Key Takeaways
- Volume recovery, margin pain: Volumes grew ~17% YoY on strong post-festival momentum, but per-ton EBITDA languished at ~₹640, a level management called "not good," as fuel costs stayed 35% higher YoY with no pricing power to pass them on.
- B2B mix shift is a margin headwind: B2B sales jumped to 51% of volumes (from 41% YoY), dragging OPC share to 47% and pressuring both realizations and per-ton fuel consumption. The adverse mix partly offset the QoQ fuel cost decline.
- Fuel cost relief is visible but delayed: QoQ power & fuel cost per ton fell 4%, and AFR saved ~₹10 crores. But the latest petcoke shipment was booked at a slightly higher cost, so any softening in global fuel prices benefits the P&L only from June 2023 onward.
- Capex is on hold, reassessment underway: FY23 capex was slashed to ~₹150 crores vs an earlier >₹800 crores estimate. Management is relooking at expansion plans and will provide FY24 guidance only with full-year results in April.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 pricing delivers the historical seasonal uptick management hopes for but has no visibility on, the pace of B2C demand recovery that would restore mix and lift StrongCrete share, and the FY24 capex plan in April.
Volume & Demand
- Q3 volumes surged post-festival: After a slow October hit by extended monsoons and festivals, demand momentum built sharply post-Diwali/Chhath Puja, delivering ~17% YoY volume growth against industry growth of 10% YoY per DIPP data.
- Capacity utilization improved: Utilization crossed 70% in Q3, a meaningful step up from the 60s range, though management emphasized capacity will never be the constraint on supplying volumes.
- Q4 outlook is cautiously optimistic: January demand indicates good growth, and Q4 historically sees momentum build. The company is working toward 0.17–0.18 crore tons for the quarter, with full-year FY23 expected at ~0.58 crore tons, slightly below the original 0.6 crore ambition.
- FY24 industry growth could hit double digits: Management cited the pro-capex Union Budget (roads, railways, PM Awaas Yojana, affordable housing) and the fact that industry demand is still below pre-COVID levels as reasons it "would not be surprised" by double-digit industry growth in FY24. The company aims to continue its track record of growing faster than the industry.
Khetrapal: "The demand if it sustains, obviously, we will once again push the pedal when it comes to capex."
Pricing & Realizations
- Pricing power remains absent: Q3 realization was ~₹5,100/ton, only 1% higher YoY and 3% QoQ, despite steep fuel cost inflation. Management acknowledged that throughout the financial year, costs have not given any relief and the company has not been able to pass on cost increases.
- No line of sight on Q4 price improvement: Management sees no visible signs of prices going up this quarter, though it has not given up hope because Q4 has historically seen price improvement. Volume assumptions for Q4 do not factor in any price increase.
- Size limits pricing power: The company acknowledged it does not have much option to determine the price at which it sells the volume it needs to sell, a structural constraint for a player of its scale.
Khetrapal: "The challenge has been that despite all the key variables, variable costs pushed high and market seeing demand momentum. We just perhaps need an opportunity to be able to pass on the increased cost to the markets, which as of now are not visible."
Costs & Fuel Mix
- Power & fuel cost still elevated: Q3 power & fuel cost per ton was ₹1,578, 35% higher YoY, though 4% lower QoQ. Blended fuel cost was nearly 40% higher YoY. The QoQ reduction was partly offset by adverse product mix as higher OPC share increases per-ton fuel consumption.
- Fuel sourcing split: Overall fuel mix was ~40–41% domestic coal, ~40–41% imported petcoke, with the rest AFR. Chittapur runs largely on imported petcoke plus AFR, while Devapur runs largely on domestic coal plus AFR, with imported coal only ~1% in Q3.
- Petcoke cost softening is months away: The latest petcoke shipment was booked at just under 3% higher cost than the previous one and covers requirements up to May 2023. Any benefit from softening global petcoke prices will only become visible from June 2023 onward.
- Fuel cost outlook is turning benign: Management sees a somewhat benign climate ahead because US/Australian coal prices have been coming down, and a large Indian petcoke manufacturer has announced it will stop selling petcoke, which could force petcoke suppliers to reduce prices or prompt a switch to coal.
- AFR and renewables are structural cost levers: AFR reached 17% of fuel mix volumetrically, saving ~₹10 crores in the quarter vs fossil fuels despite AFR costs more than doubling. Solar at Jalgaon supplied 62% of that unit's power, and company-wide renewable power share reached 18% without any waste heat recovery plant yet. The Chittapur WHR plant (~10 MW) is expected to commission on schedule with benefits from Q1 FY24.
Product Mix & Channel Shift
- B2B surge reshaped the mix: B2B sales jumped to 51% of volumes from 41% YoY and 45% QoQ because B2C demand remained soft. B2B buys more OPC, pushing OPC share to 47% (blended 53%), an adverse shift that increased per-ton fuel cost and pressured realizations since B2B pricing is lower.
- B2B margins are structurally thinner: B2C sales have traditionally given higher contributions because PPC production cost is somewhat lower and prices remain attractive. B2B is largely OPC and prices get negotiated very hard by large buyers, yielding lower margins. Currently, B2B buyers are not getting a discount over B2C prices because the company cannot afford it, but margins still come under pressure due to higher costs.
