Key Takeaways
- Brutal quarter, embarrassed management: EBITDA collapsed over 70% YoY to Rs. 37 crore and the company slipped to a small PBT loss, which the MD called "a matter of great embarrassment."
- Costs attacked from all sides: Power and fuel cost per ton surged 61% YoY to Rs. 1,647, with pet coke, domestic coal, alternate fuels, and even renewable power all inflating simultaneously.
- Pricing power was absent: The ability to pass on costs to the market "have not been fruitful at all," leaving the company squeezed between relentless fuel inflation and soft demand.
- Brand strategy is the chosen defense: Management is refusing to match low prices from new competitors around Devapur, betting that brand positioning will protect the company long-term even if it means suffering lower utilisation now.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-festival demand kick finally materialises, the pace of fuel cost softening from the newly-booked pet coke shipment, and any sustained improvement in cement realisations.
Demand & Volume Environment
- Volumes held up despite headwinds: Cement volumes fell only 1.4% YoY even with heavy rains and zero clinker sales, a result management considered not so disappointing given the absence of large government projects in Telangana and Karnataka.
- Geography split the quarter: Maharashtra and the west carried the load, contributing close to 55% of sales versus a normal 50–51%, because demand was present there while southern markets stayed soft.
- B2B mix surged as retail retreated: Non-trade sales jumped to 45% from 39% YoY because large projects with mechanised equipment continued construction through the rains, but these customers negotiate hard, keep prices challenged, and consume more OPC, which is costlier to produce.
- Post-festival recovery is missing so far: As of the call date, the expected demand kick after Dussehra and Diwali had not materialised, with management speculating that labour unavailability even in cities like Delhi was holding back activity.
- No volume growth guidance: Management declined to give a number for FY23, stating "your guess is as good as mine" and that there is no basis until markets show indication.
Khetrapal: "I'm naming it as a brutal year for the industry. It's really been brutal on us. We too have had our own share of grief."
Cost Structure: The Perfect Storm
- Fuel inflation hit from every direction: Pet coke cost rose from Rs. 1,500 to Rs. 2,568 per million kcal, domestic coal from Rs. 1,330 to ~Rs. 1,900, alternate fuels nearly doubled, and renewable power generators raised prices despite no cost escalation, simply taking advantage of high thermal power prices.
- Plant mix amplified the pain: Chitapur ran at much higher utilisation than Devapur because southern markets were soft, but Chitapur uses more pet coke (landed coal cost there is unaffordable) while Devapur uses cheaper domestic coal from Singareni, so the shift pushed up the overall fuel bill.
- Devapur forced into expensive imports: The plant did not get enough higher-quality domestic coal and had to use expensive imported coal, normally only a sweetener, just to maintain production and deliveries.
- Logistics added another layer: Rake shortages forced road transport of coal from Singareni mines to Devapur, increasing freight and the input cost of domestic coal, while railways hiked demurrage charges 400–500%, forcing a logistics rejig that dropped rail share from 20% to 15%.
- Monsoon disrupted materials: Heavy rains slowed coal mining, disrupted gypsum availability, made alternate fuels wet and difficult to use (low calorific value when wet), and caused short supply of liquid hazardous waste.
- Fixed costs carried ~Rs. 10 crore of distortions: Q2 fixed costs appeared higher YoY due to a reversal of variable pay provisions in the base quarter (~Rs. 4 crore), a one-time sales tax settlement (~Rs. 1.8 crore), SAP migration costs (~Rs. 2 crore), and additional brand-building spend (~Rs. 2 crore), together adding Rs. 70–80 per ton.
- Fuel cost was broadly stable sequentially: Blended fuel cost rose only ~1% QoQ despite the industry reporting 10–20% surges, partly because of the higher Chitapur utilisation and a shift in product mix toward OPC.
Khetrapal: "So, there's been a beating from all possible quarters."
Pricing & Competitive Dynamics
- Cost pass-through failed completely: The results were bad "purely because of the costs," and the ability to pass them on to markets was not fruitful at all, leaving pricing to hurt as much as the costs themselves.
- New competition is pressuring Devapur volumes: New capacities from Dalmia and Birla Corp around the older Devapur plant are pushing low-priced B2B volumes, and Orient is refusing to match those prices to protect brand positioning, resulting in lower capacity utilisation at Devapur versus Chitapur.
- Brand strategy is the long bet: Management believes that chasing every new competitor by matching prices would destroy brand strategy and positioning, and that branding is the right survival path for a manufacturer of Orient's size because remaining a commodity forever with these capacities means never getting good realisations.
- Small price improvements, no trend yet: A small improvement in prices came in October over Q2, and a further slight improvement in early November, but both are still too small to call a trend.
- Product mix worsened the blended ratio: OPC share rose to 45% from 39% YoY, worsening the blended cement ratio because OPC is unblended and costlier to produce, while premium brand Strongcrete reached 15% of trade sales, its highest ever.
Khetrapal: "If I start chasing every new competition which comes in front matching the prices, my brand strategy and positioning will go for a toss. So, currently we are suffering... we are still sort of believing that the way we have introduced branding and the power of branding to a small manufacturer like our company is the right way for us to survive because if you remain a commodity forever with these kind of capacities, you will never, never, never be able to sort of get good."
Fuel & Cost Outlook: Glimmers of Relief
- Pet coke shipment booked at the trough: One shipload of ~55,000 tons was booked in mid-September at what management called the lowest price available before prices moved up again by \$20–\$30 per ton, a decision described in hindsight as "a brilliant call."
