Key Takeaways
- Best profit in 14 quarters, guidance raised across the board: Net profit hit ₹4,303 crore, ROA crossed 1% in H1 ahead of schedule, and management lifted full-year ROA guidance to 0.9–1% while slashing credit cost guidance to just 0.25–0.30%.
- Asset quality is no longer the story’s villain: Gross NPA fell another 50 bps to 4.48%, PCR sits at 97%, and new-vintage underwriting (₹6.31 trillion originated since July 2020) carries only 0.29% NPA. The ECL overhang that once haunted PNB has, in management’s words, “gone.”
- Recovery engine is running hot and management calls it structural: Recoveries are more than double delinquencies, the ₹92,584 crore technical write-off book is described as a “gold mine,” and the bank expects ₹1,000–₹1,500 crore in recoveries every quarter.
- Margin pressure is real but framed as a choice, not a crisis: NIM slipped on QIP liquidity deployment and overseas mix; management insists it could push margins higher but won’t, because chasing 3%+ would mean accepting slippage risk or walking away from low-yield but safe transactions.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the AS-15 provision reverses as G-Sec yields tick back up, the pace of corporate credit demand (still absent, with ₹1 trillion of sanctioned limits unutilized), and any final ECL guidelines that could reset the provisioning debate.
Profitability & The ROA Inflection
- Net profit of ₹4,303 crore is the highest in 14 quarters; NII of ₹10,517 crore and operating profit of ₹6,853 crore are the best in 4–5 years. The quarter marks a clean break from the bank’s stressed past.
- ROA crossed 1% in H1, hitting the full-year exit target six months early. Management revised full-year ROA guidance upward to 0.9–1% from 0.8%, a signal of confidence that the earnings base is now durable enough to absorb quarterly noise.
- Credit cost collapsed to 0.08% because recoveries are more than double delinquencies and the 97% PCR means ageing-related provisions are minimal (roughly ₹250 crore per quarter). Management sees a scenario where credit cost turns negative, though it has not committed to that outcome.
- A ₹350 crore floating provision was created this quarter (cumulative ₹500 crore), which absorbed what would otherwise have been a negative credit cost print. The provision can only be used with regulatory permission in bad times and is not earmarked for any specific ECL requirement.
- The tax-regime switch is a latent 10 bps ROA tailwind: PNB will move to the new tax regime once it absorbs existing carry-forward and MAT benefits, a shift management says will happen “in a matter of time” but has not yet quantified or dated.
Goel: “Although we have given the guidance that we will be in a position 1% by the exit of the current financial year, but we have achieved.”
Asset Quality: The Clean-Up Is Largely Done
- Gross NPA fell to 4.48% from 6.96% a year ago, a reduction of roughly 50 bps every quarter. Management revised its March 2025 gross NPA target down twice: first to ~4%, then to 3.5–3.75%. Net NPA guidance of 0.5% is expected to hold.
- New-vintage underwriting is the proof point: Of ₹6.31 trillion outstanding loans originated between July 2020 and September 2024, only 0.29% is NPA. That covers roughly 60% of the total loan book and gives management the confidence to declare the ECL overhang “gone.”
- Slippages are contained at 1% and management expects that to hold. Agri slippages of ₹565 crore are normal for a book exceeding ₹1 trillion, and personal loan slippages remain in the same ~2% range as last quarter.
- SMA-0 collapsed from ₹1,02,728 crore to ₹21,599 crore, partly because some of the earlier figure was an accounting artifact (installments paid in the first week of the month showing up as SMA-0). The SMA book above ₹5 crore is just ₹2,125 crore, so no major provision requirement is foreseen unless an individual exposure crosses ₹2,000–₹2,500 crore.
- PSU telecom exposure of ₹434 crore was recognized as NPA this quarter and included in the ₹2,100 crore slippage figure; adequate provision has been made. One steel PSU account is in SMA with another bank, but PNB’s working capital exposure is performing and will be monitored.
- NARCL transfers carry zero residual risk: 14 accounts worth ₹3,778 crore have been transferred, all 100% provided for, so the carrying cost of security receipts is zero. No different regulatory treatment applies versus a direct DRC sale.
Goel: “Earlier there was a worry because we were having the highest NPA, highest gross NPA and so everybody was worried that the ECL provision, the PNB will be the higher. However, as on date that worry is gone.”
Recoveries: The “Gold Mine” Thesis
- Recoveries are running at more than double the delinquency rate, which is the mechanical driver behind the collapsing credit cost. This quarter’s recovery of ₹1,369 crore flowed through other income.
- The ₹92,584 crore technical write-off book is the engine management is betting on. It describes the TWO pool as a “gold mine” and expects quarterly recoveries to sustain in the ₹1,000–₹1,500 crore range, with some quarters potentially delivering more.
- The full-year recovery target is ₹18,000 crore, and management is confident because some large LC/LD accounts are expected to resolve in the current or next quarter.
- NCLT resolutions are progressing: 275 accounts have been resolved for ₹47,444 crore, 304 accounts liquidated for ₹35,120 crore, and 218 accounts remain pending. The pipeline is material but the timeline is outside the bank’s control.
Margins & The Trade-Off Management Is Making
- NIM guidance is 2.9–3%, and management insists absolute NII is rising every quarter even if the percentage compresses. The decline this quarter was partly mechanical: QIP proceeds of ₹5,000 crore were parked in short-term investments where yield is available but lower than loan yields, a phenomenon management calls temporary.
- Cost of deposits rose from 5.08% to 5.16% as one-year deposit rates moved to 7.70–7.80%. Management believes deposit rates have peaked, so no further increase is foreseen, which would stabilize the liability-side pressure.
