Key Takeaways
- A deliberate volume sacrifice: Orient Cement posted a 15% YoY volume decline, far worse than the market, because management refused to chase low-margin B2B orders and instead defended price realizations.
- Pricing discipline held while peers bled: Realizations were stable at ~1% over last year, even as competitors in the same markets lost realizations per ton and some leading brands sold at INR10–15 below Orient's price.
- Cost-side gains were real but volume-starved: Green power reached 24% of the mix, fuel cost per ton fell to INR939 from INR1,113, and waste heat recovery delivered ~INR9 crores in benefits, yet low utilisation pushed grinding power consumption higher.
- Premium products are the structural bet: Premium cement hit 23% of the mix, up from a 10% initial target, with management aiming for 25% by year-end and an eventual ambition to sell only premium cement.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-monsoon demand rebound materialises sharply enough to salvage FY25 volume guidance, and whether the Sarni grinding unit formal approval and Chittapur environment clearance progress as signalled.
Volume Strategy: Choosing Margin Over Tonnage
- The 15% degrowth was intentional, not accidental: Management characterised the decision as a "bold strategy" to run the business differently from an industry that prioritises capacity utilisation. They refused B2B orders that fell below their contribution threshold, accepting a volume hit to protect per-bag profitability.
- B2B vs B2C logic: In the trade (consumer) channel, where brand matters, Orient aligned pricing with category-A leaders to retain market share. In B2B, where customers are price-driven and disloyal, they walked away from orders with very low net margins, stating they will return to competitive B2B pricing only when costs fall or market prices improve.
- The competitive reality: Large groups adding capacity are prioritising utilisation, pushing volumes from newly acquired and distant plants into Orient's core markets at lower prices. Some leading brands are selling INR10–15 below Orient's price.
- The inefficiency trade-off: Lower volumes caused more mill stops and starts, pushing grinding power consumption up sequentially to 62.7 from 61.7, a small but real cost of the strategy.
Khetrapal: "I would say some would call it risky, but I call it a bold strategy to say, there is another model of running cement business within the industry, which is -- most of the people are following the same track and we decided that no, we are not following that track."
Demand Environment: Softness Across the Board
- A multi-quarter slowdown: The cement sector slowdown has been visible since mid-Q4 FY24, with DIPP data showing flat growth over last year. Telangana and Karnataka have been soft for many quarters, and even Maharashtra total demand is down YoY.
- Q1 was hit by a cluster of disruptions: National elections, an extreme May heat wave that prompted local authorities to halt construction in some districts, heavy June rains across all markets, and an aggregate-supplier strike in Pune all compressed activity.
- No near-term relief: July and the first five days of August remained very soft in both volumes and pricing. Telangana shows no real signs of demand pickup yet, and Q2 will struggle to match last year's volumes.
- The post-monsoon bet: Management's outlook rests on a historical pattern: after heavy monsoons, demand picks up sharply from pent-up construction and repair work on rain-damaged roads and bridges. They expect this to repeat, but have not yet requantified FY25 volume guidance, which previously assumed 8% growth.
Khetrapal: "We would like to make money on every bag of cement that we sell rather than losing even on one bag."
Costs & Efficiency: Green Power Gains, Fuel Relief
| Cost line | Q1 FY25 | Q1 FY24 | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power & fuel cost per ton | INR1,337 | INR1,571 | — |
| Fuel cost per ton | INR939 | INR1,113 | — |
| Power cost per ton | INR397 | INR456 | INR401 |
| Blended fuel cost (INR/mn kcal) | INR1,785 | INR2,100 | ~flat QoQ |
| Green power share | 24% | 12% | — |
| Alternative fuels (TSR basis) | 13% | 5% | 16% |
- Waste heat recovery now fully online: The second phase commissioned on April 29 and was fully operational for May and June, contributing ~INR9 crores in benefits for the quarter. Solar added over INR2.5 crores.
- Solar expansion progressing: Jalgaon solar is nearly complete (3.4 MW of 3.7 MW operational), while the ~17 MW Chittapur solar project is delayed and now expected by mid-September.
- Alternative fuels doubled YoY: TSR basis reached 13%, more than double last year's 5%, though down sequentially from 16% as the mix normalised.
- Heat consumption stood at 689 kcal/kg for the company.
Premium Products: The Long-Term Identity Shift
- Premium share reached 23% of total volumes, up from an initial 10% target, with 25% expected by year-end, after which the target will be revised upward.
- The stated end-state: Management's goal is that Orient Cement should eventually sell only premium cement (Strongcrete and nothing else), a structural repositioning away from commodity competition.
- Pricing power on premium: The premium commanded over normal cement is the highest in the market, providing a margin buffer that the volume-protection strategy in B2B is designed to preserve.
