Key Takeaways
- Record profits across the group: All three entities (MSTC, FSNL, MMRPL) delivered record profits, with MMRPL turning profitable for the first time.
- E-commerce is the engine: E-commerce income jumped to ₹264 Cr from ₹202.77 Cr, driven by iron ore and scrap volumes; scrap alone now contributes 45–50% of that revenue.
- Trading drag is finally behind them: Two of three trading models are discontinued, and management expects the last provisioning tranche is done, removing a persistent P&L overhang.
- FSNL disinvestment is the near-term catalyst: The process is at an advanced stage, with the tender opening in the first week of June; the outcome will determine scrap recovery and future revenue trajectory.
- What to watch next quarter: The FSNL tender outcome, whether the Coal India portal begins to cannibalize volumes, and any concrete progress on the scrap aggregation model for smaller industries.
E-Commerce: The Core Growth Driver
- Iron ore and scrap dominate: E-commerce income rose to ₹264 Cr on strong iron ore prices and volumes; scrap sales grew ~34% YoY in volume and revenue, contributing 45–50% of total e-commerce income.
- Diversification is working: New categories added include gypsum sales for NTPC, a very old Chhattisgarh power plant sale, liquor license auctions for Rajasthan, and confiscated vehicle auctions for the Bihar excise department.
- Property portal gaining traction: The segment is making good inroads on banking sector NPAs and state/central government properties, with robust growth reported.
- Minerals mandate is a structural tailwind: The central government now requires state governments to sell major mineral blocks exclusively through MSTC's portal; management is engaging states to replicate iron ore's success for other minerals.
- Growth is real but unforecastable: Management declined to give a steady-state growth rate, citing dependence on commodity prices (steel, scrap, iron ore) that can add to or decrease revenues.
Surinder Kumar Gupta: "The government push for digital India and even state governments, central government every departments, every PSUs are going more and more towards the e-side e-commerce business... So basically the most government companies are going towards reprocessing and they want to sell all their whatever their scrap or useful things only through the e-processes so that is where we expect that we will be able to maintain the growth momentum but nevertheless the risk factors or the other factors like the commodity price... steel prices go up, scrap prices go up, iron ore prices go up, steel prices go up. So all these things will definitely to some extent will add or may decrease our revenues a bit..."
Trading Business: The Clean-Up Is Done
- Two models discontinued completely: Only the procurement model backed by 110% bank guarantee remains, with minuscule transaction volumes and small income; no losses are envisaged going forward.
- Provisioning overhang removed: This year's provisioning (~₹35 Cr, down from ~₹68 Cr last year) is expected to be the last tranche; management states almost all sticky provisioning has been done away with.
- Marketing segment distortion explained: The ₹413 Cr marketing revenue figure includes a ~₹220 Cr provision write-back; actual transaction volume was only ~₹160 Cr. The prior-year loss of ~₹5.9 Cr was a provisioning mismatch that will not recur.
- Q4 book-entry noise ends now: Large Q4 entries (₹200+ Cr other income from provision write-offs) are accounting-standard driven when financial assets are impaired; hardly any such entries are expected in the coming year.
Bhanu Kumar: "This year also we have done some provisioning but that we hope is the last tranche of provisioning and going forward there will be no provisioning required in this segment of business."
Subsidiaries & Disinvestment: The Value-Unlock Catalysts
- FSNL disinvestment at advanced stage: EOI has been floated and the tender opens in the first week of June; scrap recovery and future sales volumes depend on when the disinvestment procedure concludes.
- FSNL's Nagarnar catalyst: The NMDC plant at Nagarnar, where FSNL has secured contracts for flag operations, will become operational in the current financial year, providing good revenue projections for this year and next.
- MMRPL turnaround: The JV moved from loss to a token profit; three plants are operational with good returns, and management targets completing four or five plants in the current financial year, though state-level policy implementation by MoRTH remains a gating factor.
- Scrap aggregation model: This year's focus is expanding the aggregation model for smaller industries, using industrial development corporations or government intermediaries as facilitators, supporting the Ministry of Steel's goal of augmenting scrap supply for secondary steel production.
Client & Portal Developments
- Tata Group onboarded: MSTC signed agreements with Tata Power (Mumbai and Delhi) to sell old scrap and redundant items; Tata Group is availing services for scrap, though not yet Tata Steel or Tata Motors specifically.
- ONGC portal delivered: A portal with advanced features was delivered last year for ONGC and its group companies.
- Coal India risk is real but not immediate: Coal India has developed its own auction portal but it is not yet operational; MSTC continues to provide services and has been engaged for special changes mandated by the central government. Management's personal view is it may take at least a couple of years for Coal India's portal to stabilize, so no major volume change is expected this year.
- Jaivik portal stalled: The agriculture portal has not made much progress; logistics, packaging, and handling remain unresolved grey areas, and the channel is not yet established.
