Key Takeaways
- Clean audit, functional board, dividend restored: The company moved from a disclaimer opinion four quarters ago to a broadly clean audit report with no modified opinion, the board is fully reconstituted, and a 10% dividend was declared for the first time in a long period.
- Profit up ~50% YoY on better NIM, but loan book still shrinking: Q4 profit rose to Rs. 36.41 crores as NIM improved to 4.35%, yet the loan book has been declining for six to seven quarters and was only held flat this quarter.
- One fresh NPA broke the improving trend: After six to eight quarters of continuous decline, a single account (Vento Power, a partly commissioned renewable project) slipped into NPA, causing a nominal increase in gross and net NPAs.
- Ambitious FY24 growth targets set: Management is targeting Rs. 6,000 crores in sanctions and Rs. 5,000 crores in disbursements, aiming to grow the loan book to Rs. 9,000 crores from Rs. 7,339 crores.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the spread gap closes as the full impact of rate hikes flows through, progress on the Rs. 4,500 crore pipeline under due diligence, and resolution of the three named stress accounts.
Audit, Board & Governance Reset
- Audit trajectory transformed: The balance sheet carried a disclaimer four quarters back, moved to a modified opinion last quarter, and has now received a broadly clean report with no modified opinion. Management calls this a big development that gives comfort to lenders.
- Board fully functional: The board is now fully reconstituted with diversified members, including an ex-Secretary of DPE, an ex-CMD of Corporation Bank, and the Director Finance of PFC. Minutes of board meetings, previously not recorded, have now been completed.
- Forensic audit closed: The CNK forensic audit matter is closed: an interim report, then a final report, were considered by the board, and Q1, Q2, and Q3 financial results were completed thereafter. Board reconstitution followed SEBI conditions being met.
- Dividend restored: A 10% dividend was declared for the first time after a long period. Management acknowledges it could have been better but frames it as a beginning.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "unfortunately in our balance sheet four quarters back got disclaimer and this was a dampness in all respects. From that, last quarter we were able to move to modified opinion and happy to report that this time we have got no modified report and we have got broadly clean report."
Profitability & Margins
- Profit jump: Q4 FY23 profit increased nearly 50% YoY to Rs. 36.41 crores from Rs. 24.98 crores. EPS improved to Rs. 2.74 from Rs. 2.02, RoNW to 7.47% from 5.93%, and RoA to 2.05% from 1.24%.
- NIM improved: NIM rose from 4% to 4.35%, driven by yield increasing more than the rise in borrowing cost. Management points to this as evidence of strength in customer negotiations.
- Spread compressed temporarily: Spread saw a slight gap this quarter because most banks increased their MCLR at the end of Q3 or beginning of Q4, while PFS raised its own benchmark rate by only 25 bps in the last week of Q4. Two rate hikes occurred only in March, so the full pass-through impact was not felt. Management expects the gap to be covered in Q1 of the current year.
- Rate hike pass-through mechanics: Two rate hikes totaling 50 bps will increase yield by 50 bps straight away, improving NIM. The company’s policy requires calculating pass-through on a robust number first, creating a lag.
- Cost of borrowing rising: Cost of borrowed funds increased in line with global trends. Management perceives there could be a further 50 to 70 bps increase in borrowing cost. The additional burden is passed on to customers.
- Fee income flat: Fee income is effectively flat and primarily consists of prepayment fees. Under IndAS, fee income is amortized over the loan tenure, so no major impact on profitability in any single period.
Abhinav Goyal: "our yield has increased more in comparison. So that shows our strength, that shows our commitment and that shows our efficiency. We are having negotiations with our customers and being able to bring more what our bankers have taken more from us."
Loan Book & Asset Quality
- Loan book held flat: The loan book had been declining for the last six to seven quarters. This quarter it was held flat with a very insignificant increase, at Rs. 7,339 crores, down from Rs. 8,686 crores in the prior period. The decline was caused by constrained disbursements during the board’s non-functioning in the first two quarters and part of the third quarter.
- Disbursement decline: FY23 loan disbursement fell to Rs. 2,253 crores from Rs. 3,888 crores in FY22, again because of the board non-functioning period. Q4 disbursement was higher than the corresponding quarter of the previous year despite constraints.
- One fresh NPA: Vento Power, a partly commissioned renewable power project, became an NPA this quarter, causing a nominal increase in gross and net NPAs after six to eight quarters of continuous decline. Revenue from the project is short and not matching dues; partial dues will be served from project revenue.
- ECL provisioning already in place: Provisions for Vento Power were already made under the ECL model based on probability of loss. Management states it is becoming more conservative in provisioning and the credit cost cycle is almost over, though some very insignificant provisioning still occurs.
- Five-year clean slate: None of the loans made in the last five years went into stress, attributed to strong credit underwriting and a focus on green sectors with government policy support.
- NPA resolution pipeline: Key accounts expected to be resolved in FY24 include Meenakshi, Vento Power (looking for a change in promoter), and the IL&FS loan account, where the company has close to Rs. 2,500 crores in a TRA account.
Sanjay Rustagi: "So it is the best estimate on which we have made a provision, unless and until things change drastically, so I would not expect anything major to come in the times to come."
