Key Takeaways
- Margin dip on launch costs, not structural: EBITDA margin fell to 12.1% from 14.3% sequentially, driven by advance manpower for new launches and inventory build-up from block holidays, not a change in underlying profitability.
- High-voltage wiring harness is now a live, multi-segment business: A dedicated Chennai line is operational, orders span two-wheelers, passenger cars and commercial vehicles, and the content per vehicle can rival the low-voltage side.
- Commodity tailwinds are expected from Q2: The pass-through mechanism for copper and yen means recent price drops should start benefiting the industry from the next quarter.
- Semiconductor pain may ease by autumn: Management pointed to September/October for a visible improvement in chip supply, which would unlock OEM production schedules.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised commodity benefit and semiconductor easing actually lift volumes and allow those pre-trained launch teams to convert into revenue.
Margin Walk
- The 220 bps sequential EBITDA drop was attributed by an analyst to both gross margin contraction and a jump in employee cost; management focused its explanation on the cost side.
- Employee cost rose 6.5% QoQ because new launches in Bengaluru and Chennai required manpower to be hired, trained and deployed 3–4 months before any revenue ramp. Trial runs and efficiency build-up mean these costs normalize only over time.
- Inventory build-up amplified the ratio: Block holidays and lower-than-anticipated OEM production left finished goods on the books, making employee cost look worse as a percentage of sales. Last-minute OEM schedule changes also hurt.
- RM cost as a share of sales rose ~110 bps QoQ, which management called a product-mix effect rather than a like-for-like cost increase, adding that the difference is too small to break out in detail.
- The company does not target a margin at project award: it focuses on return on capital employed and hunts for improvement opportunities over the life of the project.
Pankaj Mital: "Basically, a profitability of a particular project or a particular product is very difficult for us to answer in general because there is no shade specific to it. It's over a period of time as the teams get opportunities and they find more and more improvement opportunities, we try keep working very hard to create various possibilities."
High-Voltage Wiring Harness
- A dedicated high-voltage line was commissioned in Chennai during the quarter, serving passenger cars, two-wheelers and commercial vehicles including buses. A new plant was also established in Chennai with associated capex.
- Orders have been received across all three vehicle segments, though management declined to disclose order values or customer names, citing confidentiality.
- Content per vehicle is highly variable: the high-voltage portion (charging connector to high-voltage cables) can be as expensive as the entire low-voltage harness, but the ratio swings widely by model and OEM, so no single EV-versus-ICE multiplier can be given.
- Safety is the differentiator in execution: high-voltage cables carry 120–180 amps versus 40–80 amps at 12 volts in a conventional car, and poor assembly creates an electrocution risk. Management framed this complexity as a barrier that rewards experienced harness makers.
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "I was just saying the care that has to be taken for the high voltage cables because if it's not taken care of then people can get electrocuted, so that's the huge difference between car. Car is operating at 12 volts and maybe 40-80 amps at max and high voltage cables go up to 120-140-180 amps."
Demand & Volume Recovery
- April and May were weak for car makers; June improved. The quarter carried the combined weight of COVID restrictions, semiconductor shortages and unpredictable OEM production schedules.
- Semiconductor relief is now in sight: management stated that "by September, October you will start to see the semiconductor issues," without specifying whether this means easing or simply increased visibility of the issue.
- Commodity price drops should flow through from Q2: the pass-through mechanism for copper and the yen means falling input prices reduce working capital and, as prices stabilize at lower averages, the benefit works through the P&L.
- The tone on the near-term pipeline was bullish: "The coming quarters seem to be that much more exciting," though no volume or revenue quantification was attached.
Competitive Position & Strategy
- Management refuses to benchmark against peers: when asked why gross margins are higher than competitors, the response was that the company follows its own continuous-improvement process ("BY BY") and does not look at others.
- The wiring harness is positioned as a high-complexity product: management pointed to two-wheeler fires as evidence that the work is harder than outsiders assume, implicitly arguing that execution quality is a moat.
- On the Hyundai/KIA question, an analyst asked whether the existing Kyungshin JV at the parent level would block MSWIL from supplying those OEMs. Management deflected, stating the JV sits outside MSWIL and the question belongs at SAMIL; when pressed, the reply was "Why would we compete with ourselves?" without a direct yes or no.
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "Wiring harness is a very difficult thing and probably I do not know whom you are referring to, but you can see a lot of bikes that catch fire and two-wheeler and all that. It is not something so simple as what people think it is."
Unanswered Questions
- Segment revenue breakup (passenger car, commercial vehicle, two-wheeler) was requested but not provided; management said these numbers are best viewed annually and the answer was cut off.
- EV versus ICE content increase by vehicle category was requested as an index or percentage; management declined, citing extreme model-to-model variability.
- High-voltage order value and customer names were requested and declined on confidentiality grounds.
- Lease payment quantum from MSWIL to SAMIL was requested; management said it was difficult to provide off-hand but confirmed it aligns with the shareholder-approved agreement.
- Hyundai/KIA supply question received a rhetorical deflection rather than a direct answer.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Commodity benefit flow-through | Benefit of recent commodity price drops to start appearing for the industry from Q2 onwards | From Q2 FY23 onwards |
| Semiconductor supply improvement | "By September, October you will start to see the semiconductor issues" | September/October |
| Employee cost normalization | Costs to normalize as new launches ramp up and efficiency levels are achieved, but specific guidance on manpower cost should be avoided | No date given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not disclosed for the quarter; management stated results are a "very good set of numbers" |
| EBITDA margin | 12.1%, down from 13.2% in Q4 FY22 and 14.3% in Q3 FY22 (per an analyst's math) |
| Gross margin | Contracted QoQ, per analyst observation acknowledged by management |
| Raw material cost as a percentage of sales | Increased ~110 bps QoQ, attributed to product mix changes |
| Employee cost | Increased 6.5% sequentially, driven by new facility staffing and training for upcoming launches |
| Employee cost as a percentage of sales | 16.5% in Q1 FY23 |
| Tax rate | 25%, the company follows the new tax regime |
| CAPEX guidance for FY23 | ₹100 cr (+/-) ₹25 cr, so maybe ₹125 cr, including a new plant in Chennai |
| High-voltage wiring harness capacity | New dedicated line established in Chennai during the quarter, covering passenger cars, two-wheelers, and commercial vehicles |
| Low-voltage wiring harness share in a passenger car | 75%-80% of the wiring harness remains low voltage, even in EVs |
| Shareholder approval for bifurcation | 99.4% of minority shareholders voted in favor |