Key Takeaways
- Apparel steals the show, real estate builds the pipeline: Branded Apparel delivered 20% sales growth and margin expansion in a quarter where industry demand was largely negative, while Real Estate secured two large society redevelopment wins with combined revenue potential exceeding ₹3,100 cr.
- Post-festive slump exposes K-curve reality: Strong Navratri/Diwali demand could not sustain, as inflationary pressures continued to squeeze discretionary spending for low-income households even while high-income consumption increased.
- The "treadmill" trade-off is explicit: Apparel margins improved to 13.9%, but management will reinvest those gains into 250–300 new stores and ₹65–70 cr of incremental annual ad spend over the next couple of years, keeping the business in a deliberate build cycle.
- Demerger unlocks pure-play value: SEBI approval received, EGM set for Feb 26; the Lifestyle business and Real Estate/Engineering business will become two independent, net-debt-free listed entities, with completion expected in early FY25.
- What to watch next quarter: The Bandra project launch, the pace of Ethnix store openings toward the 300-store target, and whether Q4 consumer sentiment improves enough to sustain apparel’s momentum beyond festive spikes.
Branded Apparel: Growth Engine in a Weak Market
- 20% growth against an industry decline: Sales growth was driven by distribution reach expansion, premiumization, and casualization across all brands (Park Avenue, ColorPlus, Raymond Ready to Wear, Ethnix by Raymond, Parx); like-for-like growth was much better than the industry, which was largely negative.
- Margin expansion with reinvestment: EBITDA margin improved to 13.9% from 11.2%, helped by operating leverage and gross margin expansion from economies of scale across EBO, MBO, and LFS channels. The extra margin was deliberately reinvested into rentals, people, and advertising, with ad spend doubling YoY.
- Growth currently skews toward distribution: The 20% quarterly growth and 18% nine-month growth are more driven by store expansion than same-store growth. Management expects a good mix of distribution-led and same-store growth over time, supported by brand building, product portfolio expansion into casualwear, and larger-format stores.
- Raymond Stores as a captive apparel channel: The 1,140-odd Raymond stores contribute both fabric and apparel sales; the focus is on increasing apparel salience through these stores, aided by the casualization and smart-casual trend.
Kataria: "I think right now, for the next couple of years, we see ourselves being on this treadmill where we get accessibility, we include stores, we pull money back into brand building, and we continue this virtual cycle going right now."
Ethnix by Raymond: Early Proof, Long Payoff
- Proof of concept achieved on three fronts: Product portfolio is a winner in quality, design, and pricing; store design, ambience, and consumer experience are premium; and SPSF saw a sharp jump during the 60-day wedding season.
- Seasonality makes near-term metrics unreliable: SPSF changes significantly between wedding and non-wedding seasons; management says a full 24-month cycle is needed to understand store potential, and ARR is not the right metric at this stage.
- Store count reached 105: The 100th Ethnix store opened during the quarter, and the target is 300-odd stores across Tier 1–3 cities to capture roughly 80–85% of the addressable market.
- Smart Ethnix sub-segment in development: A casual ethnic wear line (regular bundies, casual ethnic shirts, short kurtas) is being built to reduce the non-wedding season drop; it is currently very small.
- Store economics and brand financials withheld: Management declined to share store economics, brand-wise sales, EBITDA status, or revenue run rate, calling it "too premature" and noting the business is in an investment phase. Gross margins are much higher than regular apparel, and economies of scale are expected to expand them further over time.
Kataria: "So to see a full potential of our Ethnix brand would require a longer lead time of, I would say, maybe 24 months because there are times when you will just end up in a year seeing one large wedding cycle."
Real Estate: Pipeline Builds, Margins Normalize
- Two large society redevelopment wins: Appointed developer for a Mahim West society redevelopment with revenue potential exceeding ₹1,700 cr, and selected as preferred developer for a Sion East project with potential of approximately ₹1,400 cr.
- Margin dip is launch-cost driven: EBITDA margin was 22.1% vs 25.5%, attributed to initial launch costs for new projects. Management expects around 24–25% margin on an ongoing basis, consistent with the average over recent quarters.
- JDA margins expected to match owned-land projects: Thane FSI norms are similar to BMC areas but pricing is lower (~₹20,000) vs JDA markets (~₹30,000 or higher), so the land cost in JDA is offset by higher pricing, keeping margins comparable.
- Bandra launch imminent: The project is on schedule for Q4 FY24, with RERA registration applied and launch expected this quarter.
- No commercial projects planned: Residential remains the most remunerative use for monetizing the land parcel; as of now, there is no plan for commercial development.
- Oberoi Realty’s Thane launch had no impact: Raymond’s Q3 real estate sales were better than Q2, and management sees the MMR market as mature and stable, not speculative. Price hikes of 6–8% over the last two years are expected to continue, supported by infrastructure development and no supply overhang.
Sahni: "I don't think rapid price increases are actually healthy or good for the market. A stable market is always better and which is what we've been seeing in Mumbai."
Garmenting & Engineering: Muted Quarter, Structural Bets
- Garmenting revenue flat YoY: Two factors weighed on performance: a very slow global denim market caused a big shortfall in denim orders, and a specific order scheduled for Q3 dispatch was shifted to the next quarter. Despite this, margins expanded due to capacity expansion and staff training.
- Capacity and geographic expansion underway: Capacity is being expanded by approximately one-third to participate in the China Plus One strategy and Make in India initiative. New geographies opened up include Europe and Japan, adding to the existing strong U.S. and U.K. presence. A set of large strategic customers is being acquired.
