Key Takeaways
- Best quarter post-merger: NII, operating profit and net profit all hit their highest levels in the 14 quarters since amalgamation, driven by 20% YoY NII growth and a sharp drop in slippages.
- Asset quality transformed: Gross NPA fell to 6.96% and net NPA to 1.47%, with recovery of Rs. 5,500 crores running at double the quarterly slippage.
- NIM held above the top of guidance at 3.11%, but management kept its full-year range at 2.9%–3% because ~15% of deposits still await repricing.
- The legacy NPA stock is being reframed as a "gold mine": Rs. 1.55 lakh crores in technical write-offs and NPAs earn nothing today; any recovery drops straight to the bottom line.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Rs. 2,500 crores of expected NCLT recoveries actually land, the pace of deposit cost increase, and any movement on the 1% ROA target the bank says it may try to beat.
Profitability & Margins
- NII surge: Rose ~20% YoY to Rs. 9,923 crores, the highest post-amalgamation, on 13.43% advance growth and improved yield from new acquisitions whose NPA is just 0.22%.
- NIM above guidance but cautious: Q2 NIM of 3.11% beat the 2.9%–3% guided range, yet management maintained that range because cost of deposits rose to 4.84% and another 10–15 bps of repricing is still to come on ~Rs. 1 lakh crore of deposits.
- NII quality: The Rs. 400 crore sequential NII increase was not just recovery; it reflected CASA improvement, better asset quality on new loans, and recovery from NCLT accounts that previously earned nothing.
- Treasury income minimal: At just Rs. 136 crores, the bank is not dependent on treasury gains; operating profit exceeded Rs. 6,000 crores without them.
- Fee income gap acknowledged: Management is aware that other income lags peers by 40–50 bps and is working on non-interest income, third-party products and forex.
Goel: "This is one of the very wonderful quarters for as far as the Punjab National Bank is concerned. The 3 parameters which really you will be happy to hear the net interest income, whether it is the operating profit, whether it is the net profit, these 3 numbers which we have shown in the current quarter ending September 2023, it is the highest we have achieved first time in the last 14 quarters after the amalgamation."
Asset Quality & the "Gold Mine"
- Gross NPA reduction: Fell substantially to 6.96% from higher levels, with net NPA at 1.47%, supported by a provision coverage ratio of 91.91%.
- Slippage collapsed: Quarterly slippage dropped to Rs. 1,826 crores from Rs. 6,000 crores in September 2022, driven by improved underwriting and collection efficiency. New-acquisition NPA is only 0.22% over a Rs. 4.63 lakh crore book built across 39 months.
- Recovery doubled slippage: Rs. 5,500 crores recovered against Rs. 1,826 crores of slippage, meeting the bank's stated motto.
- Credit cost declining: NPA provisioning fell to Rs. 3,018 crores (1.31%) as PCR rose and aging provision requirements shrank; full-year guidance is 1.5%–1.75% with half-yearly at 1.75% and expected to fall further.
- Slippage balanced across segments: Agriculture Rs. 424 crores, MSME Rs. 683 crores, retail Rs. 420 crores, others Rs. 223 crores, existing accounts Rs. 76 crores; corporate slippage is negligible.
- SMA2 book contained: Only Rs. 1,448 crores, giving management confidence that slippage will keep reducing quarter by quarter.
- The "gold mine" framing: Management explicitly called the Rs. 90,000 crores of technical write-offs plus Rs. 65,000 crores of NPA a "gold mine," noting that any recovery adds directly to the bottom line and that if this stock earned 7–8%, operating profit would be Rs. 9,000–10,000 crores higher.
Goel: "Whatever the NPA we are having Rs. 90,000 crores, the TWO, and Rs. 65,000 crores, I think that is our gold mine and whatever recovery we will be making in times to come, definitely that will be added to my bottom line."
Deposits, Funding & Capital
- Cost of deposits rising: Increased to 4.84% from 4.71%, with another 10–15 bps expected as ~15% of deposits still await repricing.
- Deliberate deposit strategy: The bank is not bidding for bulk deposits and is instead concentrating on CASA, leveraging its 10,000 branches and 29,000 BC channels; it opened 51 lakh accounts in Q1 alone and sits on 6% excess SLR that can be tapped at 6.75%.
- Capital position comfortable: CET-1 at 10.23% against an 8% regulatory requirement, leaving 2.23% excess. Half-year profitability of Rs. 3,000 crores is not yet included in the calculation; full-year profitability of roughly Rs. 6,000 crores will add to CET-1 after dividend.
- No CET-1 raise planned: Management explicitly stated the stock is undervalued and raising equity at current prices would not serve shareholders.
- AT-I and Tier-II raised: Board approved Rs. 12,000 crores for the year (Rs. 7,000 crores AT-I, Rs. 5,000 crores Tier-II); Rs. 3,090 crores Tier-II raised in Q1 and Rs. 3,000 crores AT-I in Q2.
