Key Takeaways
- E-commerce volume surged 52% in 9M, but Q3 revenue dipped: The dip was driven by lower scrap prices and the absence of large one-off plant sales, not by any slowdown in underlying auction activity.
- Government ELV mandate is a structural unlock: A new notification forces all government vehicles older than 15 years to be scrapped exclusively via MSTC’s portal, promising to fill the feedstock gap for its scrappage JV.
- Profitability jumped despite a standalone revenue decline: Standalone PBT rose 45% and consolidated PAT rose ~60% in 9M, powered by operating leverage in the high-margin e-commerce business.
- Management declined to quantify key scrappage metrics: Citing competitive sensitivity and early-stage variability, the company would not disclose per-plant CapEx, per-vehicle margins, or current capacity utilization.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q4 e-commerce rebound materializes on the back of recovering scrap prices and iron ore auctions, and any concrete news flow on the FSNL disinvestment.
E-Commerce: The Core Growth Engine
- Volume growth is robust, but revenue is lumpy: The value of goods transacted grew 52.16% YoY in 9M FY23, yet Q3 standalone e-commerce revenue dipped both YoY and QoQ. The dip is explained by a slight decrease in scrap prices, which reduces the percentage-based service charge, and the absence of large one-off plant sale auctions that contributed INR 7-8 Crore in the base quarter.
- Revenue composition is granular and diversified: Revenue comes from a beehive of activities where no single plant or event dominates. Scrap now accounts for roughly 50% of e-commerce revenue, and the company is actively spreading into more commodities and sectors so that a down-cycle in one commodity can be absorbed without major disruption.
- Q4 is set up for a rebound: Q4 is historically a very heavy quarter. With iron ore auctions now open after the lifting of a Supreme Court judgment and scrap prices recovering roughly 35%, management expects a robust quarter barring unusual events.
- Full-year trajectory is positive: 9M e-commerce figures are already ahead of last year, and management expects to at least match last year’s full-year figure, landing in a "very positive result" if circumstances remain favourable.
- GeM is not seen as a near-term threat: Management stated that MSTC’s services are "far superior" to GeM’s portal-only offering, and some clients who tried GeM are returning. The company sees no current visibility of a government mandate forcing all auctions through GeM.
Gupta: “We cannot speculate on what government orders will be there. So as of now, we don't see any possibility of that kind into that because that will decrease the, I mean, they will not be able to sell their product at the market rate by using GeM.”
Vehicle Scrappage: The Structural Bet
- The ELV notification is a watershed moment: The Government of India issued a notification that all central government, state government, Panchayat, and PSU vehicles older than 15 years will be compulsorily de-registered and sold exclusively on the MSTC portal to Registered Vehicle Scrapping Facilities (RVSFs) only. Sixteen or seventeen states have announced policy guidelines, and six have already issued notifications for mandatory scrapping.
- MMRPL is scaling capacity ahead of demand: Six plants are currently in operation, with a total of eight or nine expected by the end of FY23. MSTC is investing an additional INR 1.4 Crore to fully subscribe the authorized share capital of the JV and is open to infusing further equity and opening many more plants in FY24, with a plant setup time of just 3-4 months.
- Profitability is expected in FY24: With the government ELV notification, MMRPL is expected to receive sufficient feedstock to not only break even but earn profits in the next financial year. Government vehicles alone are expected to provide enough volume to cross the breakeven threshold.
- The strategy is to maintain a first-mover advantage: Management’s explicit intention is to always have capacity above market demand, so the company is never lacking when vehicles arrive. The goal is to cover most of the country before competitors emerge.
- Key metrics remain undisclosed: Management declined to provide per-plant CapEx, average revenue or margin per scrapped vehicle, or current capacity utilization, citing variability based on vehicle condition, fixed cost absorption, and competitive sensitivity. A commitment was made to try to share capacity utilization and JV revenue data in the next investor call.
Gupta: “It's our intention to always be above the market, so that we are not lacking in the capacity when the vehicles come to us. So that is what our total strategy has been there and we want to encash on the first mover advantage, we want to maintain that advantage and so that we are ahead of our competitors whenever they come up with their plans.”
Profitability & Provisioning: The Accounting Story
- Profitability surged on operating leverage: Despite a standalone revenue decline from INR 409 Crore to INR 367 Crore in 9M FY23, EBITDA pre-provisioning rose from INR 169.79 Crore to INR 289 Crore and PBT grew 45%. Consolidated PAT jumped roughly 60% YoY to INR 165 Crore, driven by e-commerce performance and a quantum jump in EBITDA from INR 210.99 Crore to INR 314 Crore.
- The revenue mix shift explains the margin expansion: Standalone marketing revenue dipped sharply from INR 185 Crore to INR 97 Crore, while e-commerce revenue grew 19%. The higher-margin e-commerce business is now the dominant profit driver.
