Key Takeaways
- Turnaround quarter after near-total business halt: Sanctions of over ₹1,100 crores were achieved in under two months after three quarters of virtually no business, signaling a decisive operational restart.
- Credit cost is now under control: Net NPA fell below ₹200 crores and zero slippages occurred on new underwriting over 4.5 years, though a ₹22 crore impairment was booked this quarter on a conservative auditor recommendation.
- The loan book shrank, but for a quality reason: Book size declined to ~₹7,300 crores from ~₹14,000 crores five years ago, driven largely by ~₹4,000 crores of prepayments that management frames as proof of appraisal quality.
- Growth ambition is back, with targets: FY24 sanction and disbursement targets of ₹6,000 crores and ₹5,500 crores respectively, aiming to rebuild the book toward ₹13,000 crores.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹5,600 crore pipeline converts into sanctions, the pace of cash recoveries from Meenakshi and IL&FS, and whether the audit report cleans up as promised.
Business Restart & Growth Ambition
- Three quarters lost: The last quarter of the previous year and the first two quarters of the current year saw almost no business done for reasons management described as beyond its control. Business picked up only in Q3.
- Sanction sprint: From mid-November to early February, the company sanctioned over ₹1,100 crores, demonstrating that the origination engine can restart quickly once constraints lifted.
- Pipeline visibility: A current pipeline of ₹5,600 crores spans various segments, giving a base for the FY24 ambition.
- FY24 targets: Sanction target of ~₹6,000 crores and disbursement target of ~₹5,500 crores. Factoring in an estimated ₹2,000 crores of prepayments, management expects book size to reasonably reach around ₹13,000 crores.
- Current-year stretch: The ₹2,500 crore sanction and ₹2,200–₹2,300 crore disbursement targets for the current year face a tough final 1–1.5 months; management will try to meet the challenge.
- Credit line constraint: Disbursements fell from ₹1,041 crores to ₹609 crores QoQ because banking lines of ~₹4,000 crores had expired during the crisis period. Fresh limits of ₹3,000 crores were requested and are at an advanced stage of consideration, with management hopeful of getting an additional ₹1,000–₹2,000 crores before month-end.
- Liquidity deployed: ₹900 crores of the earlier ₹1,500 crores held in FDs (which carried negative carry) was utilized for disbursements, bringing the FD balance down to ~₹400 crores.
- Borrowing diversification: At a very advanced stage of taking borrowings from PFC, REC, and IIFCL; sanctions expected anytime. This will be only 10–15% of total borrowings, with cost marginally higher.
- Segment focus: Aligned with four of seven budget priority areas: infrastructure, last-mile connectivity, green, and digital/data centers. Co-lenders have already approached PFS to join as co-lender in data center deals.
- Green ambition: Management articulated a vision of becoming a green infrastructure finance company, targeting opportunities in green hydrogen, e-mobility, battery storage, and evacuation transmission for renewable energy.
- State government projects: Two recent state government deals (Smart City and Water Distribution) open a new origination channel; more such opportunities are expected.
- End-to-end positioning: The company is positioning as an end-to-end solution provider, not just a project finance lender, aiming to retain first-mover advantage in underwriting green shoots like renewable energy, e-mobility, and sewage treatment plants.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "the preceding year in terms of business was not very encouraging for the company for reasons much beyond our control and the book size didn't grow and in fact the last quarter of the previous year and the first two quarters of the current year were almost, we were not able to do any business."
Credit Quality & Resolution
- Credit cost tamed: Credit cost, which was the biggest drain on profit for the preceding 3–4 years, is now totally under control. The company absorbed close to ₹1,200–₹1,300 crores of credit costs over the last four years.
- Net NPA milestone: Net NPA reduced to under ₹200 crores, a figure management notes would look even more impressive had the book size grown.
- Zero new slippages: No slippages have occurred on new underwriting in the last 4.5 years. Prepayments have been high, which management views as a sign of churning and quality assessment, noting that assets which remain for a very long time are the ones that can go into trouble.
- Portfolio decarbonization: Thermal and hydro exposure reduced from 13% to 7% over 4–5 quarters, down from 60–70% of the portfolio 5–6 years ago. Expected to come nearly to zero in 6 months to a year.
- Stressed projects manageable: Three annuity-type projects (Namami Gange/Prayagraj, NHAI road in Andhra Pradesh, Obra C transmission) with net exposure of ~₹350 crores carry no anticipated risk: Obra C is already commissioned and repaying, the road has provisional COD with annuity to start shortly, and the Namami Gange project is 6–7 months from commissioning.
- Cash recovery focus: Management emphasized that cash recovery matters more than provision numbers. Expected to bring back more than ₹220 crores into the system, possibly this quarter or next, from Meenakshi (~₹60 crores), IL&FS (~₹60 crores), and NSL (₹90 crores offer, trying to maximize upfront).
- Meenakshi resolution: Vedanta successfully bid; closure expected this quarter or at most April. ₹52 crores to be paid by Vedanta in cash or structured loan over three to five years.
