Key Takeaways
- A year wiped out by floods, but the balance sheet held: Generation fell ~20% YoY in Q4 after the Teesta basin flash flood and Parbati-III outage, yet PAT rose ~23% YoY in Q4, cushioned by a one-off water cess reversal and insurance claims.
- The Subansiri clock is now the only clock that matters: Management is "very hopeful" to commission 3 of 8 units by March'25, a milestone that would end a prolonged period of zero capacity addition and unlock a new revenue base.
- Tariff reengineering is the quiet margin lever: For both Subansiri (target ~INR5.60/unit) and Parbati-II (target ~INR6/unit), the company plans to stretch depreciation and accept lower initial O&M charges, aiming to keep tariffs saleable without sacrificing ROE.
- The capex super-cycle is fully funded, on paper: Annual capex will run at INR13,000–15,000 Cr for the next 7–8 years, but internal accruals (PAT ~INR3,800 Cr + depreciation ~INR1,200 Cr) are expected to cover the ~30% equity portion comfortably.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Subansiri Lower hill-slope restoration stays on track through the monsoon, any movement on the Dugar court case, and the pace of PPA/PSA signings against the 10,000 MW allocation.
The Generation Shock & Financial Patchwork
- Teesta-V was the epicentre: The October'23 flash flood in the Teesta basin caused a complete shutdown of the 510 MW Teesta-V station, driving the bulk of the ~12% YoY generation decline for FY24. Restoration is underway and expected to complete only by March'25.
- Parbati-III compounded the damage: Intense rain and floods in Himachal Pradesh in August'23 knocked all units offline; the station became fully operational only from September'23, dragging down both generation and the Plant Availability Factor.
- Other Income masked the operating hit: A ~94% YoY surge in Other Income for FY24 included INR121 Cr in higher dividends from NHDC, INR108 Cr in business interruption insurance, and INR382 Cr in material damage claims for Teesta-V. The last was fully offset in Other Expenses, so it carried no profit impact.
- A one-off water cess reversal flattered Q4 PAT: Generation Expenses turned negative (INR247 Cr) in Q4 after the company reversed INR412 Cr in water cess provisions for Himachal Pradesh and Sikkim, following a favourable High Court ruling. This single item is the main reason Q4 PAT rose ~23% YoY despite the generation collapse.
- Realisation improved even as generation fell: The company collected INR9,606 Cr from beneficiaries vs INR7,435 Cr in the previous year, cutting Trade Receivables from INR5,887 Cr to INR3,984 Cr. Net dues older than 45 days stood at just INR277 Cr.
RP Goyal: "Excess monsoon impacts us in a negative sense and lower monsoon also impacts in a negative sense in respect of our power stations, which are under operations. But moderate monsoon is always welcome."
Subansiri Lower: The Make-or-Break Project
- The delay was geological, not financial: In October'23, subsidence in Diversion Tunnel 1 triggered a hill-slope slide on the left bank, damaging part of the slope and connecting the tunnel to the river at a second point. Major restoration is complete, but hill-slope work continues. Seepage has been reduced from 8–9 cumecs to less than 1 cumec.
- Three units are mechanically ready: Units 1, 2 and 3 are almost complete; Units 1 and 2 are already boxed up, and Unit 3 is about to lower its stator and rotor. Only civil works and some hydro-mechanical works remain.
- The timeline is tight and weather-dependent: Management expects civil and HM works to finish by February or March'25, leaving no possibility of commissioning even 1 or 2 units before March'25. The balanced plug portion in Diversion Tunnel 1 will be taken up only after the current monsoon season.
- Tariff has been engineered down to a saleable level: The latest tariff estimate is INR5.60 per unit, achieved by reengineering the cost structure. Management drew a parallel to the 2007 Dulhasti tariff of INR5.50/unit, arguing that power at this rate faced no market resistance then and will not now.
- The full cascade unlocks by May'26: After the first 3 units in March'25, the remaining 5 units are expected to commission one by one, with all 8 units online by May'26.