- Incoming fuel cost is meaningfully lower: The new pet coke will cost under Rs. 2,300 per million kcal versus the Q2 consumed cost of Rs. 2,568, implying at least a 10% saving as it begins reaching the plant.
- Global coal softening may force domestic follow-through: South African coal is beginning to soften, and if that continues, domestic miners like Singareni and Coal India will have to follow global price trends, while alternate fuel availability is also expected to improve, helping shift the fuel mix toward cheaper options.
- Waste heat recovery to lift renewable share: The Chitapur WHRS project is under construction and expected to commission toward the end of FY23, which will increase the renewable power share further from the current 18%.
Khetrapal: "We took the call to book at that time rather than waiting a further fall to happen. And now in hindsight I can tell you it seemed to be a brilliant call because we book at perhaps the lowest price of petcoke that was available and after that the prices again moved up \$20, \$25, \$30 a ton."
Strategic Initiatives & Expansion
- Orient Green launched as a premium, lower-carbon brand: The new cement carries a ~15% lower carbon footprint than industry norms and is positioned as environmentally responsible, initially launched in a few districts of north Karnataka near the Chitapur plant, averaging 3–4 slabs cast per day.
- SAP migration completed at speed: The company migrated from SAP ECC to SAP S/4HANA on Google Cloud in ~3.5 months versus a typical 6–9 months, claiming to be the first cement company to do so.
- Tiroda grinding unit is stalled: Progress has halted because one required document for the environment clearance application has still not been received, and management noted that Adani now owns both Ambuja and ACC but still wants Orient to put up a grinding unit and compete.
- Devapur Line 4 is interlinked with Tiroda: Land and environment approval are in hand, and the expansion can be built in about one year once Tiroda construction begins, but Tiroda must start first.
- Rajasthan greenfield remains distant: No land has been acquired yet, and even after starting construction it will take about three years, but management considers Rajasthan too lucrative to pass up despite the difficulties.
- FY23 capex will undershoot earlier guidance: No work has started, so FY23 capex will be lower than previously guided, while FY24 capex is expected at ~Rs. 850 crore to stay on track.
- Chitapur WHRS and flyash unit: Both are expected to be commissioned by the end of FY23.
Balance Sheet & One-Offs
- Karnataka government loan: The company received a Rs. 38 crore interest-free loan under the state industrial policy, repayable over four equal yearly instalments after a 10-year moratorium.
- Telangana sales tax cases closed: A one-time settlement scheme was used to close all old sales tax cases dating back to 2005 and before, with a payment of ~Rs. 1.8 crore.
- Debt repayment continued: Rs. 37 crore of project debt was repaid in Q2, bringing the H1 total to Rs. 74 crore.
- Deloitte Best Managed Companies award: Orient was selected among a handful of companies after a four-stage evaluation covering strategy, communication, implementation, innovation, culture, commitment, governance, and financials.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Chitapur WHRS commissioning | Waste heat recovery system to increase renewable power share | End of FY23 |
| Chitapur flyash unit commissioning | Flyash handling unit at Chitapur | End of FY23 |
| FY24 capex | ~Rs. 850 crore to stay on expansion track | FY24 |
| Devapur Line 4 construction | Can be built in ~1 year once Tiroda grinding unit construction begins | Contingent on Tiroda start |
| Orient Green brand rollout | Expand beyond north Karnataka districts | No date (sorting bag availability and logistics) |
| Volume strategy | Sell as much volume as possible but not at the cost of profitability | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net sales | Down 1% YoY, down 14% sequentially |
| Cement volume | 12.36 lakh tons, down 1.4% YoY (excluding clinker); down ~10% sequentially |
| H1 cement volume | 26.37 lakh tons, ~1% growth YoY (excluding clinker) |
| Realization | 4% higher YoY, down 4% sequentially |
| EBITDA | ₹37 cr, down from ₹157 cr YoY, more than 70% drop |
| EBITDA per ton | ~₹300, more than 72% drop YoY |
| PBT | Small loss (negative) |
| Power & fuel cost per ton | ₹1,647, 61% higher YoY |
| Blended fuel cost per million kcal | ₹2,379, vs ₹1,336 YoY |
| H1 blended fuel cost per million kcal | ₹2,358, vs ₹1,296 YoY |
| Pet coke cost per million kcal | ₹2,568, vs ₹1,500 YoY |
| Domestic coal cost per million kcal | ~₹1,900, vs ₹1,330 YoY |
| Non-trade (B2B) sales share | 45%, up from 39% YoY |
| OPC share of sales | 45%, up from 39% YoY |
| Premium cement (Strongcrete) share of trade sales | 15%, highest ever |
| Renewable power share in overall mix | 18% |
| Rail dispatch share | 15%, down from 20% YoY |
| Maharashtra & west sales share | Close to 55%, vs normal 50–51% |
| Total interest-bearing debt | ₹408 cr |
| Project debt outstanding | ₹236 cr |
| Working capital borrowings | ₹172 cr |
| Project debt repaid in Q2 | ₹37 cr; H1 total ₹74 cr |
| Interest-free loan from Karnataka government | ₹38 cr received |
| Total debt including interest-free loan | ₹446 cr |
| Power consumption per ton of cement | ~63 units |
| Heat consumption per ton | ~680 kcal |
| New pet coke shipment cost per million kcal | Under ₹2,300, at least 10%+ saving vs Q2 pet coke cost |
| FY24 CAPEX expectation | ~₹850 cr |