Key Takeaways
- Profitability divergence: PBT rose to ₹216.63 crore but PAT fell to ₹152.41 crore, entirely because last year's tax rate was lower due to a bad-loan write-off benefit that did not repeat.
- Core e-commerce engine stalled: The main breadwinner (75-80% of business) is on a flatter trajectory as scrap rates declined ~10% YoY and iron ore charges were squeezed, muting the top line even where volumes grew.
- Vehicle scrapping ecosystem still not ready: The JV is near breakeven but the 15-lakh-vehicle target looks difficult even in FY25; states are still implementing the MORTH policy framework and data gaps on the Vahan Portal block vehicle acceptance.
- Strategy remains a work in progress: Management declined to give FY25 guidance, a roadmap, or a map of new e-commerce opportunities, saying it needs a couple of months to reach internal consensus on where to focus.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether management delivers the promised "clear focus" on e-commerce expansion models, any Q4 e-commerce revenue growth, and the cash balance as of 31st March.
E-Commerce: The Core Engine Sputtering
- Scrap price headwind: Scrap rates declined ~10% YoY on a nine-month basis, directly compressing e-commerce revenue since scrap is ~50% of total e-commerce revenue. Management is trying to expand volume to compensate.
- Iron ore margin squeeze: Iron ore volumes are growing but the company was "stressed to reduce the charges," so higher volumes did not translate into higher revenue.
- Trading model flat: The trading model within e-commerce is not seeing volumes come up, adding to the flatter trajectory.
- Revenue model is fragmented: E-auction revenue comes on a percentage basis in some areas, an event basis in others (spectrum, mineral block auctions), sometimes charged to the seller, sometimes to the buyer, sometimes just a transaction cost. There is no single fixed model.
- Q4 hope, no commitment: Management is "hopeful" of some e-commerce revenue growth in the last quarter, but offered no quantification or driver beyond that hope.
Kumar: "We can articulate once we are very clear in our minds. We are working on various models, as I said very clearly. Let us all come to a consensus internally. After that, maybe I can spell it out to you. But right now, it is a little premature to talk about this."
Vehicle Scrapping: Waiting on Policy, Not Demand
- Ecosystem bottlenecks: States are at different stages of implementing the MORTH policy framework, and vehicles cannot be accepted for scrapping unless sufficient data is available on the Vahan Portal. Pending dues or encumbrances on vehicles further disincentivize sellers, and the unorganized sector enjoys a compliance advantage.
- JV near breakeven: The MMRPL joint venture is very near to breakeven and management expects it to become profitable going forward, with substantial settling down and an increase in vehicle numbers over the next 2 to 3 years.
- Target out of reach: The 15-lakh-vehicle target for FY24 looks difficult even in FY25 because of the ecosystem challenges.
- EPR policy as catalyst: The government is considering an Extended Producer Responsibility policy that would put responsibility on OEMs for scrapping vehicles they manufactured; management believes this would "substantially increase the size of the market" and MMRPL would be a beneficiary.
- No capacity disclosure: Management declined to share scrapping unit capacity numbers, saying only that there are "adequate capacities for the vehicles that are getting generated at this point of time and also over the next 1 to 2 years."
- Captive scrap stays captive: Scrap from other Registered Vehicle Scrapping Facilities will not flow through MSTC's portal because those operators (e.g., Tata) have direct arrangements with end users and consume scrap through their own foundries.
Ghoshal: "There has been a substantial amount of regulation which is coming in at this point of time as guidelines which have been set out by the Ministry of Road, Transport and Highways. Now, different states are at different stages of implementing these guidelines as a policy framework and which is still happening. It is not yet complete."
Real Estate & New Verticals
- B2C pivot: Management announced a shift to also focus on the B2C segment for real estate, moving beyond its traditional B2B base. A real estate conference with CII in November 2023 served as an awareness campaign and a way to gauge business opportunities.
- New property auction webpage: A newly developed integrated web page for property auctions was launched during the real estate conference.
- Sector-wise conference series: The company plans to expand its basket to include liquidators, assets under IBC, development authorities like Yamuna Express and DDAs, and monetization of PSU assets.
- Critical mineral auctions: 20 critical mineral blocks have been put up for auction, with roadshows held for the first tranche.
- Bihar MOU: An MOU was signed with the Government of Bihar for e-auction of major mineral blocks; 77 blocks have been successfully auctioned so far.
- Spectrum auctions continue: MSTC has been doing spectrum auctions for the past three years, and a news report indicated more frequencies will be auctioned, which MSTC will carry forward.
