NIBE Ltd’s record shows a company that has grown revenue rapidly but has not converted that growth into cash. Cumulative operating cash flow over the last four years is negative ₹22 crore against a cumulative profit of ₹48 crore, while capital work-in-progress has swollen to ₹62.40 crore and dividends have been paid in two of those years. The standalone internal-financial-controls opinion was qualified in FY23 and FY24, the auditor has repeatedly flagged loans granted without specified terms, and the company has cycled through five audit firms in six years.
Key findings
- Profits are not converting to cash, even as capital work-in-progress balloons
Major- Cumulative operating cash flow over FY23-FY26 was negative ₹22 crore against a cumulative profit of ₹48 crore, a cash-to-profit ratio of -0.47x. In FY26 alone, cash from operations was negative ₹34.52 crore while profit was ₹0.06 crore. Capital work-in-progress stood at ₹62.40 crore as of FY26, up from zero amounts aged more than one year in the FY23 ageing schedule, and the Board recommended dividends of ₹1.25 per share for FY25 and ₹0.10 per share for FY23 despite the cumulative cash deficit. - Receivables are stretching far beyond stated credit terms
Major- The company states a credit period of 45 to 60 days, yet receivable days computed from reported financials rose from 54 days in FY24 to 109 days in FY25 and 178 days in FY26. The FY25 annual report attributes the deterioration to “delay in customer payments,” and the DSRI, the ratio of receivables to revenue, rose 63% over the window. - Interest-free, open-ended loans to related parties carry no repayment terms
Major- The auditor reported in FY25 that the company “has not charged interest on loans given to subsidiaries and others,” and in FY23 and FY24 stated that loans were “given without specifying terms and conditions” and “repayment of principal and interest has not been stipulated.” Outstanding balances at 31 March 2025 were 12 crore to a step-down subsidiary and 10 crore to other related parties. - The auditor flagged missing internal controls for two years running
Major- In FY23 and FY24, the standalone internal-financial-controls opinion was qualified: the auditor stated the company did not have appropriate system manuals, predefined standard operating procedures, or formal written internal financial controls over financial reporting. The qualification was resolved in FY25, when the internal-controls opinion was unqualified with no mention of missing manuals or formal written controls. - Five audit firms in six years
Major- M/s R. T. Jain and Associates resigned on 12 August 2020 after the Audit Committee declined a proposed remuneration increase as unaffordable. The company has had five different statutory audit firms since August 2020, with the current auditor, Kailash Chand Jain & Co, appointed on 13 August 2024 to fill a casual vacancy. - Consolidated profit reveals substantial subsidiary-level losses
Major- Consolidated PAT was ₹0.06 crore against standalone PAT of ₹17.13 crore in FY26, indicating that subsidiaries in aggregate contributed a loss of approximately ₹17 crore. On 30 March 2026, subsidiary Nibe Defence and Aerospace Limited agreed to sell its entire shareholding in step-down subsidiary Nibe Aeronautics Limited to promoter Mr. Ganesh Nibe for not less than ₹1.52 crore, and the transfer was completed on 9 April 2026.
What to watch
- Warrant proceeds. ₹147.37 crore remains to be received from warrant holders, payable upon conversion by 4 September 2027.
- Nibe Aeronautics sale. The ₹1.52 crore share sale to promoter Mr. Ganesh Nibe was completed on 9 April 2026; subsequent RPT disclosures are due in the FY26 annual report.
- Related-party loan balances. The 12 crore and 10 crore unsecured, interest-free loans outstanding as of 31 March 2025 are to be reported in the FY26 annual report.
- Auditor stability. The current auditor’s five-year term runs to the 24th AGM (FY29-30); any early resignation would continue the pattern.
Bottom line: This is a company whose reported profits have not reached the cash line for four years, whose receivables are ageing far beyond its own credit policy, and whose governance record shows persistent auditor churn, promoter dominance, and related-party loans with no repayment terms. The consolidated numbers reveal that the subsidiary layer is absorbing value, not creating it. Watch the warrant proceeds, the fate of the related-party loans, and whether the receivables book ever converts to cash.