Key Takeaways
- Profit hit by own-book MTM losses: PAT fell 37% YoY as mark-to-market losses on the company's own equity and debt investments wiped out operating gains, a non-cash drag that reverses if markets recover.
- Yield compression is structural, not cyclical: Revenue yield dropped from 48 bps to 45 bps QoQ because market share gains came through low-yielding passive, liquid and short-end debt assets while older higher-yielding assets rolled off.
- Systematic flows are the bright spot: Quarterly SIP flows grew 30% to ₹2,300 crore, with 383,000 new SIP folios added and stickiness metrics well above industry averages, building a durable base that outlasts rate-cycle swings.
- Expenses rose on deliberate investment: Operating expenses climbed ₹7 crore QoQ to ₹145 crore as the company resumed increments after two years, reopened marketing spend, and invested in digital, framing this as future-readiness rather than bloat.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether equity net inflows sustain the six-month positive streak, any stabilization in the yield slide as the base effect begins to bite, and how much of the marketing and digital spend converts to AUM growth.
Yield Pressure: The Core Investor Concern
- Three forces compressing yields: New entrants and returning NFOs are intensifying competitive pressure on fees, distribution partners are demanding higher shares of the economics, and the asset mix is shifting inexorably toward lower-yielding categories (passive, liquid, shorter-end fixed income).
- The churn dynamic is easing: The pace at which old higher-yielding assets are being replaced by new lower-trail assets has "significantly come off" since December 2021, reducing the vulnerability of the yield base going forward even if absolute yields remain under pressure.
- Management draws a line on fee-sharing: The company explicitly does not match competitor behaviour on sharing fee income with distributors, maintaining its own profitability benchmark, a stance it argues will insulate it as outflows have now been arrested.
- The rate-cycle escape hatch: When the yield curve eventually peaks and the interest rate cycle turns, money currently parked in short-end and liquid funds is expected to migrate into long-tenure and credit funds, shifting the asset mix toward higher-yielding categories.
Prateek Jain: "This downward pressure on yields will continue for some more time because there has been a slew of new players who have come in... Therefore, there has been a tendency from the distribution fraternity about the money they will get or rather these pressures would be there on the yield... all of these are putting some pressure on the yield and which is likely to continue for some more quarters, before it comes down because of the base effect."
Own-Book MTM: The Quarter's Profit Wrecking Ball
- The ₹17 crore other-income loss: Consolidated other income swung to a ₹17 crore loss driven by MTM impact on ₹250 crore of own equity exposure (market fell 12-15%, schemes down 10-12%) plus some decline on the fixed-income side from a 50 bps G-sec yield drop and skin-in-the-game requirements across all debt schemes.
- Tax accounting smooths the optics: The effective tax rate of 24% reflects a deliberate policy of assuming a flat market for the full year, neither recognizing MTM appreciation nor decline on equity schemes until sold, and not offsetting capital gains. This means the P&L hit is real but the tax line does not amplify it.
- Reversibility is the silver lining: These are mark-to-market losses, not permanent impairments; a market recovery would reverse them, making this quarter's PAT decline a timing issue rather than a structural earnings reset.
Prateek Jain: "We assume that market is going to be flat for the year and, basis that, we have accounted for the profit... neither the appreciation nor the decline is being considered, while we are calculating the ETR for the full year."
Flows: Where the Money Is Moving
- Equity flows have turned the corner: Gross flows are improving on the back of better one-year and three-year performance; redemptions have stopped; the persistent net outflows that ran from December 2018 to December 2021 have been arrested, and the last six months have seen decent positive inflows.
- Fixed-income flows are a mix story: A large part of the money that went out was time-bound FMPs that matured and returned, but it came back into low-yielding assets at the shorter end of the curve, a deliberate strategy while the rate environment remains uncertain.
- Passive/ETF is the volume engine: ETF AUM stands at ₹60,100 crore with 14.1% market share; the company claims the largest ETF player position excluding EPFO allocations to two specific MFs, holds 60% of industry ETF folios, and captured 83% of industry folio additions this quarter.
- Systematic flows are the quality engine: 51% of AUM has been invested for more than five years, 13% of folios are older than five years, and quarterly SIP flows of ₹2,300 crore provide a recurring base that is less sensitive to market cycles and yield compression.
Expenses & Operating Leverage: The Frugality Promise
- The ₹7 crore QoQ step-up unpacked: Employee costs rose on inflation-linked increments after a two-year freeze and a strong profit year; other expenses increased on marketing (TV and newspaper campaigns) and digital investment, both framed as future-readiness spend.
