Key Takeaways
- Solid quarter, operational ramp-up underway: Revenue grew ~25% YoY despite headwinds from fewer working hours and customer production losses, while three new plants added 7,000–8,000 employees over nine months to support a growing order book.
- Order book deepening with 17 new models: Six new or full model changes added to the 11 already launched, and the company is winning EV orders across passenger vehicles, buses, two-wheelers and commercial vehicles.
- Working capital bloated by customer-driven inventory: Inventories rose ₹312 crores vs March 2022 as customers asked MSWIL to hold higher stock amid supply chain uncertainty and extended older-model lifecycles; normalization is expected over 3–6 months.
- Margins under construction: New models start with lower profitability due to initial setup and low localization, while cost-realignment negotiations with customers remain a continuous, unresolved process.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹312 crore inventory overhang begins to unwind, the pace of margin maturation as new plants reach optimum utilization in Q1 FY24, and any closure on outstanding cost negotiations in the seasonally important Q4.
Revenue & Operational Performance
- Top-line growth despite disruptions: Revenue grew ~25% YoY, but the quarter was marked by fewer working hours, ERP maintenance shutdowns, and customer production losses from supply chain issues. Copper price movement was in a narrow range and not a material factor.
- Forex loss hit the bottom line: A ₹10 crore forex loss arose from the sharp strengthening of the Japanese yen in December, which impacted the reinstatement of sundry creditors.
- Other income collapsed QoQ: Non-operating other income fell from ₹11 crores to under ₹1 crore. Management initially attributed this to lower pass-through service volumes under Ind AS 115, then noted it is non-operating and outside EBITDA, promising to check and revert.
- Employee base rationalizing after a build phase: Net headcount rose by 7,000–8,000 over nine months for three new plants, but declined QoQ from September to December as efficiencies improved and ramp-up progressed, leading to better cost absorption.
Order Book & New Model Pipeline
- 17 models in the pipeline: Six new or full model changes were added to the order book this quarter, joining 11 models already launched. These wins span both ICE and EV platforms across passenger vehicles, buses, two-wheelers and commercial vehicles.
- EV traction is broad-based: The company is winning EV orders across multiple vehicle segments, and these are already part of current financials. Management expects positive market traction in FY23–24.
- New model profitability is a ramp, not a switch: New models start with lower margins because of initial setup costs, training, and low localization on day one. Profitability matures over time as volumes become visible, efficiencies improve, and localization ramps up.
- Content-per-vehicle detail withheld: An analyst asked for quantification of how much higher content MSWIL supplies on a full model change versus the earlier model. Management declined, saying, “Let's avoid getting into that level of discussion.”
Gauba: “Motherson has been known for localization and it's not possible to just start with a high level of localization on day one, given sometimes the volume visibility as well. So straight away, it takes time for model profitability to mature over a period of time.”
Capacity Expansion & Capex
- Three new plants commissioned: The company opened three new plants in the last 9–10 months, and optimum utilization of these facilities is expected in Q1 FY24.
- Capex is forward-looking by design: Current capacity is adequate for the 11+6 models, but capex will continue because plants must be built to full capacity well in advance of launch. Planning for FY24–25 models is already underway in FY23–24.
- The 80% trigger: Management’s golden rule is that once utilization crosses 80%, capacity expansion begins.
- New wire types under development: The company is developing high-temperature cables, LVD cables, and data cables with group synergy, with a strong focus on localization.
Sehgal: “Jinesh, we are continuously winning orders. So, for those things we will be doing it. And normal time when we start looking at new capacity enhancement, we start almost a year, year and a half before the predicted date of supply.”
Working Capital & Inventory
- Inventory build is customer-driven, not operational: Inventories rose ₹312 crores vs March 2022 for three reasons: customers asked MSWIL to maintain high inventory levels amid supply chain uncertainty; customers extended the life of older models, creating dual inventory; and express inventories were requested by customers.
- Normalization expected in 3–6 months: Management expects the inventory overhang to equalize as the supply chain stabilizes, older-model inventory unwinds, and planned orders execute.
Sehgal: “Many of the customers are extending the life of the older models, because of supply chain issues or things like that. So there is two kind of inventory and also express inventories have been asked because of this confusion. So, I think over the period of time, maybe three months, six months, it's going to equalize and that will lead to reduction of the working capital.”
Cost Negotiations & Margin Levers
- Cost realignment is a continuous process: The company is engaged in ongoing negotiations with customers to recover cost increases from labour, components, and forex. Many have already been resolved, but the process continues with positive customer engagement.
- No quantification provided: An analyst asked for a specific number on under-recovery or how close the company is to resolving cost realignment. Management described it as a continuous process and did not provide a figure.
- Q4 is the seasonal push for closure: The company tries to finalize all outstanding negotiations as much as possible in Q4, the last quarter of the fiscal year.
Sehgal: “Negotiations in our business is a continuous process, because wirings harness is the most changed component in an automotive, whichever way you look at it. If an electrical part changes, the wiring harness changes.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Optimum utilization of new plants | Three new plants to reach optimum utilization | Q1 FY24 |
| Working capital normalization | ₹312 crore inventory overhang to unwind as supply chain stabilizes and older-model inventory reduces | 3–6 months |
| Cost negotiations closure | Outstanding cost-realignment negotiations to be finalized as much as possible | Q4 FY23 |
| Demand outlook | Car demand expected to go up normally; results to reflect improvement | Coming quarters |
| EV market traction | Positive market traction expected for EV orders already in financials | FY23–24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated in absolute terms; growth impacted by fewer working hours, ERP maintenance, and customer production cuts due to supply chain issues |
| EBITDA | ₹4 cr in one-off items recognized in the quarter |
| Forex loss | ~₹10 cr, due to Japanese yen strengthening and reinstatement of sundry creditors |
| Other income | Less than ₹1 cr, down from ~₹11 cr QoQ |
| Capacity expansion | Over 25% increase with three new facilities added |
| Net employee addition (9M FY23) | ~7,000–8,000 people added |
| Employee headcount (QoQ) | Declined from September quarter to December quarter |
| New model pipeline | 11 existing + 6 new/full model changes to constitute 40% of revenues |
| New model composition | ~60–70% completely new models, ~30–40% full model changes |
| Inventories | Increased by ~₹312 cr vs March 2022 |
| Utilization threshold for capacity expansion | 80% of capacity triggers further expansion |