Key Takeaways
- Profitable growth sustained, yields improved: Equity yields rose QoQ, driven by granular, sticky B30 and IFA flows, while debt and ETF yields were marginally increased, helping overall blended realization tick up 1 bp QoQ to 43 bps.
- Debt outflows a macro headwind, not a franchise problem: Industry-wide rising rates drove debt redemptions; Nippon's slightly higher outflows reflect a strong prior buildup in fixed income assets, and management expects flows to return as yields stabilize.
- One-off costs mask underlying expense run-rate: 60% of the opex increase was non-recurring, split between IT spend (40% of the increase) and office consolidation costs, implying a lower recurring base going forward.
- Equity market share inflecting up: Net sales growth moved toward the 6% mark month-on-month, lifting market share from 6.12% to 6.18%, with SIP folio gross share jumping from 5.4% to 8.5% of the industry's incremental folios.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether debt flows begin to return as global yields stabilize, the sustainability of improved equity yields if AUM mix holds, and any regulatory draft on TER that could reset industry economics.
Revenue Quality & Yield Dynamics
- Equity yields improved on flow mix: New money came predominantly from IFAs and B30 cities, which are more profitable, sticky, and granular, and the absence of NFOs removed a dilutive force on overall equity yields.
- Debt and ETF yields managed higher: Marginal increases on both sides helped maintain the run rate versus the prior quarter and the corresponding quarter, cushioning the blended realization.
- Blended realization edged up: A 1 bp sequential increase to 43 bps was helped by improved realization on fixed income and ETF sides, with no one-off revenue from specially managed or advisory accounts.
- TER chargeability structurally declining: Reverse telescopic rates as scheme AUMs grew pulled TER chargeability down by 15 bps, a structural drag that disproportionately affects larger AMCs.
- Q4 yield outlook tied to AUM mix and MTM: If the AUM composition remains similar QoQ, current realization should sustain; a mark-to-market drop in AUM would mechanically increase TERs and improve yields further.
Prateek Jain: "So all the three things, the composition has remained more or less the same, or rather it has improved on the equity side. We have been able to marginally increase our yields on the debt and the ETF side, which has helped us to maintain the run rate, vis-à-vis, the last quarter or vis-a-vis the corresponding quarter."
Debt Outflows: Causes & Recovery Path
- Industry-wide pressure from rising rates: Debt outflows were driven by rising yields globally and in India as investors avoided MTM losses, competition from bank deposits as deposit rates moved up, and corporate treasuries repaying loan credits to banks.
- Nippon's outflows slightly higher due to prior success: A fairly robust buildup in fixed income assets over the last two years meant a larger base from which money could move out when the cycle turned.
- Recovery expected within one to two quarters: Management is fairly confident that as conditions settle and yields stabilize, some of those flows should return to the system.
Aashwin Dugal: "And we are fairly confident that as things settle down and yields stabilize over the next one or two quarters, we should see some of those flows come back into the system."
Equity Franchise: Market Share & Customer Base
- Market share inflecting after a period of flattening: Equity market share moved from 6.12% to 6.18%, with net sales growth month-on-month starting to approach the 6% mark, driven by a combination of SIP inflows and lump-sum inflows.
- SIP folio share surging: Gross folio share jumped from 5.4% to 8.5% of the industry, reflecting strong SIP growth every month, even as unique customers declined marginally from 13.4 to 13.2.
- Unique customer decline explained by outflows: The marginal drop was attributed to outflows on the fixed income side and some lump-sum redemptions on the equity side, offset by the SIP folio momentum.
- Further market share growth has room: Management noted there is still some margin of growth to take place, and equity market share will rise with a lag effect as net sales momentum continues.
Cost Structure & Operating Leverage
- Opex spike was 60% one-off: 40% of the increment came from a one-off IT spend, and the remainder of the non-recurring portion was from consolidating the Nariman Point sales office into the corporate office at Lower Parel.
- Recurring cost drivers also present: Full reopening after COVID drove increased travel and distribution activities, adding to the recurring portion of the opex increase.
- Base effect should improve going forward: With the one-off IT spend and office relocation costs behind, the recurring opex run-rate is lower than the reported quarter suggests.
