Key Takeaways
- Edible oil hedge divergence crushed revenue, but the worst is past: Revenue fell 8.13% YoY as unprecedented divergence between futures hedges and local physical prices persisted through August. The divergence has since narrowed sharply, and management expects edible oil to recover to profitability in H2.
- Food & FMCG is now the margin engine: The segment contributed 31.8% of revenue, up 666 bps QoQ, with biscuits growing 20.37% YoY and Nutrela TSP hitting a record quarter. This shift is structural, not seasonal, and is pulling blended EBITDA to 5.34% from 2.41% a year ago.
- Nutraceuticals collapsed, and the fix is still in progress: Revenue plunged from ₹62.47 crores to ₹14.53 crores QoQ with negative 21% EBITDA. Management is refining the product range and leaning into e-commerce, but a turnaround is not yet priced in.
- The 10% blended EBITDA ambition is a five-year story: Management set a long-term target of double-digit blended margins, built on FMCG premiumization, edible oil normalization, and palm plantation annuity income. Near-term FMCG margins are guided at 16–18%.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether edible oil EBITDA turns positive as guided, whether nutraceuticals stabilize toward the ₹150–200 crore full-year target, and whether the FMCG margin holds near 16–18% after the festival-season staples surge fades.
The Edible Oil Hedge Shock
- Unprecedented divergence drove losses: Hedging on BMD (Kuala Lumpur) and CBOT (Chicago) failed to track local Indian physical market prices, producing a negative EBITDA of ₹-27 crores in Q2. The phenomenon was described as "truly exceptional and unprecedented."
- Divergence narrowed sharply through the quarter: Palm oil divergence fell from 19% in Q1 to ~3% in Q2; soya oil from 25% to 8%. The misalignment persisted until August, so the full benefit of normalization flows into H2.
- Risk management tightened: Hedge ratio was cut from 38% in June to 25% by September, contra-positions were taken on global exchanges, and physical positions were replaced with lower-rate purchases.
- Volume held up despite price headwinds: Edible oil volume grew 3% in Q2 and 11% in H1, even as falling prices drove the 8.13% YoY revenue decline. Branded sales stayed above 75% of total value.
- H2 recovery is a conviction call: Management expects edible oil to be "EBITDA neutral or more positive" in Q3 and Q4, with revenue of ₹10,000–11,000 crores per quarter and margins of 2–4%. The uptick in physical market prices and El Nino supply constraints support the view.
Asthana: "This phenomenon is truly exceptional and unprecedented in the world of hedge business. In risk management, it is indeed rare and extraordinary for us to proactively mitigate our exposure only to witness an unfavorable outcome."
Food & FMCG: The Structural Margin Shift
- Segment share jumped on festival and wedding demand: Food & FMCG reached 31.8% of revenue, a 666 bps QoQ increase, driven by staples pickup during the festive and wedding season. Staples carry lower margins, so the mix effect tempers the headline margin story.
- Biscuits delivered volume-led growth of 20.37% YoY: Doodh Biscuits grew 28% and Nariyal biscuits 68%, backed by distribution expansion to ~0.1 crore outlets. Margins benefited from lower input costs on edible oils, sugar, and wheat.
- Nutrela TSP hit a record: Highest-ever quarterly sales of 8,918 MT, up 11% YoY, signaling sustained demand for the brand's core protein portfolio.
- FMCG margin guidance of 16–18% is achievable on a normalized basis: The Q2 margin fell below that range because of the staples surge and nutraceutical losses. Excluding those two factors, management says margins would be in the 16–18% band.
- Premiumization is the next leg: Management plans to expand the margin construct by adding newer, more premium categories, with more launches promised in coming months.
Asthana: "The core loyal base of customers who typically would comprise about between 75% to 80% would tend to stay with the brand and the 20% who are switching between the brands owing to various reasons... would tend to switch."
Nutraceuticals: A Sharp Setback
- Revenue collapsed to ₹14.53 crores from ₹62.47 crores QoQ: The segment swung to negative 21% EBITDA, a sharp reversal that management attributed to the need for product range refinement and distribution rework.
- Channel mix is shifting to e-commerce: 31% of sales now come through e-commerce channels, with the balance through AK/CK channels (mega stores, arogya kendras, chikitsa kendras).