- IL&FS progress: Lead lender PNB submitted resolution plans; lenders approaching NCLAT for distribution of surplus TRA money. If the NCLAT order passes, the company will get ₹50 crores plus as its share of the consortium loan. Remaining money will come over time because the PPA is for 25 years.
- Danu recovery: High Court order released; PFS recovered close to ₹50 crores in the last 6 months, with about ₹52 crores received due to the late payment surcharge scheme of PFC and REC. In the next 4–5 months, receivables are expected to come to a negligible amount and the account may come out of stage 3.
- NRSS XXXVI resolved: The transmission line project went into crisis, became NPA, and was resolved in March 2022 with money received in the first week of April 2022. Taken over by Tata Project; no longer on the balance sheet.
- Other resolutions in process: Konaseema Gas under liquidation (carrying only 15% of value); NSL Nagapatnam in NCLT with an OTS offer of ~₹90 crores received; Asian Hotel in very initial NCLT stages; Varam Bio already liquidated; ICOM resolved through NCLT with only collateral properties remaining.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "the credit cost which was a big drain on this company for last say preceding 3 to 4 years. That is now totally under control."
Q3 Impairment & Audit Dynamics
- Impairment charge breakdown: ₹22 crores impairment booked in Q3, driven by: (a) ~₹14 crores on KSK Mineral due to unresolved litigation on the interest component (12% simple interest on coal-block de-allocation compensation not yet agreed); (b) ~₹2 crores additional on another stage-3 account; (c) ~₹5–₹7 crores on stage 1 per the ECL model.
- Auditor-driven conservatism: The provision on KSK Mineral was made on a conservative basis at the new statutory auditor’s suggestion, though not required by RBI regulations. Management argued that a legal case becoming more seasoned over time does not mean it has weakened, but the auditor’s view prevailed.
- New statutory auditors: A new set of statutory auditors was appointed; they picked up the KSK Mineral litigation item and recommended the provision.
- Audit report trajectory: Improvement was seen from Q2 to Q3 in the audit report. Management is quite hopeful that the Q4 report will be clean and is working in that direction, having engaged consultants and other professionals.
- Audit committee minutes issue: A qualification related to audit committee minutes not being finalized for a certain period appeared in the financials because the erstwhile Audit Committee Chairman did not sign them. A reputed third-party agency (one of the top lawyers in India) has been appointed to prepare minutes from recordings. The qualification is expected to go away in the next financials.
- Regulatory queries dissipating: Issues are almost over; one or two queries still coming but expected to dissipate in the next few days. Management linked the genesis of these queries to the previous audit committee chairman not finalizing minutes and the skirmishes around director resignations.
Dr. Pawan Singh: “My argument was that a legal case if it becomes more seasoned over a period of time there is a better chance of winning it if it is delay in the legal case, doesn’t mean that the case has become weakened, that was my argument with the auditor.”
Governance & Leadership Reset
- Board now full-fledged: New board includes Dr. Pawan Singh (MD & CEO), Mr. Rajib Kumar Mishra (Non-Executive Chairman, also CMD PTC India Ltd), Mr. Pankaj Goyal (CA), Ms. PV Bharati (Ex-MD Corporation Bank, Ex-ED Canara Bank), Ms. Seema Bahuguna (Ex-Bureaucrat, recently retired from GoI), and Mr. Naveen Bhushan Gupta (Ex-Director Finance, PFC).
- Senior hires in place or imminent: Director Finance selected (a very senior person who was Director Finance in an Energy Efficiency government JV). ED Credit selected (Chief General Manager of IIFCL, a respected name in infrastructure credit underwriting). ED Monitoring & Recovery in process, expected in ~45 days. Chief Internal Auditor appointed.
- New CFO joining: New head of finance expected to join on 8th March; MD trying to persuade him to prepone.
- Promoter support restored: Board and promoters have given full support for growth; operational autonomy and recruitment are now allowed. The earlier contention around PTC stepping out is no longer there.
- Director resignations: Four independent directors from PTC resigned at different times. Two went gracefully (term complete, purpose fulfilled); one resigned with bitterness 10 days before term end; one mildly criticized and raised one or two issues. All had to go as new IDs were appointed.
- Compliance normalization: All pending compliances with RBI, SEBI, and financial publication requirements completed; company moved out of the 'Z' category.
- Rating reaffirmations: CRISIL reaffirmed rating; ICRA removed the "development" tag and reaffirmed A+; Care reaffirmed A+. Management expects further reaffirmation.
Dr. Pawan Singh: “But let me tell you, it is almost over. I mean, it's almost over it is namesake now one or two, you know queries from here and there are coming, I would not say there are zero queries, but there are one or two queries which are coming, but this is all because these people resigned in skirmishes of that are still seen which should dissipate in next few days.”
Financial Performance & Margins
- NII stability: 9-month NII of ₹252 crores was almost the same as ₹257 crores in the previous year 9 months, despite a slight reduction in the loan book.
- PAT growth: 9-month PAT increased significantly to ₹139 crores from ₹105 crores, due to a significant reduction in provisions during the 9 months.
