Key Takeaways
- Profit up despite revenue dip: PAT grew 2.14% QoQ and 8.66% 9M, even as total income fell, driven by a surge in subsidiary and JV profit contributions.
- Coal security is strengthening: NTPC Group hit its highest-ever 9M coal production of 2.54 crore MMT, up 74% YoY, while generation loss from fuel supply collapsed from 200 crore units to just 33 crore units.
- A massive thermal bet is taking shape: Beyond the 10 GW already under construction, management is actively considering awarding 16.8 GW of new thermal capacity, with the first 5.6 GW to be tendered in Q1/Q2 of the next fiscal year.
- Renewable execution is a self-confessed pain point: Management is "not happy with the pace of execution" for its 7.8 GW under-construction RE portfolio, citing module supply disruptions from regulatory changes, though supplies have now started arriving.
- What to watch next quarter: The promised reversal of the INR740 crore 9M under-recovery, the pace of tendering for the 16.8 GW thermal pipeline, and any concrete progress on module procurement for the 7.8 GW renewable portfolio.
Financial Performance
- Revenue headwind, profit tailwind: Total income fell to INR40,288 crore in Q3 and INR1,21,486 crore in 9M from INR42,149 crore and INR1,24,685 crore respectively, but PAT grew on the back of a sharp jump in JV profit share, which rose from INR481 crore to INR1,424 crore in 9M, and a 17.45% increase in subsidiary profits.
- Dividend income halved: Dividend income dropped to INR662 crore from INR1,053 crore in 9M FY23, partially offsetting the JV and subsidiary gains.
- Interest cost ticking up: The average rate of interest on borrowings rose to 6.66% from 6.32% in 9M FY23, reflecting the broader rate cycle.
- CAPEX is running behind the annual target: Group CAPEX stood at INR21,552 crore in 9M FY24 against a full-year outlay of INR28,373 crore, implying a heavy Q4 spend is required.
- Regulatory deferral had a one-off distortion: A prior-year methodology change booked all ash sale collections under regulatory deferral, then shifted them to actual revenue, creating a one-time item that will not repeat and makes year-on-year comparisons misleading.
- Surcharge income is structurally declining: Surcharge is on a reduction trend due to improved collection efficiency from beneficiaries, a positive for the ecosystem but a headwind for this line item.
Under-Recovery & Regulatory Outlook
- Q3 under-recovery spike was a planned outage story: Higher under-recovery of INR256 crore in Q3 and INR740 crore in 9M resulted from preponing overhauls into Q3 after the government directed power companies not to take outages from March onwards, anticipating high Q1 demand. No overhauls were allowed up to June either due to grid conditions, compressing the maintenance window.
- A full reversal is expected in Q4: Management expects the entire INR740 crore nine-month under-recovery to reverse in the fourth quarter, with the full-year figure landing around INR400-450 crore.
- New regulations remove a structural irritant: The 2024-29 tariff regulations have eliminated the high-demand/low-demand seasonality distinction, which management says will structurally reduce under-recovery going forward.
Management: "Under recovery in the third quarter was close to INR256 crores. And overall, it is around INR740 crores, which we should see the reversal during the fourth quarter."
Thermal Capacity: The Big Build-Out
- A 26.8 GW thermal pipeline is forming: 10 GW is already under construction, and NTPC is actively considering awarding another 16.8 GW of new thermal capacity directly, while also supporting state utilities in awarding 7 GW indirectly.
- Tendering is front-loaded: 5,600 MW will be tendered in Q1 and Q2 of the next fiscal year, covering Singrauli 3 (1,600 MW), Sipat 3 (800 MW), and Darlipalli (800 MW). A further 6,400 MW is slated for tender up to Q2 of FY26, and 4,800 MW in FY27.
- Project readiness varies: Singrauli has all studies completed and environmental clearance in place. Sipat is waiting for environmental clearance. Darlipalli still needs land acquisition and environmental clearance. Meja requires land. Despite these hurdles, management is committed to awarding within the next six months.
- PPAs are not a concern: The entire 16.8 GW will be predominantly cost-plus, and management states that PPAs exist for some projects (Darlipalli, Singrauli) and will be signed for others (Sipat, Telangana 2), with states willing to sign.
- Conventional capacity addition is on track: The FY24 target of 3,580 MW will be achieved, with North Karanpura Unit 2, Telangana Unit 2, and Maitree Unit 2 (Bangladesh) expected by February. FY25 targets around 4 GW, and FY26 around 2.7 GW plus.
Renewable Energy: Ambition Meets Execution Friction
- A 22.7 GW tangible pipeline exists: 3,364 MW commissioned, 7,808 MW under construction, 8,225 MW in tendering, and a 3,350 MW land bank, totaling a 22,747 MW pipeline.
- Execution pace is a self-identified problem: Management is "not happy with the pace of execution," attributing the primary bottleneck to module supply disruptions caused by changes in government regulations. Module supplies have now started arriving, and management says it is "back on track."
- Module procurement is mostly direct, not turnkey: Most of the 7.8 GW under construction uses a 2-package mode where modules are procured directly by NTPC, not on a turnkey basis. Orders have been placed for only 2.5 GW so far, leaving significant procurement still to be locked in.
- Commissioning is back-end loaded: Only 1 GW is expected by March, close to another 3 GW next year, with the balance over the following 24 months. The FY26 target of 15 GW operating capacity remains in the ballpark.