- Premium brand share dipped: StrongCrete share slipped slightly under 15% from above 15% due to soft B2C sentiment. A recovery in B2C demand would restore the traditional B2B/B2C proportion, show benefit in operating costs, and lift StrongCrete share.
- Geographic mix tilted West: West markets performed better, contributing 56% of Q3 volumes. Railway dispatch share rose to 16% from 15% QoQ as the company optimized the road-rail mix to manage busy-season surcharges, though it remained lower YoY because the company chooses not to sell in markets that become unattractive net of freight costs.
Khetrapal: "We do continue our philosophy of trying to basically go for recovering the price for our cement, which is justified by the quality that we give to the market. And any orders which do not meet our threshold of contribution per ton, we're happy to say no to and walk away from the business."
Profitability & Balance Sheet
- EBITDA rebounded sequentially but remains weak: Q3 EBITDA was ₹91 crores, 25% lower YoY, though a large sequential rise from Q2's ₹37 crores. Per-ton EBITDA was only ~₹640, which management explicitly said is "not a good level to be."
- Working capital stretched by B2B shift: Working capital borrowing increased because B2B sales carry longer credit periods. Total debt stood at ₹403 crores (interest-bearing ₹365 crores), with term loan repayments of ₹37 crores in Q3 and ₹111 crores YTD.
- FY24 EBITDA per ton target set at ₹1,000: Management believes ₹1,000 per ton is a "fairly achievable expectation" for FY24 given the demand momentum, though this depends on cost regime improvement and some pricing recovery.
Khetrapal: "It looks a huge rise, but quite honestly, we are not proud of that huge rise because on a per ton basis, we are still just about INR 640 a ton, which is not a good level to be, but let's see."
Expansion & Capex
- FY23 capex slashed: Full-year capex was limited to ~₹150 crores against an earlier estimate of over ₹800 crores, because the company did not start large investments in the grinding unit and Line-4 as previously planned.
- Expansion plans under reassessment: Management has started relooking at expansion plans. At the Telangana Devapur plant, it wants to put up a Line IV, with some investments needed for clearing activities. There is no immediate panic on capacity constraints.
- Capex decision is demand-contingent: If demand sustains, the company will push the pedal on capex. From the time of pressing the pedal, commissioning would take 15 to 18 months. FY24 capex guidance will be provided only with full-year results in April.
- Rajasthan project progressing slowly: The mining lease has come back, and the company has started identifying and buying key land (initial ~100 acres needed out of ~1,500 acres) to submit the geolocation of the proposed plant to the Ministry of Environment and Forests. The project remains a minimum three-year timeline.
Khetrapal: "As a company, the size that I am in, I really don't have much option to determine the price and sell my volume that I need to sell."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 full-year sales volume | ~0.58 crore tons (vs original 0.6 crore ambition) | FY23 |
| Q4 FY23 volumes | Working toward 0.17–0.18 crore tons | Q4 FY23 |
| Petcoke cost softening benefit | Benefits from lower global petcoke prices flow to P&L | From June 2023 onward |
| Waste heat recovery plant | Chittapur ~10 MW WHR plant benefits visible | From Q1 FY24 |
| FY24 EBITDA per ton | ₹1,000 per ton described as "fairly achievable" | FY24 |
| Rajasthan project | Minimum three-year project from current stage | Not before FY26 |
| Capex commissioning post-decision | 15–18 months from the time of pressing the pedal on capex | 15–18 months after decision |
| FY24 capex guidance | Granular picture to be provided | April 2023 (full-year results) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total sold volumes | 14.30 lakh tons, ~17% YoY and ~QoQ |
| Capacity utilization | Higher than 70% |
| Net sales growth | 19% YoY and QoQ (in ₹ crores) |
| Realization per ton | A little over ₹5,100, 1% YoY and 3% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹91 crores, ~25% lower YoY; Q2 was just over ₹37 crores |
| EBITDA per ton | ~₹640 |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | ₹1,578, 35% higher YoY; 4% lower QoQ |
| Blended fuel cost per million Kcal | Well below ₹2,200, nearly 40% higher YoY |
| Total cost | Nearly 5% lower sequentially over Q2 |
| B2B sales share | 51% vs 41% in Q3 last year and 45% in Q2 |
| OPC share in sales mix | 47% OPC, 53% blended cement |
| West markets volume share | 56% |
| StrongCrete premium brand share | Slightly under 15% vs previously over 15% |
| AFR volumetric share | 17%, quarterly cost benefit of ~₹10 crores |
| Total renewable power consumed | 18% |
| Railway component of dispatches | 16% vs 15% in Q2, lower than last year |
| Total debt | ₹403 crores, including working capital; interest-bearing debt ₹365 crores |
| FY23 capex | Limited to just about ₹150 crores (earlier estimate above ₹800 crores) |
| Full-year FY23 volume expectation | ~0.58 crore tons (within 3% of original 0.6 crore ton ambition) |
| Q4 FY23 volume expectation | In the region of 0.17 crore to 0.18 crore tons |
| 9-month FY23 EBITDA per ton | Close to ₹560 |
| WHRS expected annual saving | Around ₹30 crores a year, cost ~₹100 crores, payback of three years |
| Lead distance | A little over 300 kilometres, no major difference from previous quarter |