Key Takeaways
- Subdued demand, brand investment drags profit: Revenue grew 15% in Q3 and 19% in 9M against a muted retail backdrop, but PAT degrew 7% in 9M as the company made a conscious call to raise advertising spend during a "decluttered" period.
- Margin sacrificed for brand building: EBITDA margin fell to 28.3% in Q3 from 29.8% in 9M, driven by higher ad costs; excluding this, EBITDA would have grown ~18% YoY. Management intends to keep ad spend at 4-5% of revenue for at least the next year or two.
- Same-store growth stalled at 0.5%: Management is not happy with this number and blames muted market demand and consumer sentiment across the industry, with minimal growth seen only in Q3.
- Online is a liquidation channel, not a growth driver: The company uses online to clear old-season merchandise profitably and does not produce special units for it; online sales fluctuate based on inventory levels of old stock.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 revenue can accelerate enough to hit the 18-20% full-year growth target, given Q3 was 9% down QoQ and last year's Q4 was soft; and whether the elevated ad spend starts converting into improved same-store growth.
Demand & Revenue Performance
- Growth despite headwinds: Revenue grew 15% in Q3 and 19% in 9M, which management frames as outperformance in a subdued retail sector with a muted festive period.
- Seasonality explains QoQ softness: Q1 and Q3 are generally muted compared to Q2 and Q4; Q2 is a higher season because of the autumn-winter and spring-summer season cycles.
- Same-store growth near zero: SSG was just 0.5%, with the company remaining flattish till H1 and seeing minimal growth only in Q3. Management targets 3-5% SSG going forward, which would be a mix of volume and price.
- Full-price sell-through dynamics: Roughly 80% of production is cleared by end of season sale, split roughly half fresh sale and half end of season sale; in a good season, fresh sale is a little more than half, in a bad season, a little less.
- Q4 uncertainty: Q4 is generally higher than Q3, but the season has been muted and the outcome will depend on goods returned by distributors. Last year's Q4 was impacted because GR percentage was a little higher and the company sent out fresh goods earlier to test the market.
Khushlani: "The most important thing in our business is to be able to liquidate everything we make profitably. That's what our business is all about."
Advertising Investment & Margin Impact
- Conscious brand investment in a quiet window: Management raised advertising spend during a period when competitors were cutting back, calling it a "decluttered time" to build brand appeal through cinema films, digital, social media, billboards, multiplex cinemas and live events.
- Margin hit quantified: EBITDA margin fell to 28.3% in Q3 from 29.8% in 9M, entirely attributable to higher advertising costs; excluding this expense, EBITDA would have grown ~18% YoY. PAT for 9M degrew 7% YoY for the same reason.
- Ad spend to stay elevated: Management plans to spend 4-5% of revenue on branding and advertising going forward, with no significant uptick anticipated next fiscal year versus the current year. The commitment extends for at least the next year or two.
- Sustainable margin range: In normal conditions, EBITDA margin should be higher than 30%, ranging 30-33%; if the market is subdued, it would range around 30%.
- Tactical, not permanent: Decisions on advertising spend will be taken year-on-year and season-on-season, implying the 4-5% range is a ceiling rather than a fixed annual commitment.
Khushlani: "This is an investment that is made in the brand, and that's a conscious call that was taken. And when some calls are taken in the middle of that, there's a clutter that happens when everyone is advertising. And it was a decluttered time."
Channel Strategy & Store Expansion
- EBOs as primary growth engine: The company aims to add 50-55 new stores on a net basis for full year FY24, with a steady-state pace of 50-60 stores per year depending on availability. EBO growth was 12% in the period.
- MBO expansion ambition without a timeline: Management believes Mufti must be present in every mid-premium to premium casual wear MBO, but cannot give an exact number or timeline for reaching 1,500 or 1,800 MBOs, citing multiple dynamics.
- Online as a profitable liquidation channel: The company does not produce special units for online; it uses the channel to clear old-season merchandise. Online sales fluctuate based on inventory levels of old stock, and the company is able to liquidate profitably even online.
