Key Takeaways
- Turnaround quarter after a washout H1: Two quarters were lost to board non-constitution, but Q2 sanctions of ₹1,160 cr and disbursements of ₹1,041 cr restarted the engine, lifting the loan book to ₹7,528 cr.
- Profit doubled sequentially despite a smaller book: Net profit rose from ₹24.98 cr in Q4 to ₹52.86 cr in Q2, helped by a steadily improving interest spread that reached 3.12%.
- The legacy thermal overhang is clearing: Thermal exposure is down to single digits, management targets a zero-thermal company by Q4 or next year, and the credit cost cycle from those assets is over.
- Capital adequacy is a fortress at 31.74%: The ratio jumped from 26.71% in March, giving ample headroom for growth, while cost of funds improved quarter on quarter without fresh borrowing.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹5,000 cr+ pipeline converts fast enough to hit the ~₹8,600 cr March book target, resolution of the ~₹250 cr stress pool, and any signal on the rating outlook upgrade promised by January-end.
The Washout and the Restart
- Two quarters lost: Q1 was nearly a washout because the board was not constituted and there was no clarity on whether it would conduct proper operations; almost two quarters were lost for PFS.
- Loan book shrank first, then recovered: The book declined from ₹8,651 cr at FY22-end to ₹7,165 cr at Q1-end because no incremental sanctions could be done and only ₹19 cr was disbursed. Q2 sanctions of ₹1,160 cr and disbursements of ₹1,041 cr pushed the book back to ₹7,528 cr.
- Prepayments added a drag: The loan book came down a little further because of certain prepayments, including the ₹300+ cr E-Mobility project in UP under Fame II that became operational and was subsequently prepaid.
- Reporting catch-up complete: The company has now completed Q4FY22, Q1 and Q2 FY23 results and is up to date on financial reporting.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "That is almost two quarters for us, was wash out for PFS."
Profitability and Spreads
- NII held up on better spreads: Net interest income for H1 crossed the previous year's six-month number (₹170 cr vs ₹169 cr) despite a decrease in loan book size due to prepayments, because the interest spread improved consistently: 2.92% in March, 2.98% in June, 3.12% in September.
- Sequential profit doubled: Profit rose from ₹24.98 cr in the March quarter to ₹50.56 cr in June, then to ₹52.86 cr in September. H1FY23 net profit stood at ₹103.22 cr vs ₹98.7 cr in the prior year, in spite of the smaller book.
- Cost of funds trending down: Cost of funds has constantly improved quarter on quarter, achieved without taking any fresh borrowing yet. Further improvement is expected in the coming quarter, with a major improvement anticipated when the credit rating increases.
- NPA visibility masked by denominator effect: The reduction in gross NPA is not visible because of the decline in the portfolio; expected business growth did not happen to the extent expected, so the ratio did not compress as it otherwise would have.
Legacy Clean-Up: Thermal and Stress Assets
- Thermal exit in sight: Thermal exposure has been reduced from double-digit to single-digit share of the book. The credit cost cycle from legacy thermal and hydro assets is over, and balance stress thermal assets have a resolution plan.
- Zero-thermal target: Management is hopeful of becoming a zero-thermal company by the end of the fourth quarter or next year.
- Stress account progress: Larger NPA accounts have already been taken care of. The Danu account, which is a stress account but not an NPA, is now receiving payments from APDISCOM and a central government scheme and there is a possibility it could become standard shortly.
- OTS offer in hand: The company has a one-time settlement offer from one borrower and is discussing for a better offer; if it materializes, there would be a reversal. Management is hopeful of resolving stress assets (net of provisions, ~₹250 cr) very soon.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "We are committed to as the globe is moving towards, Net zero... We hope to become a zero of thermal company."
Board Reconstitution and Governance Reset
- New board in place: Three new independent directors have been inducted: an ex-Chairman of a large bank (also ex-ED of a large bank), an ex-Director Finance of India's largest NBFC (PFC), and an ex-Secretary to the Government of India (Department of Public Enterprises).
- Old IDs exited post-forensic audit: Previous independent directors have exited; the new board has come in and old IDs had to go after completion of the forensic audit.