Khetrapal: "My goal rather would be that Orient Cement actually should be selling only strongcrete and nothing else."
Expansion & Clearances: The Pipeline Inches Forward
- Chittapur environment clearance: Applications for both capacity and mining expansion are on the MoEF portal. Public hearing minutes were finalised after elections; a presentation to the committee is expected around end-August, with approval a few weeks thereafter.
- Sarni (MP) grinding unit: The MP Power Generation Corp board has informally agreed to the term Orient wanted altered. A formal letter is awaited; board minutes are expected soon. This is the immediate priority to utilise existing low clinker capacity at Devapur.
- Devapur forest clearance: The file has reached the Telangana Forest Minister. Once signed, it moves to MoEF Delhi for evaluation; management describes it as at a very advanced stage. A INR150 crores payment is required this year to convert stage-1 to stage-2 clearance.
- Rajasthan mining lease: Land acquisition negotiations continue; no deals closed yet. The Board-approved strategy is to diversify into Rajasthan, not monetise the lease.
- Capex phasing: Real investment outflows for Chittapur and Sarni will mostly land in FY26, not FY25. Construction activity starts this year but heavy spending comes next year. Management has begun touching base with banks to fund the ~INR2,000 crores total capex.
Industry Structure & Pricing: No Trigger in Sight
- The consolidation question: When asked what single trigger could improve pricing given consolidation in the South, management deflected, calling it a "tricky question" because consolidators' strategies are known only to themselves. No specific catalyst was identified.
- The structural threat: Two large groups are simultaneously acquiring and building organic capacity. If they decide to prioritise volume push, prices will always be under threat. Management sees this as a fact of the industry, not a temporary condition.
- The stability condition: Management's view is that prices become stable only when the industry accepts that pushing more volume at lower prices helps no one, neither the company doing it nor the rest of the industry.
- State mining tax risk: A new Supreme Court ruling giving states power to levy additional taxes could create state-to-state variation, but the situation as of today is unchanged.
Khetrapal: "The only way prices become stable is when people accept the fact that trying to sell to the market more volume at a lower price does not help anyone. It does not help that company. It does not help the rest of the industry also."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Premium cement mix | Reach 25% of total volumes, then revise target upward | By end of this year |
| Chittapur solar contribution | ~17 MW solar plant to begin contributing | Mid-September 2024 |
| Chittapur environment clearance | Presentation to MoEF committee expected | Around end-August 2024 |
| Devapur stage-1 forest clearance payment | INR150 crores to be paid to convert to stage-2 | This year (FY25) |
| Sarni grinding unit formal approval | Formal letter from MP Power Gen Corp board awaited | Minutes expected soon (board met ~2 weeks ago) |
| Capex heavy outflows | Real investment for Chittapur and Sarni | Mostly FY26, not FY25 |
| FY25 volume guidance | Previous 8% growth target to be relooked; H1 unlikely to deliver | Reassessment after monsoon ends |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | 15% degrowth YoY, similar degrowth in rupee crore terms |
| Volume | 13.5 lakh tons, 15% degrowth YoY and 21% degrowth QoQ |
| Price realization | Stable, around 1% over last year and sequentially steady |
| EBITDA per ton | ~₹750, up from ~₹650 in Q1 FY24 |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | ₹1,337, down from ₹1,571 YoY and ₹1,351 QoQ |
| Fuel cost per ton of cement | ₹939, down from ₹1,113 YoY and ₹950 QoQ |
| Power cost per ton of cement | ₹397, down from ₹456 YoY and ₹401 QoQ |
| Blended fuel cost per million kcal | ₹1,785, down from ₹2,100 YoY; sequentially almost flat |
| Green power share | 24%, up from 12% in Q1 FY24; highest ever |
| Alternative fuel TSR | 13%, down from 16% QoQ; up from 5% YoY |
| Heat consumption | 689 kcal/kg clinker |
| Premium products share | 23% of total volumes, target 25% |
| Trade share | 44% trade, 56% B2B |
| West region volume share | 68% of Q1 volumes |
| South region volume share | 24% of Q1 volumes |
| Maharashtra volume degrowth | 5.5% YoY |
| OPC share of unblended cement | 45%–47% |
| Lead distance | 300–320 km, unchanged |
| Waste heat recovery benefit in Q1 | Close to ₹9 crores |
| Solar power net benefit in Q1 | Over ₹2.5 crores |
| FY25 capex expectation | ₹200–300 crores total, down from earlier ₹1,000 crores guidance |
| Chittapur expansion capex | ₹1,500 crores |
| Sarni grinding unit capex | ₹500 crores |
| July pricing | Down 2.5%–3% sequentially vs Q1 |