Key Takeaways
- Flattish Q4 despite weak operations: PAT rose just Rs. 9 Crore to Rs. 569 Crore as a one-time tax gross-up of Rs. 350 Crore in revenue offset a sharp drop in generation, PAF-based incentives turning negative, and lower other income.
- Subansiri Lower is the near-term catalyst: Two units are set to spin in Q2 FY24 and commission in Q3, unlocking partial capitalization of 60% of project cost and delivering part financial benefit this year before full-year benefit in FY26.
- PAF collapse exposes hydrological risk: Q4 PAF fell to 68% from 77% YoY, driven by four underperforming stations, wiping out PAF incentives and highlighting vulnerability to low-water periods.
- Capex cycle is accelerating: The company guided Rs. 8,000-9,000 Crore annual capex, with Rs. 10,857 Crore budgeted this year, as multiple large hydro projects move toward commissioning between FY24 and FY26.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Subansiri units actually spin in Q2, progress on the 150 meters of remaining HRT excavation at Parbati-II, and any monsoon-driven recovery in generation and PAF at the four troubled stations.
Subansiri Lower: The Inflection Point
- Commissioning timeline: Two units to spin in Q2 FY24, commission in Q3 FY24 (by November); the remaining six units are scheduled for Q2 FY25. Three radial gates, the country's largest by hydraulic capacity, have already been successfully operated.
- Capitalization mechanics: 60% of the project's capital cost will be capitalized upon commissioning of the first two units in Q3 FY24, with the remaining 40% following next year, front-loading the balance-sheet impact.
- Earnings phasing: Part financial benefit accrues in FY24 and FY25, with the full-year benefit available only in FY26, making the ramp gradual rather than a single-step jump.
R P Goyal: "We are expecting to commission two units of Subansiri in third quarter of this year i.e. FY'24 and balance units to be commissioned in second quarter of FY'25. Full year benefit will be available in FY 2025-26, but part benefit, financial benefit will be available in current financial year as well as in next financial year."
Operational Weakness: PAF & Generation
- Q4 generation drop: Generation fell 14% YoY to 289 Crore units, a decline of 49 Crore units, dragging full-year generation to only a marginal 12.5 Crore unit improvement.
- PAF collapse in four stations: Overall PAF dropped to 68% from 77% YoY, with Rangit-IV, TLDP-III, Dulhasti and Kishanganga the primary culprits, turning PAF-based incentives negative at Rs. 40 Crore versus a positive Rs. 22 Crore a year ago.
- Incentive income evaporated: Total Q4 incentives crashed to Rs. 68 Crore from Rs. 207 Crore, with deviation charges also flipping negative, removing a key earnings swing factor.
- Full-year PAF held up: Despite the weak Q4, FY23 PAF of 88.75% marginally exceeded the prior year's 88.19%, indicating the problem was concentrated in the final quarter.
The Tax Gross-Up: How PAT Stayed Flat
- Mechanics of the mismatch: Tariffs are grossed up at the 28% normal tax rate, adding Rs. 344-350 Crore to Q4 revenue, but the company actually pays tax at the 18% MAT rate by utilizing accumulated MAT credit, creating a non-cash revenue uplift.
- What it offset: The Rs. 350 Crore revenue boost compensated for the collapse in incentive income, a Rs. 144 Crore drop in insurance claim income, a Rs. 97 Crore fall in dividend income, and a Rs. 175 Crore decline in late payment surcharge for the full year.
- Sustainability caveat: This gross-up is a function of available MAT credit; as that pool depletes, the revenue uplift narrows unless the effective tax rate rises to match the gross-up rate.
Project Pipeline: The FY24-26 Commissioning Wave
- Parbati-II nearing the finish line: All four units have been tested and commissioned; only 150 meters of HRT excavation and 3 km of lining remain, though TBM breakdown from 11th April halted excavation. Management aims to commission all four units on a single day by March 2024, with capitalization in one phase.
- Other projects on deck: JPCL Rangit (Aug 2024), Ratle (May 2026), Kiru (Mar 2026), Pakaldul (Sep 2026), Kwar (Nov 2026), and LTHPL Teesta-VI (Aug 2026) form a rolling wave of completions that will add capacity steadily through the decade.
- Dibang, the long-dated giant: Investment approval came in February 2023 with the LOT-2 infrastructure package awarded, but scheduled completion is not until February 2032, making it a decade-long value driver.
- New allotments in Arunachal: The Subansiri Basin projects (2,000 MW Upper, 1,800 MW Middle) will be developed standalone, while the Siang Basin projects (10,000 MW Upper Siang, 2,700 MW Siang Lower) proceed in JV mode, securing the post-2030 pipeline.
Capital Allocation & Balance Sheet
- Capex trajectory: Management guided Rs. 8,000-9,000 Crore annual capex going forward, with the current year budgeted at Rs. 10,857 Crore including Rs. 2,500 Crore for renewable projects, signaling an acceleration.
- Hydro dominates the mix: 80% of capex is directed at hydro, with roughly 20% allocated to solar and other renewables, framing NHPC as a hydro-first developer that does renewables at the margin.