- Growth composition: Future growth will come from a combination of inorganic (new stores and MBOs) and organic (same-store growth) factors.
- Warehouse capacity tripled: Warehouse space was expanded from 50,000 sq ft to 140,000 sq ft across different levels, making the company future-ready for anticipated growth.
Khushlani: "If there is any MBO, worth its salt, which has mid-premium to premium casual wear, then Mufti has to be a part of it."
Inventory & Working Capital
- Inventory build is strategic: Inventory is high because the company utilizes lean periods with vendor partners to get best prices, and some inventory has come in for the next season.
- Revenue recognition: Revenue is booked when goods are billed to channel partners (COFO, COCO, MBOs); secondary sale sits in partners' books; all margins are built into the billing.
- Working capital commitment: Management will endeavour to reduce working capital days, though no specific target was given.
- Gross margin tailwind: Benefits from reduction in raw material prices reflected in margins sequentially; gross margin will normalize annually.
Brand Reinvention & Product Evolution
- Brand overhaul in 2019: The company conducted an internal assessment and reinvented its brand philosophy with a new brand identity, new merchandise architecture and new retail identity.
- Product mix transformation: The range has evolved from only shirts, t-shirts and trousers in 1998 to now include sweatshirts, jeans, cargoes, chinos, jackets, blazers, sweaters, outerwear and athleisure, positioning Mufti as a 360-degree men's lifestyle brand.
- Technology backbone: The entire supply chain is managed end-to-end on ERP Ginesys, with further investment in IT planned for supply chain and customer experience.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth FY24 | 18% to 20-odd-percent | Full year FY24 |
| EBITDA margin FY24 | 28% to 30% | Full year FY24 |
| PAT FY24 | Relatively flat YoY | Full year FY24 |
| Advertising spend | 4% to 5% of revenue | At least next 1-2 years |
| Revenue growth next year | 15% to 20% | FY25 |
| Store additions | 50-55 net new stores | Full year FY24 |
| Same-store growth target | 3% to 5% | Ongoing |
| Long-term growth | Double the business | Next 4-5 years |
| Working capital | Reduce working capital days | No specific timeline |
| Sustainable EBITDA margin | 30-33% in normal conditions | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹150 cr, +15% YoY |
| Revenue (9M FY24) | ₹434 cr, +19% YoY |
| Gross profit | ₹90 cr, +19% YoY; gross margin 59.8% |
| Gross profit (9M FY24) | ₹252 cr, +19% YoY; gross margin 58% |
| EBITDA | ₹42.5 cr, -1% YoY vs ₹42.9 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| EBITDA margin | 28.3%, vs 30%+ normal range; impacted by higher advertising spend |
| EBITDA (9M FY24) | ₹130 cr, +5% YoY; margin 29.8% |
| PAT (9M FY24) | ₹52.1 cr, -7% YoY; PAT margin 12% |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 18% to 20% |
| FY24 EBITDA margin guidance | 28% to 30% |
| FY25 revenue growth goal | 15% to 20% |
| Same-store sales growth (SSSG) | 1.4% YoY for Q3; 0.5% for 9M |
| Advertising & promotion spend | ₹12.8 cr in Q3, up ₹8.3 cr YoY; ₹23.7 cr in 9M, ~5.5% of revenue |
| EBO count | 413, net addition of 40 stores in 9M; target 50-55 net adds for FY24 |
| Total touch points | 1,818 across 592 cities (413 EBOs, 73 LFS, 1,332+ MBOs) |
| Revenue mix (9M FY24) | EBOs 55.7%, MBOs 23.8%, LFS 2.9%, online 14%, others 3.6% |
| Working capital days | 142 days as of December 2023 |
| ROCE (annualised) | 32.1% |
| ROE (annualised) | 20.8% |
| Average revenue per store | ~₹90 lakhs per annum |
| Full-price sell-through | ~50% net of returns (management estimate); ~80% of production cleared by end-of-season sale |