Key Takeaways
- Steady core, Europe a drag: Standalone camshaft business grew on strong multi-year order visibility, while German subsidiary MFT and Dutch EMOSS face European slowdown headwinds that will impact the upcoming quarter.
- eLCV commercial sales begin: First lot of electric Tata Ace vehicles sold beyond pilots, deployed for e-commerce in Delhi; two variants certified, with demand pickup expected in H2 after data collection.
- EV business restructuring on the table: Management is discussing consolidating the EV business into a separate entity to potentially raise capital, with an ambitious plan to move from retrofitting to offering a ground-up OEM product.
- Margins stable at 10-11%: Consistent profitability over the last 3-5 quarters, and management expects this range to continue.
- What to watch next quarter: The depth of the European slowdown impact on consolidated numbers, progress on EMOSS India conversion capacity expansion, and any concrete steps toward the EV business restructuring.
Core Business & Order Book
- Camshaft business growing: Standalone PCL grew by better utilizing its foundry and machine shops, onboarding several new customers in India and overseas.
- Order book visibility: Management cites a fairly strong order book for at least the next three to five years, with additional business from Indian and overseas customers and no reduction in camshaft volumes expected.
- New assembled camshaft plant: A new plant for assembled camshafts is under construction with INR50 crores capex already sanctioned and approved by the Board.
- MEMCO steady: The Nashik subsidiary has seen consistent demand.
- Non-engine diversification begins: One braking system component is already in production and supplying to a European customer, in ramp-up phase, with a complete machining line dedicated to this project; casting for this product to be developed in-house in the coming year.
European Headwinds
- MFT Germany: Continues to face several headwinds due to the slowdown in Europe.
- EMOSS Netherlands: Shows a strong order book, but short-term demand has reduced because subsidies earmarked for e-mobility have been diverted for the war situation, causing pushback on order delivery and delay in customer decision-making; no order cancellations, but a definite slowdown.
- Impact confirmed: Management stated the European slowdown will surely impact the upcoming quarter.
Karan Shah: "A lot of the subsidies that have been earmarked for e-mobility have been diverted for the war situation at this point of time. We hope that these will be reissued or brought back in the coming months or years, but it's a very uncertain situation right now."
EMOSS India & eLCV Progress
- eLCV commercial milestone: First lot of vehicles sold besides pilot vehicles, deployed in Delhi region and used for e-commerce applications; more than 20 vehicles deployed with large customers across India, collecting data for further product optimization.
- Conversion capability: The Solapur plant can convert an entire vehicle start to end in 8 to 10 hours, or one shift.
- Geographic constraint: Demand is coming from multiple cities (Delhi, Bangalore, Mumbai), so conversions cannot all be done in Solapur due to prohibitive logistics costs; company is looking at partners or own smaller setups closer to customers.
- Customer profile: Customers are third-party logistics operators who own the assets and run them for end customers like municipal corporations, e-commerce and FMCG companies.
- Product appeal: Performance is at par with ready-made EVs like Tata Ace or Dost; customers like the customization flexibility where range and price can be tailored to need.
- Local supply chain: More than 90% of the components are made in India; none of the battery packs are imported.
Karan Shah: "We are able to convert an entire vehicle start to end in, let's say, 8 to 10 hours or one shift."
EV Business Restructuring
- Separate entity under discussion: Management is discussing consolidating the EV business into a separate entity and potentially raising capital.
- Ambitious OEM pivot: The plan is to move away from retrofitting in the coming years and become more OEM-like, offering a ground-up build product, which will require significant capex, R&D and development costs.
- Retrofitment vehicle suitability: Typically, a 3 to 7 year old vehicle is suitable for conversion.
Karan Shah: "We have an ambitious plan to actually move away from retrofitting in the coming years and become more OEM like a company where we offer our own ground up build product. So that will require significant capex, significant R&D and development costs."
Margins & Exceptional Items
- Margin consistency: Margins have been consistent in the last 3-5 quarters at 10-11% range, and management sees this continuing forward.
- Exceptional items explained: The write-back of INR70 crores and write-down of INR36.5 crores are at the consolidated level, stemming from consolidation of different write-offs at subsidiary companies; certain programs in MFT were cancelled several years ago, machines were reutilized into different programs, but customer-specific machines were written off in recent quarters.
- No camshaft impairment: Management confirmed no programs or contracts in the camshaft business have been cancelled, and there is no impairment due to that.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| eLCV demand pickup | Demand expected to pick up after sufficient data collected from deployed vehicles | Second half of this year |
| European slowdown impact | Will surely impact the upcoming quarter | Next quarter |
| EMOSS India conversion capacity clarity | Better idea on conversion capacity and expansion plans | Next couple of quarters |
| Camshaft order book | Fairly strong order book, no reduction in volumes expected | At least next 3-5 years |
| Non-engine component casting | Casting for braking system component to be developed in-house | Coming year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income (standalone) | ₹173 cr, +1.2% YoY |
| Total income (consolidated) | ₹270 cr, -9% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | 24.5% |
| Standalone PAT margin | 13.6% |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 15% |
| Consolidated PAT margin | 9% |
| MEMCO total income | ₹12.47 cr |
| MFT total income | ₹33.3 cr |
| EMOSS total income | ₹51.6 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA growth | +26% YoY |
| eLCV conversion cost range | ₹5,00,000 to ₹12,00,000 depending on variant and vehicle type |
| eLCV average conversion cost | ₹6,00,000 to ₹7,00,000, with customer saving ₹2.5 lakh per year on fuel |
| eLCV battery warranty | 5 to 8 years, approximately 100,000 kilometres |
| Camshaft new plant capex | ₹50 cr, Board sanctioned, under construction |
| Non-engine component status | One product (braking system component) in production and ramp-up |