- Forensic audit addressed: The company has addressed every point in the forensic audit. Management noted that the forensic auditor was not clear on a few subjects and assumed possibility and guesswork at many places instead of mentioning facts.
- Process improvement mandate: The board has mandated engagement of a leading consultant to improve processes and provide suggestions on corporate governance.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "Our forensic auditor himself was not clear on few of the subjects and have assumed the possibility and guesswork at lot of places instead of mentioning facts."
Portfolio Composition and Pipeline
- State power utility share rose on denominator effect: Exposure to state power utilities increased from 29% to 38% majorly because the denominator (total book) was drastically reduced; only ~₹300 cr was incremental in absolute terms. Management stated this percentage will decrease by March 23.
- State utility track record is clean: During the last six to seven years, there has not been a single day's delay from state power utility borrowers.
- Pipeline of more than 5000 crores: The highest portion is in transmission (private sector), with more than 500 crores of E-Mobility, plus port, water infrastructure and waste-to-energy.
- Book target by March: Management is confident of covering lost ground by December or maximum by March 23, targeting around ₹8,600 cr.
Capital, Funding and Rating
- Capital adequacy jumped to 31.74%: The ratio rose from 26.71% at March 22-end, giving significant headroom for further growth.
- Rating upgrade path: The company is trying to restore its rating outlook to stable probably by the end of January, then take it up for further upgradation. A major improvement in cost of funds is expected once the credit rating increases.
- Dividend question went unanswered: An analyst asked whether the company would pay even a token dividend (₹1 or ten paisa) to send a strong signal on corporate governance; management did not address the dividend question in their response.
- Consolidation or takeover question also unaddressed: An analyst asked for clarity on whether there will be consolidation or takeover of the company, noting this worries employees; management did not directly address consolidation or takeover in their response.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Loan book target | Reach around ₹8,600 cr | By March 2023 |
| Rating outlook | Restore rating outlook to stable | Probably by end of January 2023 |
| Thermal exit | Become a zero-thermal company | By end of Q4 FY23 or next year |
| State power utility exposure | Percentage of book to decrease | By March 2023 |
| Stress asset resolution | Resolve stress assets net of provisions (~₹250 cr) | "Very soon" (no date) |
| Danu account | Become standard from stress | "Shortly" (no date) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net profit (H1FY23) | ₹103.22 cr, up from ₹98.7 cr in H1FY22 |
| Net profit (Q2 FY23) | ₹52.86 cr, up from ₹50.56 cr in Q1 FY23 and ₹24.98 cr in Q4 FY22 |
| Net interest income (H1FY23) | ₹170 cr, up from ₹169 cr in H1FY22 |
| Yield on earning portfolio | 10.754% |
| Interest spread | 3.12% in Q2, up from 2.98% in Q1 and 2.92% in Q4 FY22 |
| Net interest margin | 4.28% |
| Cost to income ratio | 12.24%, consistent |
| Return on net worth | 9.9% |
| Earnings per share | ₹0.82, up from ₹0.79 in Q1 and ₹0.39 in Q4 FY22 |
| Loan book size | ₹7,528 cr, down from ₹8,651 cr at FY22 end; expected to reach ₹8,600 cr by March 23 |
| Sanctions (H1FY23) | ₹1,160 cr, all in Q2 |
| Disbursements (H1FY23) | ₹1,061 cr, of which ₹1,041 cr in Q2 |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 31.74%, up from 26.71% at March 22; regulatory requirement 15% |
| Liquidity | ₹1,200–1,250 cr as of November, against HQLA requirement of ₹525 cr |
| Gross NPA | Reduction not visible due to portfolio decline; stress asset resolution net of provisions around ₹250 cr |
| Renewable energy exposure | 35% of loan book (₹2,351 cr outstanding), up from 33% in March 22 |
| State power utility exposure | 38% of loan book (₹2,864 cr outstanding), up from 29% in March 22 |
| Thermal asset exposure | Reduced to single-digit percentage of loan book |
| Loan pipeline | More than ₹5,000 cr, including over ₹500 cr in E-Mobility |
| Market capitalization | ₹1,140 cr as of December 2, 2022 |