RP Goyal: "In case of Dulhasti, in the year of 2007, the tariff was INR5.50 per unit, and there was no issue. So, this tariff will also not be the issue in selling the power."
The Project Pipeline: What Commissions When
| Project | Expected Commissioning | Key Risk / Note |
|---|---|---|
| Parbati-II | December'24 | Excavation complete, daylighting achieved; only concrete lining remains using 4 steel gantries. Tariff being reengineered to ~INR6/unit by accepting lower O&M for first 5 years and stretching depreciation. |
| Subansiri Lower (Units 1–3) | March'25 | Hill-slope restoration and balanced plug work must survive the monsoon. |
| Subansiri Lower (Units 4–8) | By May'26 | Sequential commissioning after first 3 units. |
| Rangit-IV (Jalpower merger) | May'25 | Merger process with NHPC underway. |
| Ratle | December'26 | No specific risks flagged. |
| Pakal Dul | September'26 | No specific risks flagged. |
| Kiru | September'26 | No specific risks flagged. |
| Lanco Teesta-VI | December'27 | Acquired project; no specific risks flagged. |
| Kwar | December'27 | No specific risks flagged. |
| Dibang Multi-Purpose | February'32 | All land acquired; road/bridge/tunnel works awarded to L&T and Patel-GR Infra JV; main concrete dam tender ready to float. |
- Parbati-II tariff reengineering mirrors Subansiri: The company will accept lower O&M charges for the first 5 years and plan for a longer depreciation period, targeting a tariff within INR6/unit with no loss to the company on ROE.
- Dibang is the next giant, and it is fully mobilised: Construction of roads, bridges and culverts is underway, powerhouse and tunnel packages are awarded, and the main dam tender is ready to float within 3–4 months. All land acquisition is complete.
RP Goyal: "We will accept lower operation maintenance charges for the first 5 years and we can plan for a longer period of depreciation. So we will try to keep it within the range of INR6 and there will be no loss to the company."
Capex, Cash Flow & the Equity Question
- The capex trajectory is locked in: INR11,761 Cr targeted for FY25, rising to ~INR13,317 Cr in FY26, and then sustaining INR13,000–15,000 Cr annually for the next 7–8 years. None of the FY25 capex includes pumped storage expenditure.
- Internal accruals are expected to cover the equity need: At a 70:30 debt-equity ratio, the equity requirement on ~INR13,000 Cr of annual capex works out to roughly INR3,000–3,500 Cr, per an analyst's math. Management pointed to PAT of INR3,800 Cr plus depreciation of INR1,200 Cr, leaving ~INR3,200 Cr available for equity capex after dividend, and argued this will only grow.
- No specific cash flow bridge was provided: When asked directly about coverage ratios or a detailed cash flow walk, management stayed at the level of "very comfortable" and did not quantify the equity requirement or map it to specific project draws.
- Debtors are at a multi-year clean level: Net Trade Receivables stood at INR818 Cr as of 31st March'24, with only INR277 Cr older than 45 days. By 16th May'24, the position had improved further to INR1,192 Cr net, with INR160 Cr over 45 days.
Stressed & Contingent Projects
- Dugar is in legal limbo: The Himachal Pradesh Government withdrew all previously agreed concessions, and NHPC is now in court. Without those concessions, the project may not be viable. Tenders have been quoted, but an award depends entirely on the court outcome or a government follow-up.
- Bursar is viable only with a government grant: The storage component drives the tariff to INR25–30 per unit, making the project unviable on a standalone basis. Management stated it would develop Bursar only if the Government rethinks and provides a grant for storage. Expenditure already provided for has been incurred.
- Sawalkot awaits CCEA approval: The EPC tendering process is underway, with packages being prepared, but the award is subject to CCEA approval. The issue has been taken up with the J&K Government and the Ministry of Power.
RP Goyal: "This project will be viable only when the Government will provide grant for the storage component. Otherwise, tariff is coming very high. It is coming in the range of INR25 to INR30 per unit."