- Yield on funds declined because the investment book grew much faster than the advance book, and the overseas loan book (which carries lower margins) also contributed. Management frames the overseas exposure as a conscious choice: absolute NII matters more than NIM percentage, and cutting that book would shrink earnings.
- The margin-versus-risk trade-off is explicit: management says it can increase margins but won’t, because some transactions yield only 1–2% and chasing 3%+ would mean either accepting slippage risk or walking away from safe, low-return business.
- Penal interest reclassification from interest income to other income had only a 1–2 bps impact on margins, so it does not explain the broader compression.
Goel: “We can increase the margin. We can increase the margin, but there is a risk of slippage also.”
Costs: The AS-15 Distortion & Operating Leverage
- Cost-to-income ratio jumped to 54.58% almost entirely because of a ₹2,057 crore AS-15 provision, up from just ₹7.42 crore last quarter. The trigger was a 26 bps decline in the 10-year G-Sec yield (from 7.01% to 6.75%), which mechanically increases the present value of future employee benefit obligations.
- This is a non-cash provision, not an actual outgo, and it is cumulative: it moves with interest rates in both directions. Since the 10-year G-Sec has already risen back to ~6.85%, management expects the December-quarter AS-15 requirement to reduce, potentially reversing some of the drag.
- Fee income dropped sequentially because processing fees are charged in Q1 for the full year, making Q2 naturally lower. This is a seasonal pattern, not a structural decline.
- Treasury income was strong at ₹761 crore in trading profit (G-Sec, non-SLR, and equity), plus an additional ₹731 crore from revaluation gains due to a change in valuation norms. Management expects the treasury to remain active and deliver good profits in coming quarters.
Balance Sheet & Growth
- Advances grew 12.8% YoY, above the 11–12% guidance range, and management expects to achieve 12% for the full year while noting it will not turn away demand if opportunities arise.
- Corporate credit demand is absent: management was candid that there is “no much demand in the corporate” segment, and the bank is sitting on ₹1 trillion of sanctioned central limits that borrowers are not utilizing. Growth is coming from RAM (retail, agriculture, MSME) and overseas.
- RAM ratio improved to 55.77% from 55.46% in June 2024, with a near-term target of 58% by March 2025 and a 3–4 year aspiration of 60–61%. MSME growth of 8.9% understates the true run-rate because some accounts graduated out of the MSME classification due to higher turnover; otherwise growth would have been double-digit.
- Deposit growth was favorable, with overseas contributing positively. The credit-deposit ratio is being managed with an eye on LCR, which the bank expects to maintain comfortably at 115–120%.
- Capital adequacy crossed 16% for the first time in 5–10 years, boosted by the ₹5,000 crore QIP (which was over 8x subscribed at ~₹41,000 crore of bids). No further equity raise is planned, though the bank may raise some AT1 in the December quarter if pricing is attractive.
Goel: “In corporate, I am very honest to you, there is no much demand in the corporate, even as on date also, I am having the central limit of the 1 trillion, which they are not utilizing.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross NPA ratio | Reduce to 3.5%–3.75% | March 2025 |
| Net NPA ratio | Maintain at 0.5% | Ongoing |
| Credit cost | 0.25%–0.30% for the full year | FY25 |
| Slippage ratio | Maintain at 1% | Ongoing |
| ROA | 0.9%–1% for the full year | FY25 |
| NIM | 2.9%–3% | Ongoing |
| Advance growth | ~12% for the full year | FY25 |
| RAM ratio | Increase to 58% | March 2025 |
| RAM ratio (long-term) | Increase to 60–61% | 3–4 years |
| Recoveries | ₹18,000 crore for the full year; quarterly run-rate of ₹1,000–₹1,500 crore | FY25 |
| LCR | Maintain 115–120% | Ongoing |
| Tax regime | Shift to new regime once existing benefits are absorbed; would add ~10 bps to ROA | Undated (“matter of time”) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Net profit | ₹4,303 cr, +145% YoY and +32% QoQ; highest in 14 quarters |
| Operating profit | ₹6,853 cr, +10.3% YoY |
| Net interest income | ₹10,517 cr, +6% YoY |
| Global NIM | 2.92%, domestic NIM 3.06%; guidance maintained at 2.9–3% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 54.58%, up from 53.28% in Jun'24 and 52% in Sep'23, driven by AS-15 provision |
| Credit cost | 0.08%, down from 0.32% in Jun'24 and 1.31% in Sep'23; full-year guidance revised to 0.25–0.30% |
| ROA | ~1% in H1 FY25; full-year guidance revised to 0.9–1% |
| Gross NPA ratio | 4.48%, down from 4.98% in Jun'24 and 6.96% in Sep'23; FY25 guidance revised to 3.5–3.75% |
| Net NPA ratio | 0.46%, down from 0.60% in Jun'24 and 1.47% in Sep'23 |
| Provision coverage ratio | 97% |
| Gross advances growth | 12.8% YoY, against guidance of 11–12% |
| Gross deposits growth | 12.8% YoY, to ₹10.62 trillion |
| CASA growth | 3.4% YoY, to ₹5.57 trillion |
| CD ratio | 72.82% |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 16.36%, up from 15.79% in Jun'24; CET-1 at 11.59% |
| Slippages | ₹2,181 cr, including one corporate account of ~₹425 cr |
| Total recovery (incl. TWO and derecognised interest) | ₹4,891 cr, vs ₹3,249 cr in Jun'24; full-year target ₹18,000 cr |
| RAM to total advances | 55.77%, target 58% by Mar'25 |