Key Takeaways
- Volume degrew 3% YoY as elections, festivals and a Maratha agitation hit dispatches, but YTD growth of 9% stayed in line with industry.
- Realization rose despite volume drop, lifted by premium brands and a temporary Q3 price uptick, though the price benefit dissipated by quarter-end.
- Waste heat recovery delivered ahead of promise: Phase-I commissioned and generating over ₹4 crores per month, with the balance 20% due soon.
- B2C demand is the real worry: Telangana B2C volumes collapsed 29% as top brands cut prices ₹20/bag below Orient's, and rural/semi-urban consumer sentiment stayed soft across markets.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether B2C demand picks up post-elections, the pace of the Chittapur and Devapur environmental clearances now that public hearings are set, and whether the OPC-heavy mix begins to reverse.
Volume & Demand: What Broke and What Might Fix It
- Election disruption, but not only that: Telangana and Madhya Pradesh elections caused labor slowdowns, while the Maratha agitation brought cement/concrete bans in Mumbai and Pune. Management flagged that consumer demand, especially rural and semi-urban, has been soft across industries, not just in poll-bound states.
- Telangana B2C collapse: B2C volumes in Telangana fell 29% as administrative uncertainty followed a change of government. Top brands sold at roughly ₹20 per bag below Orient's Birla A1 price, but management held its pricing line and lost volume rather than chase.
- B2B filled the gap, at a cost: B2B share rose to 56% of volumes, driven by infra demand in Maharashtra. That pulled the product mix to 50% OPC, which uses more clinker and raises power and fuel cost per ton. Management wants this trend to reverse but does not expect it in the current quarter.
- January momentum missing: Demand stayed slow from December into January, with pricing stuck at December exit levels. Management sees the post-election environment as the reset: if a strong central government forms without dislocation, 10-11% industry growth is a given, and Orient could do somewhat better than the national average.
- Lead distances stretched: Loss of Telangana volumes forced sales to farther markets, pushing average lead distances up by roughly 10-11 km.
Khetrapal: "We are surprised as to how many players in Telangana are beginning to offer prices which quite frankly surprised us... some of the top most brands who've enjoyed premium for a long, long time in the markets because of the brand equity... we have seen them selling not just quoting, selling at about Rs.20 less per bag than our price of Birla A1 cement."
Realization & Mix: Premium Held, But the Base Shifted
- Blended realization improved: Revenue rose 3% YoY and 4% QoQ even as volumes fell, driven by premium cements (StrongCrete, Orient Green, Dolphin) and a temporary price pickup that lasted 5-6 weeks before dissipating.
- OPC-heavy mix is adverse: OPC reached 50% of product mix because B2B infra demand favors OPC over PPC. This raises clinker consumption and power/fuel cost per ton versus peers running 80% PPC. Management's ideal mix is roughly 60% B2C and 40% or under B2B.
- Premium strategy unchanged: Management will not compromise on price or sell cheap to buy volume. The plan is to go slow and steady on premium brands, charging what the product deserves and relying on word of mouth. The 25% premium share target by FY'25 was always going to be difficult; without a Telangana B2C recovery, it is a challenge.
Khetrapal: "We will go slow, but go steady and keep charging the price that we believe our product actually deserves."
Costs: Power & Fuel Relief, Freight Pressure
- Power and fuel costs fell sharply: Down ₹157/ton YoY and ₹87/ton QoQ, helped by softening fuel prices, AFR usage at 25% volumetric (17% TSR), and the new waste heat recovery system. However, the 50% OPC mix pushes per-ton fuel costs higher than a PPC-heavy mix would.
- Waste heat recovery outperforming: Phase-I (80% of capacity) commissioned during the quarter and is generating over ₹4 crores per month, above vendor guarantees. The benefit worked out to ₹56/ton for the quarter despite not running a full quarter or at full capacity. From next quarter, management expects roughly ₹5 crores per month, or close to ₹100/ton on 5-5.5 lakh tons of volume.
- Freight costs rose: Up 4.5% YoY and 8% QoQ. Three drivers: loss of Telangana volumes forced sales to farther markets; higher bulker usage (40% of volumes) for B2B projects in Mumbai and Pune; and withdrawal of the railway lean season discount.
- Operational efficiency remains a strength: Blended power consumption at 63 units and heat consumption at 687 kcal/kg clinker are among the best in the industry, even with 50% OPC.
- Renewables scaling: 50% of Jalgaon grinding unit power now comes from solar; 25% of total power is from renewables including waste heat recovery. Further solar investments at Jalgaon and Chittapur should be available in roughly a quarter and a half, delivering more savings.