- The operating leverage thesis: Management asserts that even if assets grow 1.5x to 2x, no significant incremental investments or expenses would be required, and that is where operating leverage will materialize. Non-discretionary spend is under tight control.
- Variable costs provide a buffer: Employee expenses are expected to run at a steady rate unless profitability changes significantly; the variable payout lever remains contingent on profit, giving the P&L some downside protection.
- Marketing and digital spend will persist: Given good traction and performance, the company will continue investing in both marketing and digital, with benefits likely accruing in future periods rather than the current quarter.
Prateek Jain: "Even if the asset has to grow one-and-a-half to two times, no significant investments or expenses would be required and, that is where the operating leverage will come into play."
Competitive Positioning & Distribution
- Market share rising, but the quality is mixed: Overall market share has risen for five consecutive quarters, but recent share gains have concentrated in low-yielding assets (passive, liquid, short-end debt), diluting the revenue benefit.
- IFA-heavy distribution keeps brokerage costs low: A larger share of wallet comes from IFAs even in absolute terms, and average brokerage is lower than most peers precisely because so much flow comes through the IFA channel rather than higher-cost national distributors.
- The cross-sell opportunity is untapped: The strategy going forward is to cross-sell various other products to the large and growing ETF customer base.
- Active-side discipline: The company will not launch new active schemes merely for the sake of launching unless they can be scaled up; on the passive side, a few new schemes are planned, but the core focus remains execution and leveraging the existing ETF ecosystem.
Sundeep Sikka: "one strategy that we are very clear is that we are not going to be doing any business, which is going to get a loss."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Yield pressure persistence | Downward pressure on yields will continue before base effect kicks in; impact going forward not significant unless fee-sharing with distributors rises materially | "Some more quarters" |
| Equity market share | Composition of equity assets will increase further, building on last six months' momentum | "Next few quarters" |
| Asset migration to higher yield | Assets currently in low-yielding categories will be migrated to higher-yielding assets when the rate cycle turns | When yield curve peaks / rate cycle changes |
| Operating leverage | Even if assets grow 1.5x to 2x, no significant incremental investments or expenses required | No date (structural claim) |
| Marketing and digital investment | Will continue to invest given traction; benefits likely to accrue in future periods | Ongoing |
| Employee expense run rate | Steady run rate expected unless significant change in profitability; variable payout contingent on profit | Ongoing |
| Profitable growth | Confident to continue trend of profitable growth | "Coming quarters" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax | ₹110 crore, decrease of 37% YoY |
| Operating income | ₹170 crore, up 1% YoY |
| Operating profit to average AUM | 25 bps, vs 28 bps in Q1 FY22 |
| Total expenses | ₹145 crore, up ₹7 crore QoQ from ₹138 crore in Q4 FY22 |
| Other income (consolidated) | Loss of ₹17 crore, vs loss of ₹7 crore on standalone basis |
| Effective tax rate | 24%, calculated on anticipated full-year profit assuming flat market |
| Revenue yield | 45 bps, down from 48 bps in Q4 FY22 |
| Equity yield | 75–80 bps |
| ETF blended yield | 11–12 bps |
| Annualised systematic transaction book | ₹9,700 crore |
| Quarterly systematic flows | ₹2,300 crore, increased 30% QoQ |
| Systematic AUM | ₹48,200 crore, rose 7% QoQ |
| Systematic folios added in Q1 | Over 383,000 |
| SIP AUM continued over 5 years | 51%, vs 22% for the industry |
| SIP folios continued over 5 years | 13%, vs 9% for the industry |
| Passive/ETF AUM | ₹60,100 crore, market share of 14.1% |
| Gold ETF AUM | ₹6,800 crore, biggest fund in the category |
| Share of industry ETF folios | 60% |
| Share of ETF volumes on NSE and BSE | 74% |
| New investors added in Q1 | Over 0.1 crore, 83% of total industry folio additions |
| Digital share of new purchase transactions | 55% |
| Purchases executed through digital assets | Over 750,000, increase of 25% |
| Empanelled distributors | Over 85,500; MFD base rose to 85,300, addition of 1,200 in Q1 |
| Equity flow market share (MFDs) | 7–8% of industry |
| Equity flow market share (banks, large wealth counters) | 5–6% of industry |
| Equity flow market share (blended) | 6–6.5% of industry |
| Assets over four years old | ~30% of total assets |
| Own equity exposure | ₹250 crore; debt exposure ~₹2,500 crore in mutual fund schemes |
| Own debt portfolio in short-term category | 70% |
| FY22 dividend payout ratio | 96% |
| Cumulative dividend distributed (last 8 years) | ₹3,400 crore |