MSTC Ltd Q2 FY2023 Concall Summary

Source transcript PDF: https://assets.stockscans.in/docs/o8x9vzo4zcwvsws06uq5uswe.pdf

Key Takeaways


The Marketing Runoff

Marketing revenue collapsed from ₹176.36 crore to ₹92.40 crore YoY, a ~50% drop that management had previously flagged and now treats as structural. The segment is limited to 110% BG-backed transactions only, and the company will not pursue new marketing ventures once existing business fizzles out.

Sarkar: "Let me tell you and let me make it very clear right now, the philosophy of the management is not to have any, expect any growth in the marketing."

E-Commerce: The Growth Engine

E-commerce revenue grew 35% YoY (₹124 crore to ₹167 crore), and the total value of goods traded across MSTC's ecosystem grew 30% H1 YoY to ₹91,962 crore. Management expects this momentum to sustain through Q3, though Q4 is too difficult to predict given retail market interlinkages.

Sarkar: "We are trying our level best, but we feel that we can maintain the trajectory as I said earlier... But the retail market as you are all aware, how it happens we do not know. The world is now interrelated."

Profitability & Provisioning

EBITDA grew 120% and PAT grew 119%, driven by the near-absence of fresh provisions and steady e-commerce earnings. Approximately 70% of PBT is derived from operational income, with other income mainly comprising dividends.


Balance Sheet: Strong but Opaque

The balance sheet carries ~₹900 crore in cash against a net worth of ₹584 crore, and trade receivables are near-fully secured. However, management declined or was unable to answer several basic analytical questions on the call, leaving investors to do their own math.

Sarkar: "That particular figures are generally not captured in our accounting system. We go by the income."

Catalysts & Overhangs

Sarkar: "It is very difficult right now, sitting today itself so to tell, that what will happen this year or next year. But if anything substantial happens, of course, we'll get back to you."

Guidance & Commitments

CommitmentSpecificsTimeline
E-commerce revenue trajectoryMaintain current momentumQ3 FY23 (Q4 too difficult to predict)
Marketing segmentNo growth expected; limited to 110% BG-backed transactions only; no new ventures once existing business fizzles outWind-down timeline not in management's hands; management not averse to continuing 110% BG-backed business
Private-client mixRatio of private business expected to increase as iron ore opens and private miners are roped inFrom next quarter onward
DRAT case disclosureUpdate stock exchanges immediately upon order receiptOrder expected evening of call date
DividendFirst interim dividend on DIPAM path (5% of net worth or 30% of PAT, whichever higher)Current financial year; minimum dividend policy
FSNL stake saleMSTC facilitating; DIPAM-led processToo difficult to say this year or next; update promised if anything substantial occurs

Key Metrics

MetricQ2 FY23
Standalone revenue from operations (H1)₹163.3 cr
E-commerce revenue₹167 cr, +35% YoY
Marketing revenue₹92.40 cr, down ~50% YoY from ₹176.36 cr
EBITDA₹225.83 cr, +120% YoY
Profit before tax₹145 cr, up from ₹83.23 cr
Profit after tax₹115.32 cr, +119% YoY
Other income₹103 cr; net ~₹25 cr after removing ₹78 cr provision write-back
Provision for bad debt (net new)₹0.95 cr
Total value of goods traded (H1)₹91,962 cr, +30% YoY
Group revenue₹463.72 cr, down ~7% YoY
Group profit after tax₹117.96 cr, nearly doubled from ₹61.85 cr
FSNL revenue₹203 cr, flat vs ₹201 cr
Standalone trade receivables₹350 cr; ~₹60 cr from e-commerce, balance from marketing
Net worth (H1)₹584 cr
Cash balance~₹900 cr