajectory and provide the robust services and what we say, we pay you the best value."
Marketing Business: The Clean-Up
- Revenue near-zero, headcount redeployed: Marketing revenue fell from ₹112.08 crore to ₹10.19 crore YoY, a 90% drop. The business has been scaled down and is almost over, with only a couple of people now engaged in it. Staff previously in marketing were redeployed into e-commerce as the company opened offices across major states.
- Provisioning overhang lifted: Standalone Q1 FY23 had zero provisioning, and management stated major marketing provisions have been taken care of, with no major provisions expected going forward. A roughly ₹4.25 crore provision write-back also boosted other income this quarter.
Vehicle Scrapping: Early Traction, Policy Catalyst Ahead
- Volumes building from a low base: 1,459 vehicles were received in Q1 FY23, roughly 50% higher than the FY22 quarterly average of about 1,000, reflecting increased traction. The Bihar excise department engagement alone saw roughly 4,000 vehicles sold in two to three months.
- Government mandate as a trigger: The deadline for mandatory scrapping of government vehicles has been extended to October, creating a near-term volume catalyst. Assam has also recently announced its vehicle scrapping policy.
- JV with Mahindra still waiting: The MMRPL joint venture is working below par capacity because not enough vehicles are coming for scrapping. Management expects volumes to rise once state governments finalize and implement policies on the lines of the MoRTH policy, with states reportedly in advanced stages of finalization.
- Dedicated portal coming: A portal for end-of-life vehicle scrapping, onboarding both buyers and sellers, is soon to be launched, which could streamline the process and attract more participants.
Profitability & Balance Sheet
- Profit more than doubled: PBT rose from ₹37.17 crore to ₹66.11 crore YoY, and PAT from ₹21.20 crore to ₹43.84 crore, aided by e-commerce growth, zero standalone provisioning, and a provision write-back in other income.
- Other income abnormally high: Consolidated other income got a major boost from provision write-backs and a rise in interest rates, making the quarter's profitability partly non-recurring.
- Virtually zero debt: The company is virtually debt-free except for a small SBI term loan that will be taken care of, and a disputed Standard Chartered Bank entry that management denies, disputes, and protests.
Sarkar: "So virtually, we are right now a zero debt company, virtually we can call. ... Otherwise it is a zero debt company."
Strategic Initiatives & Pipeline
- 5G spectrum auction delivered: MSTC successfully conducted the 5G spectrum auction for the Department of Telecom, running 40 rounds smoothly and earning appreciation from the Minister and Secretary, DoT, reinforcing its credentials for high-stakes government auctions.
- Coal India portal in advanced stages: MSTC is developing a platform for Coal India's new coal sale policy, with Coal India currently testing the portal, securing a near-term revenue stream even as the long-term relationship evolves.
- Property sales gaining queries: Management expects good revenue from property sales in the coming year, with increasing queries from state government and central agencies, though the company admits it does not have a good presence in the broader B2C segment like bank loan auctions.
- FSNL disinvestment in process: The subsidiary's disinvestment is at the Expression of Interest stage, handled by DIPAM. No timeline can be given, and management will update as developments occur.
Gupta: "I will admit that we do not have that good presence in the B2C segment."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Growth trajectory | Maintain growth trajectory and achieve very good results in FY23, supported by additional business wins | FY23 |
| Vehicle scrapping portal | Launch dedicated portal for end-of-life vehicle scrapping, onboarding buyers and sellers | "Soon" |
| Coal India portal | Complete development of platform for Coal India's new coal sale policy; currently in testing | No date (advanced stages) |
| Government vehicle scrapping mandate | Mandatory scrapping of government vehicles deadline | October |
| Cash utilization / buyback assessment | Management will reply with fresh assessment of cash and cash equivalents | September (balance sheet publication) |
| Investor presentation granularity | Provide more breakup (vehicles scrapped by type, number of auctions) in next meeting | Next meeting |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue (standalone) | ₹93.85 cr, declined 45% YoY from ₹171.26 cr |
| E-commerce revenue | ₹83.58 cr, grew from ₹59.11 cr YoY; down from ₹90.97 cr in Q4 FY22 |
| Marketing revenue | ₹10.19 cr, down 90% YoY from ₹112.08 cr |
| EBITDA (pre-provisioning) | ₹67.76 cr, up 42.70% YoY from ₹47.48 cr |
| Profit before tax | ₹66.11 cr, up from ₹37.17 cr YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹43.84 cr, up from ₹21.20 cr YoY |
| Cash profit | ₹45.39 cr, up from ₹29.97 cr YoY |
| Consolidated total revenue | ₹194.81 cr, declined from ₹268.68 cr YoY |
| E-Auction/E-Sale revenue growth | 39% YoY |
| Scrap sales volume | ~₹2,500 cr (approx) |
| Scrap revenue as % of e-commerce revenue | Less than 50%, similar to Q4 FY22; down from 75–80% a couple of years ago |
| Vehicles received for scrapping | 1,459, ~50% growth over FY22 quarterly average of ~1,000 |
| Provisions written back (other income) | ₹4.25 cr |
| Coal India contribution to e-commerce earnings | Less than 10% |
| Employee count | ~300 |