Khetrapal: "What has been completed is doing well. We are quite sure that, even the pre-heater section when it's completed and commissioned soon, we will keep getting this significant benefit that we have told the shareholders, but the benefit is proving to be a little higher than what we had perhaps conveyed to all the analysts and shareholders."
Expansion Pipeline: Clearances in Motion, Bandwidth a Constraint
- Chittapur expansion: Public hearing scheduled for 17th February for both production capacity and mining environment clearance. Management wants to complete Chittapur for sure between FY'25 and FY'26.
- Devapur line-IV: Public hearing for mines scheduled for 15th February. The Sarni grinding unit in Madhya Pradesh will support this line.
- Sarni grinding unit (MP): Conditional approval received from the Madhya Pradesh state electricity generating company, which will provide land, use of railway siding, and fly ash at competitive cost. Management is still negotiating on the landed cost of fly ash and colony space; the deal is close to being signed. Bulk of the unit to be completed between FY'25 and FY'26.
- Rajasthan mining lease: A valid signed lease deed is now obtained, allowing land acquisition to begin. Construction activity is not expected for at least three years; the near-term investment is roughly ₹100 crores for land acquisition, an 18-21 month process.
- Bandwidth acknowledged as a constraint: Management candidly stated that picking up two clinker lines at the same time may test the company's bandwidth given its size. The sequencing plan: Chittapur now, Sarni grinding unit in parallel, Devapur line-IV sometime in the middle.
- Forest clearance anxiety: The file is moving through Telangana forest departments and should be ready to move to the center fairly soon. Management's biggest anxiety is that central elections may be announced in about a month, potentially causing another 2-3 months of delay.
Khetrapal: "Honestly. I personally think that picking up two clinker line at the same time may test our bandwidth. That's a very honest acknowledgment of our size of the Company."
Capital Allocation: Funding Plan Taking Shape
- CAPEX plan still being finalized: Management declined to provide FY'24 and FY'25 CAPEX figures, asking for a few weeks to prepare its own plan now that clarity on public hearings is emerging. The exact split between FY'25 and FY'26 depends on when environment clearance is in hand.
- Debt funding approach: For the roughly ₹2,000 crore CAPEX program, management wants to largely use internally generated cash flows. Debt in the next two years is expected to be perhaps roughly ₹1,200 crores.
- Q4 volume target: Management expects to comfortably do roughly 1.8 mt in Q4, and is trying to do more, ending FY'24 at roughly 6.2 mt.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 FY'24 volumes | Comfortably do ~1.8 mt, trying for more; FY'24 exit at ~6.2 mt | Q4 FY'24 |
| Waste heat recovery benefit | ~₹5 crores per month, close to ₹100/ton on 5-5.5 lakh tons | From next quarter |
| Renewable power additions | Further solar investments at Jalgaon and Chittapur delivering savings | ~1.5 quarters |
| Chittapur expansion completion | Complete for sure between FY'25 and FY'26 | FY'25-FY'26 |
| Sarni grinding unit completion | Bulk completed between FY'25 and FY'26 | FY'25-FY'26 |
| Rajasthan construction start | Not for at least three years; land acquisition first (~₹100 crores, 18-21 months) | 3+ years |
| Forest clearance | File moving; anxiety that central election announcement may cause 2-3 months delay | Conditional on election timing |
| Post-election demand | If strong central government without dislocation, 10-11% industry growth; Orient may do somewhat better | Post-general election |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹2,292 cr YTD net sales, +11% YoY |
| Realization per ton | ₹5,400, +5% YoY and +7% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹117 cr, +28% YoY; YTD ₹309 cr, +33% YoY |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹840, up ~₹200 YoY and ~₹220 QoQ |
| Operating margin | 21.7% (per an analyst's math) |
| Volumes | 13.92 lakh tons, -3% YoY and -2% QoQ |
| YTD volumes | 44 lakh tons, +9% YoY |
| B2B sales share | 56% of total volumes |
| OPC share in product mix | 50% of total volumes |
| Premium brands share | 21%-22% range |
| B2C volumes in Telangana | -29% YoY |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | Down ₹157 YoY and down ₹87 QoQ |
| Freight cost per ton | +4.5% YoY and +8% QoQ |
| AFR in fuel mix (TSR basis) | 17% |
| Renewable power share | 25% of total power consumption |
| Total borrowings | ~₹150 cr (including working capital) |
| Expansion CAPEX guidance (FY25-FY26) | ~₹2,000 cr for Chittapur and Sarni |