- Full-year target implies a steep H2 recovery: Management expects to end the year between ₹150 crores and ₹200 crores in revenue and to correct the negative P&L, which requires a significant ramp from the current run-rate.
Palm Plantation: The Quiet Annuity
- Consistent revenue with 17% margin even in a low season: Q2 revenue was ₹315 crores, described as annuity-like income. The plantation segment is a steady contributor that grows predictably.
- Expansion is accelerating: 4,500+ acres developed, 15 lakh seed sprouts imported, 8 nurseries across 5 states, and a new MoA with Andhra Pradesh for 13 mandals across 3 districts. Nearly 75 farmer producer organizations have been set up.
- The big inflection is four years out: Sequential growth of 10–12% YoY continues, but a substantial peak arrives when new plantations mature. From next year, a "huge uptick" begins due to the 15-month gestation cycle.
Asthana: "A big uptick will happen probably in 4 years' time. But sequential growth of 10% to 12% year on year will continue."
New Categories & Distribution
- Dry fruits launched under Nutrela on e-commerce: Less than four weeks live at the time of the call. All 5,000+ Patanjali stores will carry dry fruits within weeks, followed by modern trade and general trade. Flavors, spice variants, and dates will be added by year-end or early next quarter.
- M.S. Dhoni signed as brand ambassador: The association covers Mahakosh and Sunrich brands, signaling an advertising ramp-up at both ATL and BTL levels.
- Sports nutrition and millets expanded: New packaging and flavors launched in sports nutrition; Nutrela MaxxMillets and Ragi Choko entered West Bengal after a southern debut; Nutrela Maxx Nuts went nationwide via e-commerce.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Edible oil revenue recovery | ₹10,000–11,000 crores per quarter | Q3 and Q4 FY24 |
| Edible oil EBITDA margin | 2% to 4% | Q3 and Q4 FY24 |
| Edible oil profitability | Recover losses, post positive EBITDA | Next 2 quarters |
| FMCG revenue growth | ~15% plus | Ongoing |
| FMCG EBITDA margin (normalized) | 16% to 18% | Ongoing |
| Nutraceuticals full-year revenue | ₹150–200 crores with corrected P&L | FY24 |
| Palm plantation sequential growth | 10–12% YoY | Ongoing |
| Blended EBITDA margin | Closer to 10% | Over next 5 years |
| Dry fruits store rollout | All 5,000+ stores carrying dry fruits | Next few weeks |
| Dry fruits product expansion | Flavors, spice variants, dates added | By year-end or early next quarter |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹7,821.9 cr, +0.71% QoQ, -8.13% YoY |
| Total income | ₹7,845.8 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹419.20 cr, +97.75% QoQ |
| EBITDA margin | 5.34%, vs 2.7% in Q1 FY24 and 2.41% in Q2 FY23 |
| PAT | ₹254.54 cr, vs ₹112.29 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| PAT margin | 3.24%, vs 1.12% in Q1 FY24 and 1.32% in Q2 FY23 |
| Food & FMCG segment revenue share | 31.8% of revenue from operations, +666 bps QoQ |
| Food & FMCG segment EBITDA margin | 15.25% for Q2 FY24, 16.67% for H1 FY24 |
| Edible oil segment revenue | ₹5,421 cr, sequential degrowth due to falling prices |
| Edible oil segment EBITDA | ₹-27 cr, vs ₹-435 cr in Q2 FY23 and ₹97.8 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| Edible oil volume growth | +3% in Q2 FY24, +11% YoY in H1 FY24 |
| Premium oil segment growth | +49% YoY |
| Branded sales share | Over 75% of total sales value |
| Biscuits portfolio growth | +20.37% YoY in Q2 FY24 |
| Nutrela TSP quarterly sales | 8,918 metric tons, +11% YoY, highest-ever quarterly sales |
| Retail outlet expansion | 3.06 lakh retail points, +9% QoQ |
| Hedge ratio | ~25% by end of September, decreased from 38% at end of June |
| Palm plantation revenue (Q2, low season) | ₹315 cr, EBITDA ₹52 cr, margin 17% |
| Palm plantation area developed in quarter | Over 4,500 acres |
| Exports | ₹41.65 cr to 23 countries |