Permanent Magnets Ltd Guidance Report - SOIC x StockScans Report
as of Oct 2026
- Quantum Magnetics - 5,000 tons capacity, ₹3,700 cr revenue by FY30
Pending - At the Q2 FY26 call, management outlined a Quantum Magnetics plan of 5,000 tons production and about ₹3,700 cr revenue till FY 2030, with total investment of ₹550-750 cr implemented step by step; Q4 FY26 reframed this as ₹3,000-4,000 cr of realized value possibly by '30, '31, and the FY26 annual report as 5,000 tons of integrated NdFeB magnet capacity by FY31. Phase 2 was commissioned in October 2026 with PLI approval under the ECMS scheme covering ₹400 cr of capex, but no revenue from the rare earth business yet and the Phase 3 decision pending Phase 2 success.
- FY27 capex - ₹40-50 cr PML + ₹40-50 cr Quantum
Pending - At the Q4 FY26 call, management guided FY27 capex of "between INR 40 crores to INR 50 crores for PML itself and another INR 40 crores to INR 50 crores" planned in Quantum. CWIP rose from ₹8.08 cr in FY26 to ₹26.83 cr on a TTM basis, with capex ongoing for relays and alloys; no specific disclosure of FY27 spend against the plan is in our record.
- FY27 EBITDA margin - 15-18% (later 20-25%)
On track - At the Q4 FY26 call, management guided FY27 EBITDA margins at "roughly that level, 15% to 18%", revised at the Q2 FY27 call to 20-25%. H1 FY27 EBITDA margin was 25%, with Q2 FY27 also at 25%, tracking at the top of the revised 20-25% range.
- FY27 revenue growth - 20-30%
On track - At the Q2 FY26 call, management guided FY27 revenue growth of 20% to 30%, reiterated at Q4 FY26 ("maybe 20% to 30%", possibly "a little higher") and again at Q2 FY27 driven by EV pickup despite the relay delay. H1 FY27 revenue of Q1 ₹63.23 cr (+18.08% YoY) and Q2 ₹72.46 cr (+47.49% YoY) totals \~₹135.7 cr against H1 FY26 \~₹102.7 cr, \~32% growth, above the guided range.
- Alloys - FY27 revenue ₹40-70 cr (later ₹40-50 cr)
On track - At the Q2 FY26 call, management guided FY27 alloy revenue of ₹40-70 cr; Q4 FY26 raised this to "maybe about 3 to 4 times" last year, before Q2 FY27 lowered it materially to ₹40-50 cr. H1 FY27 alloys revenue was \~₹12 cr with the full year expected at ₹40-50 cr, and delayed alloy orders pushed back rather than cancelled, the order situation "still healthy".
- Alloys - FY26 revenue ₹20-30 cr
Delivered - At the Q4 FY25 call, management gave an FY26 alloys revenue expectation of "somewhere between INR 20 crores to INR 30 crores maybe". FY26 alloy mix was 10% of ₹225 cr, about ₹22.5 cr, within the guided range.
- Alloys - new furnace by December 2025
Delivered - At the Q4 FY25 call, management said a new furnace would be added "by this December" to expand capacity, reiterated at the Q2 FY26 call as installed by December 2025. The furnace was installed in January 2026 and commercialized in Q4 FY26, one month behind the target.
- Relays - commercial sales from H2 FY26, meaningful traction in FY26
Missed - At the Q4 FY25 call, management expected relay manufacturing to commence "in the second half of financial year 2026 at a new facility" with "meaningful traction in this product line in 2026". Revisions pushed commercial ramp-up from Q4 FY26 trials to H2 FY27 pilots and then FY28; the facility is "almost ready" with customer approvals near "the end stage", but no commercial sales or off-take agreements exist, and management acknowledged "We were expecting the Relay to start much earlier. That did not happen".
- FY26 EBITDA margin - 16-18%
Delivered - At the Q2 FY26 call, management guided FY26 EBITDA margin at 16% to 18%, an upgrade from the Q4 FY25 view of "about similar level" \~14-15%. FY26 standalone EBITDA margin was 17% and consolidated 16%, within the guided range.
- FY26 revenue growth - around 20% (later \~15%, ₹220-230 cr)
Delivered - At the Q4 FY25 call, management guided FY26 top-line growth of "around 20% growth plus/minus something" while cautioning growth is "lumpy", lowered at Q2 FY26 to about 15% and roughly ₹220-230 cr. FY26 standalone revenue from operations was ₹225.46 cr, +13% YoY, within the ₹220-230 cr range though slightly below the revised \~15%.
