Key Takeaways
- Soft quarter, confident full-year tone: Telecom revenue declined sequentially on price pressure and billing seasonality, while project margins were dragged by a low-margin defense contract. Management still guided to 20% FY23 revenue growth and a recovery in project margins to FY22 levels by the end of the financial year.
- Order book provides visibility: A ₹411 Crores VSS order was finalized, and the company expects to book close to somewhere around ₹300 Crores from it this year, anchoring a total project revenue target of somewhere around ₹800 Crores to ₹900 Crores.
- Kavach is a deliberate wait, not a miss: RailTel sat out initial zonal tenders, citing an immature, near-monopolistic technology market. It expects to partner with an OEM this year and can later aspire to a 20–25% share of the national rollout.
- RailWire target reset on industry headwinds: The subscriber goal was cut from 10 lakhs to 7–8 lakhs by year-end, reflecting volatility and new operator models, though a localized OTT+IPTV launch offers a partial offset.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the COD and RDN tenders convert into orders, any OEM partnership announcement for Kavach, and the pace of revenue booking on the VSS project.
Telecom Performance & Margin Trajectory
- Sequential revenue dip: Q1 telecom revenue declined QoQ due to continuous price pressure and a billing pattern where Q1 is typically lower, with some contracts billed annually. The prior quarter also included a one-time ₹13 Crores DRDO lease-line installation income, making the comparison unfavorable.
- Margin subdued by O&M and new sections: Telecom margins are under pressure from higher operation and maintenance costs for fiber and equipment. When RailTel takes over OFC sections from railways, some have skeletal revenue but are necessary for network ring protection to avoid SLA penalties.
- Access charges rising: Higher access charges reflect telecom business moving off the railway network, plus associated O&M expenses.
- Employee cost step-up: Employee costs reached ₹50 Crores, driven by salary increases for outsourced staff to comply with the minimum wages act and a normal 10% annual escalation.
- Margin floor set at 19.5%: Management sees 19.5% as the basic norm going forward. If new business can be onboarded onto newly acquired sections, both revenue and margins can rise from that floor.
Anand Kumar Singh: "19% which we are showing it can go up. On these new sections if we are able to onboard new business the revenues can go even higher. The margin can go even higher but 19.5% will be the basic norm going forward also."
Project Business & Order Inflow
- Defense project drags margin: Project business EBIT margin fell to 3.94% in the sequential quarter because the company is executing a defense-related project taken at a margin of 4%. Some other projects yield 8–9%, while consultancy/MSI-type work with minimal expenditure boosts overall margins.
- VSS order anchors near-term revenue: The Nirbhaya fund VSS tender was finalized with a Letter of Acceptance worth about ₹411 Crores. Management expects to book close to ₹300 Crores from this project in the current financial year, with a minor part completed in the current financial year.
- Total project revenue target: Overall project business revenue expected this year is around ₹800–900 Crores, including the VSS contribution. This assumes the international semiconductor shortage subsides and no other incidental hurdles arise.
- Order inflow healthy: The company received orders of more than ₹660 Crores this quarter, all through competitive bidding.
- Key tenders in pipeline: The RDN tender is under final stages of evaluation. The COD tender is likely to open this month, with the last bid submission date of August 22. The Delhi SafeCity project, a ~₹220 Crores order with a telecom bandwidth element, will help grow RailWire by laying fiber within the city for last-mile expansion.
- Long-gestation projects: Data center and tower projects have long gestation periods; revenue is likely only in the second half of FY24 or later, at least 18 months away.
Kavach: Strategy of Deliberate Abstention
- Why RailTel did not bid: The company stayed out of zonal railway Kavach tenders because the technology is not yet fully developed or foolproof. The industry is close to monopolistic, with two or three OEMs attempting to play monopoly, making competitive rates difficult to secure.
- Waiting for maturity and a partner: RailTel will certainly enter the segment but is waiting for the product to mature substantially. It expects to partner with an OEM in this financial year itself, once the product is completely or largely matured.
- Market structure and sizing: Kavach orders will come as multiple section-by-section tenders, not one large order, with individual orders in the range of ₹200–300 Crores. High-density traffic sections will be prioritized first. Management conservatively aspires to a 20–25% share of the entire project.
- Center of Excellence: The Ministry of Railways has set up a Kavach center of excellence in Secunderabad for complete specification, including alignment with LTE technology.
