Key Takeaways
- A once-in-a-generation inventory shock: An unprecedented PVC price crash wiped out ₹80–90 crores in a single quarter, pushing EBITDA and PAT into negative territory. Management calls it a 15–20 year event.
- Volumes masked by destocking, not demand destruction: Q2 volumes fell YoY as the channel ran down inventory in a falling price environment, but H1 volumes still grew 14% and underlying plumbing demand remains healthy.
- The margin reset is structural, not just cyclical: Past high EBITDA per tonne was inflated by inventory gains that are now phasing out; management’s sustainable margin guide is 12–15%, with recovery starting Q3 and normalizing by Q4.
- CPVC is the quiet compounder: The segment grew 25%+ YoY and now contributes 22–24% of revenue, steadily improving the mix even as PVC realizations fell.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised H2 demand rebound materializes as PVC prices stabilize, the pace of channel restocking, and the trajectory of margin recovery toward the guided 12–15% band.
The PVC Price Shock
- Magnitude of the fall: PVC prices dropped ₹62/kg from April, with ₹20/kg of that decline occurring in July alone. The total decline was nearly equal to the base price of the commodity itself, a volatility event management says happens once every 15–20 years.
- Inventory loss mechanics: The steep, sustained price fall triggered an inventory loss of ₹80–90 crores in Q2, the sole driver of negative EBITDA (minus ₹11 crores) and PAT (minus ₹24 crores). Inventory is valued at cost or NRV whichever is lower per Ind AS, and the gap to spot prices was wide enough to force NRV valuation.
- Channel behavior amplified the pain: Nonstop price declines caused sustained destocking among channel partners, which suppressed Q2 volumes (38,458 MT vs 42,845 MT YoY) even as end-demand stayed healthy. Additional channel incentives were needed in a destocking market to ensure fixed cost recovery, further pressuring gross margins.
- The silver lining: Management expects the low-PVC-price environment to drive a strong demand rebound in H2 FY23, particularly in price-sensitive Agri markets where the past two seasons were muted precisely because PVC was too expensive.
- Losses not over, but easing: Inventory losses will continue in the December quarter, but the extent will not be as significant as Q2. With inventory levels now normalized to ~65 days, future gains or losses should be more in line with industry norms.
Nihar Chheda: "This kind of volatility is extremely unprecedented and maybe happens once every 15-20 years, because normally the price of PVC itself would be around Rs. 70 per kg, whereas, as we highlighted the decrease has been around Rs. 60 per kg. So, the reduction in PVC prices has been almost as much as the base price of the commodity itself."
Demand & Volume Outlook
- Underlying plumbing demand is healthy: The real estate market is strong and plumbing demand continues to be robust, but this is not yet reflected in reported volumes because the channel is operating on very low inventory. True plumbing demand will show up once prices stabilize and restocking begins.
- Agri poised for a comeback: The past two Agri seasons were muted due to high PVC prices. At current low prices, demand becomes highly conducive. Management has seen green shoots and is bullish on Agri delivering good volumes in H2 FY23.
- Restocking timing: Management anticipates restocking to begin sometime in December or January, believing PVC prices are very close to a bottom. The organization is building finished goods inventory to service any demand uptick.
- Volume growth trajectory intact: On an annualized basis, management expects to continue expanding market share and maintains that double-digit volume growth is achievable. H1 volumes grew 14% YoY despite the Q2 destocking drag.
- Industry growth view: Management believes high-single-digit to low-double-digit industry volume growth over the next three years is achievable, driven by consolidation, strong real estate tailwinds, low PVC prices, and pent-up Agri demand.
Parag Chheda: "The fall in the PVC prices has a silver lining as attractive prices will lead to demand rebounding strongly in H2 of FY23."
Margins: The Reset and the Recovery
- The inventory-gain era is over: Past years’ high EBITDA per tonne was driven by inventory gains that are now phasing out. In a normal year, inventory gain or loss usually evens out on an annual basis, and management’s sustainable EBITDA guide is 12–15% on a long-term, normal-state basis.
- Recovery path: Overall operational margins should start recovering from Q3, but will normalize only in the March quarter. The Q2 gross margin hit from inventory loss and channel incentives is described as a one-time impact not expected to repeat every quarter.
- Sustainable margin levers: Product mix improvement (CPVC growing faster than PVC), pricing power as the Prince brand strengthens, operating leverage, and manufacturing decentralization to reduce freight costs are the long-term drivers.
- Realization held up better than resin: Resin prices fell ~25% QoQ while realization fell ~14% QoQ. The gap is explained by product mix improvement (CPVC contribution at 22–24%) and price reductions occurring at different points during the quarter, not all on day one. CPVC and PPR price increases were also taken during the quarter.
Nihar Chheda: "We've always maintained that sort of 12-15% EBITDA is something which is sustainable on a long-term in a normal state basis and I would stick to that right now."
CPVC: The Mix Shift Accelerator
- Outsized growth: CPVC volumes grew 25%+ YoY, making it the fastest-growing segment. CPVC contribution to revenue now stands at 22–24%, slightly higher than the 20% mark.
- Stable pricing, different market structure: Unlike PVC, CPVC prices have not seen any correction and continue to be stable. The CPVC market has a consolidated supply base with the top four processors controlling ~70% of demand, giving it different pricing dynamics.