Renewables, Pumped Storage & New Avenues
- Solar is incremental, not transformational, in the near term: A 300 MW Bikaner project is progressing well, land acquisition is underway for 600 MW in Gujarat and 100 MW in Andhra Pradesh, and a 200 MW Khavda project was won at INR2.66/unit. But management conceded that only "a few megawatt of solar" can be added before March'25.
- Floating solar is in the pilot-to-project transition: An MOU has been signed with Norway's Ocean Sun to identify water bodies for floating solar development. The Omkareshwar floating solar project is expected to commission by October'24, while Rengali is in re-tendering and may commission only in FY27.
- Pumped storage is a FY30 story: No expenditure is budgeted for pumped storage in FY25. The first DPR (Indra Sagar Omkareshwar) will take some time to complete. Management expects work on the ground for 3–4 projects totalling 5,000–6,000 MW to begin within 2 years, with commissioning by FY30.
- Nepal is a quiet optionality: DPR preparation is in progress for the 750 MW West Seti Project, and the Inception Report for the 450 MW Seti River-6 has been accepted by the Investment Board of Nepal. A review report for the 480 MW Phukot Karnali project has also been submitted.
- PPA/PSA execution is a gating item: Against a 10,000 MW allocation from MNRE, the company has signed PPAs/PSAs for 3,000 MW and has another 1,400 MW in process. Management expects to sign for 4,400 MW in total but did not specify a timeline for the remainder.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Teesta-V restoration | Full restoration of generation | March'25 |
| Parbati-II commissioning | Project completion | December'24 |
| Subansiri Lower first 3 units | Commissioning | March'25 |
| Subansiri Lower all 8 units | All units online | May'26 |
| Rangit-IV commissioning | Project completion | May'25 |
| Ratle commissioning | Project completion | December'26 |
| Pakal Dul commissioning | Project completion | September'26 |
| Kiru commissioning | Project completion | September'26 |
| Lanco Teesta-VI commissioning | Project completion | December'27 |
| Kwar commissioning | Project completion | December'27 |
| Dibang Multi-Purpose commissioning | Project completion | February'32 |
| Pumped storage ground-breaking | 3–4 projects, 5,000–6,000 MW work starts | Within 2 years |
| Pumped storage commissioning | First set of pumped storage projects online | FY30 |
| Consolidated ROE | 10% to 11% | FY25 |
| Capex | INR11,761 Cr | FY25 |
| Capex | ~INR13,317 Cr | FY26 |
| Capex run-rate | INR13,000–15,000 Cr annually | Next 7–8 years |
| Omkareshwar floating solar | Commissioning | October'24 |
| Dividend | As per policy and DIPAM guidelines | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from Operations | ₹1,652 cr, down 4% YoY from ₹1,717 cr |
| PAT | ₹698 cr, up 23% YoY from ₹569 cr |
| Other Income | ₹591 cr, up 133% YoY from ₹254 cr |
| Generation | 230.4 crore units, down 20% YoY from 289.1 crore units |
| Plant Availability Factor (PAF) | 54.65%, down from 67.96% YoY |
| Generation Expenses | negative ₹247 cr, vs ₹152 cr in Q4 FY23, due to reversal of water cess of ₹412 cr |
| Employee Cost | ₹369 cr, down from ₹417 cr YoY |
| Finance Cost | ₹95 cr, down from ₹112 cr YoY |
| Depreciation and Amortization | ₹280 cr, down from ₹286 cr YoY |
| Other Expenses | ₹788 cr, up from ₹486 cr YoY |
| Total Incentives (Secondary Energy + PAF Incentive + Deviation Charges) | ₹339 cr, down from ₹457 cr YoY |
| MAT Credit utilized | ₹129 cr, negative impact on PAT |
| Trade Receivables (net, as of Mar 31) | ₹818 cr net amount due; more than 45 days dues ₹277 cr |
| Capex incurred (FY24, consolidated) | ₹8,652 cr, against target of ₹10,857 cr |
| Final dividend recommended | ₹0.50 per share (5%), total dividend ₹1.90 per share (19%) for FY24 |