- The INR 80 Crore provisioning figure is an optical distortion: The 9M provision/write-off figure of INR 80 Crore is largely a technical entry appearing on both sides of the P&L. Fresh standalone provisions made during the period were only INR 95 lakhs, entirely for e-commerce. The remainder represents the write-off of old provisions, with approximately INR 4.5-5 Crore of old provisions also written back during the year. Marketing provisioning is fully behind the company.
Sarkar: “This INR 80 Crore is nothing, but it is appearing on both sides. If you see the other income, you see it has gone up like anything, you see. It is only INR 95 lakhs of provisions has been made during this nine-month period.”
FSNL Disinvestment & Other Catalysts
- FSNL disinvestment is at a "very definite level": DIPAM is progressing the process with multiple meetings held and wants to close the deal as soon as possible. Management indicated that news could come in the next quarter or the quarter after, though timelines remain uncertain as DIPAM steers the process.
- Standard Chartered litigation is with DRAT: The appeal has been restored by the Bombay High Court and is now lying with the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal, with INR 90 Crore deposited with DRAT.
- Coal India portal developed: MSTC has built a new portal for Coal India following a government policy change on coal auctions, adding another government-linked revenue stream.
- Property auctions for banks are gaining traction: Volumes and success rates in e-auction of NPA properties for banks have increased. The revenue model here is per-property-sold, not percentage-based.
Gupta: "DIPAM wants to close this deal as soon as possible. So could be in next quarter or next to next quarter you will get some news on that front. We are not still sure about the timelines that the total process is being steered by DIPAM..."
Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns
- Dividend payout is already high: The company is already paying a 63% dividend. Management stated it is not sitting on cash, has liabilities to meet, and will utilize balances properly, requesting patience until March-end figures are ready.
- Cash conversion is strong: Earnings are said to convert to cash in a "very good ratio," though the net cash figure was not disclosed and investors were asked to wait for the March-end balance sheet.
- MMRPL equity infusion is ongoing: MSTC is investing an additional INR 1.4 Crore to fully subscribe the authorized share capital of MMRPL and remains "very open to infuse further equity" as traction increases.
Sarkar: “We are always thinking as far as shareholders are concerned to appreciate their values as well as to make them those who have shown loyalty. So, it is their only, we are thinking, we are not sitting on the balances.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| MMRPL profitability | Sufficient feedstock from government ELV mandate to break even and earn profits | FY24 |
| MMRPL capacity | Eight or nine plants operational | End of FY23 |
| MMRPL capacity disclosure | Share capacity utilization and JV revenue/vehicles scrapped data | Next investor call (post-March numbers) |
| E-commerce full-year result | Land in a "very positive result" if circumstances remain positive | FY23 |
| FSNL disinvestment news | Deal closure steered by DIPAM; news possible in next one or two quarters | Next quarter or next-to-next quarter |
| Investor presentation | Address requests for more granular business details | Next presentation |
| ELV auction fee | Zero service charge until March 2023; 3% fee on transaction value from 1st April 2023 | FY24 onwards |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Standalone total revenue (9M) | ₹202 cr, up from ₹185 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Standalone PBT (9M) | ₹206 cr, up 45.05% from ₹142 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Standalone PAT (9M) | ₹163.17 cr, up from ₹88.74 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Standalone EPS (9M) | ₹23.18, up from ₹12.61 in 9M FY22 |
| Consolidated revenue (9M) | ₹646.79 cr, down 7% from ₹699.48 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Consolidated PBT (9M) | ₹218.09 cr, up 30% from ₹167.63 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Consolidated PAT (9M) | ₹165 cr, up ~60% from ₹103.15 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Consolidated EPS (9M) | ₹23.44, up ~60% from ₹14.65 in 9M FY22 |
| E-commerce segment revenue (9M) | ₹244.85 cr, up 19% from ₹205 cr in 9M FY22 |
| E-commerce volume (value of goods transacted, 9M) | ₹1,60,266 cr, up 52.16% over 9M FY22 |
| Marketing segment revenue (9M) | ₹97 cr, down from ₹185 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Standalone EBITDA pre-provisioning (9M) | ₹289 cr, up from ₹169.79 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Consolidated EBITDA (9M) | ₹314 cr, up from ₹210.99 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Fresh provisions (standalone, 9M) | ₹95 lakh, against e-commerce base of ~₹235–250 cr; marketing provisions fully behind |
| Write-back of provisions (FY23 to date) | ~₹4.5–5 cr |
| Vehicle scrappage policy: estimated eligible government vehicles | ~15 lakh vehicles across central, state, PSU, and Panchayat levels |
| MMRPL plants operational by end of FY23 | 8–9 plants, up from 6 currently |
| ELV auction service charge | 3% of transaction value from April 2023; zero until March 2023 |
| Amount deposited with DRAT for Standard Chartered appeal | ₹90 cr; total demanded amount fully provided for in books |
| Cash balance (per analyst's math from 30 Sep 2022 balance sheet) | ~₹1,000 cr (per an analyst's math) |
| Dividend payout | 63%, already at last year's level |