Key Takeaways
- Soft quarter, pre-announced: EBITDA of ₹103 crores, flat YoY, absorbed ~₹25 crores in one-off costs from a planned kiln shutdown, clinker transport and a McKinsey engagement. Management had flagged the softness three months ago.
- Volume growth masks a structural mix shift: 15% YoY volume growth was driven entirely by B2B infrastructure demand, while B2C fell to 47% of sales from 56% last year. This shift consumes more clinker, pressuring consent-to-operate limits at Chittapur.
- Premium product strategy is working: StrongCrete and OrientGreen combined volumes grew 34% YoY, now forming over 20% of B2C volumes, and helped hold realizations flat at ~₹5,200/ton despite a soft market.
- The capex cycle is shifting from promise to execution: Chittapur Line 2 construction is expected to start by end-Q3 FY24, with a 15-month build timeline. FY2025 capex is estimated at ₹1,500–1,700 Cr, a material step-up.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the July demand setback from heavy rains reverses in August-September, the pace of environment clearance for Chittapur expansion, and the actual cost of the next pet coke procurement in October-November.
Volume & Mix: The B2B Surge
- B2B took over: B2B share rose to 53% (from 44% last year) as large infrastructure projects and ready-mix plant operators drove demand, while B2C demand stayed soft. This mix shift consumes more clinker per ton of cement sold.
- OPC now out-earns PPC at Chittapur: For several consecutive quarters, OPC contributions have exceeded PPC contributions at Chittapur, reversing the historical norm. Management credits quality, demand, customer relationships and transparent costing.
- Premium products held the line on price: Despite B2C volumes dropping 7.5% sequentially, premium product volumes grew 34% YoY. The company refuses orders that do not meet its price or contribution thresholds.
- Regional identity transformed: West region exposure reached 62% of sales (from 55% last year); 72% of sales now come from non-south markets.
Khetrapal: "anybody who still believes we are a south-based company this is a wakeup call we are 62% in west, and we are 10% in central, so 72% of sales of Orient Cement actually comes from non-south markets"
Costs: A Quarter of One-Offs
- Kiln shutdown bunched costs: The Chittapur kiln ran 23 months without maintenance, far exceeding the typical 9–11 month maximum, because the previous monsoon shutdown was skipped to save money. The refractory could not stretch to 26 months, forcing a Q1 shutdown that concentrated costs.
- Clinker logistics distorted: 72,000 tonnes of clinker were transported from Devapur to Chittapur during the shutdown to avoid letting down large loyal customers, inflating logistics cost per ton.
- Fuel mix worked against reported costs: International pet coke prices softened, but Chittapur (which uses pet coke) was shut for a month, so savings were lower. Devapur (which uses domestic coal) produced more clinker, and domestic coal prices rose 17–18% YoY. The net effect: a higher proportion of higher-cost domestic coal in the quarter's fuel mix.
- Grid power costs rose: Maharashtra and Karnataka changed grid power prices. Despite solar at Jalgaon and captive power at Chittapur, committed grid loads carry steep fixed charges that increased.
- AFR supply dipped: Alternative fuel usage fell to 12% from 13% due to lower supply availability.
Khetrapal: "the nuances are important to see behind the numbers. Our proportion of domestic coal consumption went up in this particular quarter, which if you compare the domestic coal prices, they have actually gone up during the year by 17 to 18% over the same quarter last year."
Expansion Pipeline: Chittapur First
- Chittapur Line 2 is the priority: The brownfield expansion is the number one priority because of higher clinker need driven by the B2B mix shift. Construction is expected to start toward the end of Q3 FY24, subject to environment clearance, with commissioning within 15 months of start.
- Devapur Line 4 waits on MP: The Devapur expansion will be triggered only after the Madhya Pradesh grinding unit agreement is signed and clearances are applied for. The MP site is more or less closed, but the counterparty still needs Board approval for the right-to-use land agreement.
- Rajasthan mining lease restored but not final: The government restored the mining lease, but digital measurement found ~5 hectares of extra area requiring State Minister of Mines approval to finalize coordinates. Land acquisition will start only after coordinates are frozen.
- WHRS near completion: The waste heat recovery plant is in the final stages of commissioning; cooler waste heat (80% of power) is expected to start generating in August, with the preheater part delayed by ~4 weeks. Full 10 MW is expected by year-end, targeting ₹3 Cr+ per month in savings at an FY2025 run rate.
- Solar power in 9 months: An agreement with Cleantech Solar (a Shell JV) will add 21+ MW of solar captive capacity, with supply starting in about 9 months. Management declined to disclose the contractual power price, stating only that it provides significant savings from grid price.
Khetrapal: "We cannot get fixated with any decision taken. That is the definition of being agile."
Market & Competitive Dynamics
- Maharashtra capacity additions absorbed over time: Management acknowledged new capacity from competitors (Ambuja adding 0.6 Cr tonne) but argued that demand growth in India's largest market will absorb it, citing Chittapur's own experience of thriving amid multiple competitors in Gulbarga.
- No Maharashtra grinding unit planned: Management ruled out a new grinding unit near Patas/Solapur due to unfavorable fly ash availability and cost dynamics, and would only reconsider if an existing asset comes up for sale at a reasonable price.