Sanjai Kumar: "Presently Kavach industry is close to monopolistic. There are I think two or three OEMs only are there and they are trying to play monopoly in such environment and in such circumstances it is very difficult to get competitive rate number one. Number two the technology itself is not yet foolproof."
RailWire & Tower Infrastructure
- Subscriber target reset: The RailWire broadband subscriber target was revised down to seven to eight lakhs by year-end from an earlier target of 10 lakhs. The reset reflects industry volatility, new operator models like OTT and IPTV, and struggles across urban, semi-urban and rural segments.
- OTT+IPTV launch as a counter: RailTel recently launched OTT plus IPTV in localized circles and expects good results from this initiative.
- Tower RFP coming: The company is likely to issue an RFP inviting private investment to install towers, at least one at each station to begin with. All towers offered will be fiberized, positioning RailTel as a beneficiary of 5G-driven tenancy increases.
- 5G opportunity not immediate: Management does not expect sizable expansion from 5G in FY2023. Operators have been given time to deposit spectrum fees, and the momentum to install equipment will not be immediate. However, 5G deployment is expected to drive average tower tenancy to 1.5–2 minimum, making fiberized tower infrastructure a good opportunity.
Sanjai Kumar: "I do not think that there will be a sizable expansion on this account. They will be launching it in few cities but the kind of expansion which we are expecting may not be there in this financial year."
Health, Data Centers & Other Initiatives
- Health sector push: RailTel is executing POC projects with AIIMS and completed a ~₹9 Crores POC with the Karnataka Government ESIS. It is already integrated with NDHM and in touch with NHA to take medical facilities to rural and remote areas. Management expects to arrive at a number for the size of the health opportunity before the beginning of FY2024.
- Data center at AMTZ: A data center has been set up at the Andhra Medtech Zone.
- BSNL 4G opportunity distant: BSNL 4G rollout will take not less than a year due to indigenous product development and the semiconductor chip shortage. Management cannot comment much on the opportunity at this stage.
- Low-orbit satellites not a threat: Management expressed a personal view that low-orbit satellites will not play a major role in the Indian telecom industry or materially affect it.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 revenue growth | 20% top-line growth | FY23 full year |
| FY23 EBITDA margin | 19% to 20%; endeavor to exceed 19% | FY23 full year |
| Project margins recovery | Overall project margins in line with FY22 levels | By end of FY23 |
| VSS project revenue booking | Book close to ~₹300 Crores of the ₹411 Crores order | FY23 |
| Total project revenue | ₹800–900 Crores (including VSS), assuming semiconductor shortage subsides | FY23 |
| RailWire subscribers | Grow to 7–8 lakhs | By end of FY23 |
| Kavach OEM partnership | Partner with an OEM once product is substantially matured | In this financial year (FY23) |
| Kavach market share aspiration | 20–25% share of the entire Kavach project | Over the project lifecycle |
| Health sector opportunity sizing | Arrive at a number for the size of the opportunity | Before beginning of FY2024 |
| Data center and tower revenue | Revenue contribution to begin | Second half of FY24 or later |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated operating revenue | ₹377 cr, +23% YoY |
| Profit before tax | ₹35 cr, +25% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹26 cr, +24% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹74 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 19.22% |
| Earnings per share | +23% YoY |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance | 20% top line |
| FY23 EBITDA margin guidance | 19% to 20% |
| Telecom business revenue | ₹274 cr |
| Project business revenue | ₹103 cr |
| Project business EBIT margin (Q4 FY22) | 3.94%, impacted by a defense project taken at 4% margin |
| New orders received | ₹662 cr |
| Order book | ₹5,800 cr plus |
| VSS tender (Nirbhaya fund) | ₹411 cr, Letter of Acceptance issued |
| Project revenue expected in FY23 | ₹800 cr to ₹900 cr, including ~₹300 cr from VSS |
| Capex guidance for FY23 | ₹150 cr |
| RailWire broadband subscribers | 4.69 lakhs |
| RailWire ARPU | around ₹560 |
| RailWire subscriber target by year-end | 7 to 8 lakhs |
| NLD revenue | ₹127 cr |
| ISP revenue | ₹93 cr |
| IP-1 revenue | ₹54 cr |
| Telecom revenue from railway project | ₹36 cr |
| Other projects revenue | ₹67 cr |
| Tower count | roughly 1,000 |
| Current tower tenancy | around 1.25 to 1.5 |
| Cash on balance sheet | ₹522 cr |
| Employee cost | ₹50 cr |
| One-time DRDO income in Q4 FY22 (not repeated) | ₹13 cr, against installation of lease lines |