Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, steady execution: Revenue grew 5% YoY in a tough market, while EBITDA and PAT rose 9% and 14% respectively on cost optimization. Management stayed focused on inventory control and profitable liquidation.
- The consignment model is the moat: With 98% of sales on consignment, the company controls inventory from factory to shelf, takes back unsold goods, and discounts them at its own pace, protecting both brand value and gross margins.
- Store expansion is cautious and conditional: The plan calls for 25–30 new stores in FY25, but Tier 2/3 markets have underperformed and management will alter plans as the year unfolds, preferring to under-commit and over-deliver.
- Mid-teens growth aspiration rests on a demand recovery: The target depends on a festival and marriage season pickup now that elections are behind; the market for mid-premium apparel remains subdued by inflation and a summer heat wave.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festival season actually delivers the hoped-for demand recovery, the pace of store openings against the cautious Tier 2/3 outlook, and any movement on the working capital reduction target.
Demand Environment
- What hurt Q1: Consumer behaviour was dampened by an inflationary environment and a nationwide heat wave during summer, keeping the market for premium and mid-premium branded apparel subdued.
- The recovery bet: Management is hoping that with elections behind and prices stable, the festival season and marriage season should pick up well, though this is an aspiration rather than a forecast.
- Same-store sales held up: SSSG stood at 3% despite difficult market conditions, suggesting the brand retained its core customer base even as discretionary spending stayed tight.
- Tier 2/3 caution: Tier 2 and Tier 3 markets have not behaved to their true potential, prompting a cautious approach to store openings that will be altered as the year unfolds.
Khushlani: "we believe in under committing and over delivering rather than just putting numbers out there"
Business Model & Inventory Control
- Consignment as competitive advantage: Nearly all sales (98%) are on a consignment basis, giving the company total control over inventory throughout the pipeline from factory to store shelves. Unsold seasonal inventory is taken back and discounted at the company's desired pace rather than pushed onto channel partners.
- Returns provision reflects model shift, not distress: The provision for returns increased from 22% in Q1 last year to 25% this year, consistent with Q4 FY24. This is not due to an expected increase in returns but reflects the shift to sale-or-return (SOR) basis from outright sales. If returns percentage reduces, the provision will be changed accordingly.
- Liquidation discipline protects margins: Old inventory is cleared through third-party e-commerce partners and factory outlets at the company's own pace to avoid deep discounting that would erode brand value. This approach helps maintain gross margins.
- Online is a liquidation channel, not a margin driver: Profitability on online third-party channels is considerably lower than main channels (EBO and MBO) because e-commerce remains a liquidation channel for old-season merchandise, though the company still earns profits on those sales.
- IT backbone enables control: The company has a direct POS connection with sales data every 30 minutes, an ERP providing SKU-wise data on what sells where, and a strong internal team monitoring sales for inter-store transfers and merchandising decisions using BI tools.
Khushlani: "we intend to have total control of the entire inventory in my pipeline, starting from what is on my machines at my factories to what is on my shelves in my stores to what is in my warehouse. Because at the end of every season whatever is left over I like to pick that up and discount it and sell it at my own pace at the discount at which I desire rather than pushing it down the primary partner's throat"
Margins & Profitability
- Gross margin trajectory: Gross margins will remain "there and thereabouts"; last year was a little north of 56–57%, this year 58-odd percent.
- EBITDA margin range: Expected to be maintained between 28% to 30%, with management explicit that the business is not about making 1% or 1.5% extra EBITDA but about keeping inventory in check and ensuring products can be liquidated profitably.
- Returns impact on margins: If less inventory is returned from channel partners, margins will go up, creating a potential upside lever tied to sell-through performance.
- Cost optimization drove profit growth: EBITDA and PAT grew 9% and 14% respectively on 5% revenue growth, mainly due to cost optimization measures.
Khushlani: "Our business is not so much about making 1% extra EBITDA or 1.5% extra EBITDA. Our business is about keeping the inventory in check ensuring that whatever we have made we are able to liquidate that profitably."
Store Expansion & Channel Mix
- Measured rollout: The company added five new stores in Q1 FY25, bringing total store strength to 430. The full-year plan calls for 25 to 30 new stores, though management may end up opening 40 or two to three fewer depending on the type of stores that come up.
- MBO and EBO move together: MBO performance in the last quarter has been decent, and the two channels typically move hand in hand.
- Digital salience push: The company intends to increase salience on digital platforms to improve market share in the D2C space, with branding and advertising spend planned at approximately 5% of revenues for the full year.
Competitive Positioning
- Differentiation over price: Management argues the brand occupies a unique position created from inception by finding gaps in the market, with a distinct tribe of followers. The company does not see itself as a "me too" brand competing on price.
- D2C competition dismissed: When asked about heat from new-age D2C brands with more customization, management said "not really" and stated they do not see these brands giving them heat, though this deflected from the specific question about competitive pressure.
Khushlani: "if you end up being just another me too brand trying to sell or be another app also ran in the industry where you're trying to sell on the edge of price or something but we are not like that. We are a brand which is very unique in itself and you will only know that if you visit some of the competitor stores and visit our stores. And actually touch and feel our products"
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Debt-free: The company is debt-free as on the date of the call.
- Working capital target: Management is targeting another five-odd days reduction in working capital. Deposits from franchises (around INR40 crores) reduce working capital by about 25 days if given effect.
- Receivables context: Receivable days appear higher but include facing stock required in stores and advances from franchisee partners as deposits. No material write-offs on account of inventory or receivables in company history.
- Dividend policy: The company has been a dividend-paying company in the past (except COVID years) and will continue to do so, with the payout ratio decided on an annual basis. Besides using cash for expansion, the company will continue dividends.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Mid-teens growth, subject to recovery in industry demand | FY25 |
| Store expansion | 25 to 30 new stores (may reach 40 or fall short by 2–3) | FY25 |
| Branding spend | Approximately 5% of revenues | FY25 |
| EBITDA margin | Maintain between 28% to 30% | FY25 |
| Working capital reduction | Another five-odd days reduction | FY25 |
| Long-term growth | Double the business | Four to five years |
| Profitability principle | Will never compromise profitability for growth | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹124 cr, +5% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹33.4 cr, +9% YoY (vs ₹30.3 cr in Q1 FY24) |
| EBITDA margin | 27%, vs 28-30% targeted range |
| PAT growth | +14% YoY |
| Gross profit | ₹72.6 cr, +9% YoY |
| Gross margin | 58.6%, vs a little north of 56% last year |
| Same-store sales growth | 3% YoY |
| Total stores | 430, added 5 in Q1 |
| FY25 planned store additions | 25 to 30 new stores |
| FY25 revenue growth aspiration | Mid-teens, subject to market recovery |
| FY25 branding and advertising spend | ~5% of revenues |
| Touchpoints | Over 1,800 across 596 cities as of June 30, 2024 |
| Provision for returns | 25%, up from 22% in Q1 FY24, consistent with Q4 FY24 |
| Realization vs MRP | ~70% of MRP |
| Average revenue per store | ~₹90 lakhs per annum |