Key Takeaways
- Volume push without price damage: Q4 volumes grew 20% QoQ while price slipped only 0.5%, a combination management called highly significant.
- Mix shift masks true demand: Trade (B2C) de-grew 9% while B2B surged 29%, pushing OPC share to ~43% and clinker utilization to 98%. Management calls the B2C weakness transitory.
- Cost pressure easing, margin recovering: Q4 EBITDA of ~INR840/ton rebounded 31% QoQ, only 7% below Q4 FY22, as fuel cost inflation moderated to 19% YoY from 30–35% earlier.
- Chittapur expansion now urgent: The single kiln ran at >100% clinker utilization for the full year; a new kiln line is targeted to start construction in Q3 FY24, with total capex of INR1,550–1,600 crores.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether B2C demand returns as management expects, the pace of fuel cost declines flowing through the P&L, and progress on environmental clearances for the Chittapur expansion.
Volume & Mix Dynamics
- B2B pivot drove the quarter: Trade demand was lower in Orient’s markets and trade prices suffered, so the company pivoted aggressively to B2B, which grew 29% while trade de-grew 9%.
- OPC share spike strains capacity: B2B sales are predominantly OPC, pushing Q4 OPC share to ~43%. Cement industry nameplate capacity assumes a 65% PPC / 35% OPC mix; when OPC exceeds 35%, no company can produce at boilerplate capacity, so effective cement output drops.
- Chittapur running beyond limits: Clinker utilization hit 98% in Q4 and >100% for the full year at Chittapur, which has a single kiln with no redundancy. The kiln ran 23 months continuously before its April shutdown, versus an industry norm of 9 months.
- Western India exposure rose: OPC volumes rose dramatically because exposure to Mumbai and Pune increased, where large housing projects are B2B sales using OPC. Tier 3/4/5 town housing would typically be B2C and PPC.
- Premium products held up: Strong Crete grew 17% YoY despite the company increasing its premium gap from INR35 to INR45 over PPC; combined premium growth was 22% including newly launched Orient Green.
- Jalgaon under pressure: The grinding unit faces the most acute competition because two competitors have set up grinding units in the same market and are selling cement cheaper even after incurring INR800/ton transport cost. Orient typically avoids OPC sales from split grinding units there because margins are negligible.
Khetrapal: "My own assumption is that these blips of suddenly B2B demand becoming so much higher and B2C going down so low, these are transitory phase. I'd personally do not think this'll sustain."
Costs & Margins
- Full-year cost hit was severe: Total cost rose ~INR570/ton for FY23, driven by power and fuel (INR467) and logistics (INR66). Q4 costs fell 5% QoQ but were still up 7% YoY.
- Fuel cost trend improving: Q4 blended fuel cost was INR2,110/ton (full year INR2,230 vs INR1,486 last year). Q4 power and fuel cost of INR1,570/ton saw YoY inflation moderate to 19% from 30–35% in earlier quarters. Petcoke prices are softening.
- Alternative fuel savings material: Full-year savings exceeded INR40 crores from alternate fuels, with focus shifting to lower-cost options like RDF, MSW and hazardous waste. Rice husk availability was impacted by Telangana government paddy procurement issues.
- Renewable power growing: Savings exceeded INR10 crores from renewable power, with renewable share reaching 15% for the year. Telangana policies remain unfriendly for buying renewable power via open access at Devapur.
- Heat consumption controlled: Total heat consumption stayed under 690 kcal/kg clinker despite a challenging year.
- Employee cost dip was one-off: Q4 employee costs were lower because of year-end provision reversals for variable costs and bonuses, plus in-house talent development saving on senior-level salaries. Management did not provide a normalized quarterly run-rate.
- April will look softer: Maintenance shutdown costs are bunched in April and booked on the P&L, plus clinker had to be shipped from Devapur to Chittapur at ~INR800/ton transport cost during the kiln shutdown. The impact normalizes over the full year.
Khetrapal: "Price is barely 0.5% below the preceding quarter, and with that we have 20% growth. I just want to highlight how important and how significant this is."
Capacity Expansion Pipeline
- Chittapur is the top priority: Management described the new kiln and grinding capacity at Chittapur as an "absolute desperate need." The single kiln is at >100% clinker utilization, and new competitor capacities that came up around Chittapur since 2015 are already absorbed.
- Chittapur timeline and cost: Total capex estimated at INR1,550–1,600 crores. Physical on-site work targeted to start in Q3 FY24, pending environmental clearances for plant and mines, which are expected within the next six months. Construction time is 15–18 months from start.
- Tiroda replacement in progress: The Tiroda grinding unit project was cancelled. The company has zeroed in on one alternative site in Madhya Pradesh near a power plant and is under negotiations. It hopes to freeze the site and have land in-hand within six months, with minimal capex cash outflow in FY24.
- Devapur expansion to follow: Work on Devapur expansion will run in parallel once construction starts on the Madhya Pradesh grinding unit, likely sometime in FY26. Forest clearance for Devapur mines has been applied for; Stage One clearance is expected within this year.