- Mix improvement is structural: Assuming PVC prices are stable, realization should continue to improve as CPVC contribution grows over the medium term. Management expects CPVC to remain the fastest-growing segment, though it declined to quantify a target contribution percentage.
- Limited cannibalization risk: The wide price differential between CPVC and PVC is not expected to cause significant cross-cannibalization. Some shift from hot-and-cold to cold-water plumbing is possible in metro markets, but structural changes take a long time and the impact is not seen as substantial.
- Capacity headroom: CPVC capacity has enough room for growth over the next one to two years, and CPVC lines have one-way fungibility to also manufacture PVC pipes if needed.
Competitive Position & Strategy
- Volatility favors the scaled: Sharp price volatility, upward or downward, is not good for smaller players. Larger players like Prince can absorb inventory losses because of a strong balance sheet, cash on the books, and a debt-free position, while smaller players cannot absorb such shocks.
- Unorganized players may return, but narrowly: Some unorganized players that lost out will come back into the market with better PVC availability, but this will be mostly restricted to the agriculture segment and will not happen immediately. Branded players will continue to gain in plumbing and building materials.
- Long-term playbook unchanged: Management will continue to invest in brand, expand network, add newer products, and will not get panicked or distracted by commodity cycle changes. Network expansion, brand-building, and investments in new products will drive market share over the long term.
- Distribution and B2B push: Over the next one to two years, the company aims to structurally improve reach and distribution, including filling identified whitespace markets. The project/B2B market is seen as a good volume driver and brand builder over the next two to three years.
- Bathware entry: A bathware segment launch is planned in Q4, with an approach management describes as solid and prudent.
Nihar Chheda: "Sharp volatility, whether it’s upward or downward, is not good for smaller players, larger players like ourselves can absorb such kind of an inventory loss, because we have a strong balance sheet, we have good amount of cash on the books and are long-term debt free, but this kind of shocks are not something that smaller players can absorb."
Balance Sheet & Working Capital
- Working capital improved despite the shock: Debtor days improved from 60 to 48 days and inventory days improved from 85 to 65 days between March and September 2022. Finance costs reduced 15% YoY to ₹3.2 crores.
- Debtor days still a priority: Debtor days have risen to 47–48 days from ~38 days in FY20. Management acknowledges this and states improving receivables days is a top priority for CXOs, with a target of moving closer to 30–35 days over the next two to three years as the brand strengthens and network expands.
- Channel finance mix: The channel finance portfolio has a mix of recourse, partial recourse, and non-recourse on the company.
- Capacity ready for the upturn: Additional capacity is now available from two units at Jaipur and Telangana to capture any demand uptrend. The company is debt-free and can debottleneck those facilities when needed.
Parag Chheda: "As a management and for our CXOs our top priority is to improve the receivables days. So, as an organization that is something that we acknowledge, appreciate and that is something that has to see a structural improvement."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Margin recovery | Operational margins start recovering, normalize to 12–15% sustainable range | Q3 recovery begins; Q4 FY23 normalization |
| Inventory losses | Losses continue but not as significant as Q2; more in line with industry thereafter | Q3 FY23 (easing); normal state from Q4 |
| Demand rebound | Strong H2 demand rebound driven by low PVC prices, Agri pickup, and channel restocking | H2 FY23; restocking Dec–Jan |
| Volume growth | Double-digit annual volume growth achievable | FY23 (annual basis) |
| Bathware launch | Segment launch, solid and prudent approach | Q4 FY23 |
| Debtor days | Improve from ~48 days toward 30–35 days | Next 2–3 years |
| Distribution expansion | Structurally improve reach, fill whitespace markets | Next 1–2 years |
| B2B/project market | Build as volume driver and brand builder | Next 2–3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹636 crores |
| Volumes | 38,458 metric tonnes, vs 42,845 metric tonnes YoY |
| H1 FY23 volumes | 69,707 metric tonnes, 14% YoY growth |
| EBITDA | minus ₹11 crores |
| H1 FY23 EBITDA | ₹33 crores |
| Profit after tax | minus ₹24 crores |
| H1 FY23 profit after tax | minus ₹8 crores |
| Finance costs | ₹3.2 crores, reduced by 15% YoY |
| Q2 inventory loss | ₹80 crores to ₹90 crores |
| H1 FY23 inventory loss | ₹100 crores to ₹120 crores |
| CPVC volume growth | 25% plus YoY in H1 FY23 |
| Advertising and promotion spend | ₹14 crores, 2.2% of overall revenues |
| Debtor days | 48 days in September 2022, improved from 60 days in March 2022 |
| Inventory days | 65 days in September 2022, improved from 85 days in March 2022 |
| Overall working capital | 68 days at September end |
| Channel finance outstanding | ₹54 crores to ₹55 crores as of September 2022 |
| PVC resin sourcing | ~40% local, ~60% imported |
| CPVC contribution (value) | 22-24% of revenue |
| Agri share of business | ~33% |
| Channel partners | more than 1,500 |
| FY23 capex plan | ₹100 crores to ₹120 crores, maintenance, replacement and efficiency-improving |
| Operating margin guidance | 12-15% on a long-term sustainable basis |