- Quantum Magnetics phase 2 - implementation within 6 months to 1 year
Partial - At the Q2 FY25 call, management guided Phase-2 implementation "within next... six months to one year", explicitly "my judgment today". Revisions moved go-live to around FY '26-'27 and then Q3-Q4 of FY27; Phase 2 capex (block cutting, machining, surface treatment) was commissioned in October 2026, about a year past the original deadline, with product approval expected to start soon.
- Alloy plant capacity - 150,000-200,000 kgs within FY25
Partial - At the Q4 FY24 call, management guided alloy plant capacity to reach "maybe 150,000 to maybe 200,000 kgs" "within this year" (FY25) after improvements, from roughly 100,000 kgs at the time. Revisions promised a furnace "by this December" making capacity "almost 6-7 times" current levels, then 750 tons annual post-furnace; the furnace was installed January 2026 and commercialized in Q4 FY26, so the FY25 target was missed and expansion completed a year late at 750 tons, exceeding the original figure.
- Alloys business - ₹15-30 cr revenue in FY25
Missed - At the Q4 FY24 call, management guided alloys top line of "maybe INR15 crores to maybe INR30 crores" in FY25 depending on scaling speed. FY25 offtake was "slower than our anticipation" with alloy mix only 3% of ₹205 cr, about ₹6 cr; the target rolled into FY26 (\~₹22.5 cr, 10% of ₹225 cr) and then FY27, where H1 revenue was \~₹12 cr and full-year guidance was lowered to ₹40-50 cr.
- Quantum Magnetics phase 1 revenue - ₹7-15 cr in FY25
Missed - At the Q2 FY24 call, management estimated Quantum Magnetics main revenue in FY25 at "about Rs. 7 crore to let's say Rs. 15 crore" with the current investment. Q2 FY25 scaled this back to "very marginally small business", Q2 FY26 set assembly-only turnover at \~₹5-10 cr, and Q2 FY27 doubted even that would be met; actuals were ₹5 cr of assembly orders in FY24, zero rare earth revenue in FY26 due to China's export restrictions, and no revenue yet in FY27.
- Quantum Magnetics facility - operational by end of FY24
Delivered - At the Q2 FY24 call, management said the Quantum Magnetics manufacturing facility was in final stages of commissioning and "expected to be operational by end of financial year 2024", with the Chinchoti facility set to become operational by Feb/Mar 2024. Phase 1 capex was complete, production started at the new facility in FY24 with final customer approvals underway, meeting the end-FY24 deadline.
- ROCE - remain same or improve over 2-3 years
Missed - At the Q4 FY23 call, management expected ROCE to remain the same or possibly improve by picking good-margin projects over the next two-three years. ROCE fell from 20.91% in FY24 to 13.80% in FY25 and 10.80% in FY26, a material decline over the lapsed horizon rather than maintenance or improvement.
- Margins - remain same, no major change
Partial - At the Q4 FY23 call, management expected margins to remain the same given the product mix - "we do not expect a major change in the margins", maybe 1% or 2% here and there. FY24 EBITDA margin came in at 18% versus 23% in FY23 and FY25 at 15%, before recovering to 17% in FY26 and 25% in Q2 FY27, with guidance successively reset to \~14-15%, then 16-18%, then 15-18% and 20-25% for FY27.
- Automotive segment revenue - cross ₹100 cr in 2-3 years
Missed - At the Q4 FY23 call, management expected automotive segment revenue to cross ₹100 cr over the next two-three years: "We are likely to cross 100 Crores". FY24 automotive sales were \~₹60 cr, FY25 automotive \~25% of H1 revenue, and the FY26 application mix shows Automobiles at 23% of ₹225 cr, about ₹52 cr; Q2 FY27 automotive sales were ₹24 cr in the quarter, with no disclosure of annual automotive revenue crossing ₹100 cr in our record.
- New facility - two years from May 2023, no downtime during shift
Partial - At the Q4 FY23 call, management expected the new facility to take about two years from May 2023, with civil construction to begin after land closure expected "in a few months", and no downtime due to shifting. The plan slipped to "maybe 2 to 3 years from here" at Q4 FY25 and to 2 more years from Sep 2026 after land legal delays, with building capex \~₹30 cr and land \~₹25 cr; 8 acres near Vasai have been acquired with 2 pending, legal matters are being resolved, and operations remain in rented premises.
- FY24 revenue growth - 20-25% target
Missed - At the Q4 FY23 call, management guided FY2024 revenue growth of about 20% to 25% "as per visibility today". At Q2 FY24 the target was lowered with EV order push-outs ("75 seems to be a better growth", appearing \~15%, and an expected ₹200-210 cr turnover); FY24 total income reached ₹201.47 cr, +9% YoY, below even the lowered target.