- Rating mix shift explained: AAA and AA shares declined not because of downgrades but because the bank is walking away from rates that do not suit it; the BBB increase is largely MSME where higher ratings are structurally difficult.
Goel: "Why we are not raising the CET-I from the market is because my price is undervalued as on date, because to serve the equity is also a challenge."
Recovery Pipeline & NCLT Expectations
- Full-year recovery target: Rs. 22,000 crores, with Rs. 11,000 crores already achieved in the first half.
- NCLT pipeline front-loaded: Management expects around Rs. 2,500 crores in Q3, though the legal process creates uncertainty; Q4 is expected to deliver more than Rs. 1,089 crores.
- Recovery directly lifts NII: Because NCLT accounts currently earn nothing, any recovery improves NII immediately.
Costs, Provisions & Transformation
- Wage revision provision stepped up: Increased to Rs. 694 crores in Q2 from Rs. 283 crores in Q1, taking the half-year total to roughly Rs. 950–1,000 crores. Management declined to disclose the assumed hike percentage, stating only that it has "provided adequately" and that the provision assumes roughly 10% versus the 15% settled last time.
- Digital transformation underway: Began in June 2022; around 36 products launched and roughly 70 processes and services digitized so far.
- HR transformation in progress: Benefits expected to accrue by March 2024.
- Asset monetization modest: The bank is monetizing excess space where possible but cautioned it is not a very big amount and is unlikely to become material.
- DTA reduction distant: Management acknowledged the DTA is a very large number that will take a lot of time to reduce; the decision on whether to move to the new tax regime is still under discussion with a tax consultant.
Goel: "I will tell you we have provided adequately. Please try to understand. I have told you also because that will not be a good intent if I will give the percentage."
Subsidiaries & Strategic Updates
- PNB Housing Finance: No monetization planned; the entity published results recently showing good recoveries and growth. The bank renounced and sold shares from its rights issue.
- Canara-HSBC stake: The disinvestment plan changed because IRDA revised regulations to allow up to 25% as an investor category; PNB holds 23%.
- PNB Cards & Services: Received regulatory approval; a DSA model will be implemented for lead generation.
- No subsidiary monetization on the table: Management stated there is no plan as of now to monetize any subsidiary.
- Overseas book: Growing at 9.9%, which management considers reasonable; no pressure is being applied to overseas branches.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NIM | 2.9% to 3%; absolute NII maintained or grown even if percentage dips | Full-year FY24 |
| Credit cost | Within 1.5% to 1.75%, expected to decrease from half-yearly 1.75% | Full-year FY24 |
| Gross NPA | Below 6% | March 2024 |
| Net NPA | Below 1% | March 2024 |
| ROA | Achieve 1% | Exit of FY25 (management may try earlier) |
| Recovery | Rs. 22,000 crores total; Rs. 11,000 crores done in H1 | Full-year FY24 |
| NCLT recovery | ~Rs. 2,500 crores expected (subject to legal process) | Q3 FY24 |
| Cost of deposits | Increase of 10–15 bps from current 4.84% | Near term (deposit repricing) |
| Advances growth | 11% to 13%, supported by 9% growth rate already achieved | Full-year FY24 |
| CET-1 capital raise | No immediate need in next 12 months unless growth target rises to 20–25% | Next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Net interest income | ₹9,923 cr, +19.98% YoY and +4.4% QoQ |
| Operating profit | ₹6,216 cr, +11.67% YoY and +4.2% QoQ |
| Net profit | ₹1,756 cr, +327.35% YoY and +39.9% QoQ |
| Gross NPA ratio | 6.96%, improved from 10.48% YoY and 7.73% QoQ |
| Net NPA ratio | 1.47%, improved from 3.8% YoY |
| Provision coverage ratio | 91.91%, up from 83.96% YoY and 89.83% QoQ |
| Slippages | ₹1,826 cr, down from ₹6,000 cr YoY and ₹2,390 cr QoQ |
| Credit cost | 1.31% for the quarter, vs 1.98% QoQ; half-yearly at 1.67% |
| Net interest margin | 3.11%, vs guidance of 2.9%–3.0% |
| Yield on advances | 8.23%, up from 8.13% QoQ |
| Cost of deposits | 4.84%, up from 4.71% QoQ; ~15% of term deposits still to reprice |
| Return on assets | 0.46% for the quarter; target of 1% by exit of FY25 |
| Gross advances growth | 13.43% YoY, to ₹9.4 lakh cr |
| Deposit growth | 9.7% YoY, to ₹13.09 lakh cr |
| RAM growth | 13.41% YoY; RAM to total credit at 55.63% |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 15.09% total; CET-I at 10.23%, Tier-I at 12% |
| Recovery | ₹5,500 cr for the quarter, vs slippages of ₹1,826 cr |