Key Takeaways
- India wiring shines in a tough quarter: MSWIL revenue rose ~14% QoQ and EBITDA ~31% QoQ, while the global group battled inflation, energy shocks and supply disruption.
- Global margins under real pressure: SAMIL standalone margin was 18.2%, flattered by a one-off ₹65 crores from MSWIL fees; PKC margins fell YoY on double-digit wage hikes in Europe and Mexico.
- Energy and wage costs are being pushed to customers: Transparent discussions are underway across all businesses, but timelines vary by contract and no standard pass-through exists, especially in SMP where contracts lack automatic indexation.
- Chip supply is improving, not yet solved: Management sees daily improvement and expects considerable easing by September end, with December as the fallback if the war disrupts that timeline.
- What to watch next quarter: The new segment-wise reporting construct, the pace at which customer cost-sharing talks convert into margin relief, and any concrete sign that chip supply has indeed eased considerably.
India Wiring: The Standout Performer
- MSWIL delivered strong QoQ growth in a quarter where the rest of the group struggled, with revenue up ~14% and EBITDA up ~31% sequentially. Management called India "a shining point in the whole group."
- Gross margin held broadly flat from nine months to full year despite raw material increases, aided by cost containment across shipping, freight and transport.
- A one-off fee inflow lifted SAMIL standalone: MSWIL paid nine months of rental and management fees (₹65 crores pre-tax, ₹48.9 crores post-tax) accrued in Q4 as the first quarter giving effect to the demerger. This partly explains the 18.2% standalone margin.
- Workforce structure as a margin lever: A 60–70% female workforce with a higher churn rate was cited as one advantage point helping margin sustainability.
- Management declined to break down revenue outperformance into content increase vs pricing increase, stating it does not perform such analysis and focuses instead on plant-level execution and waste elimination.
- Market share questions were firmly rejected: When pressed for MSWIL market share in PV, CV and two-wheeler segments, management responded "We do not believe in market share" and "Why do you want to know that? How does it help you?"
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "I do not subscribe to this that I have to compete with them. I have to keep competing with Motherson. If I can beat Motherson, then I am sure I am going to be in business."
Global Cost Pressures & Customer Negotiations
- Energy costs hit SMP harder than SMR because SMP has more plants in Germany and affected areas, while SMR is more concentrated in less-affected regions. Hungary continues with its Russian gas contract while the rest of the EU tries to move away.
- SMP contracts lack automatic raw material pass-through: Contracts allow some margin of movement, but beyond a certain limit it becomes a discussion with the customer. Those talks are already happening, on an annual basis.
- PKC margins fell YoY despite slightly higher revenue, driven by high inflationary pressure on raw materials and people costs, plus erratic production due to material shortages. Capacity exists but plants are not running at 100%.
- Wage inflation is unprecedented: Europe saw double-digit minimum wage hikes in most countries, and Mexico imposed a 22% minimum wage increase. Wiring is a people-intensive business, so the impact is compounded.
- Management argues customers face the same problem: Car makers also have workforces and are affected by the same minimum wage hikes, so "there is no way that they can run away from it." Discussions are at different stages depending on contracts, launches and information exchange, with no standard timeline.
Laksh Vaaman Sehgal: "These are all costs that are really out of our control, including not just the energy costs, but also the raw material and consequent raw material prices that, for example, they are getting from our suppliers, etc."
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "It has always been mitigated that the customer also is facing the same problem. Customer is not that he is sitting pretty, and he has his own workforce, and he has to pay them nothing. I mean, here, the minimum wage has gone 22% in Mexico. So, even the car makers are affected, so there is no way that they can run away from it."
SMP Greenfield Plants: Turnaround Validated
- Tuscaloosa (Alabama) is now a "very-very satisfactory" performer on both top and bottom line, with all past Greenfield growing pains behind it. The plant serves Daimler SUVs and is continually improving operational efficiency.
- Kecskemét (Hungary) is a "very different story than it was two years ago," now a well-operating organization performing above the SMP average on financial indicators. It supplies Daimler and Audi premium vehicles.
- Both locations face the same inflation pressures as the rest of SMP but are counter-measuring through effective customer negotiations and price discussions.