- Rajasthan is the long game: Land acquisition is expected to take about two years, with clearances to start alongside. Management is realistic about the timeline, acknowledging the difficulty of land acquisition.
- FY24 capex target reset: After spending only ~INR130 crores in FY23, the company targets INR1,000–1,050 crores in FY24 to keep growth plans on-track and not lose market share. This includes ~INR600 crores for Chittapur, INR130–150 crores for Devapur forest clearance deposits, and INR100-odd crores for Rajasthan land.
Khetrapal: "It is the last simply, because you know how difficult land acquisition is. So, because of that, I'm not getting over ambitious that I'll be able to get the land within a year and start construction, it's unlikely to happen, you know it, I know it. Even if I say, you won't believe it."
Balance Sheet & Funding
- Working capital stretched temporarily: Working capital was stretched at March-end due to stockpiling ~75,000 tons of clinker at Chittapur ahead of the planned April kiln shutdown. Inventory was liquidated by 20th April, with clinker stock down to 2,000 tons.
- Karnataka incentives received: The company received INR57 crores as a 10-year interest-free soft loan from the Karnataka government, with repayment due after 10 years.
- Debt capacity and limits: If the company spends INR600 crores on capex, it may borrow INR600–700 crores, using own cash flow as much as possible. The board mandate caps debt-to-equity at 1.5x and debt-to-EBITDA between 3x and 3.5x.
- Equity may be needed: If Chittapur, Devapur and Rajasthan projects overlap, the current balance sheet cannot sustain the load. Management indicated it may bring in equity to create room to leverage.
- Fuel cost lag: Softening energy prices will hit the P&L with a lag. Lower-priced petcoke was booked at 13% lower, but there is risk of further price decline before consumption.
Operational Milestones
- Waste heat recovery near completion: Construction at Chittapur is over; the kiln was connected during the April shutdown. ~80% of expected power is expected by late May/June, with the balance 20% by July/August.
- Rake handling system ready: The system is up and the first rake has been brought in and is normalizing. Rail dispatch fell to 16% in Q4 from 25% last year due to non-availability of rakes, re-imposition of peak period surcharge, and penal wharfage charges.
- Solar SPV approved: The board approved investment in an SPV to add ~21.5 MW DC solar power at Jalgaon and Chittapur.
- Plastic-positive status achieved: The company now burns more plastic than it consumes in packaging and processes, adding to its existing water-positive status.
Khetrapal: "We perhaps are setting some kind of, I would say, world records in our ability to keep running kilns without having to take maintenance shutdowns."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY24 volume | 0.63–0.65 crore tons (0.63-0.65 crore tons) vs ~0.58 crore tons in FY23 | FY24 full year |
| Renewable power share | Over 35% | By FY25 |
| Chittapur WHR power | 80% of expected power from WHR | Late May/June 2023 |
| Chittapur WHR balance | Remaining 20% of expected power | July/August 2023 |
| Chittapur expansion construction start | Physical on-site work begins, pending environmental clearances | Q3 FY24 |
| Chittapur expansion capex spend | ~INR600 crores within FY24 | FY24 |
| Devapur forest clearance deposit | INR130–150 crores deposited with Forest Department | FY24 |
| Rajasthan land acquisition spend | INR100-odd crores | FY24 |
| Total FY24 capex | INR1,000–1,050 crores | FY24 |
| MP grinding unit site freeze | Exact site finalized and land in-hand | Within six months |
| Devapur Stage One forest clearance | Clearance received | Within this year |
| Debt ceiling | Debt-to-equity max 1.5x; debt-to-EBITDA 3x–3.5x | Ongoing board mandate |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Volumes | 17.2 lakh tons, +6% YoY and +20% QoQ |
| Full-year volumes | ~58 lakh tons, +5% YoY |
| Realisations | +3% YoY; QoQ barely 0.5% below preceding quarter |
| EBITDA per ton | Close to ₹840, +31% QoQ, -12% YoY from ₹958 |
| EBITDA | -7% YoY vs Q4 FY22; +58% QoQ vs Q3 |
| Total cost of operations | -5% QoQ, +7% YoY |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | ₹1,570, YoY increase under 19% (full year +41%) |
| Blended fuel cost (per kcal) | ₹2,110; full year ₹2,230 vs ₹1,486 last year |
| Trade sales mix (B2C) | 51% vs 61% in Q4 last year and 61% in Q3 |
| OPC proportion | ~43%, driving clinker utilization to 98% |
| Clinker capacity utilization | 98% in Q4 (cement-level ~80%); full year 78% |
| Premium cement volume growth | +22% YoY (Strong Crete +17%, combined with Orient Green) |
| Western India exposure | 61% of volumes (Maharashtra + Gujarat), up from 53% last year |
| Railway dispatch share | 16% of volumes vs 25% in Q4 last year |
| Renewable power share | 15% for full year; target over 35% by FY25 |
| Project debt | ~₹240 crores, after repaying ₹148 crores during the year |
| FY24 volume target | 0.63–0.65 crore tons (from ~0.58 crore tons in FY23) |