Key Takeaways
- Consolidated revenue dipped 9.5% YoY, but EBITDA jumped 36%: The top-line decline was driven entirely by European weakness at EMOSS and MFT, while the core camshaft business grew and a new solar plant lifted consolidated margins to 17%.
- EMOSS is in a cyclical trough, not a competitive one: Revenue has slid from ~₹50 crores to the ₹30–35 crores range over two quarters as every European auto OEM has degrown. Management insists no business has been lost to rivals and the pipeline of new customers and applications is intact.
- The India EV story just became real: First deliveries of the retrofitted e-LCV (Tata Ace version) have reached government, fleet and corporate customers, and real-world testing is underway. The Dost version is slated for early 2024.
- Camshafts keep funding the transition: Casting volumes rose 19% YoY, the business carries long-term contract visibility, and a 15 MW solar plant is now cutting power costs by 30–35%, saving roughly ₹1 crore per month.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether EMOSS revenue stabilizes or slides further, any early demand signals from the e-LCV test fleet, and the pace of the Solapur campus build-out.
EMOSS: European Slowdown
- Revenue trajectory: EMOSS posted ₹31.62 crores in Q2, down from ₹33.26 crores last quarter and roughly ₹50 crores in Q4 last year. The degrowth reflects a general recessionary environment in Europe, with delayed customer decision-making, uncertainty from the Ukraine war and Israel conflict, inflation, and a broad auto slowdown.
- EV-specific headwinds: Electric vehicles cost significantly more upfront than diesel or gasoline counterparts, creating customer hesitancy that compounds the macro drag.
- Competitive position intact: Management was explicit that no business has been lost to competitors. EMOSS holds products and technical capabilities that few in the market possess, and discussions with several new customers and new applications are ongoing. The issue is the overall market, not share loss.
- No near-term catalyst visible: Management does not see any immediate change in the European market situation. OEM customers remain connected and partnered, but it is a wait-and-watch environment with no timeline for recovery.
Karan Shah: "I think the issue is that overall, market has slowed down in Europe. And you're not only seeing this on the -- on us, on EMOSS performance, but every single car OEM in Europe has degrown in the last few quarters or even in the last one year."
India E-LCV: Early Commercialization
- First deliveries completed: The company has started delivering retrofitted electric LCVs to customers in India, including government bodies, large fleet operators and corporate bodies. The Tata Ace version began deliveries last month and continues this month, with the first 10–15 customers having taken delivery.
- Testing phase underway: The next few months will involve real-world testing of these vehicles in customer use cases. In parallel, the company is scaling up operations to cater to demand once confirmed and finalized.
- Dost version next: The company will start the Dost version in early 2024.
- Retrofit positioning vs OEMs: Management clarified it is not directly competing with Tata Motors. The retrofit solution targets existing vehicle owners and fleet operators who want to electrify their existing fleets, while OEMs target new-vehicle buyers.
- TCO promise: The total cost of ownership of the electrified vehicle is targeted to be less than that of a diesel vehicle over a 7-to-8-year period. On whether sale proceeds from a second-hand vehicle plus conversion cost would beat a new EV purchase, management said that is the target but could not answer specifically yet.
- Full launch deferred: A full-scale launch with pricing and TCO details is expected in the early part of next year, once testing yields sufficient data. Management declined to provide an order book outlook or exact price points, citing the initial phase of the rollout.
- Focus narrow and deep: The objective is cargo LCVs under 4 tons GVW. Penetration in niche applications like garbage trucks, road sweepers, heavy equipment and airport buses is very low single-digit, and the company sees itself as among the first movers there.
Karan Shah: "We are not directly competing with Tata Motors. I think that's quite clear because we are not the OEM. We don't build the entire vehicle. We are providing a retrofit solution."
Camshafts: The Cash-Generating Core
- Volume growth: Camshaft castings sold increased 10.6% QoQ and 19% YoY to 0.18 crore units. Machined camshaft volumes dipped 5.3% QoQ and 5.9% YoY to 0.07 crore, but the overall trajectory remains positive with long-term contract visibility across domestic and international customers.
- Margin tailwind from solar: A 15 MW solar power plant commissioned at the casting business is reducing power costs by 30–35%, generating savings of approximately ₹1 crore per month from July onward. Additional efficiency efforts on material and machining equipment are ongoing.
- Stand-alone performance: Stand-alone revenue grew 8.23% YoY to ₹177.28 crores, with an EBITDA margin of 18% and PAT margin of approximately 11%.
Subsidiary Health Check
| Subsidiary | Revenue (Q2) | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
| EMOSS | ₹31.62 Cr | ▼ Declining | European recession and EV hesitancy driving degrowth; pipeline intact, no competitive losses. |
| MFT | ₹38.82 Cr | ▬ Stabilized | Business has stabilized during difficult times but still faces challenges from the European slowdown. New non-engine component production planned for H1 2024. |
| MEMCO | ₹11.91 Cr | ▬ Steady | Consistent demand reported. |
Strategic Build-Out
- Solapur campus: Groundbreaking completed on a 25-acre site. PCL will build a state-of-the-art machine shop for assembled camshafts and other niche, intricate products, and will also expand its electric mobility footprint on this campus over the coming year.
- Electric driveline developed: The company has developed an electric driveline for sub-4-ton LCVs, underpinning the current retrofit rollout.
- OEM ambition is a multi-year journey: Work continues on becoming an OEM in India with Precision or EMOSS branded vehicles. Management characterized it as at least a 2-to-3-year journey, distinct from the faster powertrain development track, and said it is too early to estimate the capital required.
- Geographic priorities: Europe remains the technology and early-adopter hub. India is viewed as a very large market in terms of size and revenue. The US is on the radar but hands are full with India and Europe for now.
- Capital questions unanswered: Management declined to comment on any plans to raise capital for India EV expansion or the EMOSS business, and said the powertrain business is not very capital-intensive outside of working capital needs.
Karan Shah: "I think it's at least a two- or three-year journey that we have embarked on. And I think it will not be as immediate as developing powertrains because it comes around with a whole different ball game..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| E-LCV Dost version launch | Start deliveries of the Dost version | Early 2024 |
| E-LCV full-scale commercial launch | Full launch with pricing and TCO details | Early part of next year (2024) |
| MFT new production | Build production of new non-engine components | H1 2024 |
| Solapur machine shop | Build state-of-the-art machine shop for assembled camshafts and niche products | Coming year |
| OEM track in India | Become an OEM with Precision or EMOSS branded vehicles | At least 2–3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Standalone total income | ₹177.28 cr, +8.23% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | 18% |
| Standalone PAT margin | ~11% |
| Consolidated total income | ₹259.63 cr, -9.5% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹44 cr, +36% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 17% |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹10.5 cr |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹8.4 cr |
| Consolidated PAT margin | 3.25% |
| Camshaft castings sold | 0.18 cr units, +19% YoY and +10.6% QoQ |
| Machined camshafts sold | 0.07 cr units, -5.9% YoY and -5.3% QoQ |
| MEMCO revenue | ₹11.9 cr |
| MFT revenue | ₹38.8 cr |
| EMOSS revenue | ₹31.6 cr, down from ₹33.26 cr QoQ and ~₹50 cr in Q4 FY23 |
| Solar power cost reduction | 30–35% reduction in power cost; savings of ~₹1 cr per month from July |