Chip Supply & Production Outlook
- Management sees daily improvement in the chip situation and expects it to have eased considerably by September end. If the war or other disruptions intervene, December is the fallback timeline for visible betterment.
- Behind-the-scenes recovery work is underreported: Plants that had been "given up as bad have been raised, started," but companies do not publicize which plants are restarting because competitors would gain that intelligence.
- Management declined to comment on a customer CEO's statement about easing chip supply and ramping production pace, stating "Can't answer customer comment."
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "People are thinking that the world is doing nothing, but please believe me even plants which had been given up as bad have been raised, started, lot of things are happening, but the people are not talking about which plant what is happening and all that because the competitor gets that information that becomes at risk for tougher for obvious business reasons."
MSWIL Strategy: EVs, Diversification & Capital Allocation
- EV component localization is on hold because electric car volumes in India are too small to justify the tooling investment, which alone can cost crores. Management will revisit the make-or-buy decision in 2–5 years when volumes materialize.
- Electrification and hydrogen investments are coming: MSWIL will invest "a tremendous amount of money" in electrification needs and hydrogen cars, requiring new technologies, new products and new materials beyond normal wires and components.
- Industrial wiring diversification will be addressed at a five-year plan waypoint meeting in November 2022, with a half-yearly report to follow. Management asked analysts to wait six months for details.
- Cash will be returned to shareholders alongside necessary investments to stay ahead of customer needs as the domestic industry undergoes change. A dividend is proposed and will be paid in FY23 to all shareholders including public shareholders.
Vivek Chaand Sehgal: "If you go and blindly go and copy the components since I am making it here, I think it is a big, big mistake, at the end of the day, you need the volume, otherwise, you are better off importing it."
Reorganization & Reporting Changes
- The demerger is complete: Q4 FY22 is the first quarter giving effect to the segregation of MSWIL. Businesses that existed in erstwhile SAMIL standalone are now part of SAML standalone, while 100% subsidiaries and JVs remain as separate legal entities.
- A new reporting construct arrives next quarter: SAMIL will share broad business segment-wise revenue and EBITDA, replacing the current format.
- SAMIL standalone other income surged to ₹711 crores for the full year (vs ₹110 crores), largely due to dividends received during the year from merged entities. ₹264 crores of dividend income was received in Q4 alone.
- Several data requests were deferred to the annual report: gross block figures for FY21 and FY22 for both SAMIL and MSWIL, and foreign exchange exposure data for MSWIL's import content.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| New segment reporting | SAMIL to share broad business segment-wise revenue and EBITDA | From next quarter (Q1 FY23) |
| Chip supply easing | Situation improving daily; expected to ease considerably | By September end; December if disrupted |
| Industrial wiring update | Half-yearly report on industrial segments at five-year plan waypoint | November 2022 |
| MSWIL dividend payment | Dividend proposed, to be paid to all shareholders | In FY23 |
| EV component localization decision | Make-or-buy decision depends on volumes materializing | In another 2–5 years |
| Customer cost-sharing talks | Discussions ongoing at different stages; margins "definitely will be better" if customers give support | As contracts and negotiations conclude |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (MSWIL) | ₹1,662 cr, up almost 14% QoQ |
| EBITDA growth (MSWIL) | Up almost 31% QoQ |
| Revenue (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹16,911 cr |
| EBITDA (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹1,287 cr |
| PAT (SAMIL consolidated) | ₹122 cr |
| Revenue (SAMIL standalone) | ₹1,611 cr |
| Operating margin (SAMIL standalone) | 18.2%, includes one-off pre-tax income of ₹65 cr from MSWIL rental and management fees accrued for nine months |
| One-off pre-tax income (SAMIL standalone) | ₹65 cr, nine-month rental and management fees from MSWIL |
| One-off post-tax income (SAMIL standalone) | ₹48.9 cr |
| Copper as a percentage of raw material cost (MSWIL) | 18% to 22% ballpark, varies by product mix; higher for EVs |
| Workforce composition (MSWIL) | 60–70% ladies, which tend to have a higher churn rate |
| Mexico minimum wage increase | 22% |
| Europe minimum wage increases | Double-digit increases in most countries |
| Working capital expansion (SAMIL) | ₹2,000 cr, driven by higher inventory and multiple supplier bases due to supply chain disruptions |