MSTC Ltd Q1 FY2024 Concall Summary

Source transcript PDF: https://assets.stockscans.in/docs/2uzxng2s2oy7n80ssi631jbc.pdf

Key Takeaways


E-Commerce: The Core Engine

Mrs. Bhanu Kumar: "It is almost impossible to switch from event basis to percentage basis, at least in such auctions. So, wherever it is possible, we are already on percentage basis."

Coal Auctions: A Shrinking, Non-Critical Contributor

Mrs. Bhanu Kumar: "It doesn't actually affect my earnings."

Vehicle Scrapping: Early Days, Slow Build

Mrs. Bhanu Kumar: "It is not just about demand and supply. It is also creating the entire ecosystem. So, those things are still at quite a nascent stage and unless we achieve some better facilities, this thing is going to take some time."

Standard Chartered Litigation: A Reversal with Uncertain Impact


Subsidiaries & JVs: Drag and Uncertainty

Mr. Subrata Sarkar: "All the decisions are taken at the highest level by the Government of India. And most of those decisions, even we are not privy to such decisions. And we are not even present in those meetings. So obviously, we are not in a position to reply to investor queries on this."

Capital Allocation & Transparency

Mr. Subrata Sarkar: "Whenever there is a write-up, then there is a tax rate that goes down. And write-ups are based on certain parameters. Every quarter we cannot make write-ups. Every debt cannot be written up, until and unless each and every hope is gone down."

Guidance & Commitments

CommitmentSpecificsTimeline
Share buyback reviewReview cash position and buyback feasibility on 30th September; discuss internally30th September
Investor relations portalCreate portal on website to answer all investor queries transparentlyNo date (committed)
Investor presentation timingProvide presentation well in advance of future earnings callsNext quarter onward
E-commerce contract updatesUpdate on contracts with government departments once finalised"Coming next quarter"
Standard Chartered refundCredit ₹90 cr refund to account once written DRAT orders received and examinedAwaiting written orders
FSNL disinvestmentProcess still going on, yet to be completed; refer to DIPAM websiteNo visibility

Key Metrics

MetricQ1 FY24
Revenue from operations (standalone)₹100.63 cr, +7.22% YoY
Revenue from operations (consolidated)₹199.76 cr, +2.53% YoY
EBITDA (standalone)₹72.27 cr, up from ₹67.76 cr in Q1 FY23
EBITDA (consolidated)₹86.02 cr, down from ₹86.85 cr in Q1 FY23
PBT (standalone)₹70.56 cr, up from ₹66.12 cr in Q1 FY23
PBT (consolidated)₹80.56 cr, flat vs ₹80.54 cr in Q1 FY23
PAT (standalone)₹44.57 cr, up from ₹43.85 cr in Q1 FY23
PAT (consolidated)₹50.61 cr, down from ₹54.29 cr in Q1 FY23
EPS (standalone)₹6.33, up from ₹6.23 in Q1 FY23
EPS (consolidated)₹7.19, down from ₹7.71 in Q1 FY23
Cash profit (consolidated)₹56.08 cr, down from ₹60.52 cr in Q1 FY23
Total value of goods transacted through e-commerce and marketing (standalone)~₹19,364 cr, down 18.5% YoY, driven by ~20% fall in iron ore prices
Scrap sale share of total revenue~52% of total revenue
E-commerce segment revenue₹94.05 cr
Marketing segment revenue₹6.41 cr
Other income (standalone)₹18.29 cr
Government vehicles sold since March to RVSF8,586 vehicles
Government vehicles in pipeline for auction4,000+ vehicles
Government vehicles projected for sale in FY2415,000 to 20,000 vehicles
Coal India auction events per month~4, down from 6–7 earlier, due to policy change
Coal India auction market share~40%, other service provider gets ~60%
Private player share of e-commerce revenue~10% (management estimate, no supporting data)
Joint venture loss (consolidated impact)₹1.22 cr loss from JV this quarter
Standard Chartered litigation: DRAT ruling₹222.51 cr demand set aside in MSTC's favour; ₹90 cr refund ordered by DRAT
Employee average age~37–38 years (management recall)