- Yield compression: Q3 yield on the loan portfolio declined to 10.35% from 10.58% in the previous quarter. Management is revisiting yields because market interest rates have risen (bank rates up 160 bps) and borrowing costs may marginally increase with diversification.
- Cost of funds: Cost of borrowed funds increased to 7.66% from 7.46% in the previous quarter. At 7.66% for an A-rated entity, management considers this quite good, comparable to or even lower than PFC/REC AAA sovereign borrowing.
- NIM outlook: NIM expected to remain at a similar level around 4% for FY23–24.
- Leverage headroom: Debt-equity is currently at 2.24, against an ideal of around 6. More leveraging would bring more returns to shareholders.
- Dividend intent: Dividend is very much on the top of the agenda and the board is appreciative, but no timeline was given on whether it will be before or after March.
- Valuation argument: Management argued there is no reason to discount the company at 50% of book value now that stress assets have been taken out, noting that the ₹1,200–₹1,300 crores of credit costs absorbed was effectively the minus of book value.
Dr. Pawan Singh: “I have been able to absorb close to 12-1300 crores of credit costs in the last four years I mean that we have been able to absorb so that 12-1300 crores was the in fact the minus of my book value. So, now having done that, again, I am back to that minus 1300 core that should not happen.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Sanction target (current FY) | ₹2,500 crores | Current financial year (next 1–1.5 months) |
| Disbursement target (current FY) | ₹2,200–₹2,300 crores | Current financial year (next 1–1.5 months) |
| Sanction target (FY24) | ~₹6,000 crores | FY2024 |
| Disbursement target (FY24) | ~₹5,500 crores | FY2024 |
| Book size rebuild | Reasonably around ₹13,000 crores (factoring ~₹2,000 crores prepayments) | FY2024 |
| Thermal/hydro exposure reduction | Nearly to zero | 6 months to 1 year |
| Meenakshi resolution closure | ₹52 crores from Vedanta | This quarter or at most April |
| Danu account normalization | Receivables to negligible amount; account may exit stage 3 | Next 4–5 months |
| Cash recoveries | More than ₹220 crores (Meenakshi, IL&FS, NSL) | Possibly this quarter or next |
| Audit report | Clean report expected | Q4 |
| Audit committee minutes qualification | Qualification to go away | Next financials |
| NIM | Around 4% | FY23–24 |
| Credit lines | Additional ₹1,000–₹2,000 crores | Before month-end (February) |
| Borrowing diversification (PFC/REC/IIFCL) | Sanctions expected anytime | Advanced stage |
| ED Monitoring & Recovery appointment | In process | ~45 days |
| New CFO joining | Expected 8th March; MD trying to prepone | March |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net interest income | ₹82 cr for Q3; ₹252 cr for 9M FY23 (vs ₹257 cr in 9M FY22) |
| Net interest margin | 4.19%, maintained around same level for last 1–1.5 years |
| Yield on loan portfolio | 10.35%, vs 10.58% in Q2 FY23 |
| Cost of borrowed funds | 7.66%, vs 7.46% in Q2 FY23 |
| Spread | 2.17 paisa for Q3 (vs ₹2.02 for entire FY22) |
| Total income | ₹194 cr, vs ₹195 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Profit before tax (9M) | ₹186 cr for 9M FY23, vs ₹140 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Profit after tax (9M) | ₹139 cr for 9M FY23, vs ₹105 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Earnings per share | 0.58 paisa for Q3; ₹2.69 for 9M FY23 |
| Provision for contingencies | ₹22.82 cr, increased from ₹7 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Loan sanctions | ₹1,131 cr for Q3 (vs ₹1,160 cr in Q2); ₹2,291 cr for 9M FY23 |
| Disbursements | ₹609 cr for Q3; ₹1,670 cr for 9M FY23 |
| Loan book | ₹7,301 cr as at end of December 2022 |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 33.30%, vs 31.74% in Q2 FY23 and 26.71% as at March 2022 |
| Debt-equity ratio | 2.24 times |
| Gross NPA | ~₹500+ cr (after excluding Danu Wind, which is stage 3 but not NPA, of ₹308 cr from stress figure of ₹888 cr) |
| Net NPA | ₹218 cr (net NPA figure); gross NPA is ~₹500+ cr (after excluding Danu Wind of ₹308 cr from stress figure of ₹888 cr) |
| Sanction target for FY24 | ~₹6,000 cr |
| Disbursement target for FY24 | ~₹5,500 cr |
| Renewable portfolio share | 28% of portfolio |
| Transmission portfolio share | ~22% of portfolio |
| State sector portfolio share | ~25% of portfolio |
| Thermal and hydro portfolio share | 7%, down from 13% 4–5 quarters ago |
| Current pipeline | ₹5,600 cr |
| Cash and HQLA | ₹740 cr cash; ₹554 cr earmarked for HQLA |
| Expected recovery from stressed assets | More than ₹220 cr expected to be brought back, possibly in Q4 FY23 or Q1 FY24 |