- Dividend commitment held: The board recommended a total dividend of Rs. 1.85 per share (18.5%) for FY23, and management committed to maintaining the 30% of PAT or 5% of net worth payout while still meeting capex requirements.
- Trade receivables cleaned up: Net trade receivables stood at just Rs. 787 Crore as of 28th May 2023, with only Rs. 80 Crore over 45 days overdue; the headline Rs. 5,887 Crore figure includes Rs. 2,757 Crore of unbilled debtors, Rs. 948 Crore already received via bill discounting, and Rs. 1,619 Crore converted into government-mandated instalments.
- Impairment taken: A Rs. 106 Crore provision was booked against the investment in subsidiary Loktak Downstream Hydroelectric Power Corporation, a clean-up item in other expenses.
Rajendra Goyal: "Actually, we are mainly focusing on hydro projects only, but we will be doing some solar projects also to support the Government of India initiative. You can say, we will be doing 80% of our capex in hydro and around 20% in solar or other renewables."
Renewables & Pumped Storage: Early Innings
- Solar wins: NHPC bagged a 1,000 MW CPSU scheme project (EPC awarded, target FY25 commissioning at fixed cost with 12% ROE expectation) and a 200 MW Gujarat project at Rs. 2.73/unit with an estimated outlay of Rs. 1,007 Crore. A 100 MW Uttar Pradesh floating solar MoU was also signed.
- Pumped storage exploration: PFRs for Indira Sagar Omkareshwar (525 MW), Tekwa-2 (800 MW), and Panchet (1,000 MW) have been submitted; an MoU with DVC is signed. Management expects to take up one pumped storage project in FY25, though execution modalities are still being explored.
- Nepal expansion: An MoU covers the 750 MW West Seti and 450 MW Seti River-6 projects, with a survey license issued for the latter; discussions for the 480 MW Phukot Karnali in JV mode are in final stages, diversifying the geographic footprint.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Subansiri Lower commissioning | 2 units commissioned; 60% of project cost capitalized | Q3 FY24 (by November) |
| Subansiri Lower balance units | Remaining 6 units commissioned | Q2 FY25 |
| Parbati-II completion | All 4 units commissioned in single phase | By March 2024 |
| JPCL Rangit completion | Project commissioned | August 2024 |
| Ratle HE Project completion | Project commissioned | May 2026 |
| Kiru HE Project completion | Project commissioned | March 2026 |
| Pakaldul HE Project completion | Project commissioned | September 2026 |
| Kwar HE Project completion | Project commissioned | November 2026 |
| LTHPL Teesta-VI completion | Project commissioned | August 2026 |
| Dibang Multipurpose Project | Project commissioned | February 2032 |
| Annual capex run-rate | Rs. 8,000-9,000 Crore | Going forward |
| FY24 capex budget | Rs. 10,857 Crore (incl. Rs. 2,500 Cr RE) | FY24 |
| 1,000 MW CPSU solar project | Commissioned at fixed cost, 12% ROE expected | FY25 |
| Pumped storage take-off | One project expected to start | FY25 |
| Dividend payout | Maintain at 30% of PAT or 5% of net worth | Ongoing |
| Sawalkot HEP tendering | Tenders issued | FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from Operations | ₹1,717 cr, +14% YoY; increase mainly due to unbilled revenue on account of effective tax rate by ₹344 cr |
| PAT | ₹569 cr, +1.6% YoY from ₹560 cr |
| Other Income | ₹254 cr, -49% YoY; decrease in dividend income by ₹97 cr and insurance claim income by ₹144 cr |
| Total Tax Expense (FY23) | ₹605 cr vs negative ₹761 cr in FY22; current tax ₹761 cr, deferred tax MAT credit recognized ₹417 cr |
| Employee Cost | ₹417 cr, -16% YoY from ₹498 cr; due to superannuation of employees |
| Finance Cost | ₹112 cr, -16% YoY from ₹133 cr; due to change in interest rate and loan repayment |
| Generation | 289.1 cr units, -14% YoY from 337.8 cr units |
| Plant Availability Factor (PAF) | 67.96% vs 76.76% in Q4 FY22; NAPAF for the fleet was ~77% |
| Total Incentive Income | ₹68 cr vs ₹207 cr in Q4 FY22; PAF incentive negative ₹40 cr, deviation charges negative ₹2 cr |
| Capex Incurred (FY23) | ₹6,961 cr on consolidated basis vs target of ₹8,061 cr |
| Trade Receivables (31 Mar'23) | ₹5,887 cr vs ₹4,621 cr as on 31 Mar'22; includes ₹2,757 cr unbilled debtors |
| Net Trade Receivables (28 May'23) | ₹787 cr, of which >45 days debtors only ₹80 cr |
| Regulated Equity (31 Mar'23) | ₹13,000 cr; expected to reach ₹22,000 cr after full commissioning of Subansiri Lower and Parbati-II |
| Dividend per Share (FY23) | ₹1.85, total 18.5% on face value of ₹10; final dividend ₹0.45 plus interim ₹1.40 |
| Subansiri Lower Commissioning | 2 units expected in Q3 FY24, balance 6 units in Q2 FY25; 60% of capital cost to be capitalized on first 2 units |