- IRR is a "competitive" black box: Management declined to provide a specific IRR for renewable projects, offering only a range and stating it is "comparable with what we are earning in the cost-plus segment." It noted that if module prices remain corrected or fall further, IRRs will improve.
- Transmission is a known but unquantified risk: Management acknowledges transmission is a challenge for all developers and says most projects have connectivity in place, but there might be minor delays in a few, with no material impact anticipated.
Management: "First things first, no, we are not happy with the pace of execution, but these are things which are not in our control and now hopefully, we are back on track."
Fuel Security & Coal Mining
- Coal supply improved materially: Coal materialization against ACQ dipped slightly to 95% from 98% YoY, but total coal supply rose to 62.37 MMT (including 2.15 MMT imported) from 54.02 MMT, and generation loss due to fuel supply collapsed to 33 crore units from 200 crore units.
- Captive mining is scaling fast: NTPC Group achieved its highest-ever 9M coal production of 2.54 crore MMT, a 74% jump from 14.55 MMT in the prior period, driven by cumulative mine development spend of INR10,612.52 crore. The full-year target of 3.4 crore tons is intact and on track.
- A 5 crore ton ambition: Management expects to reach an annual coal production run-rate of 5 crore tonnes within the next 3 years.
- All six mining projects now have MDO contracts: The Badam Coal Mining Project MDO contract was awarded on December 15, 2023, completing the MDO coverage for all six of NTPC's coal mining projects.
Pumped Storage & Green Hydrogen
- Pumped storage pipeline narrowed to 7 GW: After studies and analysis, the opportunity set has been narrowed from 14 GW to 7 GW under active stages. An MOU for 2 GW in Maharashtra was signed, Tamil Nadu is at the last stage, and other states (Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Meghalaya) are being pursued.
- Timeline is long-dated: Each project requires roughly 2 years for DPR preparation and 5-6 years for construction, totaling 7-8 years, making this a next-decade story.
- Green hydrogen is early-stage and off-take dependent: An MOU was signed with the Maharashtra government for NTPC Green Energy to invest up to INR80,000 crores in green hydrogen and ammonia projects. Management cautioned that "ultimately without off-take, this may not be easy to get off the ground," signaling the contingent nature of this ambition.
Management: "Generally, the time taken is two years for DPR and construction period is between five to six years. Totalling, around seven, eight."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Under-recovery reversal | INR740 crore 9M under-recovery to reverse; full-year FY24 to end at INR400-450 crore | Q4 FY24 |
| Conventional capacity addition | 3,580 MW target for FY24 | By March 2024 |
| Thermal tendering | 5,600 MW to be tendered (Singrauli 3, Sipat 3, Darlipalli) | Q1/Q2 next fiscal year |
| Thermal tendering | Further 6,400 MW to be tendered | Up to Q2 FY26 |
| Thermal tendering | Remaining 4,800 MW to be tendered | FY27 |
| Renewable commissioning | 1 GW to be commissioned | By March 2024 |
| Renewable commissioning | Close to another 3 GW to be commissioned | Next fiscal year |
| Renewable commissioning | Balance of 7.8 GW under-construction portfolio | Over subsequent 24 months |
| Coal mining production | 3.4 crore tons for FY24 | FY24 |
| Coal mining production | Annual run-rate of 5 crore tonnes | Within 3 years |
| FGD commissioning | FGD for entire operational and under-construction capacity | Over next 3 years |
| Biomass pellet plant | 22 TPD plant at Bhatinda | Q4 FY24 |
| Capex (standalone) | ~INR22,700 crore | FY25 |
| Capex (standalone) | ~INR26,300 crore | FY26 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total Income (Standalone) | ₹40,288 cr, as against ₹42,149 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| PAT (Standalone) | ₹4,572 cr, increase of 2.14% YoY |
| Adjusted PAT (Standalone) | ₹4,468 cr, as against ₹4,424 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Group PAT (9M FY24) | ₹14,842 cr, increase of 21.16% YoY |
| Subsidiaries Profit | ₹1,516 cr, increase of 17.45% YoY |
| Regulated Equity (Standalone) | ₹82,094 cr as on 31 Dec 2023 |
| Average Rate of Interest (9M FY24) | 6.66%, as compared to 6.32% in 9M FY23 |
| Group CAPEX (9M FY24) | ₹21,552 cr, as compared to ₹26,058 cr in 9M FY23 |
| Standalone CAPEX Guidance (FY25) | ~₹22,700 cr |
| Under Recovery (Disincentive) | ₹256 cr in Q3, around ₹740 cr in 9M FY24; expected to end FY24 at around ₹400-450 cr |
| Commercial Capacity (Group) | 73,874 MW as on 31 Dec 2023 |
| Coal Station PLF (9M FY24) | 76.40%, as against National Average of 68.51% |
| Coal Supply | 62.37 MMT, including 2.15 MMT of imported coal; materialization against ACQ at 95% |
| Group Coal Production (9M FY24) | 2.54 crore MMT, growth of over 74% YoY; full-year target of 3.4 crore tonnes intact |
| Renewable Energy Commissioned | 3,364 MW; 7,808 MW under construction, 22,747 MW tangible pipeline |
| Thermal Capacity Addition Pipeline | 16.8 GW to be awarded in near future, in addition to 10 GW under construction |