Key Takeaways
- Resilient earnings despite commodity headwinds: E-commerce revenue grew ~10.33% and PBT grew ~9.60% even as scrap prices fell 15-20%, demonstrating the platform’s transactional resilience.
- Non-scrap revenue hits a milestone: Non-scrap activities now contribute ~50% of revenue, diversifying the mix while scrap remains the core backbone.
- Vehicle scrappage JV is stuck in low gear: The Mahindra MSTC Recycling JV is underperforming because state-level infrastructure and policy frameworks are not yet mature, choking raw material supply.
- Standard Chartered Bank case resolved favorably: Fixed assets were released and a ₹90 crore deposit was refunded after the appeal was allowed in MSTC’s favor, removing a long-standing overhang.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the anticipated 5-10% scrap price increase materializes in H2, any progress on state-level scrappage policies, and the pace of new e-commerce project wins.
Financial Performance & Drivers
- Growth decoupled from commodity prices: Revenue and profit grew despite a 15-20% decline in scrap prices and a reverse trend in iron ore, because service charge revenue is event-based (auctions, spectrum, coal blocks) rather than volume-linked.
- E-commerce revenue composition: The ~₹20 crore gap in H1 e-commerce revenue came from project development charges and AMP charges, which are milestone-linked and not a constant stream, though not necessarily one-off.
- Marketing segment deprioritized: The small marketing segment (piggybank scheme) is being consciously wound down to focus entirely on e-commerce.
- Other financial liability explained: The fluctuating liability on the balance sheet represents payments held to be passed on to principals; net cash position has increased and is comfortable at ~₹260+ crore.
- Legacy provisioning nearly complete: All trading receivables are already provided for; only very small, insignificant e-commerce provisioning may remain, meaning going forward there will be more or less no provisions.
Ms. Bhanu Kumar: "The government, as on date, doesn't support or tell anyone that they have to go to MSTC platform. Whatever business we are getting is totally on the basis of our experience, exposure, our merits, the infrastructure, our credentials, our past, everything."
Vehicle Scrappage & ELV Business
- Policy ambition vs ground reality: Despite the scrappage policy and government push, growth has not materialized because many states have not set up automated testing stations or supportive policy frameworks, so raw material is not flowing to the JV.
- Eight scrapping centers operational: Locations include Noida, Chennai, Pune, Indore, Ahmedabad, Hyderabad, Bangalore, and Guwahati. New locations are being explored but nothing is crystallized, contingent on which states come up with supportive policies.
- Management promises more disclosure: An investor suggestion to include a slide on the Mahindra JV (number of centers, opportunities, quarterly progress) in the next presentation was accepted.
Ms. Bhanu Kumar: "But in ground reality, it has not taken that kind of growth that was envisaged. It is still taking time."
Mr. Surinder Kumar Gupta: "I think request you to at least wait for a year to see which way it goes."
Auction Verticals & Volume Drivers
- Coal auctions are residual by design: Coal auctions are largely restricted to state government entities and Coal India; only the leftover portion beyond long-term FSAs (85-90% of output) comes for auction. If mining output increases, auction volumes increase proportionately.
- Iron ore supply tightening: Iron ore prices have declined YoY and some private producers have increased internal consumption, reducing the volume available for auction.
- E-commerce volume growth expected: Most state and central government entities have already been onboarded; the volumes they transact through the portal are expected to grow over the next few years.
- No government mandate: Business is won entirely on merit, experience, credentials, and a two-decade compliance track record, not because MSTC is a government undertaking.
FSNL Disinvestment
- MSTC is a bystander in the process: The disinvestment is being handled by DIPAM directly; MSTC is just a party to the process with no decision-making role. Transaction Advisor and Legal Advisor are done, certain interested bidders have been shortlisted, but price and other details are in the government’s purview.
- Management declines to assess impact: When asked whether the disinvestment (FSNL contributes ~30% to topline and bottomline) is in MSTC’s interest, management stated “only time will tell” and declined to analyze or question government decisions.
Ms. Bhanu Kumar: "You see, we have made it categorically clear that FSNL disinvestment is being done by the government of India itself, DIPAM specifically. This is not a decision that has been taken by the company, MSTC, and none of the activities are also done by the company directly. So, we are also just a party to the entire process, and when we are not in a decision-making position, there is no point in saying whether it is good for the company, bad for the company, only time will tell."
New Initiatives & Projects
- E-commerce project pipeline: MSTC is engaging with software developers and SaaS companies and planning to pick up bigger government projects, though results will come over a period of time, not in the immediate future.
- Barytes and Bluestone auctions completed: Successfully sold Barytes on behalf of APMDC and conducted Bluestone e-auction for HSIIDC.
- Madhya Pradesh Sand Groups: 36 Sand Groups successfully auctioned, replicating the earlier UP work.
- Coal linkage auction: 0.24 crore MT of coal sold during the quarter.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Scrap price recovery | Anticipate another 5-10% increase in scrap prices | H2 FY24 |
| Full-year growth | Significant growth in revenues and profits as commodity prices and worldwide scenario improve | Full year FY24 |
| JV disclosure | Include a slide on Mahindra JV (centers, opportunities, quarterly progress) in investor presentation | Next investor meet |
| Jai Balaji recovery | Assures no stone left unturned to realize ~₹81 crore; legal process ongoing | No fixed timeline |
| Cash distribution | If cash exceeds a certain level per guidelines, shared with shareholders as per policy norms | Condition-based |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| E-commerce revenue (H1 FY24) | ₹185.03 cr, +10.33% YoY from ₹167.71 cr |
| Profit before tax (standalone, H1 FY24) | ₹158.99 cr, +9.60% YoY from ₹145.07 cr |
| Profit after tax (standalone, H1 FY24) | ₹113.08 cr, flat YoY from ₹115.33 cr |
| EPS (standalone, H1 FY24) | ₹16.06, compared to ₹16.38 YoY |
| Profit before tax (consolidated, H1 FY24) | ₹158.56 cr, +3% YoY from ₹154.54 cr |
| Profit after tax (consolidated, H1 FY24) | ₹105.95 cr, lower from ₹117.97 cr YoY |
| Total value of goods traded (H1 FY24) | ₹62,603 cr |
| Non-scrap e-commerce revenue share | ~50% of total e-commerce revenue |
| Scrap price trend | Down ~10% YoY in Q2; picking up 8–10% post July–August |
| Coal sold via linkage auction (H1 FY24) | 0.24 cr MT |
| Net cash position (net of other financial liabilities) | ₹260+ cr, up from 31 March |
| Other financial liabilities | ₹924 cr remaining, down ~₹452 cr since March |
| JV with Mahindra (Mahindra MSTC Recycling) quarterly loss | ₹2.15 cr |
| Vehicle scrapping centers operational | 8 (Noida, Chennai, Pune, Indore, Ahmedabad, Hyderabad, Bangalore, Guwahati) |
| Combined scrapping capacity | At least 1 lakh vehicles per annum; utilization hardly 10% |
| Dividend declared | 55% in H1 FY24; 150% in FY23 |