- Engineering consumables weak: The consumable category was impacted by sluggishness in the export market. Growth strategy is pivoting toward sunrise sectors of Aerospace and EV via the Maini Precision stake acquisition, with all formalities and regulatory clearances expected to complete during Q4 FY24.
- Auto ancillary growing: The auto ancillary segment is witnessing good growth, even as engineering consumables face export headwinds.
Demerger & Capital Allocation
- Demerger on track: SEBI approval received; EGM scheduled for February 26, 2024; post-EGM, the filing will go to NCLT with completion expected in the first fiscal quarter of FY24–25. The effective date is April 1, 2023. The result will be two independent, net-debt-free, pure-play listed entities: a B2C lifestyle business and a real estate & engineering business.
- Auto business demerger deferred: Management will act when the businesses mature, with no timeline committed.
- Working capital improved: Net working capital reduced by 5 days QoQ to 71 days, driven by reductions in inventory and receivables in Lifestyle and other businesses. Real estate saw a ₹120 cr increase due to initial approval costs for new towers and projects.
- Interest cost rose on specific items: Higher interest cost was driven by ₹38 cr interest on NCD to RCCL (to be netted off post-demerger), increased lease liabilities from new store openings, and ₹10 cr for MHADA approval cost deferment for the Bandra project.
- Cash flow and balance sheet priority: Dedicated focus on generating free cash flow through profitable growth; with no major capex requirement, the group will remain net cash positive going ahead.
Agarwal: "We want to make sure that the businesses get mature, and then we will do the right thing for shareholder value creation."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Demerger completion | Lifestyle and Real Estate/Engineering become two independent listed entities | First fiscal quarter of FY24–25 |
| Retail store expansion | Add 250–300 stores via asset-light franchise model across Ethnix and all apparel brands | Next 18 months |
| Incremental ad spend | ₹65–70 cr per year above normal cycle to pull revenue forward | Every year |
| Real estate EBITDA margin | ~24–25% on ongoing basis | Ongoing |
| Bandra project launch | RERA registration applied; launch imminent | Q4 FY24 |
| Ethnix store target | 300-odd stores to reach ~80–85% of addressable market | No date; "give or take a few quarters" |
| Raymond Home revenue | Double from ₹150–160 cr | Next 3–4 years |
| JDA project sales start | Documentation to site handover in ~12 months; earliest sales process start 12 months from now | ~12 months from now |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated net profit | ₹184 cr, doubled from ₹95 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Branded Textile revenue | ₹909 cr, maintained despite muted demand |
| Branded Textile EBITDA margin | 21.6%, up from 20.9% in Q3 FY23 |
| Branded Apparel revenue | ₹437 cr, +20% YoY from ₹364 cr |
| Branded Apparel EBITDA margin | 13.9%, up from 11.2% in Q3 FY23 |
| Garmenting revenue | ₹281 cr, similar to previous year |
| Garmenting EBITDA margin | 10.8%, up from 9.1% in Q3 FY23 |
| High-value cotton shirting revenue | ₹214 cr, +10% YoY from ₹195 cr |
| High-value cotton shirting EBITDA margin | 10.9%, up from 10.7% in Q3 FY23 |
| Engineering business sales | ₹217 cr, up from ₹208 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Engineering business EBITDA margin | 13.9% |
| Realty business sales | ₹439 cr, +50% YoY from ₹292 cr |
| Realty business EBITDA margin | 22.1%, down from 25.5% in Q3 FY23 due to new project launch costs |
| Total real estate bookings | ₹428 cr, up from ₹380 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Net working capital days | 71 days, improved 5 days QoQ from 76 days in Sep 23 |
| Net working capital (absolute) | ₹1,925 cr as of Dec 23 |
| Operating cash flow | ₹319 cr generated during the quarter |
| Free cash flow | ₹233 cr generated during the quarter |
| Total gross debt | ₹2,754 cr (external ₹1,054 cr + NCDs to RCCL ₹1,700 cr) |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹1,835 cr as of Dec 31, 2023 |
| Net debt | ₹919 cr, lower by ₹220 cr vs Sep 23 |
| Interest cost | ₹104 cr, up from ₹70 cr in Q3 FY23; includes ₹38 cr on NCD to RCCL |
| Retail store network | 1,512 stores across 600 towns; 215 new stores opened in last 12 months |
| New stores opened in Q3 | 65 stores |
| Ethnix by Raymond store count | 105 stores as of Dec 31, 2023; 20% COCO, 80% franchise |
| Ethnix target store count | 300 stores in Tier 1-3 cities, covering ~80-85% of addressable market |
| Raymond Home business revenue | ₹150-160 cr annual run rate, potential to double in 3-4 years |
| Incremental annual ad spend planned | ₹65-70 cr every year going forward |
| Thane Land bank total revenue potential | ₹25,000 cr (₹9,000 cr running projects + ₹16,000 cr further potential) |
| JDA projects revenue potential (3 projects) | >₹5,000 cr combined, outside Thane Land |
| Bandra project revenue potential | ₹2,000 cr, launch imminent |
| MMR market annual price hike trend | 6% to 8% over the last 2 years |
| Peak investment per new real estate project | ₹250-350 cr |
| Engineering business pro forma FY23 revenue (incl. Maini Precision) | >₹1,600 cr, with >60% from exports and consolidated EBITDA of ₹220 cr |