Kumar: "Our focus so far has been only on B2B segments. Now, we would also like to be in the B2C segment. So, towards this end, it was more of an awareness campaign plus to gauge the business opportunities that are available."
Financials: Costs, Cash & One-Offs
- Tax-rate normalization: The PAT decline (₹163.17 crore to ₹152.41 crore) despite a PBT increase (₹206.71 crore to ₹216.63 crore) is entirely a tax-base effect: last year had a lower tax rate due to a write-off of bad loans providing an income tax benefit that did not recur.
- Employee expenses up: The increase was mainly driven by certain equipment extended to employees, some one-time purchases and some perpetual items.
- Other expenses contained: Conference expenses and similar items have come up, but there was no major jump. Management is trying to maintain total overhead around ₹110 to ₹120 crore with inflationary pressure.
- Standard Chartered Bank refund: The ₹90 crore deposited in DRAT for the appeal has been refunded along with interest, appearing in other income in Q2 and Q3. The whole deposited amount has been recovered; management declined to comment on any further gain from the case.
- Cash position undisclosed: Management said cash is "quite enough to run the day-to-day operations as well as for the future expenses" but declined to share the current balance, saying exact balances as on 31st March will be shared in the next conference.
- Ferro Scrap Nigam Limited: The subsidiary delivered better results, driving the scrap recovery and allied jobs segment profit to ₹25.87 crore (vs ₹10.98 crore last year). Its sale process is organized by DIPAM under the Ministry of Finance; management declined to comment on valuation, timeline, or the strategy behind selling a subsidiary in the same business as the core, calling it a government decision.
Strategy & Roadmap: Still Taking Shape
- No FY25 guidance: Management called it "a little too premature to talk about that" and said any numbers would be speculative.
- E-commerce expansion models undefined: The company is working on various models for expanding e-commerce and expects to have "a clear focus on where we want to be and what we don't want to do" after a couple of months.
- No activity map yet: When asked for a conceptual map of the predominant business, opportunities, challenges, and new opportunities with potential size, management said it would take more time and promised a more meaningful discussion in the next con-call.
- Infinite opportunities, no prioritization: Management stated opportunities are "infinite" and the company wants to tap each opportunity that comes its way, but offered no framework for prioritization or resource allocation.
- Old-bus replacement opportunity: The government's plan to replace 8 lakh old buses with electric buses is an opportunity, but it will happen in a phased manner over a few years.
Kumar: "The opportunities are infinite and we would definitely want to tap each of these opportunities that come our way."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| E-commerce revenue growth | Hopeful of some growth in Q4 | Q4 FY24 |
| Vehicle scrapping JV profitability | MMRPL very near to breakeven; expects to become profitable | Going forward (2-3 years for substantial settling down) |
| E-commerce expansion roadmap | Clear focus on where to be and what not to do after internal consensus | "After a couple of months" |
| Activity mapping and opportunity discussion | More meaningful discussion on existing activity mapping and new opportunities | Next con-call (three months) |
| Cash balance disclosure | Exact balances as on 31st March to be shared | Next conference |
| Overhead management | Maintain total overhead around ₹110-120 crore with inflationary pressure | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated PBT (9M) | ₹233.37 cr, +7.01% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT (9M) | ₹155.92 cr, down from ₹165 cr YoY; higher tax rate |
| Standalone revenue (9M) | ₹316.23 cr, -13% YoY |
| Standalone e-commerce revenue (9M) | ₹268.05 cr, up from ₹244.86 cr YoY |
| Standalone e-auction revenue (9M) | ₹203.43 cr, major chunk of e-commerce |
| Standalone PBT (9M) | ₹216.63 cr, up from ₹206.71 cr YoY |
| Standalone PAT (9M) | ₹152.41 cr, down from ₹163.17 cr YoY |
| Standalone EPS (9M) | ₹21.65, down from ₹23.18 YoY |
| Consolidated FSNL revenue (9M) | ₹324.78 cr, up substantially from ₹304.31 cr YoY |
| Value of goods transacted (9M) | ₹1,17,823 cr through e-commerce and marketing portals |
| Scrap rates trend | Down ~10% YoY, impacting e-commerce revenue |
| Iron ore volumes | Volumes up, but revenue flat due to reduced charges |
| Scrap recovery segment profit (Q3) | ₹25.87 cr, vs ₹10.98 cr YoY and ₹10.94 cr QoQ |
| Vehicle scrapping JV centers | 7 centers, 41 collection centers; near breakeven |
| Standard Chartered Bank refund | ₹90 cr recovered with interest, booked in other income |