- Railway policy headwind: Unfriendly railway policies caused cement transported by rail to drop to 15% from 20% of sales.
- July rains disrupted demand: Extremely heavy rains across markets dampened project work in July; early August is showing some relief and pickup.
Khetrapal: "I always keep reminding people about the time that we were putting our Chittapur plant in Gulbarga, everybody used to tell me there is Rajashree next to you, there is ACC Wadi next to you, Shree Cement is coming next door, Vasavadatta is there how will you survive and I am telling you we need more clinker there now. How did that happen?"
Energy & Fuel Outlook
- Pet coke costs set to fall: The next procurement, expected in October-November for consumption, is anticipated to be ~20% cheaper than the last purchase. Full impact will emerge as old inventory is consumed.
- Domestic coal prices stable: Management does not expect domestic coal prices to increase in the next two quarters.
- Fuel cost per million Kcal disclosed under protest: Devapur at 1,925, Chittapur at 2,340. Management pushed back on the analyst's request, calling it "nitty gritty which you cannot even relate to the reality."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Annual sales volume | 0.63–0.64 Cr tonnes kept "absolutely intact" | FY24 full year |
| WHRS power generation | 80% of power (cooler waste heat) online; full 10 MW | August 2023; year-end 2023 |
| WHRS monthly savings | ₹3 Cr+ per month run rate | FY2025 |
| Solar captive power supply | 21+ MW from Cleantech Solar SPV | ~9 months from agreement signing |
| Chittapur Line 2 construction start | Subject to environment clearance; hopeful by end-Q3 FY24 | End-Q3 FY24 |
| Chittapur Line 2 commissioning | 15 months from construction start | ~April 2025 (assuming Jan 1, 2024 start) |
| Devapur Line 4 trigger | Only after MP grinding unit agreement signed and clearances applied for | Undated, contingent on MP counterparty Board approval |
| FY2024 capex | Ambition of ~₹1,000 Cr; may become ₹750–800 Cr depending on clearance timing | FY24 |
| FY2025 capex estimate | ₹1,500–1,700 Cr (₹900 Cr Chittapur balance, ₹100–150 Cr Rajasthan, ₹300–400 Cr MP grinding unit) | FY25 |
| Pet coke cost reduction | Next procurement ~20% cheaper than last purchase | October-November 2023 |
| Domestic coal price expectation | No increase expected | Next two quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,030 cr (implied by EBITDA of ₹103 cr and operating margin context), +15% YoY; sequential shrinkage contained to 6% |
| EBITDA | ₹103 cr, flat YoY despite ~₹25 cr in additional costs |
| Volume growth | +15% YoY; sequential degrowth of 7% |
| Realisation | Shade under ₹5,200/ton, flat YoY; QoQ higher than Q4 |
| Fuel cost per million Kcal – Devapur | ₹1,925, down nearly 9% |
| Fuel cost per million Kcal – Chittapur | ₹2,340 (landed cost, imported pet coke), down about 12% |
| Domestic coal price change | +17–18% YoY |
| Pet coke price change | –14% YoY |
| AFR percentage | 12%, down from 13% in Q4 |
| Renewable power at Jalgaon | 64% of total power consumed |
| Premium products volume growth | +34% YoY (StrongCrete + OrientGreen combined) |
| Premium products share of B2C volumes | 20%+, up from crossing 20% |
| B2C / B2B mix | 47% B2C, 53% B2B (was 56% B2C, 44% B2B a year ago) |
| OPC share of product mix | 45%, up from 41% last year |
| West region sales share | 62% of total sales, up from 55% last year |
| Non-south markets sales share | 72% of total sales |
| Fuel mix – domestic coal | 53%, up from 43% last year |
| Fuel mix – pet coke | 36%, down from 42% last year |
| Total debt | ₹250 cr as of June 30, 2023 (project borrowings ₹203 cr + net working capital ₹55 cr) |
| Railway-transported cement | 15%, down from 20% at one point |
| WHRS expected monthly savings | ₹3 cr+ per month, 80% power from August, full by early Q4 |
| Annual sales volume target | 0.63–0.64 cr tonnes, kept intact |
| FY2024 capex ambition | ~₹1,000 cr (₹600 cr Chittapur, ~₹150 cr Devapur, ~₹100 cr Rajasthan land, plus maintenance/WHRS) |
| FY2025 capex estimate | ₹1,500–1,700 cr (₹900 cr Chittapur, ₹100–150 cr Rajasthan, ₹300–400 cr MP grinding unit) |
| Chittapur expansion | 0.2 cr tonnes clinker, 0.3 cr tonnes grinding; total cost close to ₹1,500 cr |
| Devapur forest clearance deposit | ~₹140–150 cr required upon stage one clearance |
| Next pet coke procurement cost expectation | ~20% less than last purchase |
| AFR cost | In the region of ₹1.2 |
| StrongCrete price premium over PPC | ₹45/ton higher |
| OrientGreen price premium over PPC | ₹25+/ton higher |
| Clinker transported Devapur to Chittapur | 72,000 tonnes in April |
| Additional costs absorbed in the quarter | ~₹23–24 cr (maintenance, clinker transport, realignment, McKinsey) |
| Chittapur kiln shutdown interval | 23 months since last maintenance (vs typical 9–11 months) |