- Website benchmarking gap acknowledged: When asked about benchmarking against Amazon or Flipkart, management admitted MSTC is not as robust because that level of consumer-grade UX is not its requirement; its buyer base is large but not comparable to those platforms.
Surinder Kumar Gupta: "We will admit that we are not as robust as Amazon or Flipkart because that is not our requirement. So basically we have a large buyer base but that also is nothing compared to the Amazon or Flipkart."
Financial Health & Receivables
- Receivables are well-secured: Of ₹408 Cr in receivables, ₹200+ Cr is secured by 110% bank guarantees, ~₹100 Cr from the associate model carries creditors' guarantees, and less than ₹100 Cr is from e-commerce; all three categories are described as safe with no major provisioning needs foreseen.
- Provisioning trend declining: Provisioning fell to ~₹35 Cr this year from ~₹68 Cr last year; only very minuscule provisions are expected going forward in the normal course of business, with further write-offs only if court or NCLT cases are lost.
- Standard Chartered case contained: No further book entries are expected; the amount already sits as a loan on the books, and any outcome will be contingent in nature.
- Tax regime choice: MSTC continues with the old tax regime due to certain tax credits and MAT credits, bringing the net effective rate below the 30% base rate; management will not forecast next year's rate but will pursue maximum tax planning available under law.
Subrata Sarkar: "We cannot comment right now what will be our income and what will be the circumstances, what type of income will derive so it is very difficult to tell all these things but we will try to take maximum amount of tax planning that is available as per the law in India that much we can do."
Identity & Structural Changes
- MOA change underway: MSTC is in the process of changing its Memorandum of Association to reflect its current business activities, which are neither pure IT nor pure trading but business assisted by IT tools; the process is described as long.
- Name change considered but not committed: Management acknowledged investor sentiment around a name change to better reflect the e-commerce nature of the business and said it will proactively think about it, but made no commitment. The "MSTC" name is now treated as a standalone identity, not an abbreviation for its scrap-trading origins.
Surinder Kumar Gupta: "Name is fine because now our name is MSTC not scrap basically previously it was a scrap now it is not that now we are known as just MSTC so no abbreviation... we are basically not IT Company also and not a trading company also but naturally we need to change our MOA we are basically doing whatever business basically assisted by the IT tools."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FSNL disinvestment tender | Tender to open | First week of June |
| FSNL Nagarnar plant operational | NMDC plant flag operations begin, driving revenue | Current financial year |
| MMRPL plant expansion | Complete four or five plants | Current financial year |
| Trading provisioning | No further provisioning required in trading segment | Going forward |
| Coal India volume stability | No major change in coal sale volumes expected | At least this year |
| Coal India portal cannibalization risk | Portal may take a couple of years to stabilize; MSTC may lose business if it scales | Personal view: at least a couple of years |
| Q4 book entries | Hardly any such entries expected | Coming year |
| Scrap aggregation model expansion | Focus on expanding aggregation model for smaller industries via industrial development corporations | This year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue from operations (net) growth | ~23% YoY |
| Standalone total income growth | 30% YoY |
| Standalone PBT | ₹220 cr, doubled from ₹114.68 cr YoY |
| Standalone PAT | ₹200 cr, doubled from ₹101.07 cr YoY |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹232.93 cr, up 70% YoY from ₹135.88 cr |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹119.13 cr, up 76.29% YoY from ₹102.95 cr |
| Standalone EPS | 28%, almost double from 14% YoY |
| E-commerce income | ₹264 cr, up from ₹202.77 cr YoY |
| E-commerce transaction volume | ~₹1,34,000 cr |
| Scrap sales volume and revenue growth | ~34% YoY |
| Scrap sales value | ₹5,000–6,000 cr |
| Scrap revenue as a percentage of total e-commerce revenue | 45%–50% |
| Scrap revenue | ~₹140 cr, grown at ~35% (per an analyst's math) |
| Marketing revenues | ₹413 cr vs ₹406 cr last year; includes ₹220 cr provision write-back, actual transactions ~₹160 cr |
| Marketing segment loss | ₹5.9 cr last year |
| Provisioning for the year | ₹35 cr plus, down from ~₹68 cr last year |
| Provision written-off (book entry, null P&L effect) | ₹221 cr |
| Provision no longer required (book entry, null P&L effect) | ₹200+ cr |
| Standalone gross receivables | ₹403 cr net of provision; ₹147 cr provision made for Standard Chartered case |
| Receivables backed by 110% BG (trading) | ₹200+ cr, more than 50% of receivables |
| Associate model receivables | ~₹100 cr, secured by creditors' guarantee |
| E-commerce receivables | less than ₹100 cr |
| Other income in e-commerce segment (registration, transaction fees) | ~₹30 cr |
| Earnings from coal segment | ₹10–11 cr |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ~₹800 cr |
| Current ratio | 1.07 vs 1.09 |
| Tax rate | 30% plus surcharge (old regime); net effective rate lower due to credits and exemptions |
| Deposit in Standard Chartered case | ₹55 cr, under financial assets deposit |