Growth Ambition & Pipeline
- FY24 targets: Management is targeting sanctions of around Rs. 6,000 crores, disbursements of Rs. 5,000 crores, and a loan book size of about Rs. 9,000 crores, factoring in net prepayment and repayment of roughly Rs. 2,300 crores.
- Pipeline visibility: A committed undisbursed pipeline of around Rs. 1,200 crores already exists, with roughly Rs. 4,500 crores under various stages of due diligence. The pipeline spans transmission lines, road HAM projects, wind and renewable projects.
- New sectors: The company has entered water distribution and smart city sectors and has built up a good pipeline in e-mobility.
- Green focus with intent to exit thermal: Management intends to become a zero thermal company by the end of this year; thermal assets currently stand at 6% of the book. The firm belief is that what is good for the environment is good for the economy and for the lender, and sectors with government policy support see fewer delinquencies.
- Leverage headroom: Debt equity ratio improved to 2.09 times from 3.14 times. Management considers this best among all NBFCs and notes the ratio should ideally be at least 4 or 5 times, providing significant cushion for balance sheet expansion. Borrowings, which came down from Rs. 7,000 crores to Rs. 5,000 crores year-to-year, are expected to return to close to Rs. 7,000 crores to fund portfolio growth.
Dr. Pawan Singh: "our firm belief and our experience also was that what is good for environment is good for the economy also and that is good for economy is also good for the lender also."
Funding & Capital
- ECB diversification: The company is engaged with various international institutions for more ECB borrowings to diversify borrowing sources. It is proposing to raise a $50 million loan from IIFCL-UK at very good terms, with the IIFC board meeting upcoming to consider the proposal. Discussions with a couple of global institutions are also ongoing.
- Primary funding source: Funding is expected to come mainly from PSU banks.
- Rs. 500 crores capital raise approved: The board has approved raising Rs. 500 crores in capital, available as an enabler, but there is no urgency to raise given the current valuation, debt/equity ratio, and capital adequacy. PTC has no plans of getting divested from PFS and continues to maintain its stake; when capital is raised, PTC’s percentage share will come down but they are not going to dilute.
- Dividend outlook: Future dividends will be “definitely reasonable,” and management will try to reach market expectations, assuring shareholders they “will not get discouraged and disappointed in future.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Sanctions | Rs. 6,000 crores | FY24 |
| Disbursements | Rs. 5,000 crores | FY24 |
| Loan book size | Reach ~Rs. 9,000 crores | FY24 |
| Spread gap closure | Cover the Q4 spread compression | Q1 FY24 |
| NIM range | Around 4% | FY24 |
| Expected yield | 11% | FY24 |
| Expected spread | 2.5% to 2.75% | FY24 (dynamic environment) |
| Thermal exit | Become a zero thermal company | By end of current year |
| NPA resolution | Resolve Meenakshi, Vento Power, IL&FS accounts | FY24 |
| Borrowing cost increase | Further 50–70 bps increase perceived | Undated |
| Dividend | Future dividends “definitely reasonable,” reaching market expectation | Undated |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax | ₹36.41 cr, up ~50% YoY from ₹24.98 cr |
| Profit after tax (full year FY23) | ₹175.81 cr, up from ₹129.98 cr in FY22 |
| Net interest income (full year FY23) | ₹334 cr, vs ₹344 cr in FY22 |
| Earnings per share | ₹2.74, vs ₹2.02 in FY22 |
| Net interest margin | 4.35%, improved from 4.30% in Q3 FY23 and 4% earlier |
| Spread | 2.83% |
| Yield on portfolio | 10.51%, vs 10.60% in FY22 |
| Cost of borrowing | 8.11%, up from 7.60% in prior quarters |
| Return on net worth | 7.47%, vs 5.93% in FY22 |
| Return on assets | 2.05%, vs 1.24% in FY22 |
| Loan book | ₹7,339 cr, vs ₹8,686 cr in FY22; held broadly flat QoQ |
| Loan sanctions (Q4 FY23) | ₹1,563 cr, vs ₹1,131 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Loan sanctions (full year FY23) | ₹3,854 cr, vs ₹4,150 cr in FY22 |
| Loan disbursements (full year FY23) | ₹2,253 cr, vs ₹3,888 cr in FY22 |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 33.05%, vs 26.71% in FY22 |
| Debt-to-equity ratio | 2.09x, vs 3.14x in FY22 |
| Gross NPA | 9.68% |
| Net NPA | 4.38% |
| Thermal exposure | 6.49% of loan book, down from 10% at end of FY22 and over 40% five years ago |
| Renewable energy exposure | 28.89% of loan book |
| Dividend declared | 10%, first dividend after a long period |
| FY24 loan book target | ~₹9,000 cr, with sanctions target of ~₹6,000 cr and disbursements of ~₹5,000 cr |
| FY24 expected yield | ~11% |
| FY24 expected spread | 2.5% to 2.75% |
| FY24 expected NIM | ~4% |
| PFS benchmark rate hike (late Q4) | 25 bps |
| Rate hikes passed to borrowers (Jan and Mar) | 50 bps total, full impact on yield and spread expected in Q1 FY24 |
| Board-approved capital raise | ₹500 cr, timing not yet determined |
| Proposed ECB loan | $50 million from IIFCL-UK, in advanced stage |
| Incremental borrowing cost expectation | 50–70 bps further increase possible |