Strategic Positioning & Competitive Moats
- ETF yield improvement capability is a competitive advantage: Taking into account liquidity on stock exchanges, management stated the company is in a far better position to increase yield wherever required compared to competition.
- Profitability is a volume and execution game: Management emphasized that long-term profitability hinges on execution and building scale, not on a single basis point of yield, and that the quality of business (granular, small ticket size, stickiness) is critical.
- Active debt to remain dominant over passive: Management believes the volume growth seen in equity passive will not be replicated in fixed income, where active will continue to play a bigger role, though the company is ready on both sides with a strong passive debt portfolio.
- Digital engagement infrastructure expanding: Rolled out a WhatsApp Channel for real-time transactions and services, and launched Business Easy 2.0, an in-house developed app providing paperless interfaces and real-time market movement-based advisory, analytics, and insights to partners and consumers.
Sundeep Sikka: "...asset management industry is ultimately a volume game. I think it's not just about that 1 basis point, what is going to be the yield. It's going to be how well we execute and how well you can scale it up."
Regulatory Uncertainty
- TER regulation under discussion, no clarity yet: A news article on SEBI's study of TER for the mutual fund industry prompted an analyst question, but management stated discussions are still underway, they await the final draft of regulations, and will avoid any comment or speculation at this stage.
Sundeep Sikka: "With regard to the recent news article regarding addition of TER, discussions are still underway. We await the final draft of the regulations. And in this regard, we'll avoid making any comment or speculation at this stage."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Debt flow recovery | Some of the outflows should return as yields stabilize | Next one to two quarters |
| Equity yield sustainability | If AUM mix remains same QoQ, broadly current realization should continue; MTM drop in AUM would improve yields further | Next quarter (Q4 FY23) |
| Opex base effect | 60% of the opex increment was one-off (IT spend + office consolidation), implying lower recurring run-rate | From Q4 FY23 onward |
| Equity market share growth | Net sales growth moving toward 6% mark month-on-month; further margin of growth exists | Ongoing, with lag effect |
| ETF yield improvement | Will keep looking at opportunities to further improvise yields, leveraging superior exchange liquidity | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax | ₹210 cr, +18% YoY |
| Operating profit | ₹200 cr |
| Operating profit / average AUM | 28 bps, vs 26 bps in Q2 FY23 |
| Blended gross realization | 43 bps, vs 42 bps QoQ; 9-month basis 42 bps vs 44 bps YoY |
| Revenue from operations | Not stated |
| Total AUM | ₹292,800 cr, +3% QoQ |
| Equity market share | 6.18%, up from 6.12% in March |
| Systematic AUM | ₹58,300 cr, +15% QoQ |
| Quarterly systematic flows | ₹2,900 cr, +45% QoQ |
| Annualized systematic transaction book | ₹12,300 cr |
| Monthly SIP book | ₹1,020 cr, up from ~₹650 cr at start of calendar year |
| Passive segment AUM | ₹68,300 cr, market share 14% |
| Gold ETF AUM | ₹6,700 cr |
| Share of industry ETF folios | 61% |
| ETF investors added in Q3 | 137,000, 99% of total industry ETF folio additions |
| Share of ETF volumes on BSE and NSE | 69% |
| Net yield on ETF side | 9–10 bps, excluding gold and CPSE |
| Unique investors | 1.3 cr+, 36% share of industry unique investors |
| Unique investors QoQ | Declined from 13.4 to 13.2 |
| SIP gross folio share | 8.5%, up from 5.4% |
| SIP net incremental folio share | ~12% |
| Systematic folios added in Q3 (gross) | 561,000 |
| SIP AUM with >5-year vintage | 56%, vs 23% for industry |
| SIP folios with >5-year vintage | 14%, vs 11% for industry |
| Digital share of new purchase transactions | 59% |
| Purchases executed through digital assets | 902,000+, +19% |
| Distributors empaneled | 89,000+; MFD base 88,800+, +1,900 in Q3 |
| TER chargeability decline from reverse telescopic rates | 15 bps |
| Proportion of equity AUM on newer lower rates | 70%, up from 2/3 earlier |
| FY22 dividend payout ratio | 96% |
| Cumulative dividend distributed over last 8 financial years | ₹3,600 cr |