Key Takeaways
- Sharp margin reset, management unfazed: EBITDA margin compressed to 14.7% from 27.6% QoQ as cost of delivery surged, yet management frames this as a deliberate long-term investment and expresses confidence in a bounce-back.
- Revenue declined across the board: Consolidated revenue fell to ₹195.4 crore from ₹210.3 crore QoQ and ₹206.8 crore YoY, with product revenue dropping to ₹168 crore from ₹179.4 crore QoQ.
- Zero new customer revenue in the quarter: The entire quarter's revenue came from existing customers, as lead times for new deals stretched beyond expectations, partly due to pricing complexity.
- Order book grew, but mix shifted toward product: Total order book rose to ₹813.4 crore from ₹780 crore, driven entirely by product business growth while the projects and services backlog shrank.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Hoshin Kanri investment begins to show in customer conversions, any sign of revenue from new customers, and the pace of margin recovery from the Q1 trough.
Financial Performance
- Revenue contraction: Consolidated revenue fell 7.1% QoQ and 5.5% YoY to ₹195.4 crore. Product revenue, the core business, dropped to ₹168 crore from ₹179.4 crore QoQ and ₹182.6 crore YoY. Projects and services revenue was ₹27.4 crore, down from ₹30.9 crore QoQ but up from ₹24.2 crore YoY.
- Cost of delivery spike: Cost of delivery including product development surged to 75.5% of revenue from 63.5% QoQ and 60.5% YoY, with absolute cost rising to ₹147.5 crore from ₹133.5 crore QoQ. The increase reflects heavy investment in the Hoshin Kanri initiative and more-than-usual wage hikes to retain talent.
- Profitability compression: EBITDA fell to ₹28.8 crore, a 14.7% margin, from ₹58 crore and 27.6% QoQ. Net profit dropped to ₹30.2 crore, a 15.5% margin, from ₹52.1 crore and 24.8% QoQ.
- Cash position strengthened: Cash and cash equivalents rose to ₹920.8 crore from ₹808 crore QoQ. Management stated the cash is held to invest in revenue, tools, and new technology, with any buyback or dividend decision left to the board.
- Top client concentration increased: The top five clients contributed 28.8% of revenue, up from 27.5% QoQ.
Dusad: "As you would have noticed, we have had a fall in our top line as well as bottom line. I would like to highlight to you that we do not give excessive weightage to quarterly or for that matter, yearly numbers. We are focused on building a long-term enterprise and hence, we would allow such things to happen to ensure that our customers get the services, is retained and the best talent is further attracted."
The Hoshin Kanri Investment
- Strategic initiative launched: The company has undertaken a significant long-term initiative called Hoshin Kanri, based on Toyota Production System Principles, aimed at continuous improvement across all areas of work with the ultimate objective of significantly enhancing end customer experience. The company is investing heavily into this initiative.
- Investment is the margin story: The surge in cost of delivery to 75.5% of revenue is driven by this initiative plus wage hikes. Management characterized the spending as consistent with its policy of retaining the best industry talent and attracting equally good talent, calling it a normal run rate rather than excess provisioning.
- Revenue acceleration lags: Investment in people and sales and marketing has been upfront for several quarters while revenue acceleration is behind the curve. Management acknowledged it is slower than expected and said exact reasons may be shared next quarter.
- Two focus areas stated: Management identified increasing new sales and converting prospects, plus improving overall customer experience through Hoshin Kanri, as the key improvement areas.
Bhise: "This is called Hoshin Kanri, based on Toyota Production System Principles. This is to bring in continuous and long term improvements in all areas of our work for the ultimate objective of significantly enhancing our end customer experience."
Customer Dynamics and Repricing
- No new customer revenue: The company generated zero revenue from any new customer in Q1 FY25. Lead times are higher than expected, partly due to complexity in pricing of the new products. Management is working to minimize those lead times.
- Repricing stalled: Nothing happened on repricing in this quarter. The balance 20% of customers are being talked to about either upgrading to FinnOne Neo or continuing with FinnOne, and the process is taking far longer than expected.
- Migration hesitation: Among customers who have moved to newer pricing, the higher percentage is continuing on the old version. Customers feel they could benefit from sophisticated FinnOne Neo and FinnAxia offerings but are not exactly ready for migration, facing internal trade-offs on timing.
- No customer loss from repricing: Management confirmed no customer has been lost because of repricing. Only a single-digit number of customers have moved out of the older version overall.
- Pricing model complexity: Pricing for both old and new products depends on the value delivered to customers, structured as per-loan, per-transaction, or portfolio-size based. Customers pay only for the features they use. Management stated customers are not confused because the return on investment is multiple times the cost, though it is taking time for customers to appreciate this.
Bhise: "We cannot let you know the time it will take."
Order Book and Pipeline
- Order book grew: Total order book as of June 30, 2024 stood at ₹813.4 crore, up from ₹780 crore as of March 31, 2024. The product business order book increased to ₹752.2 crore from ₹707.7 crore, while projects and services order book shrank to ₹61.2 crore from ₹72.3 crore.
- Execution timeline is long: The order book will be executed over the long term, typically 5 to 7 years.
- Pipeline building but slow: Conversations with prospective customers are going reasonably strong with sustained interest, but some conversations are taking longer than hoped. The pipeline is building reasonably well.
- Annuity and subscription traction: Both CapEx and recurring subscription models are available. Smaller customers especially prefer the subscription model with the product available on cloud, applicable to both domestic and international markets.
Geographic and Product Developments
- International revenue dipped: Southeast Asia, Middle East, and Australia showed a dip in revenue. Conversations with customers in those geographies are continuing, and management expressed confidence growth will start in coming quarters.
- Developed market entry planned: Focus is increasingly on international markets, including existing operating geographies and developing entry into a couple of developed markets, specifically Australia, Japan, and one or two others.
- Australia prospects: A few prospects in Australia are being worked on that could convert in due course. The existing implementation there is in BAU mode, and new implementations need to be added.
- Domestic market not saturated: Management pushed back on the idea that the domestic market is saturated, noting traction is still good both domestically and internationally despite the company already accounting for 60 to 70% of all retail loans by Indian finance companies on their systems.
- Islamic banking version: The company is building an Islamic version of FinnOne Neo for use in the Middle East, Malaysia, and similar markets.
- Senior leadership additions: A CFO and CHRO joined in the previous quarter. Sales senior leadership hires are planned for different regions.
Guidance and Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Margin improvement | Confident of improving from Q1 FY25 levels, no number given | No timeline stated |
| International revenue growth | Growth will start happening in Southeast Asia, Middle East, Australia | "Coming quarters" |
| New customer additions | Hopes to start adding value to new customers as lead times and pricing complexity are reduced | No timeline stated |
| Sales leadership hires | Plans to onboard sales leaders in different regions | No timeline stated |
| Hoshin Kanri updates | More updates will be shared going forward | No timeline stated |
| Investment benefit clarity | Exact reasons for slower-than-expected revenue acceleration may be shared | "Next quarter" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹195.4 cr, against ₹210.3 cr QoQ and ₹206.8 cr YoY |
| Product revenue | ₹168 cr, against ₹179.4 cr QoQ and ₹182.6 cr YoY |
| Projects and services revenue | ₹27.4 cr, against ₹30.9 cr QoQ and ₹24.2 cr YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹28.8 cr (14.7% of revenue), against ₹58 cr (27.6%) QoQ and ₹62.3 cr (30.1%) YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 14.7%, against 27.6% QoQ and 30.1% YoY |
| Net profit | ₹30.2 cr (15.5% of revenue), against ₹52.1 cr (24.8%) QoQ and ₹53.6 cr (25.9%) YoY |
| EPS | ₹11.28, against ₹19.48 QoQ and ₹20 YoY |
| Cost of delivery (incl. product development) | 75.5% of revenue, against 63.5% QoQ and 60.5% YoY |
| Domestic revenue share | 58% of total revenue, against 48% in Q1 FY24 |
| International revenue share | 42% of total revenue, against 52% in Q1 FY24 |
| Order book | ₹813.4 cr (₹752.2 cr product, ₹61.2 cr projects and services), against ₹780 cr as on Mar 31, 2024 |
| Total cash and cash equivalents | ₹920.8 cr, against ₹808 cr as on Mar 31, 2024 |
| Revenue from top five clients | 28.8% of revenue, against 27.5% QoQ |
| Headcount addition | 62 Nucleics added during the quarter |
| New customer revenue | Nil, entire revenue from existing customers |